Expert rejects Met police claim that study backs bias-free live facial recognition use
The Metropolitan police’s claims that their use of live facial recognition is bias-free are not substantiated by the report they cite to support their case, a leading expert on the technology has said.The Met is planning its biggest and most high profile use of LFR yet this bank holiday weekend at Notting Hill carnival in west London.The Guardian understands it will be deployed at two sites on the approaches to the carnival, with the force insisting on its use despite the Equality and Human Rights Commission saying police use of LFR is unlawful.The new claims come from Prof Pete Fussey, who led the only independent academic review of police use of facial recognition, is a former reviewer of LFR for the Met from 2018-19, and currently advises other forces in the UK and abroad on its use.The Met says it has reformed its use of LFR after a 2023 study it commissioned from the National Physical Laboratory (NPL) and it is now, in effect, bias-free.
But Fussey said: “The claims the Met are making about the absence of bias from the NPL report are not substantiated by the facts in that report.”For LFR to work, the sensitivity of the system can be varied.The more sensitive it is the more people it will detect, but the higher its potential bias will be on racial, gender and age grounds.Zero is its most sensitive setting and one the least sensitive.The NPL report found there was bias at a setting of 0.
56,At a setting of 0,6 it found seven cases where people in its test were wrongly flagged as wanted – a false positive,All were from ethnic minorities,The study results were gained after 178,000 images were entered into the system.
Four hundred volunteers walked past cameras approximately 10 times each, providing 4,000 chances for the system to correctly recognise them.They were contained in what the study estimated were crowds of more than 130,000 people at four sites in London and one in Cardiff.Testing took place in sunny conditions and totalled 34.5 hours, which Fussey said is shorter than in some other countries assessing LFR.From this sample, the report concluded there was no statistically significant bias at a setting of 0.
6 or higher, a claim the Met has repeated to defend the use and expansion of LFR.Fussey said this was far too small a sample to support the Met’s claims.“The MPS [Metropolitan Police Service] consistently claim their system has been independently tested for bias.Examining this research reveals the data is insufficient to support the claims being made.“The decisive conclusions the Met are stating publicly are based on analysis of just seven false matches.
This is from a system that has analysed millions of Londoners’ faces.It is a weak statistical basis to make universal claims from such a small sample of false matches.”The Met now uses LFR at a sensitivity setting of 0.64, which the NPL study said produced no false matches.Fussey said: “According to their own research, false matches were not actually assessed at the settings they claim is free of bias, which is 0.
64 or above,“Few, if any, in the scientific community would say the evidence is sufficient to support these claims extrapolated from such a small sample,”Fussey added: “The evaluation clearly states that bias exists in the algorithm, but claims this is eliminated if the system settings are changed,The issue here is that the system has not been adequately tested at these different settings, so it is difficult to support these claims,”The Met’s director of intelligence, Lindsey Chiswick, dismissed Fussey’s claims.
“This is a factual report from a world-renowned organisation.The Met police’s commentary is based on what the independent report found,” she said.Sign up to First EditionOur morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it mattersafter newsletter promotion“When we use LFR at the setting of 0.64 – which is what we now use – there is no statistically significant bias.“We commissioned the study to understand where potential bias might lie in the algorithm and used the findings to mitigate that risk.
“Its findings show us what level to use the algorithm at to avoid bias and we always operate above that level and in a fair way,”At Notting Hill this weekend warning signs will tell people LFR is in use, next to the vans containing the cameras which are linked to a database of wanted suspects,Police believe its use at two sites on the approaches to the carnival will act as a deterrent,At the carnival itself, police are preparing to use retrospective facial recognition to capture suspects for violence and assaults,Fussey said: “Few would doubt the right of police to use technology to keep the public safe, but this needs to be done with proper accountability measures and in accordance with human rights standards.
”The Met claims that since 2024, LFR’s false positive rate has been one in every 33,000 cases.It declined to say how many faces had been scanned but it is understood to be in the hundreds of thousands.In 2024 there were 26 false matches, with eight so far in 2025.The Met says none of these people were detained, as once the computer system flags a match, the decision on whether to arrest is made by a police officer.Before the carnival, the Met had arrested 100 people, with 21 recalled to prison and 266 being banned from attending.
The force also said it had seized 11 firearms and more than 40 knives.
Baby food firms given 18 months to improve quality of products in England
Baby food manufacturers have been given 18 months to improve the quality of their products in England, amid mounting concerns that leading brands are nutritionally poor.The new voluntary guidance from the government calls for a reduction in sugar and salt levels in food for infants and toddlers.It also requests clearer labelling of products to address misleading marketing claims that make baby foods seem healthier than they are.This will cover products with labels such as “contains no nasties”, which are high in sugar. Others are labelled as snacks for babies, which goes against government recommendations that children aged six to 12 months do not need snacks between meals, only milk
Michael Göpfert obituary
My husband, Michael Göpfert, who has died of cancer aged 77, was a consultant psychotherapist and child psychiatrist in Merseyside. In 1985 he set up a new psychotherapy service at the Royal Liverpool hospital, with integration at its heart, ensuring that therapists from different disciplines each had some training in another therapeutic method.Michael saw that separating adult and child services when a parent had a severe mental illness meant that the effect on the children was often missed. He was an early proponent of this neglected area and edited the book Parental Psychiatric Disorder (1996). He worked closely with Barnardo’s Young Carers and its Keeping the Family in Mind service in Liverpool, now well established but innovative when it began
Obesity has a serious impact on health – it shortened my mum’s life | Letter
With reference to the letters on Rose Stokes’ article (I thought we’d entered the age of body positivity. Then came ‘shrinking girl summer’ – is everyone getting smaller except me?, 10 August), I would like to add a personal view. My lovely mom was overweight all of her adult life – between 17 stone and 18 stone. She could never run around and play with us children. In her 40s she developed diabetes and high blood pressure
Tell us: how do you cope with broken sleep during the menopause?
Insomnia and disrupted nights are among the most common, and one of the hardest, symptoms of the menopause. Hormonal changes can make it harder to fall asleep, cause frequent waking, or trigger night sweats that disturb rest.We’d like to hear about what has (or hasn’t) helped you manage these challenges. Have you sought medical support, such as a prescription for melatonin or HRT? Have lifestyle changes like exercise, diet, or relaxation techniques made a difference? Or perhaps you’ve tried alternative remedies or found creative ways of coping with broken sleep.We’re especially interested in the practical steps you’ve taken – big or small – and how they’ve affected your day-to-day life
‘I dream about toilets, I admit it’: the man on a mission to improve Britain’s loos
Poor accessibility, questionable hygiene, scattered needles and budget cuts … the UK is in the midst of a public toilet crisis. Thankfully, Raymond Martin is fighting backThe first thing Raymond Martin looks for in a toilet, he says, is cleanliness. Does the tissue paper on the floor mean this public lavatory has failed his inspection? “You have to understand that it’s a working toilet, it’s now mid-afternoon – a few bits of tissue on the floor is neither here nor there,” Martin says. “If there were cigarette packets, bottles on the floor – that I’d be worried about.” We’re in Knutsford, Cheshire, and Martin is on a toilet-inspection tour of the north and west of the UK
‘Mountain to climb’: how Labour is facing a crisis in youth unemployment
Getting started in the world of work was not easy for Rose Green. Having experienced half a dozen children’s homes from the age of 13 while growing up in care in north London, finding a career was the last thing on her mind.“Having that corporate parenting, it can be difficult,” she says. “Sometimes things like completing school, or uni, you’re faced with so much trauma that you haven’t really got the time to finish all of that.“You’re kind of parenting yourself, raising yourself
Federal Reserve set to cut interest rates – but still Trump won’t be happy
Wall Street jumps after US Fed’s Powell signals possible rate cut – as it happened
Expert rejects Met police claim that study backs bias-free live facial recognition use
Trump says Intel has agreed to give US government a 10% stake
‘Pressure is a privilege’: Braxton Sorensen-McGee on being New Zealand’s youngest star
England to ring changes and ‘get everyone started’, says John Mitchell