Mandelson scandal is biggest crisis for diplomatic service in decades, says ex-Foreign Office chief

A picture


The Peter Mandelson security vetting scandal is the biggest crisis for the diplomatic service in decades, a former Foreign Office chief has said.Simon McDonald, who was the permanent under-secretary of the government department until 2020, has spoken out in defence of Oliver Robbins, saying the civil servant was “thrown under a bus” by the prime minister, Keir Starmer, when he was dismissed from his role on Thursday.Robbins was sacked as permanent secretary of the Foreign Office hours after the Guardian revealed that Peter Mandelson failed his security vetting in January 2025, during the process to appoint him as ambassador to the US.It is said that Robbins knew about Mandelson’s failure to pass the UK Security Vetting (UKSV) assessment but did not forward that information to ministers.Starmer claims he was not made aware of the outcome of the vetting process until this week.

Robbins is reportedly angry at what he considers to be unfair treatment by the prime minister and is said to believe that he was following due process.McDonald agreed with this assessment and answered “yes” when asked by the BBC’s Today programme on Saturday if Robbins was “thrown under a bus”.He said: “Yes, this story broke on Thursday morning [it broke at about 6pm] in a piece in the Guardian; within the news cycle Olly Robbins had been required to resign.”McDonald said this showed “No 10 required a scalp and wanted it quickly”, adding: “I cannot see that there was any process, any fairness, any giving him the chance to set out his case and that feels, to me, wrong.“I think this is the biggest crisis in the diplomatic service since I joined it in 1982.

”Robbins is expected to give his side of the story on Tuesday when he goes before the Commons foreign affairs select committee.Ministers are concerned he will use this public appearance to hit back at No 10’s version of events, which could be damaging for Starmer.McDonald suggested the government had misrepresented what happened during the vetting process in order to shift blame, and that the decision to appoint Mandelson despite concerns being raised by the civil service was made by the prime minister.“The whole posting was controversial,” he said.“By the time Olly Robbins became permanent secretary in the Foreign Office, the posting had been announced, it was clear that the prime minister wanted his man to go to Washington, and the system was making that happen.

”On Friday the Cabinet Office released a template page from the summary document produced by UKSV after Mandelson’s vetting.The document would be used by a vetting officer to summarise their findings.It lists three rankings for possible “overall concern”: low, medium and high.In the next box, there is a space for a vetting officer to list the outcome of the assessment with their “overall decision or recommendation”.Again, there are three options: clearance approved, clearance approved “with risk management” or clearance denied.

According to multiple sources, the UKSV process in Mandelson’s case concluded there was a “high” overall concern and concluded “clearance denied”.It was this recommendation that was overruled by the Foreign Office, which employed a rarely used authority to grant him clearance anyway.Of the process, McDonald said: “If it [the vetting process] did amount to failure then that fact, that ultimate conclusion would have to be conveyed to the political level, but the fact that it was not indicates to me that the fact was rather more complicated than No 10 would wish to present.”The prime minister said earlier this week he was “furious” about what had happened, while Downing Street squarely blamed the Foreign Office, with Starmer’s official spokesperson saying No 10 had “repeatedly” sought the facts of the case without being told.Asked if this amounted to a “cover-up”, they did not reject this, saying: “Well, the prime minister was not informed and he’s made clear that it is staggering that he was not informed.

”The Guardian revealed on Friday that Starmer was also kept in the dark about information relating to Mandelson’s security vetting failure by two other top civil servants.The cabinet secretary, Antonia Romeo, and Catherine Little, the Cabinet Office’s permanent secretary, became aware of the situation last month but did not immediately pass on that information to the prime minister.
A picture

Move over matcha: how ube cocktails and coffees are hitting the UK’s sweet spot

Bright purple coffees and cocktails made with a root vegetable called ube have hit the high street in the UK after the yam’s striking hue caused a sensation on social media. Many are calling ube the “new matcha”, and it has a nutty, creamy, sweet taste, like a mix between coconut and vanilla.Ube coloured and flavoured drinks became popular in the US last year, after an earlier boom in Australia. Farmers in the Philippines, where the root vegetable is often sourced, have been struggling to meet demand.Now, the purple drinks have crossed the pond: Starbucks and Costa both launched ube drinks in their UK stores last month

A picture

Rachel Roddy’s ‘high-ranking’ penne with potatoes, cabbage, butter and cheese – recipe

In December 2023, the magazine La Cucina Italiana ranked Italians’ favourite pasta shapes, according to data gathered by Unione Italiana Food (“the leading association in Italy for the direct representation of food product categories”). I love this sort of thing. According to the UIF, by processing NielsenIQ data (comprehensive market research, consumer intelligence and retail measurement), they identified the five most popular shapes from over 500, and examined how preferences vary in different regions.In first place was spaghetti, while penne came in second, with these two shapes – which also takes in thinner spaghettini, chunkier spaghettoni and both ridged and smooth penne – accounting for 78% of all pasta sold in Italy in 2023. The regional variations of three, four and five are as follows: in the north-west and north-east, fusilli, short pasta and mixed pasta for broth or minestra; in central Italy, short pasta, fusilli and rigatoni; in the south, mixed pasta for broth or minestra, short pasta and tortiglioni

A picture

How to turn old bread into a brilliant Italian cake – recipe | Waste not

Old sourdough is my secret ingredient. To stop it going mouldy, I take it out of any plastic packaging and keep it in the bread bin with plenty of airflow around it – that way, it will dry out slowly, rather than turning mouldy. Any odds and ends, meanwhile, I store in a cloth bag to use in various dishes, from pangrattato (or poor man’s parmesan) to strata, a savoury bread-and-butter pudding.My new favourite recipe discovery for using up stale bread is today’s torta paesana, or village cake, from Lombardy. The best way I can come up with to describe it is that it’s a bit like a firm baked custard

A picture

Roast chicken, cheesy scones and a genius cocktail: Ravinder Bhogal’s recipes for cooking with lime pickle

I’m obsessed with lime pickle. It’s savoury, sour, funky, spicy and full of bold personality that enlivens anything it’s smeared on. It’s made by salting and fermenting limes with chillies and spices for a fierce, flavour-packed condiment that’s traditionally eaten as a side to poppadoms or with simple dal and rice. Over the years, I have also folded it into grilled cheese toasties, marinades for fat prawns to barbecue in the summer or made compound butters with it to smother over sweet potatoes before roasting. It’s an instant flavour bomb and my pantry is never without a jar

A picture

Vegemite is recognised globally – but how many people know Milo was invented in Australia?

The chocolate malt powder is sold in more than 40 countries, and Australian cafe owners say there’s ‘jingoistic pride’ in serving it on their menusGet our weekend culture and lifestyle emailWhen I order the jumbo-sized Milo Godzilla at Ho Jiak in Sydney’s Haymarket, it arrives as advertised – it’s comically large. The Malaysian restaurant prepares the drink by swirling Milo powder with hot water, adding sweet drizzles of condensed milk then chilling the mix with ice. Scoops of ice-cream are added and extra choc-malt powder is showered on top. Served in a one-litre jug, it’s so big I can’t finish it solo: staff hand me three takeaway cups to transport the leftovers.Like many beloved Milo drinks, the Godzilla is native to south-east Asia

A picture

What can I do with leftover rice? | Kitchen aide

How do I store cooked rice safely, and what can I make with it the next day?Michael, by email“It’s a bit of a running joke with rice, because I think of all the people in China who aren’t spreading their leftover rice immediately on to a tray to cool and are still alive,” says Amy Poon, of Poon’s at Somerset House in London. “But I have to be responsible and say: cool the rice as quickly as possible, within the hour, and put it in an airtight container and pop it in the fridge [or freezer] straight away.” The reason being, as food science guru Harold McGee notes in his bible On Food & Cooking, “Raw rice almost always carries dormant spores of the bacterium Bacillus cereus, which produces powerful gastrointestinal toxins. The spores can tolerate high temperatures, and some survive cooking.” In short: good storage practices will prevent bacterial growth, not to mention open a whole world of dinner opportunities