Vodafone incentivised security staff to fine its own franchisees
Vodafone incentivised its security staff to increase “clawbacks” levied on its own franchisees, as part of a programme that led to the telecoms group fining its own shopkeepers millions of pounds for seemingly small administrative errors,The policy – which included one alleged case of a £10,000 penalty for a franchisee whose mistake cost Vodafone £7,08 – involved setting “key performance indicators” (KPIs) for the telecoms group’s internal employees to collect total annual fines of £1,5m from the small business people running the FTSE 100 company’s high street stores,The existence of the fines regime has proved controversial for years and forms part of a high court claim brought by 62 former Vodafone franchisees in 2024, who allege the mobile phone company “unjustly enriched” itself by up to £85m by using tactics MPs have compared to the Post Office Horizon IT scandal.
The court filings include an allegation that Vodafone attempted “to increase its revenue” as “senior staff members were tasked with and incentivised to implement” fines, as part of a policy that the group has since tacitly admitted was flawed.In 2024, Vodafone told the Guardian: “We have made a number of changes to our formal processes and governance and made a series of goodwill payments to numerous franchisees.For example, we made the decision to reimburse £4.9m including VAT [£4m] across our franchise estate (this included retrospective reimbursement of fines and clawbacks).”However, the Guardian has seen fresh details suggesting the company had specifically encouraged its own staff to increase the fines they were collecting from franchisees – while also ring-fencing the proceeds to reduce the cost of running the company’s security department.
While the company did not deny it had set its employees targets to increase penalties on its own partners, it stressed individuals were not “financially” incentivised to hit these goals.The cost to Vodafone of investigating each individual case is understood to have been £33.20, according to former Vodafone staff members claiming knowledge of the programme, which is considerably below the £350 minimum fine given to a franchisee for a first infringement.Figures contained within an internal Vodafone document, dubbed the “consequence matrix”, go on to detail how those charges quickly ramped up: a second violation within a three-month period resulted in the forfeiture of 15% of a franchisee’s monthly commissions, rising to 30% for a third complaint.Franchisees could then suffer a reduction in the number of stores in their portfolio for a fourth complaint, while their franchise agreement could be terminated for a fifth offence during a 90-day rolling period, internal Vodafone records set out.
The matrix did not appear to discriminate between small stores and much larger outlets situated on bustling high streets or in busy shopping centres, which were likely to attract higher numbers of customers, complaints and commissions – and, consequently, fines.Some of the larger Vodafone franchise stores are understood to have earned commissions anywhere between £40,000 and £100,000 a month.The document also gives examples of possible offences that could lead to a franchisee being fined including “not checking [a] customer’s delivery address”, “providing incomplete information that leads to a customer coming back” and “not applying the correct plan or discount”.Clawbacks form only a small part of the high court claim, with the most significant area concerning an allegation Vodafone imposed “an inexplicably drastic and patently irrational and/or arbitrary cut to the claimants’ commission” when it “very substantially [preferred] its own interests without any or any proper justification, analysis, and/or process”.Many franchisees claim the move left them with six-figure debts, anxiety about losing their homes and a “massive impact” on their mental health.
A spokesperson for Vodafone, which continues to contest the high court claim, said: “We conduct regular audits across our retail estate to ensure regulatory compliance and that our customers receive the service they deserve.On occasion, we have issued penalties to ensure these obligations are met.“Fines and clawbacks are not in place to generate profit.They are designed to discourage behaviours which could lead to poor customer outcomes and regulatory non-compliance.We continue to run a successful franchise business in the UK with over 350 stores, and the majority of our partners have expanded their business with us.
”The company added that comparisons to the Post Office scandal are “wholly inappropriate”.
Winners and judges out of pocket as £20,000 writing awards appear to have closed
A competition for new writers that promised a £20,000 prize fund appears to have shut down, leaving winners and judges, including a Booker prize-winning novelist, out of pocket.Established in 2022, the Plaza Prizes last year offered 10 awards that were judged by the “finest poets and writers in the world”.However, some of the judges for the 2025 competition say they were not paid, and a number of winners say they had their entries withdrawn after being accused of using AI to create their work – allegations they strenuously denied.One judge, the 2021 Booker prize winner Damon Galgut, described the competition as a “scam” after he did not get paid for his work judging a fiction section of the annual competition.Anthony Joseph, who won the 2022 TS Eliot poetry prize, also says he was not paid for his work
Zelda taught me the importance of play – and has helped me deal with work, parenting and grief
I initially dismissed the Wind Waker’s cartoonish visuals as juvenile. But now I try to carry the game’s sense of joy into all aspects of my lifeI had a complicated relationship with video games when I was a teenager. I had straightforwardly, wholeheartedly loved the Nintendo games that I’d grown up with, tumbling around primary-coloured dreamscapes in Super Mario 64 and having the time of my life. But as I grew into a pretentious young adult in the early 00s, I started to want more from games, and I wasn’t finding it. So many of them were mindless, or juvenile, or needlessly violent
From Lee Cronin’s The Mummy to Zayn: your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead
Lee Cronin’s The MummyOut now You probably know what The Mummy is, but do you know what a Lee Cronin is? Allow us to assist: he’s the Irish director responsible for effective indie horror The Hole in the Ground and the highest grossing entry in the Evil Dead franchise, Evil Dead Rises. His version of this classic horror sees a journalist (Jack Reynor) and his wife (Laia Costa) reunited with their child who went missing in the desert eight years ago, with nightmarish consequences.The Wizard of the KremlinOut now Jude Law is, wait for it, Vladimir Putin, with Paul Dano as fictional spin doctor Vadim Baranov in a new thriller from Olivier Assayas (Personal Shopper). Based on the l’Académie française prize-winning debut novel from Giuliano da Empoli.Miroirs No 3Out now German director Christian Petzold returns with a new film (the title refers to the piano solo by Ravel) starring his regular collaborator Paula Beer as a classical piano student recuperating in rural idyll afrer a dramatic car crash
Lost Federico García Lorca verse discovered 93 years after it was written
A previously unknown verse attributed to Federico García Lorca has been discovered 93 years after the celebrated Spanish poet and playwright is believed to have jotted it on the back of one of his manuscripts.Lorca is thought to have written the eight-line poem in 1933 while working on the collection Diván del Tamarit, a homage to the Arab poets of his native Granada.The newly discovered verse was found on the reverse of a manuscript of one of the Tamarit poems – Gacela de la raíz amarga – which the flamenco singer and Lorca enthusiast Miguel Poveda bought from a German antiquarian.It has since been verified by the Lorca expert Pepa Merlo and will feature in a forthcoming book.The brief verse, composed three years before Lorca was murdered in the early days of the Spanish civil war, reveals the poet’s familiar preoccupation with the passing of time: “The clock sings / I count the hours mechanically / Seven o’clock; twelve o’clock / It’s all the same / I am not here / It is the mark of flesh / That I left behind when I departed / So as to know my place / Upon my return
Stephen Colbert on Trump’s Vatican feud: ‘Damn, the pope just read you for filth’
On Thursday night, late-night hosts weighed in on Donald Trump’s tense back and forth with the pope over the war in Iran, high gas prices and outlandish details from a new biography of Robert F Kennedy Jr.On the Late Show, Stephen Colbert focused on Maga’s escalating feud with the pope. Reacting to comments by the House speaker, Mike Johnson, that Pope Leo XIV misunderstood the concept of the just war doctrine, Colbert said incredulously:“Correcting the pope on Catholic theology is a little like going into the woods and saying: ‘Excuse me Mr Bear, do you really think this is the appropriate place for you to be pooping? Who’s going to clean that up?”Colbert went on to explain that the “just war” is a concept of Catholic doctrine that goes back to the earliest days of the church. “It must be in self-defense once all peace efforts have failed,” said the host. “Only then can the war can be said to have ‘just cause’
‘Packaging evil into something funny’: is making fun of Trump now just ‘clownwashing’?
During Donald Trump’s first term, as his lies distorted reality and gaslighted Americans, Stephen Colbert said his goal was to remind his audience: “Hey, you’re not crazy.”But watching political comedy during Trump’s second term – be it a deranged Saturday Night Live impression of a cabinet member, or a rapid-fire late-night monologue full of ICE jokes – it’s hard not to wonder: are we placating ourselves from the enormity of Trump-induced horror?It’s not a new concern, of course. Weak mockery of Nazi leaders may have allowed Germans to “let off steam” while the regime solidified its power. Decades later, as The Daily Show was taking off, some pundits feared it encouraged apathy by rolling its eyes at the political sphere. As the US inches closer to autocracy, how can comedy work against repression, rather than sanitizing its targets – call it “clownwashing”?“We are in a hyper-individualistic, transactional, consumerist kind of culture
More Britons opt to holiday in UK this summer amid uncertainty over flights
Carmakers scramble to plug £3bn shortfall for UK loan scandal payouts
Reeves rightly fears the bond market, but she can afford to ditch one unhelpful rule | Phillip Inman
As Franco Manca scales back, is the air going out of the sourdough pizza craze?
Growing knowledge, growing yield: British wine-making comes of age
Survivors of alleged sexual abuse by former owner of Harrods want enablers to face justice