Parliament must heed public opinion on assisted dying | Letters
The Nuffield Council on Bioethics is an independent research and policy centre that aims to put ethics at the centre of decision-making about bioscience and health so that we all benefit.We agree that public views should be central to the debate on assisted dying (Editorial, 29 April).This is why we commissioned England’s first citizens’ jury on assisted dying in 2024, which produced rich and independent evidence about what the English public think about assisted dying, and the ethical, social and practical considerations that underpin their views.Over eight weeks, 30 jurors – who were reflective of the demographic makeup of the English population – spent a total of 24 hours hearing evidence from experts, engaging with perspectives from all sides of the debate, and deliberating in groups.At the final vote, the jury concluded that the law should be changed to permit terminally ill adults, with capacity, to access an assisted death.
The jury emphasised the need for safeguards to ensure legalised assisted dying would not be abused and to protect vulnerable people.They also expressed a strong view that deliberative public engagement on death, dying and end-of-life care should be ongoing.Approaches such as citizens’ assemblies offer a valuable way to further enrich our understanding of diverse public perspectives as the debate evolves.However, with the possibility of another private member’s bill on assisted dying appearing after the king’s speech, it is vital that parliament engages with the substantial, independent evidence on public views that already exists, including from the our citizens’ jury.Danielle HammDirector, Nuffield Council on Bioethics We strongly support the idea of a citizens’ assembly on our relationship with death, only we would broaden it beyond the question of assisted dying.
We co-chaired the Lancet Commission on the Value of Death, which concluded that we have an unbalanced, unhealthy relationship with death.Increasingly, death, dying and grieving are not seen as a family, community, cultural process but a medicalised event, increasing suffering, cost, carbon consumption and reinforcing the delusion that death is a problem to be fixed.Industrial societies like the UK have a diminishing capacity to deal with death.Neither increased access to palliative care nor legislation for assisted dying will fix our broken relationship with death.Death takes place in complex social systems and we need to understand, debate and change those systems to rebalance our relationship with death.
A citizens’ assembly, such as the one that has been held in France, would be an important step forward in that rebalancing.Libby Sallnow and Richard Smith Co-chairs, Lancet Commission on the Value of Death As a terminally ill woman, I read your editorial with profound dismay.For those with the luxury of time, another forum for reflection may sound measured.For people like me, whose remaining time is measured in months, perhaps weeks, it sounds like yet another delay.Terminally ill people have too often been marginalised in this debate – spoken about rather than listened to.
Our suffering and our choices are treated as subjects for endless discussion while we endure the consequences of inaction.We do not need more deliberation.We need parliament to act.Every month of delay means more dying people denied autonomy, more families traumatised and more people forced into desperate or lonely endings that they would never have chosen.Those calling for patience rarely bear the cost of it themselves.
Parliament has debated this long enough,It must act now,Dr Pamela FisherSkelmanthorpe, West Yorkshire Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section,
Man charged over bomb hoax after Peter Kay show evacuated
A man has been charged over a bomb hoax after a live show by comedian Peter Kay in Birmingham was stopped when a “potentially suspicious bag” was found around the venue.The Utilita Arena Birmingham was evacuated and a 19-year-old man was taken into custody, West Midlands police said on Friday evening.On Saturday, the force said: “A man has been charged in connection with the events which led to the evacuation of the Utilita Arena in Birmingham last night.“Omar Majed, 19, has been charged with false communications relating to a bomb hoax,” a police spokesperson said. “Majed, of Washwood Heath, Birmingham, has been remanded to appear before magistrates in Birmingham on 4 May
Guy Montgomery: ‘One fan took us back to his house and showed us all his guns’
Have you ever won a spelling bee?No! I don’t think I’ve entered any formalised spelling competition. When I was eight or nine, there was a guy who I used to copy during tests. We were doing a spelling test and the word was “vehicle” and he made an absolutely terrible attempt at it. I knew he’d spelled it wrong and was like, wait – have I been copying someone who’s more stupid than me this whole time?Which word do you hate the most?None! That’s crazy! I love all words. They’re just out there, doing their best
‘We have to mock the site’s insanity’: comedian Tim Heidecker on the allure of becoming Infowars’ new boss
If you’ve tuned in to Infowars over the years, you might have heard a very angry man screaming about the 2020 election being stolen for “reanimated corpse” Joe Biden, or chemicals in the water turning frogs gay, or the Sandy Hook school shooting, which killed 20 children and six staff members, being faked. Founded in 1999, Alex Jones’s Infowars has long been a platform for toxic conspiracy theories with real-life consequences, in addition to weird dietary supplements. But if the Onion has its way, the InfoWars of the future will have a very different impact.The satirical newspaper has been working for several years to take over the site, amid legal battles over Jones’s false claims about the 2012 Sandy Hook shooting. Pending a Texas court’s approval, the platform could soon be in the hands of the Onion and a newly installed creative director, comedian Tim Heidecker, known for his surreal sketches and mockery of the far right
Prince’s death made me upend my life and move to his home town
The star’s potent sexuality made him my ‘secret friend’ but, with my career in the arts stalling, his death led me to the life-changing decision to move to Minneapolis and maintain his legacyI distinctly remember the first time I heard Prince. I was a dreamy, artistic child growing up in 80s rural Australia, feeling completely out of place. One day, I turned towards the cassette radio in my bedroom, hearing something totally different to the rock music I had grown up with – something electric and alive. It was Prince. My body moved
The Devil Wears Prada 2 to Lenny Henry: your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead
Meryl Streep stars in the long-awaited sequel to the fashion-industry hit, and the comic, actor and bona fide national treasure returns to the stageThe Devil Wears Prada 2Out nowSequels, for spring? Groundbreaking. OK, but this just happens to be one of the most anticipated sequels of the last decade, with Meryl Streep, Anne Hathaway and Emily Blunt returning to their respective roles of high-fashion supervillain Miranda Priestly, journalist Andy Sachs and type-A nightmare Emily Charlton.HokumOut nowAdam Scott (Severance) stars in this Irish-set haunted-house horror about a man whose journey to spread his parents’ ashes involves some unexpectedly spooky twists and turns. Irish former electrician Damian McCarthy writes and directs his first Hollywood feature after a couple of lower-budget homegrown hits.Wild FoxesOut nowValéry Carnoy directs this French coming-of-age drama which premiered at Cannes last year to prize-winning effect
Peter Kay show stopped and 19-year-old in custody after ‘suspicious bag’ found
A live show by comedian Peter Kay in Birmingham has been stopped after a “potential suspicious bag” was found around the venue.The Utilita Arena Birmingham was evacuated and a 19-year-old man was taken into custody, West Midlands police said on Friday evening.The force said: “We are assisting with an evacuation at the Utilita Arena in Birmingham after a potential suspicious bag was found.“A 19-year-old man is in custody and as a precaution the site is currently subject of a search. We will provide further updates when we can
Spring soup and bean and cheese quesadillas: Thomasina Miers’ Mexican-inspired seasonal recipes
How to make the perfect Spanish broad bean stew – recipe | Felicity Cloake's How to make the perfect …
‘We don’t want to make the same mistakes’: Jamie’s Italian reopens in London
Willy’s, Margate, Kent: ‘It chortles in the face of small plates’ – restaurant review | Grace Dent on restaurants
Helen Goh’s springtime spinach sponge cake with cream cheese icing – recipe | The sweet spot
Why we care so much about preserving family recipes