Senior DWP civil servant blames victims for carer’s allowance scandal
One of the most senior civil servants in the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has placed the blame for the carer’s allowance benefits crisis on victims, many of whom have been left with life-changing debts.In an internal blogpost written for Whitehall colleagues, Neil Couling, the director general of DWP services, said individual failings by carers were “at the heart” of the issue that has been likened to the Post Office Horizon scandal.The post, which was removed after the Guardian made inquiries about its content, has been met with an outcry by charities and politicians.An independent review into the scandal last month found that longstanding and “unacceptable” systemic DWP leadership problems and poor benefit design were at the root of the failure, which it said could not be blamed on carers.Some carers who fell foul of the benefit’s outdated and complex rules felt so shamed, distressed and desperate they contemplated suicide, the review found.
It described being caught in the system as like being “at the whim of a faceless machine”.The review, by the disability rights expert Liz Sayce, concluded that senior DWP leaders had for a decade failed to grip or fix problems with the benefit, despite repeated warnings by whistleblowers, auditors and MPs.Couling’s post said one of the main causes of overpayments was as a result of the DWP’s “rather byzantine” guidance on the averaging of carer’s earnings.But he suggests these overpayments ultimately occurred because individual carers failed to report fluctuations in their earnings that breached benefit rules.“Incidentally what has been missed in all the [media] coverage is that this error (and hands up we made it and we will put it right) affects only a relatively small number of cases and wasn’t the cause of the original complaint.
Because at the heart of the overpayment issues in CA [carer’s allowance] is a failure to report changes of circumstances,” Couling wrote,This is at odds with the government’s own position, which accepts the DWP itself was the main cause of overpayments because of its confusing guidance and unclear reporting processes,Kirsty McHugh, the chief executive of Carers Trust, said: “This seems to be a really serious error of judgment,There has been an independent review which came up with some very clear findings,The DWP must now stand by this report and get on with returning money to carers.
”The Liberal Democrat leader, Sir Ed Davey, said: “I’m disgusted by this blogpost as it shows some senior DWP people have learned nothing about the scale of the misery their policies and procedures inflicted.It’s high time the DWP showed some respect to carers and some awareness of their own gross errors.”Emily Holzhausen, the director of policy at Carers UK, said: “To say that the heart of the matter is claimants’ fault for not reporting changes in circumstances is missing the point entirely.The root cause of this is a confusing, complex and difficult-to-navigate system, which has caused numerous errors.”The government-commissioned Sayce review was ordered after an award-winning Guardian investigation revealed how unpaid carers had been unfairly hit with draconian penalties of as much as £20,000 after unwittingly running up overpayments of carer’s allowance benefit.
The government announced in response to the review last month that it would reassess some overpayments issued to carers during the past 10 years.It estimates about 200,000 cases will be reviewed, with 26,000 likely to have debts cancelled or reduced.Sign up to Headlines UKGet the day’s headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morningafter newsletter promotionLast week, Sir Peter Schofield, the DWP permanent secretary, apologised to MPs for what ministers have called a “mess” inherited from the previous government.“I am sorry for all of those who are affected by this, but I am going to sort it out,” Schofield said.Six years ago, Schofield refused three times to apologise to MPs over carer’s allowance failures.
Although he then promised to fix the overpayment problem, 180,000 carers ran up debts of £300m on his watch between 2019 and 2025, roughly one in five of all claimants, of whom 854 were convicted of fraud.Speaking on Sunday morning, Pat McFadden, the secretary of state for work and pensions, said: “What he [Couling] said is not the position of the department.This was a longstanding problem which had been ignored by the last government, like many other things that we’re having to deal with.“We commissioned Liz Sayce to do a report on this.She came forward with recommendations and – let me be clear, on behalf of the department – we support her report.
We’re going to fix this.We’re going to fix the issues that were wrong with payments to carers.That’s the position of the department.”A DWP spokesperson said: “We have been clear, and remain of the view, that we accept the vast majority of recommendations put forward in the Sayce review, including that confusing rules on averaging earnings left carers facing unexpected debts.“That’s why we are tackling this issue and have already put in place extra staff to prevent carers building up large debts, updated internal guidance, and ensure letters to unpaid carers clearly explain what changes need reporting.
“And we will continue putting things right and rebuilding trust by reassessing affected cases, and potentially reducing, cancelling or refunding debts for tens of thousands of carers,”
China’s trade surplus hits $1tn for first time despite Trump’s tariffs – business live
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of business, the financial markets and the world economy.China’s annual trade surplus has exceeded $1tn for the first time, as the manufacturing powerhouse shrugged off the impact of Donald Trump’s trade war.New trade data today shows that Chinese factories swelled their sales to non-US markets this year, making up from a sharp drop in shipments to the US.In November, China’s exports grew 5.9% year-on-year, customs data shows
‘Zombie’ electricity projects in Britain face axe to ease quicker grid connections
Britain’s energy system operator is pulling the plug on hundreds of electricity generation projects to clear a huge backlog that is stopping “shovel-ready” schemes from connecting to the power grid.Developers will be told on Monday whether their plans will be dismissed by the National Energy System Operator (Neso) – or whether they will be prioritised to connect by either the end of the decade or 2035.More than half of the energy projects in the queue will be removed to make way for about £40bn-worth of schemes considered the most likely to help meet the government’s goal to build a virtually zero-carbon power system by 2030.The milestone marks the end of a two-year process to clear the gridlock of laggard “zombie” projects awaiting connection that meant many workable proposals were facing a 15-year wait to plug into Britain’s transmission lines.Ed Miliband, the energy secretary, said: “We inherited a broken system where zombie projects were allowed to hold up grid connections for viable projects that will bring investment, jobs and economic growth
Scores of UK parliamentarians join call to regulate most powerful AI systems
More than 100 UK parliamentarians are calling on the government to introduce binding regulations on the most powerful AI systems as concern grows that ministers are moving too slowly to create safeguards in the face of lobbying from the technology industry.A former AI minister and defence secretary are part of a cross-party group of Westminster MPs, peers and elected members of the Scottish, Welsh and Northern Irish legislatures demanding stricter controls on frontier systems, citing fears superintelligent AI “would compromise national and global security”.The push for tougher regulation is being coordinated by a nonprofit organisation called Control AI whose backers include the co-founder of Skype, Jaan Tallinn. It is calling on Keir Starmer to show independence from Donald Trump’s White House, which opposes the regulation of AI. One of the “godfathers” of the technology, Yoshua Bengio, recently said it was less regulated than a sandwich
A robot walks into a bar: can a Melbourne researcher get AI to do comedy?
Robots can make humans laugh – mostly when they fall over – but a new research project is looking at whether robots using AI could ever be genuinely funny.If you ask ChatGPT for a funny joke, it will serve you up something that belongs in a Christmas cracker: “Why don’t skeletons fight each other? Because they don’t have the guts.”The University of Melbourne’s Dr Robert Walton, a dean’s research fellow in the Faculty of Fine Arts and Music, is taking a different approach to working out whether robots can do comedy.Thanks to an Australian Research Council grant of about $500,000, he will train a swarm of robots in standup. And, at least in the beginning, they won’t use words
Standing up for Alex Carey, undoubtedly the finest wicketkeeper in world cricket right now | Brendan Foster
Just after lunch on the fourth day of the Centenary Test at the MCG in 1977, the classroom speaker at my Perth primary school crackled into life with the muffled voices of the ABC radio.Our teacher demanded we stop what we were doing because history was about to be made. Perhaps Queen Elizabeth, who was in Australia on her Silver Jubilee tour of the Commonwealth, was about to address her colonial subjects with a momentous announcement?A thunderous bluster from the tiny speaker filled the room as the teacher proudly declared that Rod Marsh had just become the first Australian wicketkeeper to score a Test century against England.The pugnacious Western Australian, who had the reckless bravery of a bare-knuckle fighter at a travelling agricultural show, revolutionised world cricket because he was the first player to be selected for Australia for his batting ability rather than his glovework. It’s a template that most cricketing nations have been copying ever since, with varying degrees of success
Packers edge Bears and Bills topple Bengals in thriller: NFL week 14 as it happened
(2-11) Las Vegas Raiders 17-24 Denver Broncos (11-2)(3-10) Arizona Cardinals 17-45 Los Angeles Rams (10-3)(9-3-1) Green Bay Packers 28-21 Chicago Bears (9-4)Big shift in the NFC with these results. LA take over at the top of the conference with an absolute rout of Arizona while Green Bay jump to the top of the NFC North above Chicago as the Bears just fall short. Goodnight!Green Bay Packers 28-21 Chicago BearsNot like this, not like this! Chicago go for it all on 4th down as Williams rolls out on the boot leg to the left but he under throws the pass straight into the arms of Keisean Nixon. Game over.Packers 28-21 Bears 0:27, 4th quarterOn 3rd down in the red zone Monangai gets the hand off but is short! Huge play by the Green Bay defense to stop him
Senior DWP civil servant blames victims for carer’s allowance scandal
Young unemployed told to engage with jobs scheme or risk benefit cuts
Gambling addicts risk losing ‘life-saving’ help due to funding overhaul, say UK charities
New US seed ban risks driving cannabis genetics underground, growers warn
Gen Z office survival guide: how to overcome telephobia and get up early
UK IVF couples use legal loophole to rank embryos based on potential IQ, height and health