Can Starmer maintain ‘defensive strikes’ stance as Trump escalates threats on Iran?
In Downing Street, Keir Starmer has been at pains to emphasise that he will only authorise the use of UK bases by the US for “defensive” strikes on Iranian military targets.In the White House, Donald Trump has threatened to bomb civilian infrastructure – and said on Monday that he was “not at all” worried about committing war crimes.So far in the war, Starmer’s position has allowed him to present the UK as a responsible actor concerned for regional security – but not a direct participant in the conflict on the US side.But while that has incurred Trump’s displeasure, it has also drawn questions about whether it is legally plausible to neatly divide defensive and offensive operations – and if US attacks do begin against targets such as bridges and power plants, scrutiny of the British position will intensify even if those attacks are not launched from UK bases.When it set out its stance on “defensive” strikes, the government took the unusual step of releasing a summary of its legal position: that it was acting “in the collective self-defence of regional allies who have requested support”.
It is fair to say that many were sceptical from the start about the UK’s attempt to distinguish defensive operations involving US bombers from offensive operations in what most international law experts agreed was a conflict illegally started by the US and Israel.Susan Breau, a professor of international law and a senior associate research fellow at the Institute of Advanced Legal Studies, said: “How do you distinguish what’s defensive from what’s offensive? It will be extremely complicated for the UK to maintain that distinction given what Trump has said – his whole battle plan is changing.I mean, today, the Israelis issued a warning about trains [and for Iranians not to use them].Trump’s whole battle plan now is to attack civilian infrastructure.”For Breau, who had concerns about the UK position from the start, allowing the US to use UK bases is the main issue.
“I could see the UK still having bases and having ships there to defend its Gulf neighbours but it’s allowing the US to use their bases that’s problematic,” she said.“When the attack came on the [UK] base in Cyprus, on their allies in the Gulf, I could understand why the UK would open up their bases.But now Trump is changing the battle plan, he’s changing the rules of engagement.”However, Victor Kattan, an assistant professor of public international law at the University of Nottingham, said he thought the UK’s existing legal position could be defended, even if Trump carries out his threats.He said the British government knowingly allowing their planes, missiles or bases for such purposes would be unlawful “and the UK government should make that clear to the Americans and perhaps even stop them from using those bases in those contexts.
”But he added: “They [the British] could say, ‘Look, we’re only allowing our systems, hardware, our personnel to shoot down rockets and the launchers as well that shoot those rockets that are being targeted at, say, the Qataris or the Kuwaitis or the Emiratis or the Saudis.But our bases and hardware’s not being used to punish the government of Iran, for example, or to participate in attacks on bridges, critical infrastructure, oil and gas, bunkers, that kind of thing.’ It’s a fine distinction to make, but I think it’s tenable.”Where Breau and Kattan do agree is that the UK will be keeping a close eye on its legal position to see whether it remains fit for purpose, even if they do not necessarily agree on the answer to that key question.Kattan said it was a given that the UK would be “constantly reviewing” it, while Breau said of the legal case: “They need to reconsider it.
And I would be surprised if they’re not [already].
UK house prices fall in March amid uncertain impact of Middle East conflict
UK house prices fell in March, as the housing market lost momentum amid uncertainty over the conflict in the Middle East and the impact on the economy and interest rates.Figures from Halifax, which is part of Lloyds – Britain’s biggest mortgage lender – showed property prices dipped by 0.5% in March compared with a month earlier. As a result, the average price of a home slipped back below £300,000, to £299,677, after first crossing the milestone in January.The pace of annual property price growth also eased to 0
Oil prices plunge 15% to below $100, stocks surge and dollar slumps after Trump announces US-Iran ceasefire – business live
European gas prices have fallen 20% since the ceasefire was announced, after nearly six weeks of war.The European bellwether front-month gas contract on the Dutch TTF hub initially dropped to €42.50 per megawatt hour this morning, its lowest since 2 March, before rising slightly to €43.46 per megawatt hour.Iran has agreed to reopen the strait of Hormuz, through which around a fifth of the world’s gas and oil passed prior to the war, assuming there are no more strikes from the US and Israel
The life-changing magic of wearing smartglasses | Letters
I read with sympathy the concerns of Elle Hunt in relation to privacy issues around Meta smartglasses (I wore Meta’s smartglasses for a month – and it left me feeling like a creep, 1 April). Clearly there needs to be ongoing development of technology and protocols that protect the public from ill-intentioned users. As the chief executive of a charity supporting people with a visual impairment, however, I would like to emphasise the point touched upon in your article: how transformative this technology is already proving for blind people.We are seeing significant numbers of our visually impaired staff and clients using Meta glasses in conjunction with their mobile phones to improve their ability to perform ordinary functions that most of us take for granted. A visual impairment can be disempowering and isolating
Tell us: do you use AI chatbots to make decisions for you?
AI chatbots like ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude are now a part of everyday life.More and more people are using them to help make decisions in their lives, like sending text messages, deciding what to cook, or navigating relationships.We want to hear about your experiences of using chatbots. Are you addicted to them? And what type of decisions are you using them for?You can tell us your experiences of using chatbots using this form.Please include as much detail as possible
From the Pocket: Music works for a showman like Charlie Cameron but fans need space between the notes
The quote “music is the space between the notes” is usually attributed to the French composer Claude Debussy. Or maybe it was Richard Strauss. Hell, maybe it was Richard Champion. Whoever it was, they were talking about savouring silence, about embracing emptiness, about avoiding anything that insists itself upon you.You don’t get a lot of Debussy at football games
Bryson DeChambeau making his own golf clubs in quest for Masters title
Bryson DeChambeau has revealed the latest strand to his career: golf club manufacturing. The two-time major winner used pre-tournament media duties at the Masters to explain he is making his own clubs, in what marks a stark departure from elite golfers working in tandem with equipment companies.“I think it’s the willingness to always try to improve,” DeChambeau said. “There’s this nature that I have about myself where innovation is a habit of mine and I really find and take pride in that ability to learn, even through failure, even through making a bad decision or a good decision.“South Africa [at the recent LIV event] I was trying wedges
UK politics: Farage says Trump’s Iranian ‘civilisation will die’ threats went ‘way too far’– as it happened
Can Starmer maintain ‘defensive strikes’ stance as Trump escalates threats on Iran?
Reform cold calling public in bid to find ‘paper’ candidates for local elections
British Medical Association accused of hypocrisy as its own staff strike over pay
Reform UK would stop visas for people from countries seeking slavery reparations
‘Seismic change’: how election wins for nationalists in Celtic nations could reshape UK