Positive thinking could boost immune response to vaccines, say scientists

A picture


Positive thoughts may boost the immune system according to research that points to a connection between the mind and our body’s natural defences.Scientists have found people who used positive thinking to boost activity in the brain’s reward system responded better to vaccination, with their immune systems producing more antibodies than others after having the shot.The work does not mean being hopeful can rid people of disease, but hints at the potential for mental strategies to help the immune system fight infections and even attack tumours to keep them at bay.“It’s the first demonstration in humans, in what seems to be a causal manner, that if you learn how to recruit your reward system in the brain, the effectiveness of immunisation increases,” said Talma Hendler, a professor of psychiatry and neuroscience at Tel Aviv University.Previous work has shown that positive expectations can benefit patients with some medical problems, as seen in the placebo effect.

And, while animal studies suggest that activating the brain’s reward system can boost immune defences, the picture in humans has been less clear.In the Nature Medicine study, healthy volunteers took part in brain training sessions in which they tried different mental strategies to boost activity in particular parts of the brain.They knew how well they were doing thanks to real-time feedback in the form of scores that rose in line with brain activity.After four training sessions, the volunteers were given a hepatitis B vaccine.They then gave blood two and four weeks later, which researchers analysed for antibodies against hepatitis.

The scientists found that people who boosted activity in part of the brain’s reward system called the ventral tegmental area (VTA) had the strongest immune response to the vaccine,Those who boosted it most successfully did so through positive expectations, or imagining good things happening,The effect may prove useful in boosting patients’ immune systems, but larger trials are needed to show if there is any clear medical benefit,Dr Tamar Koren, a co-author, said the team was investigating whether other parts of the immune system were also affected, such as that responsible for inflammation,“The approach we tested is intended solely as a complementary tool that may enhance immune responsiveness to vaccination,” said Dr Nitzan Lubianiker, a senior author on the study.

“It cannot, and is not meant to, replace vaccines or standard medical care.”Jonathan Kipnis, a professor of pathology and immunology at Washington University in St Louis, agreed.“It is probably too early to draw conclusions about the degree of clinical relevance,” he said.“If such effects were shown to matter clinically in a larger clinical trial, they would most likely complement the established treatments.”Jeremy Howick, a professor of empathic healthcare at the University of Leicester, said the effect was small and cautioned that sick patients in a clinic may respond differently, but he still saw positives.

He said: “Given that it’s free for healthcare professionals to say things that can generate positive expectations, without exaggerating, like: ‘We’re going to do our best to take care of you,’ or: ‘I’ve seen this treatment work for people like you,’ this is a pretty robust signal suggesting we should do more of it.”
recentSee all
A picture

Nervous rex: the Davos elite brace for Trump and his dinosaur diplomacy

“There’s no diplomacy with Donald Trump: he’s a T rex. You mate with him or he devours you.” Debate at the World Economic Forum annual meetings high in the Swiss Alps is usually scrupulously polite, but as this year’s gathering got under way in Davos on Tuesday, California’s Democratic governor, Gavin Newsom, had this blunt advice for handling the week’s star speaker.The US president was yet to arrive but throughout the blond wood congress centre the hottest topic among the global elite of business and politics – on and off conference stages – was Trump’s intemperate attack on European allies, threatening punitive tariffs if they fail to let him annex Greenland.Trump’s treasury secretary, Scott Bessent, kicked off the day by urging US allies to calm down, accusing them of “hysteria” in their reaction to the president’s comments

A picture

US and European markets fall as Trump steps up Greenland rhetoric

Stock markets fell on both sides of the Atlantic on Tuesday as investor concerns persisted over the fallout from Donald Trump’s push for US control of Greenland.The sell-off hit US stocks on Tuesday, the first day of trading on Wall Street since Trump threatened new tariffs on eight European countries, after the market was closed for a public holiday on Monday. The S&P 500 was down 1.5% while the Dow Jones was down 1.3%

A picture

Big tech continues to bend the knee to Trump a year after his inauguration

Hello, and welcome to TechScape. I’m your host, Blake Montgomery, the Guardian’s US tech editor.One year ago today, Donald Trump was inaugurated as president of the United States. Standing alongside him that day were the leaders of the tech industry’s most powerful companies, who had donated to him in an unprecedented bending of the knee. In the ensuing year, the companies have reaped enormous rewards from their alliance with Trump, which my colleague Nick Robins-Early and I wrote about last month after Trump signed an executive order prohibiting states from passing laws regulating AI

A picture

Elon Musk floats idea of buying Ryanair after calling CEO ‘an idiot’

Elon Musk has floated the idea of buying the budget airline Ryanair, escalating his public spat with the Irish carrier’s boss, Michael O’Leary.The two outspoken businessmen have locked horns since last week, when O’Leary was asked whether he would follow Lufthansa and British Airways in installing Musk’s Starlink satellite internet technology on his fleet of 650 aircraft.The Ryanair chief executive rejected the idea, saying that adding antennas to the jets would result in “2% fuel drag”, adding an extra $200m-$250m to its $5bn (£3.71bn) annual kerosene bill.Musk said that interpretation was “misinformed” in a post on his X platform, prompting a tit-for-tat exchange of insults, with each calling the other an “idiot” and then the Tesla and SpaceX CEO saying O’Leary should be fired

A picture

Wales coach Steve Tandy left trapped in middle of toxic Ospreys and Cardiff saga

The prevailing mood in Welsh rugby has frequently been dark but rarely this bible black. Once upon a time a Six Nations squad announcement would have topped the agenda across the country; on Tuesday it felt like a semicolon in a much bigger narrative. Even Wales have never selected seven players whose club is in imminent danger of being axed by their own union.The bare facts of the situation are increasingly stark for all involved. The existing owners of Ospreys, Wales’s most successful region of the past two decades, have just been controversially nominated as the preferred bidders for Cardiff, potentially clearing the way to reduce the number of Welsh professional sides from four to three

A picture

Naomi Osaka’s jellyfish-inspired outfit steals the show at Australian Open

Naomi Osaka’s renowned 125mph serve is positively slow compared with a jellyfish’s sting, which can cover 10 to 20 micrometres in less than one-millionth of a second. But it wasn’t just the invertebrate’s speed that the tennis player was calling on when she wore a jellyfish-inspired outfit to face Antonia Ruzic of Croatia in their first-round match at the Australian Open.Entering Melbourne’s Rod Laver Arena, the 28-year-old tennis player’s look consisted of a pleated miniskirt over wide-legged trousers, a wide-brimmed hat with a white veil and a parasol. Jellyfish-esque elements were also incorporated into her on-court outfit, which featured a watery turquoise and green palette and soft frills on the warm-up jacket and dress, alluding to tentacles.As Osaka told Vogue before the match, which she went on to win 6-3, 3-6, 6-4, the inspiration came when she was reading a storybook to her two-year-old daughter, Shai: “Reading to my daughter, discovering beauty in unexpected places like the underwater world, working with artists who care about meaning – those moments have all shaped the way I see this expression now