Rishi Sunak only politician sent witness statement in China spy case
Rishi Sunak was the only politician to be sent a witness statement by the deputy national security adviser at the centre of a controversy about the collapse of a case against two British men accused of spying for China.According to letters sent to the joint committee on the national security strategy, the statement from Matthew Collins in December 2023, which was sent to the then prime minister and his advisers, did not describe China as an enemy, another key element of the case.The letters also set out that by this point, the start of the prosecution process, police and prosecutors were told that Collins would not call China an enemy as this was not the policy of the then Conservative government.The case against the men, Christopher Cash and Christopher Berry, was dropped in September after prosecutors concluded that a conviction under the Official Secrets Act was not realistic without government evidence China posed a threat to the UK’s national security.Both Cash and Berry have consistently denied any wrongdoing.
The Conservatives have challenged Keir Starmer repeatedly about what he and his advisers knew about the case, and whether the prime minister or others intervened so as to avoid a potential row with China.But the letters published on Friday by the joint committee, which is holding an inquiry into the affair, set out that once the formal prosecution case had begun, no politicians were involved, meaning it was only Sunak who was sent Collins’s statement.Speaking after the letters were released, Starmer’s press secretary said the Conservatives had “serious questions to answer” about their role in the affair following “weeks of baseless allegations”.However, a source close to Sunak said the former PM had checked with the Cabinet Office and found there was no record of Collins’s statement being put in his prime ministerial box, meaning he would not have seen it personally.In a letter to Matt Western, the Labour MP who chairs the joint committee, Collins and Jonathan Powell, the national security adviser, set out that a first draft of Collins’s witness statement was sent to Sunak’s office in December 2023, “to also be shared with No 10 special advisers”.
By this point, the letter said, a description of China as an “enemy” initially included in a draft had been removed by Collins “as it did not reflect government policy”,This fact was passed on to police and the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), Powell and Collins said in their letter, and added: “We understand from CTP [counter-terrorism police] that the CPS were aware of this in December 2023, which was before charges were brought,”The letter reiterated the insistence of Starmer’s government that it had nothing to do with the collapse of the case and did not see subsequent statements requested from Collins by prosecutors, produced after the change of government,“Following the submission of the first DNSA [deputy national security adviser] witness statement to CTP, no minister or special adviser (including the current NSA) played any role in the provision of evidence,The DNSA understood from lawyers that following the charging decision, his witness statement could not be shared,” the letter set out.
Later, the committee published a letter from Stephen Parkinson, the director of public prosecutions, whose role has come under increasing scrutiny.Sign up to First EditionOur morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it mattersafter newsletter promotionAnswering a series of detailed questions, Parkinson set out how the threshold for securing a conviction under the Official Secrets Act had changed following a separate trial of six Bulgarian nationals found guilty of spying for Russia, which saw legal challenges based on whether a country to which information was passed had to be an “enemy”.Parkinson said that after discussions with Collins, it became clear that he would not describe China as “an active threat to national security” because that was not, Collins said, government policy.The furthest Collins would go was “active espionage threat”, Parkinson wrote, and that in the end this was seen as not enough for a conviction.This was, he said, all connected to the situation under the Conservatives, when the charges were brought: “The position of the current government was not relevant to the case.
”In another letter to the committee also published on Friday, the attorney general, Richard Hermer, said he had played no role in the case beyond getting a “brief update” from prosecutors in August, and being told the next month that the case was being dropped.“Consent [for prosecution] was given by my predecessors on 3 April 2024.Following that date, no law officer intervened in the case at any stage,” he wrote.Starmer and his ministers have argued that the trial would not have had to be abandoned if the Conservatives had been speedier in replacing the Official Secrets Act, which dated from 1911.It has since been replaced with the National Security Act.
Factionalism, farce and chaos dog Reform UK in the garden of England
When Reform UK swept to power in Kent at the local elections this year, Nigel Farage arrived in the county by helicopter for a victory party marked by champagne and fireworks.Just over 25 weeks on from what the Reform leader described as one of the most significant days of his career, the sparks flying are of a very different kind.Farage has returned to national campaigning and left the running of Kent county council and its £2.5bn annual budget to its newly installed leader, the combative former journalist and ex-Tory Linden Kemkaran.Last week the Guardian published a recording of an incendiary meeting in which she told dissenting colleagues they had to “fucking suck it up” if they didn’t like her decisions
Lucy Powell wins Labour deputy leadership election
Lucy Powell has won Labour’s deputy leadership election, beating her rival Bridget Phillipson, as she said the party would not win by trying to “out-Reform Reform”.Powell, who was the Commons leader until she was sacked in Keir Starmer’s reshuffle at the start of September, was seen as the favourite throughout the contest. She won 87,407 votes, 54% of those cast, while Phillipson received 73,536. Turnout of eligible voters was 16.6%
Rishi Sunak only politician sent witness statement in China spy case
Rishi Sunak was the only politician to be sent a witness statement by the deputy national security adviser at the centre of a controversy about the collapse of a case against two British men accused of spying for China.According to letters sent to the joint committee on the national security strategy, the statement from Matthew Collins in December 2023, which was sent to the then prime minister and his advisers, did not describe China as an enemy, another key element of the case.The letters also set out that by this point, the start of the prosecution process, police and prosecutors were told that Collins would not call China an enemy as this was not the policy of the then Conservative government.The case against the men, Christopher Cash and Christopher Berry, was dropped in September after prosecutors concluded that a conviction under the Official Secrets Act was not realistic without government evidence China posed a threat to the UK’s national security. Both Cash and Berry have consistently denied any wrongdoing
Local election wipeout would see off Starmer, MPs say after Caerphilly rout
A wipeout for Labour in next May’s local elections would spell the end of Keir Starmer’s premiership, MPs have said, after the party suffered a crushing defeat in its traditional heartland in Wales.Though Plaid Cymru beat Reform UK to capture the Senedd seat in Caerphilly, the result highlighted a striking collapse of Labour’s vote, prompting fears in Westminster that Labour could be reduced to third place in Wales, a loss that would leave the leader’s position unrecoverable.In a town that Labour has controlled for more than a century and where it still has an MP, it secured just 11% of the vote, a negative swing of 27%. The humiliating result showed that the party is highly vulnerable to challenges from other progressive parties, as well as from Reform.It provoked renewed anger and concern from some Labour MPs, with one condemning what they called a “totally incoherent” strategy within No 10
When hearts were in the Home Office | Brief letters
The home secretary says that the Home Office is not fit for purpose (Report, 22 October). It was not always so. When Alice Bacon was a minister at Education, having moved there from the Home Office in the late 1960s, she told me, then Guardian education correspondent, that it was like moving from a Rolls‑Royce to a Mini.Richard BourneLondon Marilyn Rowley’s problem of being woken up by the irritating BBC Sounds jingle (Letters, 17 October) can be solved by setting the sleep timer in the Sounds app to turn the programme off after 45 minutes (In Our Time lasts 50).Tim MartineauPrenton, Merseyside So, Reform councillors in Kent have been told by their leader to “suck it up” (Report, 20 October)
No 10 accepts people are ‘disappointed with the pace of change’ as Plaid Cymru celebrates Caerphilly byelection win – as it happpened
The prime minister’s press secretary has responded to the Caerphilly Senedd constituency byelection, which saw a huge swing away from Labour, by saying that “Byelections are always difficult for incumbent governments,” PA Media reports.It quotes them saying:This one is no different, but we are determined to show the people of Caerphilly and working people across Wales the change the UK Government is delivering hand in hand with the Labour government in Wales.(We are) determined to go further and faster, understand people are disappointed with the pace of change, and that is what the Government is relentlessly focused on delivering for working people in Wales and across the UK.The prime minister’s press secretary has responded to the Caerphilly Senedd constituency byelection, which saw a victory for Plaid Cymru with Reform UK in second place and a huge swing away from Labour, by saying “By-elections are always difficult for incumbent governments. [We] understand people are disappointed with the pace of change”Lindsay Whittle has been sworn in as the Plaid Cymru Senedd member for Caerphilly in Cardiff after taking 47% of the vote with 15,961
Buy now, pay later holiday purchases leaving travellers exposed to losses
Co-op staff told to boost promotion of vapes after costly cyber-attack, document shows
‘He’s one of the few politicians who likes crypto’: my day with the UK tech bros hosting Nigel Farage
‘Sycophantic’ AI chatbots tell users what they want to hear, study shows
Lando Norris claims F1 Mexico City GP pole as teammate Oscar Piastri falters
Vladimir Kramnik denies wrongdoing in death of US chess star Daniel Naroditsky