‘Bizarre’ lack of urgency in putting UK on war footing, says defence review co-author
A co-author of Britain’s strategic defence review has joined criticism of Keir Starmer’s leadership on military policy, warning of a “bizarre” lack of urgency in defence planning.Fiona Hill, a former chief adviser to the White House on Russia, echoed the concerns of George Robertson, her co-author with Gen Richard Barrons on the strategic defence review (SDR), over what he had called the prime minister’s “corrosive complacency”.Robertson, a peer and former head of Nato, has publicly aired his frustration at the government’s failure to come forward with its 10-year spending plans for defence following publication of the SDR last June.He is due to elaborate further on Tuesday night in a speech in Salisbury, Wiltshire, where he is expected to accuse “non-military experts in the Treasury” of “vandalism” and warn that “we cannot defend Britain with an ever-expanding welfare budget”.However, the suggestion that public spending cuts may be necessary to fund defence prompted Diane Abbott, the Labour MP, to accuse Robertson of putting “guns before butter”, adding that Labour would lose votes to the Greens if Starmer followed the peer’s advice.
“We have already slashed foreign aid, and to cut welfare to spend on armaments is appalling,” she said.“People are going to start to wonder why they are voting Labour in the first place.It is not going to help us electorally.”But speaking to the Guardian, Hill, who worked for Donald Trump in his first term, said she also believed No 10’s lack of urgency in putting Britain on a war footing was “bizarre”.Hill said that Robertson was “basically just trying to say, we need to have more movement now.
If you get that sense of urgency then action will follow but we don’t have the sense of urgency, which is kind of bizarre really given everything that’s happening …“What George is saying, very bluntly, is there is basically a lack of resolute leadership on this.Because everybody’s worried about votes and, you know, reactions, and all of this on the left and on the right.“The political situation, you know, for the [Labour] party, is not good, but as George has been saying, this is a UK strategic defence review and, frankly, if anybody wants to make political points, I would suggest that it’s shame on them.Big time.”She added: “I think we can see [the risk], just look at what is happening in the Gulf.
You think we couldn’t get a nice drone on the Shard [building in London]?“And also, how many British assets are in the Gulf, not just expats and people working there but companies, hotel chains,Cyprus has been attacked, the airbase there,Diego Garcia,We have already had sabotage and poisonings,Why wouldn’t Iran do similar things to Russia?”Barrons told the BBC’s Today programme: “There’s an enormous gap between where we have to be to keep the country safe in the world we now live in, and where we actually are.
”“The US cavalry is not coming to bail us out now,” he said, adding that the Royal Navy and Royal Air Force were “undernourished”,Hill said the government’s failure to come forward with its spending plans for defence was leading to a loss of confidence within the British defence sector and among interested financial investors,She said: “Companies that are British, that have really important armaments and other equipment, are not getting the orders and so they are looking elsewhere and some are folding,“The City has been standing by – George and Richard have been constantly talking to them – getting ready to put together investment funds and things but if there is no signal from the Ministry of Defence then they will go and do deals with the US, which is always what happens,“And you can’t be buying American all the time, given what is happening with the war in Iran, and the US saying that it doesn’t have enough production to meet its needs.
The UK is going to miss out.”Hill said there was a wider problem that the government had yet to tell the country it needed to build civil defence and resilience in case of war.John Hutton, a former defence secretary, said he believed the UK had 18 months to show it was properly financing its defence if it were to deter Vladimir Putin from making a military move against British interests.He called on the chancellor, Rachel Reeves, to use the flexibility in her fiscal rules to borrow more for defence, as Germany had done.Hutton said: “I think there’s a significant gap in our credibility in Nato to provide a conventional deterrence to any possible Russian aggression, which I think is now more likely to happen than not.
”Tan Dhesi, the Labour MP for Slough, who chairs the cross-party Commons defence select committee, said he was concerned that Robertson had pinpointed the Treasury as being to blame for the delay on announcing the spending plans, and accused its ministers of avoiding appearing before his members.He said: “Lord Robertson’s public intervention is sobering.It is damning that a man of his stature and experience has to speak out publicly to get his message heard.When it comes to defence, the government’s rhetoric promising action does not yet align with reality.“The continuing delay to the urgently needed defence investment plan grows of more concern every day.
“Lord Robertson has pointed at the Treasury as a blocker,Treasury ministers have repeatedly refused to appear before the defence committee, giving every impression that they are trying to avoid accountability,”A government spokesperson said the SDR was “backed by the largest sustained increase in defence spending since the cold war, with a total of over £270bn being invested across this parliament”,
UK’s armed forces are in a sad state – and they have only themselves to blame
George Robertson, Tony Blair’s first defence secretary, a former Nato secretary general and an author last year of the latest in a series of evasive strategic defence reviews, accused Keir Starmer on Tuesday of a “corrosive complacency towards defence”. He said the prime minister was not willing to make the “necessary investment”.Lord Robertson could have directed his fire elsewhere. He must know that no government department has been so complacent in the face of years of devastating evidence of waste, profligate contracts, and policy decisions that have avoided confronting new but increasingly clear security threats to Britain and other western countries.Mandarins in the Ministry of Defence and successive defence secretaries have failed to confront the armed forces’ top brass – senior military figures who have a vested interested in preserving the status quo and continuing to fighting the last battles, reluctant to accept new geopolitical realities and new technologies
Reform activist suspended over racist and antisemitic comments remains election agent
A Reform UK activist in the Gorton and Denton byelection who was suspended over racist and antisemitic comments has been named as the election agent for three of the party’s candidates in Manchester ahead of polls on 7 May.Adam Mitula, an interim campaign manager in the Tameside area, confirmed in February that he had been suspended as a party member “pending investigation”.It came after evidence was published that appeared to show he posted a highly offensive racial slur aimed at black people, and also made what appeared to be a derogatory remark about Jewish women.A notice of election document published last Thursday shows that Mitula is now the election agent for Reform candidates standing in three wards in the Tameside area: Aron Webb, Audra Murray and Daniel Bennett.Mitula also appeared to have agreed with a Holocaust denier that the number of Jewish people murdered by the Nazis had been exaggerated
Starmer’s ‘corrosive complacency’ on defence has put UK in peril, says ex-Nato chief
The government has shown a “corrosive complacency towards defence” and put the UK in peril, according to a government adviser, in fierce criticism of Keir Starmer’s military policy.George Robertson, the former Nato secretary general and author of the government’s strategic defence review, believes Starmer is “not willing to make the necessary investment”, the Financial Times reported.In addition, Lord Robertson will warn in a lecture in Salisbury on Tuesday that the Iran war “has to be a rude wake-up call”.The former general Richard Barrons, who co-authored the defence review with Robertson, echoed his concerns. “It is a mark of how serious it is that someone who has been a Labour party activist for more than 60 years and was a Nato secretary general has now had to say it in these terms today,” Barrons told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme
Renewed ties with EU needed to boost UK security and economy, says Starmer
The economic and security benefits of a closer relationship with the EU are “simply too big to ignore”, Keir Starmer has told parliament as the British government prepares for more rapid alignment with European rules.Updating MPs on the Iran conflict and his visit to the Gulf last week, the prime minister was explicit about what he argued was the need for renewed ties with Europe given the chaotic global situation and Donald Trump’s unpredictable US administration.The Guardian revealed that ministers were planning to use so-called Henry VIII powers to dynamically align with EU rules by default, including the adoption of changed EU single market rules without full parliamentary scrutiny each time.Setting out what he said were the lessons of the Iran crisis, Starmer said that after Brexit, Covid and the Ukraine war the idea of a global shock to UK living standards was no longer “a novel experience”, and that lessons should be learned.This time, he argued, the response “must and will be different to reflect the changing world that we live in”, saying this included efforts to reduce energy bills
Nige and Zia set out plan to send ‘Boriswave’ traitors to the gulag | John Crace
The Reform UK press conference began a little behind schedule. Time in which Nigel Farage had gathered Zia Yusuf and a few others into a circle for a two-minute silence. A moment to reflect on the sad news from Hungary that Viktor Orbán’s 16 years as prime minister had come to a premature end. Orbán had had so much more to give the world. There would be no one left in the EU to block the €90bn loan to Ukraine
Shabana Mahmood says Southport inquiry report exposed ‘systematic failures across multiple public sector organisations’ – as it happened
In the Commons Shabana Mahmood, the home secretary, is making a statement on the first report from the Southport inquiry, published today.Mahmood says she will be not using the name of the perpetrator, or dwelling on what happened.She says the report has exposed systemtic failings.double quotation markThe findings of the inquiry are unsparing. Sir Adrian [Fulford] has uncovered systematic failures across multiple public sector organisations
Cornichon shortage leaves British sandwich shops in a pickle
Rukmini Iyer’s quick and easy recipe for chilli eggs with miso beans and spinach | Quick and easy
The US small town coffee shop that created a viral drink: ‘I still don’t understand how it went so far’
Simpson’s-in-the-Strand, London WC2: ‘A rollicking list of cosy British joys’ – restaurant review | Grace Dent on restaurants
Benjamina Ebuehi’s sweet and salty chocolate chip cookies recipe | The sweet spot
Gentleman’s Relish is toast after its maker axes the pungent anchovy spread