Private firms providing services to NHS made £1.6bn profit in two years, research finds
Private firms providing services to the NHS including healthcare and consultancy have made £1,6bn in profits over the last two years, research reveals,The findings – on the basis of contracts worth £12bn – have prompted claims of “scandalous” profiteering, concern that the health service is being “taken for a ride” and calls for ministers to impose a cap on maximum profit levels,The £1,6bn in profits made in 2023-24 and 2024-25 would have been enough to pay for 9,178 doctors or 19,428 nurses during that time, according to the Centre for Health and the Public Interest.
Its findings are based on analysis of NHS contracts in England, with 760 private firms providing services including diagnostic tests such as CT scans to patients, and treatments including hip and knee replacements, and for skin problems and mental health conditions.The thinktank found:£2bn of the £12bn of contracts went to firms with owners based outside the UK.£533m of that £2bn went to companies owned by people living in tax havens such as Jersey and the Cayman Islands.Firms, especially those owned by private equity outfits, used £353m of their £12bn NHS income to pay interest on debts.Helen Morgan, the Liberal Democrats’ health spokesperson, said: “Private companies making super-profits from our NHS is an unacceptable waste.
This money should be going on frontline services, not fattened profits for big corporations.“The NHS should be able to benefit from economies of scale and use its power as a major buyer to drive down prices.I’m afraid it looks like our health service is being taken for a ride.”The CHPI analysed contracts issued by the NHS’s 42 integrated care boards and NHS England, which oversees the service as a whole and directly commissions some specialist services, including for care, of which the NHS cannot provide enough.The thinktank did not name the 760 companies, but separate research it has undertaken shows that 28 firms earn more than £5m a year from the NHS, make profits of at least 17% and have received £4.
1bn between them over the last two years.The 28 firms include large private healthcare providers such as Spire and Circle, and consultancy firms including PricewaterhouseCoopers and PA Consulting.They also include five firms that treat eyesight problems; one, InHealth, that provides diagnostic tests; four technology and IT companies; and two electronic patient record specialists.The Labour MP Stella Creasy said: “It’s frankly scandalous that while patients wait for operations, taxpayer money is leaking out to offshore tax havens and the pockets of private equity companies through these excessive profits.We need an urgent cap on this rent-seeking and profiteering, and total transparency on where this money ends up.
”She said the NHS was not getting value for money with contracts like those the CHPI analysed because firms were making such high profit margins on them.David Rowland, the CHPI’s director, urged ministers to bring in a cap on the profits firms that provide services to the NHS can make, modelled on the 8% limit the government is legislating to introduce for children’s social care providers after similar concerns were made about providers in that sector.He said the fact that the government already capped profits that drug and defence firms that won public sector contracts could make showed that a similar system for NHS contracts was viable.The Independent Healthcare Providers Network, which represents non-NHS healthcare operators, voiced doubts about the CHPI’s conclusions.“Headline figures like this risk oversimplifying a complex picture,” a spokesperson said.
“The analysis appears to combine a wide range of companies contracted by the NHS, not just those delivering patient care, and uses a very crude approach to estimating ‘profit’ based on company-wide figures that don’t distinguish between NHS and private work.“Independent healthcare providers play a vital role in delivering care to millions of NHS patients every year and are paid on the same basis … Any surplus reflects productivity and efficiency, enabling further investment in staff, facilities and services for the benefit of patients, as well as helping to reduce waiting times.”The Department of Health and Social Care defended the NHS’s use of private firms.A spokesperson said: “The independent sector has a role to play in tackling the waiting list backlog and building a more sustainable health system.However, in working with independent providers, we will neither tolerate ‘gaming’ the national payment tariff to cherrypick the simplest, most profitable cases, nor any quality shortcomings.
Any care commissioned from independent sector providers must meet NHS standards.”
The UK needs more North Sea gas; imports from the US are the real enemy | Nils Pratley
Terrific news: despite turmoil in the strait of Hormuz, the UK will have sufficient supplies of gas to meet demand this summer, said National Gas, which operates the gas transmission system, on Monday.But contain your relief. The summer months of lower usage were never likely to be a moment of stress. Gas via pipelines from the UK and Norwegian fields in the North Sea can handle virtually all UK demand when most of the 24m households with a gas connection have their heating turned off. Little liquefied natural gas, or LNG, the stuff that arrives on ships, is needed during the summer
Oil price dips below $100 a barrel after Trump claims Iran wants deal
Oil prices have fallen back after briefly rising to above $100 a barrel as Donald Trump claimed Iran had made contact and wanted “very badly” to strike a deal in the face of his blockade of the strait of Hormuz.The Brent crude international benchmark rose above the key psychological threshold earlier in the day, at one point up 6.9% to $101.70 a barrel on news of the US president’s plan to block the waterway to Iranian marine traffic.However, it later eased back to a little over $99 a barrel after Trump said the blockade had come into force at 10am ET (3pm BST) and the Iranians had subsequently got in touch
Don’t make Marshal Foch’s mistake on AI | Letters
Emma Brockes’ article struck a chord (It’s finally happened: I’m now worried about AI. And consulting ChatGPT did nothing to allay my fears, 8 April). I am reading Marc Bloch’s Strange Defeat, in which the eminent French historian and soon-to-be-executed resistance worker gives a first-hand account of the collapse of the French army in 1940. He attributes the debacle at least in part to a failure of imagination on the part of the French general staff, who were incapable of grasping that technology, and war, had fundamentally changed since 1918.Brockes’ article suggests that we, and our leaders, are suffering from the same inability to understand that a technology which is currently amusingly alarming will develop in less amusing ways – the future Marshal Ferdinand Foch had, according to Bloch, earlier dismissed aircraft as being a toy for hobbyists and not of any military interest
Meta creating AI version of Mark Zuckerberg so staff can talk to the boss
If you are one of Meta’s almost 79,000 employees and cannot get hold of the boss, do not worry. The owner of Facebook and Instagram is reportedly working on an AI version of Mark Zuckerberg who can answer all your queries.The AI clone of Zuckerberg, Meta’s founder and chief executive, is being trained on his mannerisms and tone as well as his public statements and thoughts on company strategy.The rationale behind the project, according to the Financial Times, is that employees could feel more connected to one of the most powerful people in Silicon Valley.The Meta chief has a history of creating and experimenting with digitalised versions of himself
WNBA draft 2026: Azzi Fudd is No 1 pick; where will other top prospects land? – live updates
Flau’jae Johnson had a special guest on stage after she was selected by the Valkyries at No 8: her little brother.New Mystics draftee Lauren Betts says she can’t wait to play with Kiki Iriafen – her former teammate at Stanford and an All-Star as a rookie after being drafted No 4 last year.On UCLA’s wave of early draftees: “I want to say I’m surprised, but I’m not. … To have this night showcase all of the things we worked on all season is really amazing.”Johnson has a high upside as a player
‘Carelessly squandered’: Wisden scolds England’s tumultuous Ashes tour
The latest edition of Wisden is unsparing in its criticism of England’s Test team, describing their Ashes defeat in Australia as a “wing-and-a-prayer” campaign that ended up “feckless, reckless and legless”.Published this Thursday, the sport’s longstanding bible has a strong Indian flavour to its awards. Haseeb Hameed, captain of title-winning Nottinghamshire, is the sole Englishman among the five players of the year, with Shubman Gill, Rishabh Pant, Ravindra Jadeja and Mohammed Siraj recognised for their roles in last year’s memorable 2-2 Test series draw in England.But the nature of England’s 4-1 defeat in Australia – a tour derailed by a poor buildup, lurching tactics, and accusations of an unprofessional approach off the field – leads this year’s notes, with the editor, Lawrence Booth, saying it is “hard to think of a privilege so carelessly squandered, a chance so blithely spurned”.Booth writes: “Much of the misery was self-inflicted: from the paper-thin preparation, via a string of schoolboy dismissals, to the revelation of Harry Brook’s scrape with a nightclub bouncer in New Zealand
Goldman Sachs chief ‘hyper-aware’ of risks from Anthropic’s Mythos AI
Oil price tops $100 a barrel as US blockades strait of Hormuz; Goldman Sachs posts rise in profits – as it happened
Elon Musk’s X cuts payments to users who post clickbait
Booking.com warns customers of hack that exposed their data
Rory McIlroy says preparation at ‘home course’ Augusta aided Masters defence
County cricket: Anderson stars as Lancashire win thriller against Derbyshire – as it happened