‘Packaging evil into something funny’: is making fun of Trump now just ‘clownwashing’?
During Donald Trump’s first term, as his lies distorted reality and gaslighted Americans, Stephen Colbert said his goal was to remind his audience: “Hey, you’re not crazy.”But watching political comedy during Trump’s second term – be it a deranged Saturday Night Live impression of a cabinet member, or a rapid-fire late-night monologue full of ICE jokes – it’s hard not to wonder: are we placating ourselves from the enormity of Trump-induced horror?It’s not a new concern, of course.Weak mockery of Nazi leaders may have allowed Germans to “let off steam” while the regime solidified its power.Decades later, as The Daily Show was taking off, some pundits feared it encouraged apathy by rolling its eyes at the political sphere.As the US inches closer to autocracy, how can comedy work against repression, rather than sanitizing its targets – call it “clownwashing”?“We are in a hyper-individualistic, transactional, consumerist kind of culture.
So for us, entertainment is something to be consumed,” says the Los Angeles comedian and writer Jenny Yang, who is a former political organizer.“Sometimes it might spur you into action, but a lot of times it feels like a good laugh is a safety valve” – a way to release the discomfort.“There is a normalization when you take the buffoonery of something that’s actually really insidious and evil and package it into something funny.” But it doesn’t have to be that way.“The comedian’s and jester’s job is to say that the emperor has no clothes,” says Yang.
“The power of humor and the biting joke is the ability to say, ‘No, this person is not as important or powerful as you think they are.’” If a joke can cut a ruler down to size, that can ease the path toward fighting back.Perhaps that’s why Franklin Roosevelt reportedly encouraged Charlie Chaplin to make his Hitler parody The Great Dictator, released in 1940.Comedy “deflates the strongman’s image as invincible”, says Anat Shenker-Osorio, a political strategist and messaging consultant.And an authoritarian regime, she argues, depends on that image: it leaves the other pillars of society – big companies, law firms, universities – too scared to oppose it.
Comedy also draws power from its ability to reach people in ways that polemical speeches cannot.“Comedy is a way to get people to let their defenses down,” says the comedian and actor Sasheer Zamata, who recently hosted Brave of Us: How to Ridicule a Ruler, a comedy fundraiser in Los Angeles benefiting immigration organizations.The comedian Zainab Johnson agrees: “Comedians have the ability to penetrate people’s psyches, people’s hearts, their mind, their souls, because humor is disarming.”Shenker-Osorio, who organized the Brave of Us event, says comedy creates a “persuasion window” – a rare opportunity to change someone’s mind.One of the most difficult elements of persuasion is getting people “to realize that an opinion that they’ve held could possibly be wrong” – whether it’s about washing the dishes or ICE.
If you rail against Trump’s evils to your Maga uncle, he’s more likely to get defensive than to change his mind, she says,But comedy creates a permission structure that allows people to “feel safe being willing to reconsider their opinion, including being able to save face”, she says,“It’s very hard to both laugh and be inside of more calcified beliefs,”Take, for instance, the costumes worn at anti-ICE protests,“When you see that picture of the inflatable frogs and the masked, armed, camouflaged ICE agents,” says Shenker-Osorio, “it’s a little hard to maintain the story that these are essential law-enforcing people who are dealing with a crime-laden hellscape.
” Instead, it looks like “a place where people drink too much kombucha”.Another way to reach those who may not agree with you, Zamata says, is by going personal.“The comedy I do usually comes from a personal place, and talking about my experience as a woman or a Black woman, and that inherently has become political,” she says.“Just kind of existing in this country and talking about my experience can be foreign to some people.” She recalls a Trump voter approaching her after a show and telling her he’d been blown away; he hadn’t known her work beforehand.
“I didn’t feel like I was being talked down to,” she recalls him saying,“I got to learn in a safe space and not feel like I’m the enemy,”Had she just “ripped Trump to shreds”, he might have had a different reaction,“I feel like that just shuts people off, like because no one wants to be told they’re wrong,I don’t think that’s the best method of getting people to change their mind.
” Instead, her comedy often focuses on her own life and interests, which segue into the sociopolitical: a discussion of car eyelashes and truck nuts raises questions about gender in America; witnessing a creepy situation in Central Park leads to a reflection on criminal justice,Context also matters; the Brave of Us event was a case in point,Interspersed between comedy sets were appeals for action: representatives from the non-profit Haitian Bridge Alliance, Comunidades Indígenas en Liderazgo and the National Day Laborer Organizing Network gave compelling accounts of their work, and Jane Fonda took the stage to warn of the growing threat to democracy,(“Comedians are the most important people when you have a dictator, because authoritarianism and humor can’t exist in the same room,” Fonda said, citing the historian Timothy Snyder’s phrase “tactical hilarity”,) This summer, Yang is planning a comedy tour at immigrant grocery stores.
And while doomscrolling may not offer much hope, social media comedy can be potent,Cassie Willson’s videos use familiar social comedy formats – often two characters, both played by Willson, in earnest conversation or person-on-the-street interviews – to ridicule the billionaire class and systems that support it,In one clip, a billionaire offers advice: “You can’t afford groceries? Have you tried renting out your vacation home?” In another, she reflects on what she wishes she could tell her younger self: always wear sunscreen, and stop NBC’s The Apprentice before it rehabilitates the image of a failing businessman, with catastrophic consequences,“I think that if I can point out some of the ridiculous things that are happening in our government, in our economy, in our culture, and make my audience laugh, then it can make them feel like, OK, there’s space for me in this,” Willson says,Another model comes from Iran, where another oppressive regime appears to be beating Trump at his own social media game.
Using AI-generated Lego figures and faked images of Trump himself, Iranian accounts are posting clips that portray the US president as inept and self-obsessed – and have far more bite than the president’s own posts of himself pouring feces on a crowd or dressed as the pope,Of course, comedy works in both political directions; just look at the comics who helped lift Trump to victory in 2024, from Joe Rogan to Tony Hinchcliffe, who performed at Trump’s Madison Square Garden rally that October,At Trump’s victory celebration, his ally Dana White, CEO of UFC, thanked the comedian Theo Von and hailed the “mighty and powerful” Rogan, both of whom endorsed the now president,Trump “also might be one of those people who, on the low, wishes he was a comedian himself”, Johnson says,His rallies can feel like standup routines, whether he’s dressed as a garbage collector or mocking Joe Biden.
“I would argue that Trump has been very effective at using his star power for evil ends,” says Yang.Even humor that’s well intentioned can do more harm than good, as the British comedian Stewart Lee pointed out in a recent appearance on Pod Save the UK.“Personality-driven satire” – mocking the prime minister’s voice, for instance – “is a sideshow to what’s happening.It’s a useful distraction, if anything,” he said.It gives the impression of flexing the right to free speech – without having an impact.
“Instead of having a funny voice for Keir Starmer, it needs to be about Palantir and it needs to be about Amazon,” he said.“It needs to be about Jeff Bezos.It needs to be about Elon Musk” – tackling the systems in place and the people who uphold them.Rudolph Herzog, author of Dead Funny: Telling Jokes in Hitler’s Germany, has come to a similar conclusion.Jokes can distract us, be “mistaken for real resistance” or serve to simply reassure people things are OK.
Still, he wrote in Foreign Policy: “Satire and comedy can help stop the slippage toward totalitarianism – but only as long as they ruthlessly target policies, not just the vanity or quirks of the mighty.”In 2024, rightwing comedians’ elevation of Trump was arguably much more influential than late-night hosts’ jibes.And yet Trump’s own actions suggest he’s deeply threatened by liberal humor.His administration approved the Paramount-Skydance merger shortly after Paramount canceled Colbert’s Late Show; his FCC chair, Brendan Carr, put pressure on media companies to suspend Jimmy Kimmel.As Yang says: “He is threatened by anyone who can garner attention and love, and that’s entertainers and comedians.
”
Central bank bosses enlist for war game to gauge threat of Lehman-style bust
The bosses of the central banks and treasuries of the UK, US and EU are to take part in a war game in Washington on Saturday to test how they would handle the collapse of a globally significant bank.Amid growing unease over the risks to global financial stability, the most senior officials from the US Federal Reserve, the European Central Bank and the Bank of England – including its governor, Andrew Bailey – are expected to take part.In a so-called “desktop” stress test, behind closed doors in the US capital, the exercise will include the authorities wargaming how they would respond to another Lehman Brothers-style collapse.It comes as banking regulators from around the world sound the alarm over the growing risks to financial stability from AI, risky private credit lending, and potential disruption in markets linked to the US-Israel war on Iran.Finance ministers, executives and regulators discussed the potential risks as they gathered in Washington for the International Monetary Fund and World Bank spring meetings this week, including warning that the latest AI models from US tech companies could pose serious threats to financial stability
Iron will: Australia’s richest person counts the cost as court orders she share mining millions with rival family
Gina Rinehart, who’s been called Australia’s ‘female Donald Trump’, has long fought claims from the family of her father’s business partner – as well as her own childrenFull Story podcast: How Gina Rinehart lost hundreds of millions of dollars in courtAustralia’s richest person is reeling after a landmark court decision found her company must pay royalties worth hundreds of millions of dollars to a rival mining dynasty.Gina Rinehart, a multibillionaire with political connections in both the White House and the Australian parliament, has been described by members of the US conservative movement as “a female Donald Trump”. The 72-year-old, who inherited her father’s iron ore empire in Australia’s Pilbara region, has fought multiple claims against the family company Hancock Prospecting that were first launched in 2010.On Wednesday, in the Western Australian supreme court, Justice Jennifer Smith found that Wright Prospecting was entitled to its claim for a half share of royalties coming from one of the region’s largest projects – Hope Downs.Hope Downs is a joint venture between Rio Tinto and Hancock Prospecting and exports about 45m tonnes of iron ore annually from Australia’s north-west each year
Rachel Reeves to raise windfall tax on low-carbon electricity generators
Rachel Reeves is poised to raise the government’s windfall tax on low-carbon electricity generators to help limit UK household energy bills, the Guardian understands.The chancellor is ready to hike the levy introduced in 2022 to target the excess profits made by the owners of older renewable energy and nuclear plants as electricity market prices soared after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine.She could announce the plans to raise the so-called electricity generator levy as early as Tuesday, alongside a consultation on “radical” proposals to permanently weaken the link between soaring gas market prices and the cost of Britain’s electricity for the long term.Executives across the industry have been told to expect contact from officials on Monday to set out the government’s determination that electricity costs should be protected from the surge in gas markets and be set more often by cheaper renewable sources.Currently, the overall price is set by the most expensive source of power, which is usually gas power plants
Oil price drops below $90 a barrel after Iran says strait of Hormuz is open
Oil and gas prices fell sharply on Friday after Iran said the strait of Hormuz was open to commercial shipping, potentially clearing the way for tankers holding millions of barrels of oil and gas to reach the global market.Iran’s foreign minister said vessels would be free to transit the strait of Hormuz for the duration of the 10-day ceasefire between Israel and Lebanon, which was struck on Thursday.Brent crude, the international benchmark, fell more than 10% to $88.8 a barrel. That is well below a peak of $119 last month, but still much higher than the $72 before the war
Oil tumbles 10% and stock markets rally as Iran declares strait of Hormuz ‘completely open’ – as it happened
The oil price is tumbling, after Iran announced that the strait of Hormuz is now open.Crude oil has plunged by 10% on hopes that energy supplies could resume after weeks of disruption.Iran’s foreign minister, Abbas Araghchi, posted on social media that the waterway is ‘completely open’, following the ceasefire agreed between Israel and Lebanon overnight.double quotation markIn line with the ceasefire in Lebanon, the passage for all commercial vessels through Strait of Hormuz is declared completely open for the remaining period of ceasefire.Araghchi added that vessels must travel on the “coordinated route” previously announced by Iran’s Ports and Maritime Organisation
Employees at first ever Starbucks store seek to unionize amid fight for contract
Workers at the historic first Starbucks store are seeking to unionize as the coffee retail giant and its union appear stalemated over their first contract.The first Starbucks store opened in 1971 in Seattle’s Pike Place Market, and the store serves as a tourist site in Seattle.Nailah Diaz, a Starbucks barista for about five years, three of those at Pike Place, said the Pike Place store can often have lines out the door, with waits up to two hours for tourists to come inside and look around.She said workers at Pike Place are tasked with greater customer service responsibilities and the significant tourist traffic can bring about issues with disruptive customers and safety.“I myself have experienced unfair treatment, favoritism, discrimination and harassment with little to no support from management, and for me, joining this fight is me making sure that no one else has to go through what I have,” said Diaz
Growing knowledge, growing yield: British wine-making comes of age
Survivors of alleged sexual abuse by former owner of Harrods want enablers to face justice
UK’s OnlyFans tops $3bn valuation amid talks to sell stake to US investor
Finance leaders warn over Mythos as UK banks prepare to use powerful Anthropic AI tool
England run in 12 tries as Kildunne sparks demolition of Scotland in Women’s Six Nations
The Crucible holds tribute to former player and commentator John Virgo