Monday’s Mandelson showdown could be Starmer’s last stand | John Crace

A picture


On days like these you reckon the prime minister would have more chance of being believed if he had said the dog ate his homework.After all, it’s quite possible that Keir Starmer has not yet realised he doesn’t have a dog.His amnesia and lack of curiosity are a piece of performance art.Almost up there with Boris Johnson.Keir would probably take that as a compliment.

As it is we are left with a dilemma,Occam’s razor,Either No 10 thinks we were born yesterday,Or everyone in No 10 was born yesterday,The excuses factory has been working overtime.

But most people have already made up their minds.No one can possibly have been quite so half-witted as to not take an interest in the security vetting of a man almost everyone knew to be so controversial.Who had twice been sacked from the cabinet for breaking the ministerial code and had maintained a friendship with Jeffrey Epstein after he had been convicted of soliciting prostitution from a minor.We are left with the thought that maybe the reason Starmer never asked to see the vetting report was because he already suspected Peter Mandelson had failed.Nothing about the story makes sense.

Just supposing for a minute that the Downing Street version is true.That senior officials covered up the security vetting and approved Mandy’s appointment just because they thought that was what No 10 would like them to do.Putting their careers on the line for something that always had a high chance of being found out.The first rule of the Mandyverse: he always takes others down with him.What was in it for the Foreign Office apparatchiks to be quite this dim? Or was their job just to tell the prime minister things he wanted to hear.

“Don’t worry, Keir,When the president trashes you it’s a sign he really likes you,Just the negging of a consummate pickup artist,”To imagine that everything happened exactly as Downing Street would have us believe does not just involve a collective suspension of reality,A journey into a parallel, hallucinogenic world where nothing is as it seems.

It also means accepting that the people running the country are even more incompetent than we imagined.And that is a terrifying thought.That our politicians are nothing more than a bunch of chancers who have been winging it all along.So either Starmer misled parliament or he’s more useless than we thought.Neither position is sustainable.

Starmer, meanwhile, was in Paris to meet Emmanuel Macron for an online meeting of the Coalition of the Unwilling,Like-minded leaders who knew they ought to be seen to be doing something about the Iran war but didn’t really know what,Futile gestures all round,After all, it wasn’t as if any of them were in a position to make a difference,Mid-morning, Starmer appeared in a park to give a short prepared piece to camera.

“That I wasn’t told that Peter Mandelson had failed security vetting when he was appointed is staggering,” he began.Er, yes.But that you couldn’t even be bothered to ask to read the conclusion is even more staggering.Even if the whole thing was too much effort.There again, I suppose it was no biggy.

Only the appointment of an ambassador to a US and a president with a narcissistic personality disorder,Keir moved on,“That I wasn’t told that he had failed security vetting when I was telling parliament that due process had been followed is unforgivable,” How does he come up with such nonsense? The real question that Starmer can’t ask himself was why he was giving assurances to the Commons when he had no idea if they were true or not,He had just been living his best life.

Reordering the world as he would like it to be.A prime minister who was not responsible for the words he was saying.Next he will be telling us he has been taken over by AI.Then the piece de resistance.“Not only was I not told, no minister was told, and I’m absolutely furious about that.

” Keir has spent a lot of time being furious recently.So much he doesn’t know.So much to know.If only there was someone in charge – a prime minister, say – who could make it their business to ensure civil servants kept ministers in the loop.Talking of which … Starmer has said he only discovered his lordship had failed the vetting on Tuesday night.

But somehow he never got round to telling his foreign secretary.It was only her department, I suppose.The first that Yvette Cooper knew of it was when the Guardian broke the story on Thursday afternoon.Left hand.Meet right hand.

The same applied to Keir’s poor old chief secretary, Dazza,Jones too had been blissfully unaware,And if Keir really had been furious about being misled, he could have mentioned it at prime minister’s questions on Wednesday,Just saying,Truth, integrity and judgment matter.

Just saying.That just left Keir to say a few words – strictly no questions – at the end of the Iran summit.He was absolutely furious, he said.No one had told him Iran and the US had been at war.Yet more heads were going to roll at the Foreign Office for this.

He was minded to make Olly Robbins resign all over again.Twice in two days.That would show him.He was also absolutely furious about the blockade of the strait of Hormuz.Civil servants had removed all maps of the Middle East from Downing Street without his knowledge and he hadn’t realised the strait was so narrow.

Though the clue was in the name,This, though, was about as good as it was going to get for Starmer,Back home the wagons were circling,Every opposition party leader was calling for him to resign,Worse, he had lost the country.

Almost no one believes him.Even if he is telling the truth.Monday’s showdown in parliament will be box office.It could be Keir’s last stand.
societySee all
A picture

Future of the NHS, saviour of the high street? High hopes for health hub in a Barnsley shopping centre

It is a revolution that might just save the NHS – and the high street. Imagine being able to have your eyes tested, mole examined or get an appointment with a consultant without going to your local hospital – and maybe fit in some shopping or a cinema visit afterwards.That, increasingly, is what people in Barnsley are doing after an unprecedented relocation of medical services from the district general hospital into a purpose-built outpatients centre in the Alhambra shopping centre, which is getting a new lease of life thanks to the experiment.Those involved say the initiative – the first of its kind in the NHS – is trailblazing and revolutionary. After a recent visit, Wes Streeting, the health secretary, described it as “really inspiring”

A picture

Effect of ‘gamechanger’ Alzheimer’s drugs ‘trivial’, review concludes

Drugs that have been hailed as a gamechanger for the treatment of Alzheimer’s disease make no noticeable difference to patients, according to an extensive review.The analysis of clinical trials in people with mild cognitive impairment or mild dementia found that the effects of anti-amyloid drugs on cognition and dementia severity over 18 months were “trivial”, with improvements in functional ability “small at best”.The verdict is a blow to the new wave of drugs that are designed to slow Alzheimer’s by clearing clumps of amyloid protein that build up in the brain. Amyloid plaques are a hallmark of Alzheimer’s disease, along with another protein called tau which forms toxic tangles in neurons.The Cochrane review drew on gold standard methods to assess data from published clinical trials, but was criticised by some researchers and charities for combining results from older, failed drugs with those from newer, more effective medicines

A picture

People in north of England twice as likely to be killed in accidents as Londoners, report finds

People in the north of England are twice as likely to be killed in accidents than Londoners, with accidental deaths clearly linked to deprivation, a report has found.The research, from safety charity the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents (RoSPA), highlights vast regional differences in accidental deaths, which have also seen an overall increase.The north-east is the most dangerous region for accidents in England, with a death rate of 44 per 100,000 people, compared to an average of 32 across the country, with the north-west in second place with a death rate of 38 per 100,000 people.Scotland was the most dangerous of the devolved UK nations, with an even higher accidental death rate of 51 per 100,000, while Wales equalled the north-east of England, and Northern Ireland’s rate of 39 per 100,000 was also above the England average.Meanwhile, London was the safest place to live in the UK, with an average of 19

A picture

Sexual harassment is rife on comedy circuit and women lack protections, MPs told

Sexual harassment and abuse on the comedy circuit is persistent and under-reported, with protections available to women often limited or absent, a comedian has told MPs.Performers and campaigners said many female comedians are left to rely on informal warning systems to try to keep themselves safe but added that these systems can expose women to further risks.“Female comedians rely on so-called ‘whisper networks’, a shadow safeguarding system where warnings and experiences are shared on private WhatsApp threads,” Nina Gilligan, a comedian and the co-founder of the industry body Get Off Live Comedy, which provides HR support to those working in the industry, told the cross-party women and equalities committee on Wednesday.Chaired by the Labour MP Sarah Owen, the committee explored the experiences of women in live comedy, the representation of women across the sector and the barriers they face in building a career.The committee has been examining how employment protections apply in freelance and gig-economy sectors, where traditional safeguards are harder to enforce

A picture

Why we washed our hands of Izal | Brief letters

In the 1970s, to save money, a London psychiatric hospital replaced soft toilet tissue with Izal medicated toilet roll (Letters, 13 April). Therapists conducting successful sessions for outpatients with compulsive disorders were surprised by a sudden increase in relapse rates, until they realised that each sheet contained the exhortation “Now wash your hands”. Its use was discontinued. ‌Prof David C SandersMortain, France Izal toilet paper made excellent tracing paper, but it also made a superb sound in a comb and paper. One member of a jokey interval band at the original Concorde Jazz Club in Southampton played an Izal bumphone to great effect!David WittMalmesbury, Wiltshire It’s not all doom and gloom when products are discontinued

A picture

Government’s 1.5m housebuilding target in England is suffering from subsidence | Nils Pratley

This is what the government didn’t want to hear when its target to build 1.5m homes in England during this parliament already looked out of reach. The country’s biggest housebuilder is trimming its purchases of new land because the Iran war has created “a less certain backdrop”.Barratt Redrow’s “disciplined approach” isn’t a downing of tools, it should be said. The company had previously expected to buy between 10,000 and 12,000 plots; now it will acquire between 7,000 and 9,000