Greens’ ‘undeliverable’ promises will let voters down, says Labour minister
The Green party is offering “simple solutions to complex problems” and making “undeliverable” promises to voters ahead of the next election that could leave them disappointed, the prime minister’s chief secretary has said,Darren Jones, one of Keir Starmer’s most powerful ministers, said the resurgent Greens were “a bit like the populist left version of the populist right” of Reform UK, and that both were in danger of letting down voters,Labour has fallen to record lows in the polls, losing support to parties on its progressive wing as well as to Reform,A YouGov poll this week put it just four points ahead of the Greens, which were on 16%, more than double the 6,7% share the party won at the last election.
As Starmer returns from the Cop30 climate summit in Brazil, his government has been divided over how loudly to champion its green agenda given concerns about rising energy bills and increasingly unified opposition on the right to net zero targets.Jones insisted Labour was not rowing back from its green promises.“I can reassure people that’s not the case,” he said, citing the government’s funding of renewables and insulation.“Let’s be honest, a few years ago, there was a global consensus around net zero.There’s not now.
So it’s contested space, but Britain continues to lean into that debate,”He said that Labour had to prove to people that it was a “modern party facing the future, delivering for modern Britain” to win back progressive voters, a shift in its previous strategy of pitching to the right to prevent them going to Reform,He said he understood how younger Britons, in particular, might feel the economic system was not delivering for them, but that they would be “disappointed” by the failure of populist parties including the Greens – whom he beat into second place in his Bristol North West seat,“[The Greens] are a credible player now in the five-party system that we have right now, based on polling,” he said,“It’s their responsibility to explain to people how they would actually choose what to do if they were in government, as opposed to just promising things that are undeliverable.
“My criticism of them, much like with Reform, is that they’re offering simple solutions to complex problems and that’s failing people.They’re a bit like the populist left version of the populist right.“We have to make the case for being a new, modern party of the future, and not just part of the old status quo.What I don’t want is young people, in particular, thinking: ‘I want something different to the current economic circumstances and therefore I’m going to vote for a party that is new.’“They will be disappointed, because they’re not going to get the change they want by voting for the populist left or the populist right.
”Jones said Labour could not count on progressive voters coming back to them at the next election to keep out Nigel Farage, even though recent polling suggests they could vote tactically.“I don’t assume that at all.We have to work hard to win every single vote.”He argued the next election would be a fight between Labour and Reform, which presented a “very grave” decision for the country.“We’ve never been in a position where you could go down that populist right path, and we all have an obligation across centre and progressive politics to say that we don’t want that here.
”He admitted that the prospect of Labour failure paving the way for a Farage-led government kept him up at night,“Yes, because we can’t allow that to happen and we won’t allow that to happen,”Before Rachel Reeves’s budget later this month, at which she is preparing to increase income tax, the chancellor’s former No 2 defended breaking manifesto commitments if necessary,“You make manifesto commitments because they’re important,You wouldn’t make them lightly, but equally, if you’re in government, you’ve got to be frank with the public about the trade-offs in the situations that you have and take the right decisions for the country, even if that makes you unpopular,” he said.
Privately, cabinet ministers have told the Guardian that they would only accept a tax rise if there was also something tangible that benefited the public.“Of course, we’d want to end up in a position where people across the country can see that we are helping with the cost of living pressures.”In his new post, Jones, who is based in Downing Street and the Cabinet Office, is responsible for delivery across government.He said that Labour had to be much bolder about reforming failing public services.“What we can’t do is continue to defend the status quo where they’re not performing.
Previous attempts to incrementally improve the current system have not proven to be good enough and so we’ve got to think much more radically,”He admitted that, over time, AI would replace some civil service jobs,“We’re working with the very old structures of the state that are not fit for the modern age and the public are losing out as a consequence of that,So yes, over time, civil service headcount will reduce,”He is jointly responsible for digital ID, with it due to be introduced for right-to-work checks – the only part of the system that will be mandatory – before the next election.
At the same time, legislative and technological work will take place to prepare for a wider expansion,Much of the system will be built in-house, with external operators consulted for things such as banking levels of security,Since Starmer announced the government would bring in digital ID, public support for it has plummeted, to the alarm of ministers,“There’s been a lot of disinformation online … that says what this actually is, is surveillance,I mean, it’s just not, and we would never build a system in that way.
”Jones admitted next May’s local elections, which are felt inside No 10 to be a moment of peril for Starmer, would be tough.“Governing parties don’t do well in midterm elections, that’s just a fact,” he said.But he denied it would be a make-or-break moment for Starmer.He did not deny, when asked, that he had leadership ambitions of his own.“I’ve got multiple big jobs that I’ve been in for a couple of weeks and I’m not planning on going anywhere anytime soon,” he said.
Boris Johnson trying to undermine BBC leadership, insiders fear after leak
Boris Johnson and figures linked to him are engaging in an effort to undermine the BBC’s leadership, insiders fear, after the leaking of a memo criticising its reporting of Donald Trump, trans rights and Gaza.Tim Davie, the BBC’s director general, and other senior editorial staff are under pressure after the criticisms made in the document by Michael Prescott, a former independent external adviser to its editorial guidelines and standards committee (EGSC).Parliament’s culture, media and sport committee has demanded to know the BBC’s response to the memo, setting Monday as a deadline. The BBC’s board is compiling its response.However, insiders believe the leaking of the memo to the Daily Telegraph and the criticisms that have followed from Johnson are part of a concerted attempt to undermine the organisation, which is heading into crucial talks with the government over the renewal of its charter
Greens’ ‘undeliverable’ promises will let voters down, says Labour minister
The Green party is offering “simple solutions to complex problems” and making “undeliverable” promises to voters ahead of the next election that could leave them disappointed, the prime minister’s chief secretary has said.Darren Jones, one of Keir Starmer’s most powerful ministers, said the resurgent Greens were “a bit like the populist left version of the populist right” of Reform UK, and that both were in danger of letting down voters.Labour has fallen to record lows in the polls, losing support to parties on its progressive wing as well as to Reform. A YouGov poll this week put it just four points ahead of the Greens, which were on 16%, more than double the 6.7% share the party won at the last election
Lammy promises ‘tough new release checks’ as missing prisoner arrested – as it happened
Justice secretary David Lammy has commented on the arrest of Brahim Kaddour-Cherif.“We inherited a prison system in crisis and I’m appalled at the rate of releases in error this is causing. That’s why I’ve ordered tough new release checks, launched an investigation, and started overhauling archaic prison systems,” he posted on X.Shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick earlier tweeted a graph showing the increase in mistaken releases of violent and sexual offenders this year.In a reply to Lammy, Jenrick said: “That’s one down - where are the other 262 prisoners that have been accidentally released? And how many prisoners have been mistakenly released this year? Calamity Lammy is hiding an even bigger scandal
Nicola Sturgeon: I understand why people doubt my ignorance of alleged SNP embezzlement
Nicola Sturgeon has said she fully understands why many people find it hard to believe she had no idea about alleged embezzlement within the Scottish National party given the close links to her domestic life, but has insisted this is the case.Speaking to the Guardian’s Politics Weekly UK podcast, the former Scottish first minister said her relaxed demeanour in the period directly after she stepped down as first minister, weeks before police searched the home she shared with her then husband, Peter Murrell, would have been impossible if she had suspected things were amiss.Sturgeon announced her departure in February 2023. In April that year, Murrell was arrested, with police searching the Glasgow home the couple shared, as well as the SNP’s headquarters in Edinburgh. Officers also seized a motorhome parked outside Murrell’s mother’s house in Fife
Kemi Badenoch to relaunch exclusive ‘advisory board’ for high-value donors
Kemi Badenoch is relaunching the Conservative party’s “advisory board” for high-value donors in a different guise, the Guardian has learned.The Tory leader has drawn up plans to reinstate the exclusive group, which provided top donors with regular direct access to senior ministers, according to two people briefed on the plans.In 2021, the Conservative party’s advisory board found itself at the centre of a “cash for access” storm after it emerged that its members had regular meetings and calls with Boris Johnson, the prime minister at the time, and Rishi Sunak, the then chancellor.One donor, Mohamed Amersi, told the media that some members of the board had given the party upwards of £250,000 a year. It was quietly wound up in subsequent years after the controversy
Nandy breached code over appointment of donor to lead football regulator
Lisa Nandy, the culture secretary, has apologised to Keir Starmer after an inquiry found she failed to say that her choice of nominee to lead a new football regulator had donated to her and to Labour before she nominated him for the role.Nandy said she regretted the errors highlighted in a report by William Shawcross, the commissioner for public appointments. Her apology comes a week after the chancellor, Rachel Reeves, made her own written apology to the prime minister for failing to obtain a licence before renting out her family home.In a letter to Nandy, Starmer said he accepted the apology, but noted that the process to appoint the media executive David Kogan “was not entirely up to the standard expected” and said her department could learn lessons from it.The reprimand does not affect the role of Kogan, whose long career in sport and media has included negotiating TV rights deals for the Premier League and the English Football League
How to turn the dregs of a tin of golden syrup into a delectable toffee sauce – recipe | Waste not
Mirepoix kimchi and vegetarian umami chilli: Kenji Morimoto’s recipes for cooking with homemade ferments
The many uses of leftover chutney, from breakfast to soups and glazes | Kitchen aide
Divine dining: Australian church restaurants claim their own devout followings
How to make rotis – recipe | Felicity Cloake's Masterclass
Pancakes, cheesecakes, dips, breads, mousses and … ice-cream? 17 mostly delicious ways with cottage cheese