Racing need not fear Green party ‘conversation’ but must continue efforts on horse welfare

A picture


The Green party surged to record results at local and national level in last week’s elections, prompting Zack Polanski, the party’s leader in England and Wales, to suggest that two-party politics is “dead and buried”,Ladbrokes, meanwhile, subsequently cut the odds about the Green party winning the most seats at the next general election to 12-1, while an overall majority for the Greens is priced at 28-1,Not likely, in other words but, at the same time, far from impossible,In the case of a majority for Polanski’s party, it is roughly the same price as Moon Chime, the winner of the big handicap hurdle at Haydock last Saturday,However the party fares in terms of seat numbers, the Green voice in the next parliament, in three years’ time or possibly fewer, seems sure to be significantly louder than ever before.

Since recent, or relatively recent, public comment regarding horse racing from significant figures in the party implies a strong abolitionist streak, these are interesting times for the country’s second-biggest spectator sport.As the Sun reported – on its front page, no less – a couple of weeks ago, Polanski himself proposed the removal of “all animals involved in sport” on X in 2024.Hannah Spencer, meanwhile, the recently elected MP for Gorton and Denton, said last month that there needs to be “a conversation: about racing, a few days after two horses sustained fatal injuries at the Grand National meeting.“A conversation needs to be had about horse racing,” Spencer said.“We all saw those awful pictures of a horse that had been raced to death to make money for gambling companies.

That conversation is coming.Those conversations are shifting.People are telling me they don’t think horse racing is acceptable either.”The obvious question that prompts itself here is who and what, exactly, will this conversation involve? Will it just be Green party members and animal rights campaigners? Or will the 80,000 people whose jobs depend on the sport get a say too? And how about the fans who buy nearly 5m tickets to the races each year?Spencer’s comment is infused with the language of animal rights based activism.It holds that the use of animals by humans for any purpose at all is wrong and by extension that it is not possible to cherish and respect racehorses and also ask them to race, which is what they were bred and born to do.

The phrase “raced to death” is particularly telling.No one is trying to kill or injure racehorses, but there is a – very small – risk inherent in asking them to compete, which the sport is constantly and consciously seeking to minimise.Racing is not a blood sport.The fatal injury rate on the Flat is one in every 1,000 starts.Over jumps, it is five in every 1,000.

Unlike the millions of mammals that are killed for meat in the UK each year, in an industry that could also be said to use animals for “entertainment”, racehorses are not born and bred specifically to die.Racing is also worth £4bn to the economy annually according to the British Horse Racing Authority and, while Spencer and at least some of her fellow Greens might not appreciate it, it brings a huge amount of pleasure and social engagement to millions of people each year at race meetings large and small across the country.Antipathy towards the sport in the corridors of power is hardly a new phenomenon.According to Thomas Blake, the honourable member for Forest of Dean, racing is “an amusement which, though it may be innocent in itself, is the cause of enormous evil in almost every town throughout the country … [and] it is impossible to estimate the distress and misery caused by the speculation and gambling which attend all horse races”.Blake was speaking in June 1878, during the annual adjournment debate on the day before the Derby when MPs debated – and, for many years, approved – a motion to adjourn until Thursday to allow them, in many cases, to head for Epsom the following afternoon.

York: 1.45 Spectacular Diver 2.20 Fireblade 2.55 Dark Thirty (nb) 3.30 Cool Hoof Luke 4.

05 Felicitas 4.40 First Legion 5.15 Fox Journey.Perth: 2.00 Kaydence 2.

33 Next Twist 3.08 Manowest 3.43 The Flying Poet 4.18 Potters Party 4.55 Dublinofficecallin 5.

25 Loro White.Yarmouth: 2.08 Tonal 2.40 Almaty Star (nap) 3.18 Dubai Charm 3.

53 Reigning Queen 4.28 Beagle Bay 5.03 Staniel Cay.Bath: 5.09 Wedgewood 5.

42 Romeo Guest 6,12 Darzah 6,42 Just A Gambler 7,12 Lady Aiyana 7,42 Lucky Sevens 8.

12 Man Is King,Newton Abbot: 5,30 Lirone Du Seuil 6,00 Reel Orange 6,30 Inca De Lafayette 7.

00 Cobbler’s Boy 7.30 Viroflay 8.00 Golden Sun 8.30 Mirabello.His objections were based on an antipathy to gambling rather than any concern for welfare of the horses, but have a similar, abolitionist tone to Spencer’s view.

York 1.45 Rock Steady Beat 2.20 Corolla Point (nap) 2.55 Walsingham 3.30 Fallen Angel 4.

05 King’s Trail 4.40 Simplify 5.15 Arc Ole Ole (nb) Perth 1.58 Scriabin 2.33 Largy Force 3.

08 Easy To Follow 3.43 Kado Sacree 4.18 Double Oban 4.55 Tanking Along 5.28 Hold The Throw Salisbury 2.

08 Mumayaz 2.40 Cruden 3.18 American Psycho 3.53 Wareeth 4.28 Pierian 5.

03 Kotari 5.40 Rogue Rebellion Fontwell 5.34 Shutfrontdoor 6.10 Sun Joy 6.40 Thickthorn Tom 7.

10 Lady Henrietta 7.40 Gone In Sixty 8.10 Dernier SetA century and a half later, racing is still going strong.My guess would be that, regardless of how politics plays out over the decades to come, it will be good for another few hundred years yet.There will, at the same time, always be an onus on racing to emphasise, continue and highlight its efforts on welfare, but the sport has no reason to fear a “conversation”.

It would be helpful, though, to have it before the next election if possible, to get a clear understanding of what the Greens will, or will not, do to racing, and allow the sport’s fans and professionals alike to assess their votes accordingly.
sportSee all
A picture

‘I’m unique’: Dyson Daniels on his NBA niche, missing three-pointers… and investing tips

He is a shooting guard that doesn’t often shoot. A wing deployed less for lift than pressure. The style of Australia’s best basketballer, Dyson Daniels, is difficult to describe. “It’s kind of hard for me to describe it too,” he says. “It’s unique

A picture

The Spin | ‘We have a hoot on the field’: Oswestry CC boasts 10 mother-daughter pairs

Women and Girls section has built strong family dynamic since launching in 2018 – and embraced Wags monikerThe acronym Wags first entered popular consciousness in 2006 during England’s football World Cup adventures in Baden-Baden. Victoria Beckham, Cheryl Tweedy and the gang became a sneering tabloid obsession, their matching outfits, nightclub antics and hair extensions gleefully picked apart.Twenty years later, a very different set of Wags are causing a stir at Oswestry Cricket Club on the north Shropshire-Wales border. The thriving Women and Girls section (WaGs) has an astonishing 10 mother and daughter pairs who have played competitive cricket together, ranging from 12 years old to 67.The oldest member is the irrepressible Jools Payne, team manager and founding player

A picture

How will the liberal Masai Ujiri handle leading the ultraconservative Dallas Mavericks?

On its face, the fit between Masai Ujiri and the Dallas Mavericks is perfect. “It’s almost like a match made in heaven,” Ujiri said after being introduced as the franchise’s president of basketball operations and alternate governor last week. “Every single one of us in this world is chosen for something special, and we just have to find it,” he added. “And I found basketball.”Since he became the first African to run a major sports franchise in the United States as the general manager of the Denver Nuggets in 2010, Ujiri has accomplished everything

A picture

World’s No 1 disabled golfer Kipp Popert: ‘The best need to play for a living. The sport has stopped’

Kipp Popert is a man on a mission. The 27-year‑old Englishman, who tops the disabled world rankings, uses one word a lot: “opportunity”. Popert was “shocked” to hear from the DP World Tour that its G4D circuit, which staged a handful of tournaments per year for disabled players between 2022 and 2025, has been placed into cold storage.The G4D Open, a tournament for 80 golfers with disabilities, will be staged at Celtic Manor from Thursday. It takes place thousands of miles from Pennsylvania and this week’s US PGA Championship, which last year bestowed $3

A picture

Racing need not fear Green party ‘conversation’ but must continue efforts on horse welfare

The Green party surged to record results at local and national level in last week’s elections, prompting Zack Polanski, the party’s leader in England and Wales, to suggest that two-party politics is “dead and buried”. Ladbrokes, meanwhile, subsequently cut the odds about the Green party winning the most seats at the next general election to 12-1, while an overall majority for the Greens is priced at 28-1.Not likely, in other words but, at the same time, far from impossible. In the case of a majority for Polanski’s party, it is roughly the same price as Moon Chime, the winner of the big handicap hurdle at Haydock last Saturday. However the party fares in terms of seat numbers, the Green voice in the next parliament, in three years’ time or possibly fewer, seems sure to be significantly louder than ever before

A picture

From the Pocket: Voss coached the way he played and his brutal football failed Carlton

When John Elliott died in 2021, the old, dark, imperial Carlton was dead. The new Carlton was grounded on “respect, humility and integrity”. The new president was a master networker. The new chief executive was the best administrator in football. The new coach had been one of the great players of his generation