Labour’s ‘crabwise’ approach to closer EU ties must address damage of Brexit | Heather Stewart
Rachel Reeves joined EU finance ministers for dinner in Washington last week, on the sidelines of the International Monetary Fund spring meetings – the first time a chancellor had done so since Brexit,It was the latest symbolic step in Labour’s marked shift towards prioritising closer EU relations,That makes perfect sense against the backdrop of Donald Trump’s reckless Middle East conflict,But domestic politics and economics have increasingly aligned in favour of a lean towards the EU, too – or, rather, Labour has increasingly opened its eyes to them,As political scientists such as Rob Ford and Ben Ansell have been all but screaming for some time, Labour is losing many more voters to the left wing, pro-EU Greens and Liberal Democrats than to Nigel Farage’s Reform UK.
That is only likely to become more evident when the results of May’s elections come in,Since the departure of Morgan McSweeney, the government appears to have become markedly more willing to try to win some of these lost lefties back, instead of hankering after Reform-curious “hero voters” – those won directly by Labour from the Conservatives in 2024,When it comes to the economics, there is a growing body of evidence about the impact of Brexit on what is meant to be the overriding “mission” of the Labour government: kickstarting growth,In her Mais lecture last month, Reeves highlighted analysis published by the National Bureau of Economic Research and led by Nick Bloom, a British economist based at Stanford, suggesting leaving the EU may have knocked up to 8% off the size of the economy,“Brexit did deep damage,” she said.
That is significantly larger than many previous estimates,Whatever the right number, it dramatically dwarfs the potential upsides from the various non-EU trade deals the UK has struck since 2016,As Reeves put it: “No trade deal with any individual nation can outweigh the importance of our relationship to a bloc with which we share a land border, with which our supply chains are closely intertwined, and it accounts for almost half our trade,”Yet Labour’s current painstakingly discussed “reset” in relations with the EU, along the lines prescribed in its manifesto, is likely to be worth less than 0,5% of GDP, according to John Springford of the Centre for European Reform.
That doesn’t mean these negotiations – on agrifood, the EU electricity market and the emissions trading scheme – are not worth pursuing.But it makes sense that Reeves is now looking further – pointing to the possibility of “dynamic alignment”, or automatically following EU rules, in exchange for more access to the single market.Which industries she has in mind are as yet unspecified, but the government plans to give itself the legislative levers to track changes in EU regulations without putting every tweak to a House of Commons vote.It is not an unreasonable aim, although in reality Labour’s room for manoeuvre is likely to be limited.Widen the sectors at play too far, and Brussels is likely to object to a non-member “cherrypicking” aspects of the single market.
And the greater the economic benefits at stake, the more likely the UK will be urged to accept freedom of movement – crossing one of the government’s cherished manifesto red lines.The EU has recently renegotiated its relationship with Switzerland, precisely to avoid concerns about a pick-and-mix approach.The new set of deals falls short of full single market membership, but it entrenches freedom of movement and budget contributions.Anand Menon, the director of the thinktank UK in a Changing Europe, says Reeves and Keir Starmer may be arguing for something undeliverable.“At a certain point, they’re not going to get the benefits without the obligations.
”There is a deep irony here, not lost on veterans of the scarring and chaotic Brexit debate in the 2017-2019 hung parliament.What Labour is walking itself towards, crabwise, has much in common with Theresa May’s doomed Chequers deal, which would also have involved aligning with the EU in key areas.“Labour would bite your arm off for that now,” says Jill Rutter of the Institute for Government.Starmer, as the shadow Brexit secretary, played a crucial role in collapsing talks with May’s government over her withdrawal agreement with the EU, not least by demanding a referendum on the deal.The prospect of collapsing her government was probably too delicious to resist, but the ultimate outcome was the triumph of Boris Johnson and his harder, narrower vision of leave.
Labour opposed that with every parliamentary manoeuvre it could muster, and ended up proposing instead to reopen the entire Brexit debate with another referendum – a policy for which Starmer was the torchbearer.Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership team was by this point exhausted and divided; but the end result of the second referendum gambit was a crushing general election defeat.Starmer’s less-than-deft political touch was evident even then, for those who cared to look.If the party is now careering towards a leadership contest, the UK’s relationship with the EU will be high on the agenda: some backbenchers are already advocating a “Swiss-style” approach.That would mean thinking the unthinkable, and making the risky political argument for a return of free movement – a hard sell, at a time when Farage’s well-funded rightwing populists are running riot, and a long way from the prime minister’s “island of strangers” speech.
Any would-be candidate hoping to make that case, though, might take inspiration from the words of another putative party leader, who said at his campaign launch: “We welcome migrants; we don’t scapegoat them.Low wages, poor housing, poor public services are not the fault of people who come here: they’re political failure.So we have to make the case for the benefits of migration; for the benefits of free movement.” That candidate? Not Zack Polanski, but Starmer.
Falling fertility, debt and AI: is the US headed toward a population crisis?
Americans having less kids plus an ageing population could be a recipe for disaster that further erodes social stabilityRemember environmentalist Paul Ehrlich’s 1960s-vintage prediction about how overpopulation would deplete the Earth’s resources and condemn millions to starvation? His Malthusian condemnation of humanity’s voracious appetite has kept a grip on the debate over the future of the planet, even scaring the young out of having children.Ehrlich was wrong. Yet as we have come around to the thought that overpopulation won’t kill us all, we are being walloped by another demographic emergency: we are not having too many kids, we are having too few. This problem is real.The most recent scare came from government figures released last week suggesting the fall in US fertility – the number of children a woman will have over her lifetime – may be speeding up, hitting a record low of 1
Labour’s ‘crabwise’ approach to closer EU ties must address damage of Brexit | Heather Stewart
Rachel Reeves joined EU finance ministers for dinner in Washington last week, on the sidelines of the International Monetary Fund spring meetings – the first time a chancellor had done so since Brexit.It was the latest symbolic step in Labour’s marked shift towards prioritising closer EU relations.That makes perfect sense against the backdrop of Donald Trump’s reckless Middle East conflict. But domestic politics and economics have increasingly aligned in favour of a lean towards the EU, too – or, rather, Labour has increasingly opened its eyes to them.As political scientists such as Rob Ford and Ben Ansell have been all but screaming for some time, Labour is losing many more voters to the left wing, pro-EU Greens and Liberal Democrats than to Nigel Farage’s Reform UK
How a fiery attack on Sam Altman’s home unfolded
In the early hours of 10 April, a man approached the gate of OpenAI CEO Sam Altman’s house in San Francisco and hurled a molotov cocktail at the building before fleeing. The suspect, 20-year-old Daniel Moreno-Gama, was arrested less than two hours later while allegedly attempting to break into the headquarters of OpenAI with a jug of kerosene, a lighter and an anti-AI manifesto.Federal and California state authorities have charged Moreno-Gama with a range of crimes including attempted arson and attempted murder. His parents issued a statement this week saying that their son had recently suffered a mental health crisis. Moreno-Gama, who has not yet entered a plea, faces up to life in prison if convicted
Kenyan firm sacks more than 1,000 workers after losing Meta contract
More than 1,000 low-paid workers in Kenya have been abruptly sacked by an outsourcing company contracted by Meta, in what activists said was a shocking move exposing the precariousness of tech jobs in the global south.Sama, a company based in Nairobi to which Meta outsourced content moderation and AI training work, announced on Thursday that the workers were being laid off after Meta terminated a contract.Last month reports said some Kenyan workers involved in data annotation were asked to view content filmed using Meta’s AI smart glasses showing wearers using the toilet or having sex.The sacked workers, many involved in AI training, have been given six days’ notice, according to the Oversight Lab, an organisation that advocates for fair regulation and deployment of technology across Africa. It said it was advising the workers on legal options
Hampshire v Somerset, Gloucestershire v Lancashire, and more: county cricket – live
Essex are now eight down at Edgbaston and still 12 runs shy of Warwickshire’s first innings score of 190. Hampshire have extended their lead to a commanding 196 and counting in Southampton and Lancashire are being made to work hard in Bristol, James Bracey and Miles Hammond still going strong, Gloucs lead by 52 runs with seven wickets left. I’ll be back for a full lunchtime update shortly.At Wantage Road, Josh De Caires spills a sharp chance off James Sales in the slips, the Northants man blows his cheeks out with relief, he had 95 to his name. Sales moves to three figures a few minutes later and the deficit is down to 59 runs
‘Last year is over’: Oklahoma City launch title defense as NBA’s parity era faces test
The league hasn’t had a repeat champion since the 2017-18 Warriors. The level-headed, consistent Thunder may be the ones to change thatThe NBA has not seen a reigning champion take its title defense as far as the conference finals, let alone hoist a second consecutive Larry O’Brien trophy, since the Golden State Warriors were cut off at the ankle and calf by the Toronto Raptors in the 2019 Finals. That’s seven straight seasons in which parity has ruled supreme, for better or for worse, and dynastic runs seem fated to be a thing of the past.Not if one team in America’s heartland has anything to say about it. The Oklahoma City Thunder embark on these 2026 playoffs in search of historic greatness, trends be damned
US tech firms successfully lobbied EU to keep datacentre emissions secret
Liz Kendall urges UK public to embrace AI as government makes first £500m fund investment
‘How do I end a call?’: the elderly Japanese people determined to master smartphones
Labour and Lib Dem MPs demand ‘shameful’ Palantir NHS contract be scrapped
Man used AI to make false statements to shut down London nightclub, police say
NAACP lawsuit accuses Elon Musk’s xAI of polluting Black neighborhoods near Memphis