Meta and YouTube designed addictive products that harmed young people, jury finds
Meta and YouTube have been found liable for deliberately designing addictive products that hooked a young user and led to her being harmed, a jury ruled on Wednesday.Jurors found the tech companies to be both negligent and having failed to provide adequate warnings about the potential dangers of their products.The jury awarded the plaintiff in the case damages of $6m, with Meta to pay 70% and YouTube the remainder.It took nearly nine days of deliberations for the Los Angeles jury to reach its verdict.This lawsuit, over social media’s alleged harm to young people, was the first of its kind to go to trial.
Over the course of the six-week trial, which took place in Los Angeles superior court, jurors heard from top executives at Meta and YouTube, whistleblowers, expert witnesses on social media and addiction, and a 20-year-old woman at the center of the lawsuit, who has gone by the initials KGM for court proceedings.KGM testified that she became addicted to YouTube at age six and Instagram at nine, which she said had deleterious effects on her wellbeing.By age 10, she said, she had become depressed and was engaging in self-harm as a result.Her social media use allegedly caused her to have strained relationships with her family and in school.When she was 13, KGM’s therapist diagnosed her with body dysmorphic disorder and social phobia, which KGM attributes to her use of Instagram and YouTube.
“How do you make a child never put down the phone? That’s called the engineering of addiction.They engineered it, they put these features on the phones,” Mark Lanier, KGM’s lawyer said during closing arguments last week.“These are Trojan horses: they look wonderful and great … but you invite them in and they take over.”KGM’s lawyers say her experience is emblematic of what tens of thousands of young people have faced on social media and in their offline lives.“Today’s verdict is a historic moment – for [KGM] and for the thousands of children and families who have been waiting for this day,” KGM’s lawyers said in a written statement on Wednesday.
“A jury of [KGM’s] peers heard the evidence, heard what Meta and YouTube knew and when they knew it, and held them accountable for their conduct,Today’s verdict belongs to [KGM],”The plaintiffs’ arguments mirrored those brought against big tobacco in the 1990s, which focused on cigarettes’ addictive qualities and companies’ public denials despite knowledge of their products’ harms,They alleged some of the features that social media companies built into their platforms, such as an infinitely scrollable feed and video autoplay, are designed to keep people on the apps and have made the products addictive,To come to its liability decision, the jury was asked whether the companies’ negligence was a substantial factor in causing harm to KGM and if the tech firms knew the design of their products was dangerous.
The 12-person panel of jurors returned a 10-2 split answering in favor of the plaintiff on every single question,The jury’s verdict comes just one day after Meta was ordered to pay $375m in civil penalties in a separate lawsuit in New Mexico,In that case, the jury found the company misled consumers about the safety of its platforms and enabled harm, including child sexual exploitation, against its users,The back-to-back verdicts are the first ever to find Meta liable for how its products affect young people,Meta has said it will appeal the rulings in Los Angeles and in New Mexico.
In response to the California case’s verdict, a spokesperson for Meta said the company is confident of its protection of teens online.“We respectfully disagree with the verdict … Teen mental health is profoundly complex and cannot be linked to a single app,” the spokesperson said.A YouTube spokesperson, José Castañeda, said the video service also disagrees with the verdict and plans to appeal.“This case misunderstands YouTube, which is a responsibly built streaming platform, not a social media site,” he said.Both companies have consistently denied wrongdoing.
YouTube has called the allegations that were brought “simply not true” and Meta has said that KGM’s mental health issues were brought on by a difficult home life and social media use was not to blame.This trial is the first in a consolidated group of cases brought in California against Meta, TikTok, YouTube and Snap on behalf of more than 1,600 plaintiffs, including more than 350 families and 250 school districts.TikTok and Snap settled the KGM lawsuit just before trial.KGM’s case is also the first of more than 20 “bellwether” trials, which are slated to go to court over the next couple of years and are used to gauge juries’ reactions as well as set legal precedent.The next bellwether case is scheduled to go to trial in July.
A separate series of federal lawsuits with hundreds of plaintiffs making similar allegations is slated to start trial in San Francisco in June.
Next says Middle East conflict could raise clothing prices by up to 10%
The boss of Next has said clothing prices could rise by 4% to 10% if conflict in the Middle East extends into the autumn and factories are hit by higher fuel and fabric costs.Simon Wolfson said the clothing and home retailer had so far seen little disruption to its supply chain.While container ships are being delayed by up to two weeks as they travel slowly to save fuel, he said the company already held enough spare stock to prevent gaps on shelves.He said these costs could amount to £15m if the conflict lasts three months and prices could begin to rise by about 1% from June or July if disruption dragged on until then.Lord Wolfson added that Next was offsetting additional costs on fuel and air freight with savings elsewhere and it did not expect any effect on profits for the year ahead
There are solutions to Britain’s energy crisis | Letters
The Iran war has exposed the cost of successive governments’ fixation on short-term, vote-winning policies, leaving Britain increasingly vulnerable to strategic coercion, particularly in energy (The UK sleepwalked into this energy price shock, 23 March).British companies currently lead a new, technologically proven, job-creating industry which, had it been supported earlier, would have strengthened security of supply and reduced costs. It is tidal stream energy.Britain has about 50% of Europe’s tidal resources, all within our territorial waters and flowing at different times. It is predictable, inexhaustible and can be operational within three years of consent, independent of global energy prices and weather variability
Google warns quantum computers could hack encrypted systems by 2029
Banks, governments and technology providers need to be prepared for quantum computer hackers capable of breaking most existing encryption systems by 2029, Google has warned.The tech company said in a blogpost that quantum computers would pose a “significant threat to current cryptographic standards” before the end of the decade and urged other companies to follow its lead.The company, owned by Alphabet, said: “The encryption currently used to keep your information confidential and secure could easily be broken by a large-scale quantum computer in coming years.”As it stands, quantum computers – which can rapidly carry out complex tasks – are a nascent technology with great potential and significant obstacles to being widely usable.Google, Microsoft and universities across the UK and the US are in the midst of building systems that harness the physics of quantum mechanics to perform extremely sophisticated mathematical calculations
Starmer vows to tackle social media’s ‘addictive features’ to protect children
Keir Starmer has said he will tackle “addictive features” in social media amid increasing signs the UK government is preparing to crack down on risks to children after a US court verdict that held Meta and YouTube responsible for harms caused by designing addictive technology.The prime minister said the verdict in a California court signalled a rising public expectation for more aggressive regulation and said: “I’m absolutely clear that we need to go further.”“The status quo isn’t good enough,” he said. “We need to do more to protect children. That’s why we’re consulting about issues such as banning social media for under-16s
Prem Rugby introduce minimum salary floor of £5.4m for clubs next season
Prem Rugby will introduce a minimum salary floor of £5.4m for each club next season as part of a long-term plan to increase competitiveness. The Rugby Football Union Council voted last month to ringfence the existing 10-team Prem until the 2029-30 season, when it is hoped two clubs will be added provided they meet minimum financial and sporting standards.Explaining the Prem’s growth plans in detail for the first time, its chief executive, Simon Massie-Taylor, revealed they are aiming to open expansion windows every four years, when up to two clubs could join. The first tender process will take place during 2027 and the most impressive applicants could be invited to join Champ Rugby the following season, with a view to moving up to the Prem in 2028-29 as long as they reach the playoffs in the second tier
Tom Brady, 48, says he explored return to NFL but league ‘don’t like that idea very much’
Tom Brady says he explored the idea of making a return to the NFL as a player but the league “don’t like that idea very much”.Brady’s last NFL game came in a defeat to the Dallas Cowboys in January 2023. Since then he has become a part-owner of the Las Vegas Raiders as well as a television analyst for Fox. A spokesperson for the league said that Brady, who turns 49 in August, would need to divest his stake in the Raiders if he was to return to playing.“I actually have inquired [about a return to playing], and [the NFL] don’t like that idea very much,” Brady told CNBC Sport this week
The Middle East price shock hasn’t hit Next – yet | Nils Pratley
NS&I chief executive replaced in ‘fresh start’ over missing savings crisis; bad day for markets – as it happened
New York City hospitals drop Palantir as controversial AI firm expands in UK
Brussels opens investigation into Snapchat amid concern over children’s safety
Sinner continues smooth Miami progress with win over Tiafoe as rivals fall
From Laurel Hubbard to sex testing in five years: why the Olympics U-turned on transgender rules | Sean Ingle