MPs wary of move against Starmer while war is raging

A picture


A week after Labour’s election victory in July 2024, officials at Labour HQ held their first crisis meeting about the May 2026 local elections.The party had just secured a 174-seat majority and already strategists were predicting it would be very tough, though none were assuming the prime minister’s own position would be vulnerable.Now, according to multiple officials, it will be nothing short of a “bloodbath” – though it is an open question whether the parliamentary Labour party will use it to depose Keir Starmer.One Starmer ally said it would be impossible to spin the results.“There’s no point us doing expectation management, as the results are going to be terrible anyway,” they said.

“Afterwards, we need to remind everybody that this is classic midterm stuff, but worse, because the public hates the system more than ever and they see us as part of that.We need to spend every day of the next three years showing them we’re on their side.”Starmer will launch Labour’s local election campaign on Monday with a warning against risking the progress Labour is making with a vote for Reform or the Greens.That could also be a warning he hopes his MPs will heed.In the immediate aftermath of the results, there is a three-pronged strategy – to attempt to minimise the salience of the results as a judgment on the government, to remind MPs of the perilous international situation, and to distract immediately with a new king’s speech and potentially a cabinet reshuffle.

One thing Starmer has control over is the timing of the king’s speech – set for 13 May, just after the local elections,Officials are expecting parliament to be prorogued some time in late April, ahead of election day,That timing is convenient – it gives MPs less physical time together in the building to organise any coups while anger is hottest in the post-election fallout,“It would be much harder for somebody to challenge Keir and argue we need to take the government in a different direction when the king is about to come to parliament and announce our plans for the next year,” one senior government source said,Downing Street also hopes it will be clear of the next tranche of files relating to Peter Mandelson, which it hopes will be ready to release shortly after Easter.

The documents are understood to now be with the intelligence and security select committee, which will examine anything that may need to be redacted,Two senior government sources said there was also advance planning in place for a cabinet reshuffle – though one said Starmer had yet to take the final decision on whether that would go ahead,The reshuffle is not expected to result in a return to the cabinet for Angela Rayner, a key leadership rival, nor for Louise Haigh, the former transport secretary turned key soft-left critic,Rayner is not thought to be coveting any immediate return,“What has she got to gain? She’s better off on the outside.

At least she can say and do what she wants,” one ally said.Any reshuffle is therefore likely to focus more on senior cabinet ministers thought to be unhappy in their existing departments, and on promotions in the junior ministerial ranks for new MPs.It would also probably involve a shake-up of the whips’ office – dubbed the Wags’ office by MPs because so many of its members are related to current or former advisers or ministers.It has been clear for some months that MPs distrust their whips and that more experienced hands are needed there.Even if the most apocalyptic scenario happens in the May elections, the US-Israeli war with Iran has given many MPs pause for thought.

“I think everyone can see that a challenge right in the middle of a huge international crisis would look foolish,” one pessimistic minister said,“That doesn’t mean the fundamentals – that we are heading towards fourth in the polls and have the most unpopular prime minister on record – have gone away,”“Can you imagine what it would look like having a leadership contest in the middle of a global crisis?” another MP said,“Totally self-indulgent,The electorate would be right to punish us after that.

”But others said they had genuinely changed their view on whether Starmer should survive long term.“I think so far Keir is showing some obvious good judgment, both on our non-involvement in the war [and] resisting an urge to rush to judgment over whether we need to intervene to stop an energy bills crisis and keeping the language open-ended,” one senior MP said.Both Wes Streeting and Rayner have told allies in recent days that they understood MPs thought the prime minister should be able to focus on the Middle East crisis – and the economic fallout at home – and that it would be unwise to oust Starmer during it.“Both of them are self-interested enough to know that it would be fatal for them to do that,” one Starmer ally said.After May, No 10 hopes that the king’s speech will move the narrative on to how much time Labour has in power to make real change.

Insiders say the speech will focus on measures being taken to tackle the cost of living, but also, crucially, on public service reform.The next sessions will include Send reform as well as a major drive on the digitisation of public services.Investments promised in the spending review will begin to happen.Public services, several insiders said, are the barometer for people to measure how the state is functioning, where they can make simple comparisons with previous experiences – booking appointments, receiving government documents – and see whether things are improving.“There are three years left of this government,” one senior strategist sad.

“After May, we will spend a lot of time reminding people that much of what we have set in motion will start to bear fruit,”
politicsSee all
A picture

Labour has left its loyal supporters disillusioned | Letters

I wonder how many members still clinging on to the Labour party winced at Gaby Hinsliff’s article (Ed Miliband’s stock is rising because he’s a rare commodity in Labour these days: a thinker, 27 March). Like everyone else, she recognises that Labour has become an intellectual vacuum, with its only clear features being unpleasant policies designed to exploit the far right’s prejudices.But the electorate is ahead here. They know that resurrecting the once admirable but now compromised Ed Miliband will do nothing to heal the existential injury in the party. Most people no longer hark back to the halcyon days of New Labour’s claim to build a better society

A picture

EU offers UK ‘emergency brake’ on youth mobility scheme numbers

An “emergency brake” could be put on the number of people coming to the UK from Europe as part of a new youth experience scheme, under terms being offered to Britain by EU negotiatorsBritain wants an outright cap, but the EU opposes this on the basis that the scheme is supposed to be a positive one aimed at celebrating and preserving links with the EU.Keir Starmer’s government agreed to work towards a “youth experience scheme” with the EU in May last year, but the specifics are still being negotiated.The scheme is part of talks in which the EU hopes to “reset” relations with the UK amid fears negotiations have been foundering before a planned July summit.The forthcoming talks are viewed in Brussels as the start of a new phase of relations and take place as the UK will also feel knock-on effects from internal EU changes such as a new migration pact among member states from 12 June.The EU’s pact on migration and asylum – which is aimed at governing flows of migrants across Europe and governs how they will be checked at borders – is expected to have an impact on Channel crossings

A picture

‘A cruel penalty’: disabled people face lower benefit payments if conditions not deemed lifelong

Hundreds of thousands of severely ill and disabled people making new claims will have their benefits cut if the government assesses that their condition might improve, charities have said.In April, the health element of universal credit – an extra payment for people assessed as too unwell to work or prepare for work – will be halved to £50 a week and frozen for new claimants unless their condition is found to be terminal or severe and lifelong with no prospect of improvement.Ministers had pledged last summer that the “severe and lifelong” clause – known as the severe conditions criteria – would shield the most severely disabled and ill people from the new lower benefit rate.But charities and disabled people’s organisations (DPOs) have told the Guardian that a wide range of debilitating conditions may not meet the strict eligibility criteria, despite them often leaving someone unable to work. This includes multiple sclerosis, learning disabilities, bipolar, Parkinson’s, ME and long Covid

A picture

Reform insiders fear links to extreme figures such as Andrew Tate will scare off voters

Reform insiders are becoming increasingly irritated by the party’s association with Andrew Tate and other extreme online celebrities whose views are too toxic for the mainstream voters Nigel Farage needs to win over.Insiders have revealed that as Reform prepare for power they are trying to end their association with more controversial figures on the right such as Tate, whose extreme and misogynistic content could taint the party’s credibility.While courting online popularity before the party’s boom in the polls, their leader, Farage, appeared loth to criticise the online “manosphere” influencer. Tate is facing 21 charges for crimes including human trafficking should he ever return to the UK.In 2024, Farage said in online interviews that Tate was an “important voice” for the “emasculated” and giving boys “perhaps a bit of confidence at school”

A picture

Badenoch criticised for ‘peddling dangerous fantasy’ about North Sea oil drilling

Kemi Badenoch is “peddling a dangerous fantasy” about North Sea energy in her attempt to reverse a ban on new oil and gas licences, a leading campaign group has said.The Conservative leader is expected to call on the government to lift its suspension of the licences as part of a drive to reduce energy prices, as the party launches a new campaign aimed at boosting the fossil fuel sector.However, critics have questioned the efficiency of the policy, claiming it would be unlikely to cut household bills.Tessa Khan, executive director of the renewable energy campaign group Uplift described it as “vapid, political game playing at the expense of ordinary people”.“Kemi Badenoch is peddling a dangerous fantasy on the North Sea and is completely out of step with the UK public who just want an affordable supply of energy,” Khan said

A picture

Reform UK’s ‘pro-family’ policies are an exclusionary sham, minister says

Reform UK’s “pro-family” policies are a sham and exclude non-traditional families, the government’s early years minister has said before the rollout of hundreds of new Sure Start-style family centres across England on Monday.Olivia Bailey said she wanted the hubs to be inclusive for all families and transform communities, after what she called the “criminal” dismantling of Sure Start under the last Conservative government.“Sure Start is one of our proudest achievements as a Labour party,” she said. “Best Start is central to what we’re trying to do as a government. For the first time in a long time, even ever, this is a government that is really focusing on the early years and making sure that we give every child the best possible start in life