Starmer’s failure to demonstrate strong values ‘driving away progressive voters’
Progressive voters have been driven away from Labour by a lack of argument and vision from Keir Starmer, according to a report using research from a senior pollster to Tony Blair and Bill Clinton.Downing Street is understood to have been briefed on the research, which has also been handed to allies of the potential leadership candidates Andy Burnham, Wes Streeting and Angela Rayner.Labour is braced for dismal results in Thursday’s elections, which could result in Starmer facing a leadership challenge.The report from UCL’s Policy Lab, using research from the eminent pollster Stan Greenberg, suggested voters felt that Starmer had a “discomfort” with progressive values.Key fights that the government could pick included a more robust challenge to Donald Trump and a more passionate defence of environmentalism.
Greenberg’s findings suggested the next election would be won by those who can unite left and right “blocs” of voters.The polling suggested that would be achieved not only through delivery or policies, but through a clear articulation of core values.Marc Stears, the director of the Policy Lab, said: “Keir Starmer came in on a wave of frustration with politics as usual and a promise of change.There is no hiding from the frustration voters feel with his time so far.“Some of this can be put down to his personal style but this report suggests it is also due to his discomfort with progressive values.
The party and politics that is able to tap more effectively into the core values of their potential supporters might do better in this newly polarised age.”Examples given by the report’s authors include Starmer’s decision not to join the Iran war – which was welcomed by voters but which they said needed to be accompanied by a strong values statement about why the war was wrong, rather than technocratic explanations about illegality.Policy Lab’s James Baggaley said there was widespread expectation that Starmer intended to use closer ties with the EU as a way of signalling a progressive turn.But he said that again would not be enough without a more explicit declaration of values.“Our research shows that progressive voters do want closer ties to the EU, but they’re also looking for much more radicalism on public services, taxation, climate and democracy,” he said.
“Unlike previous Labour prime ministers, Keir Starmer faces a serious challenge from a party to his left.How Labour responds to the Greens will shape politics in the years ahead.Indeed, what the polling shows is that progressives currently have the kind of hunger for radicalism more frequently associated with challengers from the Brexit-facing right.”The polling found Starmer was viewed negatively by three-quarters of voters – similar levels to the former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn.Burnham, the mayor of Greater Manchester, had the best ratings, viewed positively by a third of voters.
The polling found about 13% to 15% of progressive voters were open to voting Labour, compared with only 2% of Reform voters.Liberal Democrat voters were more likely to consider voting for Labour than the Greens.The polling also suggested Reform UK was reaching its ceiling, with few Conservative voters willing to say they would still consider voting for Nigel Farage’s party.The polling found willingness to confront Trump brought an intensely positive dividend from voters.But the report suggested that so far most progressive voters felt Starmer had failed to do sufficiently, despite his criticism of the US president in recent months.
The polling found it was a position popular with Labour voters and those who had left the party for other progressive parties – including the Greens and Lib Dems, where it was backed by more than two-thirds of voters,Progressive voters in the report’s focus groups said Britain and the government had failed to show values-based opposition to Trump, in the way that other politicians in Canada and Spain had managed,Almost as popular was strong messaging on the climate – a fight that Starmer has been more willing to pick in recent months to underline why energy independence is so important to bills amid the Iran war’s effect on fossil fuel prices,Voters who responded to the report also cited a deep personal animosity to the prime minister that went beyond his ability to communicate,Greenberg and Steers described a “failure to come to terms with our newly polarised age”.
Seth Meyers on Trump’s poll ratings: ‘His disapproval is higher than Covid and January 6’
On Monday night, late-night hosts weighed in on Donald Trump’s erratic statements on Iran, rising oil prices and the shuttering of every budget-conscious traveller’s favorite low-cost airline.Seth Meyers opened his Monday night monologue with news of a new poll finding that Americans are overwhelmingly opposed to the Iran war and Trump’s plan to peacefully guide oil tankers through the strait of Hormuz.“Oh wait, I’m getting word that the administration has unveiled a new name for the mission,” the host joked. “Let’s see, what is it called: Operation Clusterfuck.”Meyers then reacted to a new Ipsos poll which showed Trump’s disapproval ratings at a record 62%, in large part due to gas prices rising $1
The Parallax View: remember when Hollywood made potent political cinema?
Watching Hollywood cinema in 2026 can make for a curious experience. Take a look out the window and you’ll notice that the US, and indeed the world, is in a polycrisis – though you’d hardly know it from the films at the multiplex. The odd timely picture aside, Hollywood today directly engages with the present moment only rarely; more Minecraft Movie than One Battle After Another.In the 70s, when things were arguably last in a comparably sorry state – Kent State, Vietnam and Watergate for the US, economic crises and violent acts of world revolution globally – popular cinema responded very differently. Out of the establishment-sceptical New Hollywood that emerged after the demise of the Hays code, there came a wave of confronting social and political dramas, strongly allegorical sci-fi and paranoid thrillers, including one of the most deliriously entertaining examples of the latter ever made: The Parallax View
‘We got a drive-by egging in Baltimore’: Super Furry Animals on making The Man Don’t Give a Fuck
Gruff was the first person I ever met who could just churn out songs – good, catchy ones. I joined his band Ffa Coffi Pawb, but by 1992 they’d split and Gruff and I were living in Cardiff, as were Bunf, Guto and my brother Cian, the other future Furries. We started out doing techno sets, and I had a little home studio where we demoed ideas for songs. Our first singer, the actor Rhys Ifans, slept on a mattress in the corner.I had this Steely Dan album, Countdown to Ecstasy
Ittai Gradel obituary
With a doctorate in Roman religion and a university chair, Ittai Gradel, who has died of cancer aged 61, might have confined his achievements to a successful scholarly career. However, in 2008, bored with routine bureaucracy, he left his post at Reading University, and returned to his native Denmark to deal in antiquities.His disillusionment with academia was reinforced when, a few years later, he discovered that large-scale thefts had been taking place from the British Museum’s collections. At first reluctant to believe the accumulating evidence, Gradel contacted the museum in 2021 only when it became impossible to deny – and was told nothing was missing.Ill and increasingly impatient, he took his cause to the museum’s trustees, and at last the police were called
Man charged over bomb hoax after Peter Kay show evacuated
A man has been charged over a bomb hoax after a live show by comedian Peter Kay in Birmingham was stopped when a “potentially suspicious bag” was found around the venue.The Utilita Arena Birmingham was evacuated and a 19-year-old man was taken into custody, West Midlands police said on Friday evening.On Saturday, the force said: “A man has been charged in connection with the events which led to the evacuation of the Utilita Arena in Birmingham last night.“Omar Majed, 19, has been charged with false communications relating to a bomb hoax,” a police spokesperson said. “Majed, of Washwood Heath, Birmingham, has been remanded to appear before magistrates in Birmingham on 4 May
Guy Montgomery: ‘One fan took us back to his house and showed us all his guns’
Have you ever won a spelling bee?No! I don’t think I’ve entered any formalised spelling competition. When I was eight or nine, there was a guy who I used to copy during tests. We were doing a spelling test and the word was “vehicle” and he made an absolutely terrible attempt at it. I knew he’d spelled it wrong and was like, wait – have I been copying someone who’s more stupid than me this whole time?Which word do you hate the most?None! That’s crazy! I love all words. They’re just out there, doing their best
Lacunar strokes caused by widening of arteries in brain, study suggests
Attempts to stop prison drone drug deliveries hampered by crumbling Victorian walls
Prosecutors to ‘fast-track’ hate crime cases in England and Wales after spate of attacks
Ann Barrett obituary
Slow Alzheimer’s diagnoses ‘mean UK patients missing out on experimental treatments’
‘I am invoking Martha’s rule’: how a woman saved her father from near death in hospital