The Philpster exhausts his repertoire with return to Rwanda at PMQs | John Crace

A picture


Thoughts and prayers with Alex Burghart.Not so long ago, the shadow chancellor of the duchy of Lancaster was allowed out by Kemi Badenoch to stand in for her at prime minister’s questions when Keir Starmer was otherwise engaged.Though this may be a memory Alex wishes to forget.It wasn’t his finest hour.Angela Rayner ran rings around him without even breaking sweat.

So, on Wednesday, Alex found himself sidelined.Not wanted on voyage.From time to time, he would check his phone for messages.Just in case he had missed something.Willing his phone to ping with a late call-up.

Nothing,He just had to suck it up,Take his place on the opposition frontbench and cheer on some other poor sucker,Maybe it was for the best,Some men are born failures.

Some achieve failure.Some have failure thrust upon them.Alex is unique.A combination of all three.Instead it was Chris Philp who got the job.

Given the nod by Kemi shortly after breakfast and with next to no time to prepare,The last man standing who can be trusted to be loyal,Or more or less competent,In his own way,At least some of his neural pathways function as they should.

The Philpster is Team Kemi through and through.Up until Team Kemi is no longer a thing.Much as he was with Team Truss.Then he will be his own man.Left to ponder that no one will ever be Team Philp.

Chris even looks and sounds a bit like Kemi,Just not as good,Imagine,But this was his moment,His time.

It might never happen again.He could be a hero.Just for one day.Also having an unexpectedly good day was Keir.Of all the days to miss PMQs, this was a good one.

A nice snooze on the flight back from Canada.No tricky questions on why the G7 turned into the G6.No having to cover for a US president who seemed to imagine he was the star of his own first-person-shooter video game.No having to look his own MPs in the eye as his government published its new welfare bill.Over to Angie.

Philp stuck to what he knew,Grooming gangs and immigrants,Which all felt rather familiar,As if we knew what everyone was going to say before they said it,After all, Kemi had had her say in answer to Yvette Cooper’s Commons statement on Monday.

The next day she and the Philpster had held their own press conference to fill in any gaps.And now? Now, it was third time lucky.So far, they had consistently struck the wrong note.Maybe this was the chance they needed.And it wasn’t as if Chris was capable of coming up with any other questions.

This was all about the survivors, said Philp.Which was a decent place to start, given that he and Kemi had previously made it all about them.A bit of a stretch given that neither had shown much interest in the scandal when they had been in government.Rayner thanked him for his tone and assured the house that the inquiry would be comprehensive and would put the victims first.After that, it was all rather downhill.

Maybe it was nerves, but the Philpster got increasingly shouty and squeaky.His voice racing through the octaves.Starmer should apologise for calling people far right and racist for having demanded an inquiry.Ange corrected him.Keir had only been calling out those who had previously shown no interest in grooming gangs and, besides, he had done more to secure convictions as director of public prosecutions than the Tory government had managed in 14 years.

It was just weird to think that Philp and Kemi were now positioning themselves as the champions of the survivors, but we were where we were,Chris moved on to his next pet subject,Illegal immigrants,One or two of the people who had arrived on small boats were implicated in child sexual exploitation,Therefore, it followed that every illegal immigrant was probably a paedophile.

And should be killed.Or something.And another thing … The Philpster was racing through his desperately limited repertoire and was already struggling.Rwanda.If only Labour hadn’t closed down the Rwanda scheme, then already more than a million immigrants – although why stop at those arriving by small boat? Why not go for those with visas too? – would have been safely rehoused in Rwanda to fight in the war with the Democratic Republic of the Congo.

“The deputy prime minister has a brass neck,” he declared,For … for stating the obvious,That Rwanda was always going to fail,Rishi Sunak would never have called a general election last July if he had believed in the scheme,But to his dying breath, Chris will insist otherwise.

He just needed a few more days, a week, even.Then he coulda been a contender.We ended where we always end on these occasions.Nowhere very much.Philp may have disappointed the Tory benches who had been hoping for a miracle, but Rayner hadn’t exactly shone.

It was as though she didn’t believe the lines she had been given to read out,Was starting to wonder if neither the Tories nor Labour had all the answers,A revelation that comes to all sentient politicians in the end,You could chalk it up as a win for Ange,Largely because she’s the more engaging.

She connects to people.They believe her.Well, not all.Labour’s Sarah Champion managed to throw a dampener on proceedings, saying she had had enough of point scoring from all sides of the house over the grooming gangs.The victims had even been failed by the criminal injuries compensation scheme.

Time for everyone to up their game.
societySee all
A picture

Pepper spray use in youth prisons irresponsible amid racial disparities, watchdog warns

The rollout of synthetic pepper spray for use to incapacitate jailed children is “wholly irresponsible” while black and minority prisoners are more likely to be subjected to force than white inmates, a watchdog has said.Elisabeth Davies, the national chair of the Independent Monitoring Boards, whose members operate in every prison in England and Wales, said the justice secretary, Shabana Mahmood, should pause the use of Pava spray in youth offending institutions (YOIs) until ministers had addressed the disproportionate use of force on minority prisoners.“There is clear racial disproportionality when it comes to the use of force,” she told the Guardian. “It is therefore, I think, wholly irresponsible to expand use-of-force measures before disproportionality issues are addressed.”Mahmood authorised the rollout of Pava across YOIs in England and Wales in April amid growing demands from the Prison Officers’ Association (POA) to protect staff from attacks

A picture

Ondine Sherwood obituary

My friend Ondine Sherwood, who has died from lung cancer aged 65, was one of the earliest campaigners for the recognition of Long Covid. Having failed to recover fully from Covid-19 in March 2020, she discovered that others were suffering similarly and GPs did not seem to know how to diagnose them. Ondine rapidly became the main spokesperson for the patient-created term “Long Covid”. She founded the group Long Covid SOS that June and secured charitable status and trustees.Ondine lobbied politicians, doctors and civil servants for recognition of the illness

A picture

The debate over assisted dying and palliative care | Letters

I do not disagree with Gordon Brown that palliative care should be better funded, but to present palliative care as the alternative to assisted dying is to present a false equivalence, since the principles behind the two are quite different (MPs have personal beliefs, but also solemn duties: that’s why they must reject the assisted dying bill this week, 16 June).The principle behind the entitlement to good palliative care is that one should be entitled to good medical care – in this instance, as death approaches. The principle behind the right to an assisted death is that one should be entitled to determine the time and manner of one’s passing.If one were always to prioritise the right to good medical care above the right to have control over one’s death, it is unlikely that assisted dying would ever be legalised, as there will always be some medical care for somebody that could be better funded. But that is to choose to prioritise one principle over another

A picture

NHS nurse ordered to remove ‘antisemitic’ watermelon video call background launches legal action

A senior NHS nurse who says he was ordered to remove a background on his video calls that showed a fruit bowl containing a watermelon because it could be perceived as antisemitic has launched legal action against his employer.Ahmad Baker, who is British-Palestinian and works at Whipps Cross hospital, north London, is one of three medical staff claiming Barts Health NHS trust’s ban on staff displaying symbols perceived as politically or nationally affiliated is disproportionate and discriminatory. Watermelons became symbols of Palestine amid censorship of the Palestinian flag because of its similar colours.Barts, which runs five London hospitals, introduced the ban in March in its updated uniform and dress code policy, which extends to items on workstations, laptops and iPads, even if staff are working from home and not seeing patients.The policy says it is in keeping with the trust’s responsibility to be “completely apolitical and non-biased in our care”, but the claimants point to Barts’ support for Ukraine

A picture

Teenagers who report addictive use of screens at greater risk of suicidal behaviour, study shows

Teenagers who show signs of being addicted to social media, mobile phones or video games are at greater risk of suicidal behaviour and emotional problems, according to research.A study, which tracked more than 4,000 adolescents for four years, found that nearly one in three reported increasingly addictive use of social media or mobile phones. Those whose use followed an increasingly addictive trajectory had roughly double the risk of suicidal behaviour at the end of the study.The findings do not prove screen use was the cause of mental health problems. But they highlight that compulsive use, which appears to be very common, as a significant risk factor that parents and healthcare services should be alert to

A picture

US supreme court upholds Tennessee ban on youth gender-affirming care

A Tennessee state law banning gender-affirming care for minors can stand, the US supreme court has ruled, a devastating loss for trans rights supporters in a case that could set a precedent for dozens of other lawsuits involving the rights of transgender children.The case, United States v Skrmetti, was filed last year by three families of trans children and a provider of gender-affirming care. In oral arguments, the plaintiffs – as well as the US government, then helmed by Joe Biden – argued that Tennessee’s law constituted sex-based discrimination and thus violated the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment. Under Tennessee’s law, someone assigned female at birth could not be prescribed testosterone, but someone assigned male at birth could receive those drugs.Tennessee, meanwhile, has argued that the ban is necessary to protect children from what it termed “experimental” medical treatment