Unions privately voice misgivings over BMA pay demands and doctors’ strikes

A picture


Trade unions have privately expressed qualms about the forthcoming doctors’ strikes in England, expressing frustration at the conduct of the talks and the demands of the British Medical Association.The BMA is pushing for a pay rise higher than the 3.5% offered to doctors by the government, with strikes planned in England next week.However, more than a million NHS staff who are not doctors – including nurses, physiotherapists, midwives, healthcare assistants, ambulance workers and hospital porters – are due to receive an even lower pay rise of 3.3%, set via the Agenda for Change (AfC) system.

The decision of the BMA to push for more than 3.5% has caused some other unions with NHS staff to be aggrieved, especially some of those with pay set via AfC.“The deals we have been able to present to our members are becoming a much tougher sell,” one senior union figure said.Another said they believed that the leadership of the union by resident doctors, rather than professional negotiators, meant the talks had been conducted in a chaotic fashion.“I think it stops from taking any kind of pragmatic approach.

”The first union source said they thought having resident doctors lead the negotiations resulted in less willingness to do a deal on pay and conditions that would affect people entering the workforce.“You need to zoom out sometimes and I don’t think they can see the bigger picture.”A third senior union source said there was “undoubtedly resentment” among unions representing NHS staff who were not doctors, and a sense that the government always “seemed more willing to listen to the doctors”, but added that the BMA was doing its job for its members by pushing for the best deal possible.Another union, the GMB, is in dispute with the BMA because of a pay offer the BMA has made to its own staff.Staff at the BMA union are due to go on strike to coincide with the six-day resident doctors’ strike on 7 April.

The BMA’s most recent pay offer to its staff of 2.75% is lower than the latest recommendation of 3.5% to resident doctors.A BMA spokesperson said: “The BMA is the trade union for doctors and medical students.Doctors have seen their pay fall by more than a fifth since 2008-09 and we’ve been very clear in recent years that our goal is to see this restored.

So this year’s award of 3.5% was never going to be acceptable as it makes no progress whatsoever at reversing these real-terms pay cuts.We are taking industrial action to achieve better for doctors.We cannot speak for other unions’ strategies or why they think it is their role to justify an inadequate government pay award to their members.“In talks with the government, the BMA is represented by elected resident doctor leaders, alongside expert BMA staff from the BMA, bringing together invaluable on-the-ground insight from working doctors and professional negotiating expertise.

“Doctors are in a very different position to our staff,They have experienced far greater cuts in their pay in real terms since 2008 as well as a deterioration in their overall working conditions,Whilst the UK is losing doctors because pay is so low, we have very competitive pay and benefits at the BMA, extremely good staff retention and very low rates of turnover,”NHS staff under the AfC deal are yet to begin talks about the wider structure of their pay, and their unions are likely to push for reform to pay scales,A recent Unison analysis of NHS data for England over three years shows no marked improvement, and a decline in some cases, in pay satisfaction levels for workers on AfC contracts.

Medical and dental staff are the only group where pay satisfaction levels have risen to any extent, with an 18-percentage-point increase since 2023.Unison said these findings demonstrated how many NHS employees continued to feel undervalued and that nothing had changed under the new government.This article was amended on 6 April 2026 to clarify that the doctors’ strikes are scheduled in England only.
A picture

Oats, sardines and crisps: emergency foods to stockpile – and why you should share them

People should have an emergency stockpile of food in their homes in case conflicts, extreme weather or cyber-attacks shut down supplies, leading UK experts have told the Guardian.In an ever more turbulent world, they say it is essential to choose long-life items that can be eaten without cooking – think tinned beans, vegetables and fish, rice crackers, and oats that can be soaked. But it is also important to choose items you actually like to eat, and some treats such as chocolate or crisps to keep your spirits up. You will also need water – lots of it – not just to drink but for washing too.Perhaps the most surprising advice is to be prepared to share your stockpile with neighbours

A picture

Reese’s chocolate heir accuses Hershey of altering recipes: ‘It wasn’t real peanut butter’

The grandson of HB Reese, the inventor of Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, has accused the chocolate giant Hershey of faking a pledge to investors to switch back the recipes of its popular products – including KitKat – to the original milk and dark chocolate ones.A confectionery-focused dust-up between Brad Reese and the $42bn Pennsylvania-based company began in February when Reese, 70, accused the company of “quietly replacing” the ingredients – or “architecture” – in his grandfather’s invention with cheaper “compound coatings” and “peanut-butter-style crèmes”.At a recent Hershey investor conference, the company said it would change about 3% of select products to the original recipes but maintained it had never altered the renowned Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups.The company’s chief growth officer, Stacy Taffet, said Hershey was “transitioning our sweets portfolio to colors from natural sources, and ensuring that all Hershey’s and Reese’s offerings are consistent with their brand’s classic milk and dark chocolate recipes”. The changes are planned to come into effect by next year

A picture

Put away the Aperol and raise a glass to Hugo spritz, the drink of the summer

Pub gardens and bar terraces have been awash with a sea of orange in recent years as Italy’s love of Aperol spritz spread to the UK. But this year the cocktail’s cousin, a Hugo spritz, will be the drink of the summer, according to supermarkets and bars.It is already being served across the country, including at Sea Containers on the banks of the Thames and Mayfair’s swanky Claridge’s hotel in London, 20 Stories bar in Manchester and the Bridge Tavern in Newcastle. Wetherspoons has the cocktail on its menu nationwide.“In the past year, we have noted that there has been a wider shift among our guests towards drinks with lower alcohol percentages, particularly during the day – a Hugo spritz fits rather neatly into this space,” said George Raju, director of bars at Claridge’s

A picture

Helen Goh’s recipe for ricotta, rum and raisin cake | The sweet spot

This is a cake for the long, ambling tail-end of an Easter lunch. It’s gently scented with orange and vanilla, lightened by ricotta, and studded with rum-soaked raisins that bring bursts of sweetness to each slice. Ideally, they’d be soaked overnight to plump them into something luscious, but if time gets away from you, take a shortcut: put the raisins and rum in a microwave-safe bowl, zap for 20–30 seconds, then leave to cool and absorb. The chocolate glaze is optional; on days when you want something simpler (or lighter), a generous sifting of icing sugar is all this cake needs. Serve with a small glass of grappa or something similarly warming for a quietly perfect way to bring a feast to a close

A picture

Cocoa-crazy: chocolate-infused liqueurs deserve their own moment

Among my minor childhood traumas was the time my dad returned from a business trip to Belgium with a smart box of assorted chocolates (cue tiny violins). Expecting caramel, I bit into a truffle and was met by an explosion of very boozy liqueur. The box seemed to be an exciting change from the usual duty-free Toblerone, but after this incident, truffle assortments have always struck me as deeply unsafe. (I have tried liqueur-filled chocolates since, but still remain flummoxed by them.)The Guardian’s journalism is independent

A picture

Baked cheesy smoked haddock and lemon icebox pudding: Henry Harris’ alternative Easter lunch

Sometimes all you want is a hot, bubbling dish and a spoon, and for me today’s cheesy haddock is that dish – a 15-minute supper to be enjoyed in front of the telly with a salad or a large bowl of hot buttered peas. Add a lemony, biscuity iced dessert, and you have a light, very easy and enjoyable supper that’s almost the perfect close to a long Easter weekend.Choose your smoked haddock carefully: you want large, thick fillets of undyed fish. Stating the obvious, here, but a good fishmonger will have this; a supermarket never. The creme fraiche must be a French, naturally soured cream, too, becausethe cheaper English versions coagulate when heat is applied, resulting in an unpleasant, watery gunk