Keir Starmer and his team mount a leadership challenge … to himself | John Crace

A picture


Sometimes what you see is what you get,Usually in Westminster things happen for a reason,The logic may not be obvious but if you use your imagination you can come up with some logic for someone doing something that appears to be batshit crazy,But just occasionally, you reach a singularity on the space-time continuum where the laws of physics break down and nothing makes sense,A state of Platonic batshitness.

Unadulterated madness,Where things seem crazy merely because they are,Put simply: for no good reason, Keir Starmer and his team in Downing Street have chosen this week to mount a leadership challenge to himself,As if everyone inside No 10 has simultaneously had a collective breakdown,It’s an act of self-harm on an almost unimaginable scale.

One that would leave lemmings gawping in amazement.Wondering why their destructive tendencies were so unambitious.Late on Tuesday night, Downing Street came out fighting Downing Street in a story published by the Guardian.Cabinet members were plotting to get rid of Keir.Not just Wes Streeting, though he was the worst offender.

But Shabana Mahmood and Ed Miliband, too,There were probably more,Bastards, the lot of them,A coup was imminent,Not in May after the local elections but in a few weeks’ time after the budget.

But Keir was ready for them.Oh yes! No one messes with the Little Man.Come and get him if you think you’re hard enough.Keir would fight back and Keir would win.The plotters were nobodies who would spook the bond markets.

Only Keir could deliver us from evil.Except … except it was all a morphine-fuelled fever dream.Paranoid fantasies of men and women lined up in a circular firing squad.There was no plot.Which isn’t to say that Wes and Shabana don’t have leadership ambitions.

Both would be more than happy to take up residence in Downing Street if the chance arose,Just that neither of them have a campaign team primed and ready to go,Keir has added two and two and come to five,The main reason that Streeting makes TikTok videos, talks about the NHS and Gaza is because he loves his job,Wes enjoys being Wes.

No one will ever love Wes quite the way Wes loves himself,But that applies to many successful politicians,Keir sees competence – Wes’s ease with himself – and senses danger,Someone to be cut down for showing up Starmer,Likewise Shabana.

Tall poppy syndrome.If the idea was to look hard – think Gordon Brown going for David Miliband – it backfired badly.Starmer had managed to turn his leadership into a live issue.People who hadn’t been talking about whether he needed to be replaced now were.Starmer is a bit like Kemi Badenoch in this respect.

Both have an unerring sense of political anti-matter.Doing the wrong thing at the wrong time.What’s more, Keir managed to alienate almost everyone.Wes, Shabana and Ed, obviously.But also Labour backbenchers who just want a bit of steadiness from No 10.

A sense of calm.Instead they just get panic.Bordering on insanity.As for the country at large, they just wondered what the hell was going on.Starmer has been in power for under 18 months and is trying to get rid of himself.

Even Liz Truss didn’t come up with an idea like that,To top it all, No 10 chose to launch its attacks on the evening before Streeting was due to do the morning media round,Something Wes loves doing,And is good at,Wes’s specialist subject is Wes and he was able to deflect all the leadership talk with grace and humour.

No, he had never thought of being leader,Mmm,Not entirely true but never mind,He had no idea what was going on in the addled brains of No 10,He was sure Keir would want to have a word with his team.

Just time to get in the obligatory reference to The Traitors – it’s a new law that all politicians have to declare themselves a Faithful, to themselves if no one else – and he was out of there.Looking stronger than ever.If he hadn’t been a genuine leadership contender before this, he was now.That just left prime minister’s questions for Keir to endure.Thankfully, Wes and Ed were otherwise engaged so he only had Shabana to ignore.

She didn’t seem to mind that much,In any case, the prime minister looked understandably distracted,Even a man like him, almost devoid of political instincts, could see he was in trouble,Some days you just want to go home and watch the TV,Now, it wouldn’t have been a total surprise if Kemi had misread the situation and used all her six questions to ask about the BBC.

She is every bit as hopeless as Keir.And far more irrelevant.Nothing she says really matters.Her role these days is largely performative.But for once the Tory leader could spot an open goal that even she couldn’t miss.

No wonder she looked so cheerful.She went in hard.Did the prime minister agree with the health secretary that there was a toxic culture in Downing Street? He didn’t.Any attack on a member of his cabinet was unacceptable, Keir insisted.Especially one that he had orchestrated himself.

Keir will be furious with Keir when Keir realises what he has done to Wes,You could feel the energy being sucked out of the Labour benches,This was going to be every bit as they feared,Then the pressure ramped up a bit,A goodish gag about waiting lists – Wes had reached the top of his – and then more squirming.

Did the prime minister have confidence in Morgan McSweeney, his chief of staff? “McSweeney, my team and I are absolutely focused on delivering for the country,” said Starmer,Not exactly the endorsement Morgan may have been hoping for,You also had to wonder just what Keir thought he was delivering,Chaos? That’s working,This carried on for a couple more questions before Kemi appeared to get bored and moved on to the economy.

For the first time, Keir looked vaguely relieved.If she had continued for the whole six questions on the self-generated hysteria, some real damage might have been done.A resignation from the Downing St team may have been inevitable.But Badenoch was keen to show that there was more than one person who could fuck up at PMQs.It was still an easy win for her.

But it could have been a humiliation.The rest of the session passed off uneventfully.Other than Rupert Lowe demanding the death penalty for foreigners.Nice.We ended with Labour’s Gill German offering Starmer a spot of R&R in Rhyl.

“That sounds like an appealing invitation,” he said.The most honest he had been all day.
societySee all
A picture

Peter Archer obituary

My friend Peter Archer, who has died aged 80, bettered the lives of many people by improving housing conditions and regenerating neighbourhoods from inner city Bristol to New Delhi. He combined a strategic vision with a belief that communities should have a voice in decisions that affect their lives.One of Peter’s greatest achievements was his establishment in 1986 of Care and Repair England, a project designed to help older and disabled people to continue to live independently by improving their existing housing conditions. He chaired the charity for 20 years and would later (in 2010) rewrite UK government guidance on home adaptations for disabled people.Born and raised in Bromley, Kent, Peter came from a family with a strong Methodist background

A picture

Marianne Rigge obituary

My wife, Marianne Rigge, who has died aged 77, was a passionate public advocate for the interests of NHS patients, and a pioneer in creating ways of giving people easier access to medical and health information.The daughter of a GP, she founded a national charity, the College of Health, with the renowned social entrepreneur Michael Young, in response to their experiences as patients and in the consumer movement. Young was the inspiration behind organisations including the Open University and the Consumers’ Association, which he launched in 1957.Marianne joined the Consumers’ Association in the 1970s, and she and Young set up the College of Health in 1983, with the aim of influencing NHS doctors to put the needs of patients at the centre of treatment and care decisions. She ran the charity as director, from Bethnal Green, east London, for 20 years and it helped thousands of people

A picture

Abuse by UK’s ‘most prolific sex offender’ was ignored at Medomsley detention centre, report finds

A man who worked as a prison officer and caterer in a youth detention centre was able to rape and torture boys for three decades while the abuse was “ignored and dismissed”, according to a report labelling him as possibly Britain’s worst ever sex offender.Neville Husband carried out at least 388 sexual offences against young men and boys between 1969 and 1985 while working at Medomsley detention centre in County Durham, but is believed have committed hundreds more crimes, which would take the total past the 450 committed by Jimmy Savile.Adrian Usher, the prisons and probation ombudsman (PPO) for England and Wales, has compiled a 202-page report on the conduct of staff at Medomsley from 1961 to 1987, in which he describes Husband as “possibly the most prolific sex offender in British history”.Husband, a former church minister and scout troop leader who died in 2010, is thought to have groomed and attacked hundreds of trainees in Medomsley’s kitchens, where he worked.Men and boys aged 17 to 21 who had been convicted of relatively minor crimes were sent to Medomsley where the ethos of the “short, sharp shock” was in place to deter them from reoffending

A picture

Experts concerned over health effects of high-dose nicotine pouches as sales soar in UK

Walk into any corner shop and you’ll see them: colourful tins stacked beside the chewing gum, boasting flavours from frosty berry and lime storm to something called Tomorrowland. Welcome to nicotine pouches – the tobacco industry’s latest diversification strategy.Marketed as “tobacco-free” but packed with nicotine, these small sachets promise a discreet buzz. Sales are rapidly climbing, and UK ministers are considering tighter rules. But are they helping smokers to quit – or hooking a new generation on nicotine? And what else are they doing to people’s health?Nicotine pouches are different from snus – a moist tobacco paste – and vapes, which deliver nicotine via inhalation

A picture

‘I don’t want anyone to suffer like I did’: the intersex campaigners fighting to limit surgery on children

What should be done about the small proportion of babies born with genitals that are neither typically male nor typically female? Many of those affected believe parents and doctors are often too quick to schedule operationsSmall Luk was initially “so happy” to be offered genital reconstruction surgery, aged eight. Doctors had told her she was a boy, but that she had an illness, which was why she couldn’t urinate standing up. “They told me this is a problem,” the 60-year-old from Hong Kong says. “And that in the future, you cannot marry, you cannot have a baby, so you need to have surgeries.”Having been bullied at school for her ambiguous gender presentation, she found the idea that she could be “modified back to normal” a compelling one

A picture

Private care providers in three English regions make £250m in three years

Private companies operating care services in just three regions of England have taken more than £250m in profits in three years, with more than a third going to providers owned by private equity firms or companies based in tax havens.New analysis by Reclaiming Our Regional Economies warned that public money is being rapidly funnelled out of the care system into the hands of private companies, rather than reinvested to improve services.The report, published on Wednesday, found that in the North East, South Yorkshire and the West Midlands, £256m in profit was made by private companies providing care services between 2021 and 2024.“Politicians and pundits tell us that there simply isn’t the money to invest in social care and that we can’t afford to borrow more to build a better system,” the report states.“The truth is that money exists in the care system but too much of it is leaking out