UK’s armed forces are in a sad state – and they have only themselves to blame
George Robertson, Tony Blair’s first defence secretary, a former Nato secretary general and an author last year of the latest in a series of evasive strategic defence reviews, accused Keir Starmer on Tuesday of a “corrosive complacency towards defence”.He said the prime minister was not willing to make the “necessary investment”.Lord Robertson could have directed his fire elsewhere.He must know that no government department has been so complacent in the face of years of devastating evidence of waste, profligate contracts, and policy decisions that have avoided confronting new but increasingly clear security threats to Britain and other western countries.Mandarins in the Ministry of Defence and successive defence secretaries have failed to confront the armed forces’ top brass – senior military figures who have a vested interested in preserving the status quo and continuing to fighting the last battles, reluctant to accept new geopolitical realities and new technologies.
Critics would note that many of them have benefited from jobs in leading arms companies, perpetuating a defence lobby that has prevented them from being scrutinised effectively in Whitehall or Westminster,The sad state of Britain’s armed forces and their inability to take on current threats was illustrated by the recent photos in Portsmouth docks of HMS Dragon, the navy’s lone destroyer available to help protect British interests that would be potential targets in the conflict in the Middle East, including the RAF base at Akrotiri in Cyprus,Its crew hurriedly got the ship ready to join those of Britain’s Nato allies that had already arrived in the eastern Mediterranean, and the destroyer needed further repairs almost as soon as it arrived,Neither of Britain’s aircraft carriers and the navy’s largest and most expensive ships, the Queen Elizabeth and Prince of Wales, were available,They cost more than £6bn, well above the original estimate of under £4bn.
Maintaining and repairing the ships, hit by serious mechanical problems over their short lifespan, has already cost more than £1bn.While they may be useful in “flying the flag” on long deployments around the world, as navy spokespeople put it, they do nothing to fill the gaps in Britain’s air defence systems nearer home.Meanwhile, ministers are faced with the prospect of scrapping Ajax, the army’s planned new armoured vehicle, even though more than £6bn of taxpayers’ money has already been spent on the project.Ajax is eight years late, and its defects are so serious that vibration and noise have made soldiers training on it sick, with some suffering hearing loss.The MoD is investing billions of pounds in outdated weapons systems, including heavy tanks.
Last year, Starmer succumbed to US pressure to buy 12 Lockheed Martin F-35 fighters at a cost estimated to amount to £1bn and equip them with tactical nuclear weapons,(The prospect of a new nuclear weapons system for Britain’s armed forces was not recommended in Robertson’s defence review,)The MoD was extremely slow to confront a growing – but increasingly evident – threat from cyberwarfare and other, much cheaper instruments of warfare, including drones,Robertson accused “non-military experts in the Treasury” of “vandalism”, adding that the country could not defend itself with an “ever-expanding welfare budget”,Yet it is little wonder the Treasury is reluctant to agree to the MoD’s demands, including signing off on a repeatedly delayed defence investment plan.
The MoD has shown little sign of learning lessons or even admitting mistakes.The navy’s fleet of Astute nuclear-powered attack submarines has been repeatedly hit by mechanical problems, and a new fleet of Dreadnought submarines for Trident nuclear missiles is reported to be already facing the prospect of expensive delays.The MoD has repeatedly brushed off damning criticism of its accounting procedures and procurement projects from the National Audit Office and the Commons public accounts committee.The British defence budget for 2024-25 is approximately £60.2bn, and there are plans to increase it to £73.
5bn by 2028-29, amounting to 3.8% real-terms annual growth.The MoD says it will need an extra £28bn over the next four years to meet a shortfall and achieve “war-fighting readiness”.All the evidence suggests the MoD needs more, rather than less, scrutiny by “non-military experts” – whether in the Treasury or among those more alert to the opportunities and savings presented by modern, more adaptable weapons systems, as well as those, including intelligence agencies, responsible for foreseeing and even helping to avoid military conflict.Richard Norton-Taylor writes for the Guardian on defence and security.
He joined the Guardian in 1973 as European correspondent and was later security editor,
‘It was life-changing’: the celebrated art historian who spent 46 years sitting for Frank Auerbach
Catherine Lampert is a historian, curator and model who spent much of her time sitting for her famous friends. She tells us what the likes of Auerbach, Lucian Freud and Euan Uglow meant to herLast November, a work titled Potiphar’s Wife by British painter Euan Uglow appeared in a private sale by Christie’s in London. “We were all so excited,” says art historian and curator Catherine Lampert. “I had tried many times to find out where that picture was.” It depicts a woman lying on the ground against a blue wall, legs crossed and arms stretched out behind her to, it seems, stop a man in a T-shirt from leaving
Cultural venues in England to share £130m under Arts Everywhere scheme
More than 100 cultural venues, museums, and libraries will share £130m extra funding as part of the largest cash injection into the arts for a decade, ministers have announced.The investment forms part of the Arts Everywhere Fund, a £1.5bn package to support cultural infrastructure projects over the course of this parliament, which was announced by the culture secretary, Lisa Nandy, earlier this year. The fund aims to save more than 1,000 arts venues, museums, libraries and heritage buildings across England.On Tuesday it was announced that venues ranging from the Lowry Centre in Salford, the Hexagon in Reading and the Royal Shakespeare Company in Warwickshire will receive funding to help open up access to facilities, complete much needed building projects and upgrade technology on site
Mysterious Lake District barn joins national treasures on heritage list
It is an elite list with some of the most significant and beautiful buildings and structures in England, including Battersea power station, Middlesbrough’s Transporter Bridge and the London Coliseum.Now the Grade II* landmarks are being joined by a mysterious, limestone rubble “barn” on a grassy knoll in the Lake District, which was most recently used as a shelter for sheep and cows.The Department for Culture, Media and Sport said it was awarding listed status to a building known as Henry’s Castle on the advice of Historic England. Only 5.8% of listed buildings are at grade II* level, meaning they offer “more than special interest”
‘A cauldron of people with their tops off!’ Goldie, Estelle, Courtney Pine, Flo and more pick great moments in Black British music
For its inaugural show, the V&A’s east London outpost is celebrating 125 years of Black music-making in Britain. We asked top performers to pick their favourite exhibitGoldie: Kemistry and Storm (The Diptych) by Eddie Otchere (1995)I remember riding my bike up Camden High Street and going past Red or Dead. I saw this girl Kemi, or Kemistry. She was mixed race, like me, with blond dreadlocks. Unbelievable! We ended up going for coffee and started dating
Celebrity on celebrity: are we losing the art of the big star interview?
We live in a time where ultra-rich businesspeople have accrued more wealth and power than ever, creating a growing sentiment that they ought to be held to account, no doubt exacerbated by the fact that a wealthy businessman is in his second self-enriching term in the US presidency. So naturally, CNN, Donald Trump’s supposed nemesis, has figured out the best way to use their resources to better interrogate this elevated class: by letting them interview each other about their businesses. The 1 on 1 is named not for an actual journalist going up against a major business leader; they would probably never agree to that. So instead, CEOs can “grill” each other about whatever they mutually agree are the correct things to ask fellow elites. A spokesperson says these conversations will be “refreshingly direct”
The Guide #238: The overlooked underdogs of British quizshows that are still worth a stream
The quizshow will never die. Nuclear war could rid the earth of all living creatures bar the cockroaches and still, a shiny floored half-hourer hosted by Stephen Mulhern will somehow be airing on the emergency broadcast system. Quizshows have been airing on British screens since 1938, when a televised spelling bee was broadcast on the BBC, and they have remained remarkably resilient. Today they seem a good accompaniment to an era where everyone seems to be tapping away at puzzles on their phone.Scroll down the channel guide of your TV and it won’t be long until you find a quizshow (and that one will almost certainly be The Chase)
We need to build houses people can afford | Letters
Sussex baby deaths inquiry will fail to learn lessons after excluding families, Streeting warned
AI to predict how bowel cancer patients will respond to new NHS drug
More than a fifth of UK’s ‘austerity children’ scarred by poverty, study says
Private firms providing services to NHS made £1.6bn profit in two years, research finds
‘I just want to feel like me again’: the women still waiting for breast reconstruction years after lockdown