Easy as ABC: voters in England tend to pick names nearer top of ballot, data suggests
Fancy your chances in politics? Then perhaps you should change your name to Aaron Aaronson or Aaliyah Aardvark, figures from last week’s local elections in England suggest.A Guardian analysis of election results compiled by the website Democracy Club points to a striking alphabet effect.In wards where a party fielded three candidates, those listed nearer the top of the ballot paper – with a surname nearer the start of the alphabet – finished ahead of their party colleagues in 2,200 cases, or 65% of the time.By contrast, candidates listed third out of their party’s list – with a surname nearer the end of the alphabet – topped their party’s slate only 382 times, or 11%.If ballot order had no relationship with performance, the figures would be expected to fall much closer to one-third in each position.
The figures show that out of the main parties in England, Reform had the strongest relationship between where candidates placed among their party colleagues, and the initials of their surname.About 74% of alphabetically advantaged Reform candidates topped their party’s vote, compared with fewer than 8% of Reform candidates nearest the bottom of the ballot paper.The Green party had the second-strongest surname effect, followed by Labour.Juliet Zhong, who unsuccessfully stood for Reform UK in Kensington and Chelsea in London, said: “In the Queen’s Gate ward, where I stood alongside my two fellow Reform UK candidates, Ms Noble and Mr Walker, all our leaflets displayed our three names together.However, the election results showed: Noble 120, Walker 115, and then Zhong (me) 102.
That is about 15% to 18% less.It makes no sense at all, as all our campaign materials featured all three of our names.”Zhong said that this phenomenon was being seen across the party.She added: “My party colleague, Henry Woodruff, also noted this in our group chat after the election.He secured 288 votes, while his wardmates trailed at 320 and 345.
It’s no coincidence that the top scorer, Andrew Barclays (345 votes), sat comfortably at the summit of the ballot paper.”She said candidates’ names should be grouped by party, rather than alphabetically, adding; “It would surely be more logical for voters to see candidates classified by their party rather than playing a game of ‘find the surname’.This would ensure a level playing field, regardless of whether a party is perched at the top or relegated to the bottom of the list.”Election-winners whose names are near the top of the alphabet are less likely to think their surname is a factor in their success.Nick Abear, a Green party candidate who was elected to the Redhill West & Meadvale Ward in East Surrey, said: “I hadn’t really considered it because I think most people know who (or which party) they are going to vote for in advance of voting.
The thought of someone turning up to vote and thinking: ‘I’ll just stick my X on the top line’ seems unlikely.”Abear did, however, get more votes than his Green party colleague Elly Heaton.Andy Adams won a council seat in Winchester for the Liberal Democrats last week, and said it was an issue he had known about for a while.“I have heard of this alleged effect before and I always regale staff at polling stations with it as I visit as the candidate, joking that I am living proof that it is by no means always true.I stood for Winchester city council 11 times and once for parliament before I was finally successful this year.
”Adams added that the effect could sometimes work: “In a very close election and at local level the numbers can be very close at times … a very long list would reasonably be expected to give rise to the effect.I would probably support randomising ballot papers in principle even if I would not stand to gain from such an innovation.”He added: “My husband is a Wiggins and whilst we decided not to double-barrel, if he were interested in politics then he would be well advised to become an Adams-Wiggins, or so it seems.”The system used across local elections varies depending on the council, with most urban areas electing three councillors for each ward, but some rural areas electing fewer.Last week, 864 wards had at least one party standing three candidates.
Another way of looking at it – looking across all wards – is to compare the average vote share each candidate got compared with the rest of their party,This shows a similar pattern: candidates with surnames near the beginning of the alphabet slightly outperformed the party average vote share, and those with surnames beginning W, Y and Z underperformed in their party,Unfortunately, the results suggest that if your name is Zebedee Zurcher, you might want to consider a career outside of politics,
Royal Opera House calls for release of Georgian bass singer jailed over democracy protests
The Royal Opera House in London has urged Keir Starmer to intervene in the case of Paata Burchuladze, a world-renowned bass singer who has been imprisoned in Georgia since October on a charge of leading a coup against the country’s authoritarian leader.The 71-year-old has performed at the Royal Opera House and the Metropolitan Opera House in New York and collaborated with the likes of Luciano Pavarotti, Plácido Domingo and José Carreras. He was arrested after joining a protest outside the presidential palace in the Georgian capital, Tbilisi. Last week he was given a seven-year jail sentence which Burchuladze suggested to the court was equivalent to a life sentence given his age.Burchuladze became a rallying figure at nightly demonstrations against the government’s perceived pivot away from the west last autumn
‘Using his Terminator voice, Arnie said: “Your song. Give it to me. Now”’: Bad to the Bone’s creation – and aftermath
Before Bad to the Bone, we just played obscure blues songs from the archives. But when we toured with the Rolling Stones, I noticed the reaction to their Start Me Up. I said: “Man, we’d better hurry up and write an original song with a catchy intro or, five years from now, people will go, ‘Oh yeah, George Thorogood – wasn’t he good at playing Chuck Berry or something?’”Bad to the Bone is a male fantasy. Let’s face it: every guy wants to be bad. We were raised on Hollywood movies and all those tough guys, like Bernardo from West Side Story, or Howlin’ Wolf – we opened for him in 1974 and he had a ferocious reputation
What is a ‘Scientology speedrun’ and why is social media suddenly obsessed with it?
Ima, if someone said “Scientology speedrun” to me I would think about Tom Cruise in tight shorts. But that is not what is happening, is it?Not quite, Cait. The Scientology speedrun appears to have spawned in March when content creator Swhileyy filmed himself rushing the Church of Scientology on Hollywood Boulevard in Los Angeles. That video gained 90m views before it was deleted.Since then, groups of mostly young men have documented themselves charging into the LA centre, pulling in millions of views on TikTok
Joseph Fiennes on parenting, politics and banning children from social media: ‘Stand up, Keir, this is your kids’ generation’
He’s played English titans from William Shakespeare to Gareth Southgate, but what does the actor really think about the country today?The Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more.We are at a corner table in a breakfast place in Chelsea, Joseph Fiennes opposite me on the banquette with his jack russell, Noa. “Dog duty,” he says, apologetic
The Guide #242: Everyday Hollywood film comedies have faded but can they make a comeback?
There was a striking moment during this week’s episode of The Rewatchables, the wildly popular film-recap podcast that I reach for when I’ve had my fill of history/football/glum current affairs pods. The episode was revisiting 90s comedy There’s Something About Mary, a film that in some ways holds up hilariously, and in others has aged about as well as a bottle of semi-skimmed on a summer’s day in Death Valley. As part of the episode, the podcast’s panel were going through their favourite comedy films by decade and were spoilt for choice – until, that is, they reached the 2020s, when they seemed to collectively draw a blank. “The Drama’s pretty funny …” one offered tentatively. Finally, host Bill Simmons cut through the umming, ahhing and awkward silence to get to the heart of the matter: “Do we have comedies any more? What happened to comedies?”Yes, what did happen to comedies? Or rather, what happened to the “everyday” American comedies like There’s Something About Mary that once set up a permanent frat house residence in cinemas? You know the ones I mean: those that took a familiar real-world situation – teens trying to lose their virginity, a man clashing with his girlfriend’s dad, a maid of honour struggling to arrange a hen do, stunted adolescents refusing to fly the nest – and stretched them to absurd and lurid extremes
Ah, ah, ah, ah - I saved my dad’s life with a little help from The Office and the Bee Gees
When my father collapsed suddenly, an episode of the US comedy in which Steve Carell does CPR to the tune of Stayin’ Alive sprung miraculously to mindIt was a boiling hot day last summer, four days after my dad’s 73rd birthday. Mum was plating up dinner and Dad was on the sofa complaining about how stifling it was. I was meant to head to work, for my job as a personal trainer, but decided to take the evening off. It was just as well: as I turned back to Mum, Dad collapsed backwards and suffered a massive cardiac arrest.Mum was hysterical
‘Hold the line’: Burnham tells allies in parliament he still has options to return
‘It’s more incrementalism’: Starmer’s safe king’s speech fails to quell mutiny
Starmer has ‘full confidence’ in Streeting despite health secretary’s allies saying he is planning to resign – as it happened
Labour politicians should put the country before their party | Letters
Labour lost the vote of small business owners like me | Letter
King’s speech might be the last word on Starmer as reluctant monarch does his duty | John Crace