Appointment of Antonia Romeo as head of civil service shows ‘poor judgment’, say former colleagues
Keir Starmer’s decision to appoint Antonia Romeo as the country’s most senior civil servant has prompted dismay among former colleagues who complained about what they considered bullying behaviour when she was a diplomat in New York.Several people who worked with Romeo at the New York consulate nearly 10 years ago have told the Guardian they are upset by the prime minister’s decision to make her cabinet secretary despite knowing about their complaints.The allegations from several colleagues were made as part of one formal complaint against Romeo in 2017.That complaint was investigated by a senior diplomat who found that she had a case to answer, but was then dismissed by her line managers at the Cabinet Office, who gave her the all clear.The complaint has resurfaced in recent days after Simon McDonald, the former lead civil servant at the Foreign Office, urged the prime minister to do more due diligence before making his decision.
Starmer put aside those objections on Thursday when he confirmed Romeo’s appointment, making her the first ever female cabinet secretary.One former complainant said: “It is pretty extraordinary but not exactly out of character for the current No 10.It is just another example of poor judgment, and the elevation of those with questionable integrity despite the concerns raised by ordinary people.”Another said: “There is a real risk this comes back to bite the prime minister.The many people she bullied and intimidated, most of them women, will now feel failed for a second time.
It’s not a good look for the civil service or the government.”A third complainant said: “Taking shortcuts to make appointments based on special treatment instead of merit and due diligence has already created chaos.This is an indication that problematic leadership decisions will persist.”Government sources have insisted that the allegations against Romeo should not be counted against her given they are 10 years old and were dismissed at the time by the Cabinet Office.Starmer defended his decision on Thursday, calling Romeo “an outstanding public servant, with a 25‑year record of delivering for the British people”.
He added: “Antonia has shown she is the right person to drive the government to reform and I look forward to working with her to deliver this period of national renewal.”Romeo said it was a “huge privilege” to become the head of the civil service.“The civil service is a great and remarkable institution, which I love,” she said.“We should be known for delivery, efficiency and innovation, working to implement the government’s agenda and meet the challenges the country faces.”Romeo’s supporters say she is dynamic and willing to break civil service conventions to achieve the government’s goals.
But her critics say she is more focused on promoting herself than the government she works for and that her impatience at more junior staff has sometimes tipped over into bullying,According to the complaint made in 2017, Romeo told several colleagues she would end or damage their careers after disagreements in the normal course of work,One allegation says Romeo warned that the refusal by a junior member of staff to comply with a particular request was a “career-limiting move” and “would only happen once”,Another who disagreed with one of Romeo’s ideas said Romeo told her she “would make sure [that person’s] reputation and career in London suffered”,Other allegations included in the complaint concerned her financial affairs.
They included her decision to get Farrow & Ball to provide more than $100,000 (£74,000) worth of paint to redecorate her residence in return for free publicity, as well as a $250 (£186) expense claim for a taxi to a football match.The allegations, which were part of one complaint, were all investigated at the time by Tim Hitchens, a former ambassador to Japan, who was flown in to conduct a week-long review.Hitchens found that she had a case to answer on her management style, but not on her financial affairs.His finding was overturned by the Cabinet Office however, which said she had no case to answer.Three complainants from the time have contacted the Cabinet Office in recent weeks to raise concerns about her previous behaviour.
Downing Street insisted on Thursday that full vetting had taken place on a previous occasion when she was considered for the job.No 10 said it had consulted the civil service commissioner, Gisela Stuart, who said the full process did not need to be re-run.
Martyn Webster obituary
My twin brother, Martyn Webster, who has died aged 86, was influential in the development of microsurgery both in the UK and internationally.In 1971 he joined the Canniesburn regional plastic surgery unit at Glasgow Royal Infirmary, one of the UK’s most respected centres for reconstructive surgery, with an international reputation as a centre of excellence, and in 1976 he became a consultant and senior lecturer there. His clinical experience covered a wide range of reconstructive procedures, especially microsurgery, head and neck surgery, hand surgery and breast reconstruction.He was a founding member of the early microsurgical societies – including the Microsurgery Travelling Club (1977) and the British Microsurgical Society (1981). He developed and directed training courses in microsurgery, and in 1986 published Free Tissue Transfer, one of the earliest books on the subject
‘It feels like a worse version of Lotto’: what Australians told us about the great intergenerational wealth transfer
Over the next two decades, economists predict that $5.4tn will be passed down from ageing baby boomers to their beneficiaries. We asked Guardian Australia readers to share their experience of giving, getting or living without an inheritance. Here is what some told us.Ash, Western Australia I don’t think inheritance should be assumed
Local reporter ‘shocked’ over picture of his face on punchbag at UK town hall
A local newspaper journalist has said he was “shocked” after a picture of his face was printed out and attached to a punchbag at a town hall.Joe McCann, who has worked for the Melksham News for 10 years, was tipped off by a contact that a print-out of his face had been attached to a freestanding punchbag inside the building.As first reported by the Melksham News, McCann raised the issue at a full council meeting on Monday, where councillors “appeared shocked”.“It has recently come to my knowledge that within this council building, there is a punchbag with my face cut out and stuck to it, with the word ‘punch me’ written at the bottom of the punchbag,” McCann told the meeting in the Wiltshire town. “I have a photo of it
Tech firms must remove ‘revenge porn’ in 48 hours or risk being blocked, says Starmer
Deepfake nudes and “revenge porn” must be removed from the internet within 48 hours or technology firms risk being blocked in the UK, Keir Starmer has said, calling it a “national emergency” that the government must confront.Companies could be fined millions or even blocked altogether if they allow the images to spread or be reposted after victims give notice.Amendments will be made to the crime and policing bill to also regulate AI chatbots such as X’s Grok, which generated nonconsensual images of women in bikinis or in compromising positions until the government threatened action against Elon Musk’s company.Writing for the Guardian, Starmer said: “The burden of tackling abuse must no longer fall on victims. It must fall on perpetrators and on the companies that enable harm
NHS to spend more to settle lawsuits over negligence during childbirth after court ruling
The NHS will have to spend more money settling lawsuits involving negligence during childbirth after a supreme court ruling that lawyers said puts right a “historic injustice”.The court ruled on Wednesday that children in England who suffer catastrophic injuries while they are being born can claim damages for future earnings they would otherwise have had.The ruling on “lost years damages” means that children whose life expectancy is shortened can recover compensation for being unable to work.It comes amid mounting concern at the rising cost of medical negligence to the NHS in England – its liabilities have hit £60bn – much of which is due to errors made during childbirth.“The supreme court today has put right an historic injustice which set injured children’s rights in negligence cases at a lesser level than those of an adult,” said James Drydale, the lawyer for a girl known only as CCC
Ketamine addiction making teenagers wet the bed, says UK’s first specialist clinic
Children are using incontinence pads and urinating in buckets next to their bed at night due to bladder problems caused by ketamine addiction, according to the first specialist NHS clinic dealing with the issue.Medics at Alder Hey children’s hospital in Liverpool have opened the first ketamine clinic for young people in the UK in response to a surge in urology problems linked to addiction of the drug.“Some of our patients start wetting the bed or find going to the bathroom at night is actually too hard, so they’ll either choose incontinence products or a bucket by the bed,” said Harriet Corbett, a consultant paediatric urologist at the clinic.“I hate to say it, but a lot of them get to the point where they’re not fussed about where they go, because the need to go overrides their desire to find somewhere private. And I suspect more of them are incontinent than are willing to tell us
How to turn any leftover fruit into curd – recipe
‘Food porn’: are sexy meal pics ruining the restaurant industry?
In a taste-test battle of supermarket mite-y bites, which will win? (Spoiler: it isn’t Vegemite)
The secret to perfect roast chicken | Kitchen aide
Cabbagecore: why are fashionable people going wild for the green vegetable?
Rukmini Iyer’s quick and easy reccipe for crispy baked gnocchi puttanesca | Quick and easy