What could Albanese do to improve productivity? Here is a short, non-exhaustive list | Greg Jericho

A picture


In his address last week at the National Press Club, the prime minister announced a “productivity roundtable” in concert with the Productivity Commission’s latest inquiry into the issue.I won’t be at the roundtable but I do have a few ideas.First off, remember that productivity is the amount you produce with the hours and equipment you have.Work better with what you have or (usually) get better equipment to do your work faster, and productivity increases.It is not about reducing the cost of producing things.

Getting paid $10 less an hour to do the same amount of work does not increase productivity even if your employer is more profitable,Unfortunately, productivity is often confused with profit and so business groups argue the key is lower company tax,They claim this will increase investment in things that increase productivity (such as new equipment or new buildings and structures),The evidence, though, is pretty nonexistent,The massive 2017 Trump company tax cuts, for example, which cut the federal US company tax rate from as high as 35% to a flat rate of 21% did bugger all to spur investment:If the graph does not display click hereHopefully the Productivity Commission will heed the advice of the current productivity commissioner, Danielle Wood, who in 2018 wrote that cutting the company tax rate would “see national incomes go backwards for six years”.

And income is really what productivity is about – specifically workers’ income and their living standards,In theory, the real value of how much you earn an hour should rise in line with productivity,In the 1990s this mostly happened but from 2000 onwards workers have missed out:If the graph does not display click hereSo, when worrying about productivity, we must remember to ask who benefits,But what could the government do to improve productivity? Here is a short, non-exhaustive list,This year, the government will pay about $10bn in diesel fuel rebates to mining and transport companies and the agriculture sector.

By 2028-29 it will be $13bn.Despite growing almost as fast as the NDIS, we never hear the government talk about needing to rein in the expense:If the graph does not display click hereBut the fuel tax credit not only encourages use of fossil fuels, it creates a disincentive to investment in more efficient and productive new vehicles – such as electric trucks.Research and development is vital to produce new equipment and technology (such as electric trucks).But the Australian government spends much less on R&D than most other OECD governments:If the graph does not display click hereThe government in April extended the $20,000 instant asset write-off for small business.This was purely a political rather than economic decision.

Rather than encourage investment in productivity enhancing equipment, it is mostly a tax rort to buy big utes.How do we know this? Well, last week the AFR’s wealth reporter, in a column about avoiding paying tax, described the instant asset write-off as “a favourite perk of small businesses and sole traders”.They ain’t lying.What else is a bad productivity investment? Residential land.It adds bugger all.

But Australians devote far too much capital to property – almost 2,5 times that of the US:If the graph does not display click hereOur tax system encourages this with the 50% capital gains tax discount and negative gearing, while also reducing housing affordability,The Parliamentary Budget Office estimated that removing the tax discount and negative gearing on investment properties would raise about $13,35bn in 2025-26,Dental health hurts the economy and reduces productivity because workers avoid going to the dentist because of the cost and end up with chronic issues that reduce output.

A public system would be much more productive because it would massively reduce the cost hurdle for workers.The PBO estimated that putting dental into Medicare would cost $13.7bn.Rather conveniently for us, that is essentially the same as removing the CGT discount and negative gearing.By the same token, we know health systems that are dependent on private health insurance, such as in the US, are unproductive because the resources devoted to them deliver worse outcomes than public health:If the graph does not display click hereAustralia’s health system is generally well regarded but a recent report noted that we faired quite poorly when it came to access to care.

Private health insurance is not a productive industry – consider the hours and expense devoted to marketing that yields no extra benefit.The same goes for private schools and the fees people pay.A 2022 study found that private education does not improve a student’s academic performance.More resources devoted to no better outcomes is the essence of poor productivity.Currently both are exempt from GST, which effectively incentivises people to spend money on them (as does allowing donations to build structures in private schools to be tax deductible).

Including both within the GST would deliver revenue that could go to improving productive public schools and hospitals, while repairing the shrinking tax base of the GST.Best of all, because richer households spend more of their income on both private school and private health insurance, the tax would actually be progressive.If the graph does not display click hereControversial? Of course.Which is why a government would also want to announce something huge – like say dental in Medicare.Productivity is an ongoing issue but the key is to always think about who benefits from changes and that the solutions are not about increasing profits or offshoring labour or reducing workers’ pay but should always be about making people’s lives better.

Greg Jericho is a Guardian columnist and policy director at the Centre for Future Work
societySee all
A picture

Pepper spray use in youth prisons irresponsible amid racial disparities, watchdog warns

The rollout of synthetic pepper spray for use to incapacitate jailed children is “wholly irresponsible” while black and minority prisoners are more likely to be subjected to force than white inmates, a watchdog has said.Elisabeth Davies, the national chair of the Independent Monitoring Boards, whose members operate in every prison in England and Wales, said the justice secretary, Shabana Mahmood, should pause the use of Pava spray in youth offending institutions (YOIs) until ministers had addressed the disproportionate use of force on minority prisoners.“There is clear racial disproportionality when it comes to the use of force,” she told the Guardian. “It is therefore, I think, wholly irresponsible to expand use-of-force measures before disproportionality issues are addressed.”Mahmood authorised the rollout of Pava across YOIs in England and Wales in April amid growing demands from the Prison Officers’ Association (POA) to protect staff from attacks

A picture

Ondine Sherwood obituary

My friend Ondine Sherwood, who has died from lung cancer aged 65, was one of the earliest campaigners for the recognition of Long Covid. Having failed to recover fully from Covid-19 in March 2020, she discovered that others were suffering similarly and GPs did not seem to know how to diagnose them. Ondine rapidly became the main spokesperson for the patient-created term “Long Covid”. She founded the group Long Covid SOS that June and secured charitable status and trustees.Ondine lobbied politicians, doctors and civil servants for recognition of the illness

A picture

The debate over assisted dying and palliative care | Letters

I do not disagree with Gordon Brown that palliative care should be better funded, but to present palliative care as the alternative to assisted dying is to present a false equivalence, since the principles behind the two are quite different (MPs have personal beliefs, but also solemn duties: that’s why they must reject the assisted dying bill this week, 16 June).The principle behind the entitlement to good palliative care is that one should be entitled to good medical care – in this instance, as death approaches. The principle behind the right to an assisted death is that one should be entitled to determine the time and manner of one’s passing.If one were always to prioritise the right to good medical care above the right to have control over one’s death, it is unlikely that assisted dying would ever be legalised, as there will always be some medical care for somebody that could be better funded. But that is to choose to prioritise one principle over another

A picture

NHS nurse ordered to remove ‘antisemitic’ watermelon video call background launches legal action

A senior NHS nurse who says he was ordered to remove a background on his video calls that showed a fruit bowl containing a watermelon because it could be perceived as antisemitic has launched legal action against his employer.Ahmad Baker, who is British-Palestinian and works at Whipps Cross hospital, north London, is one of three medical staff claiming Barts Health NHS trust’s ban on staff displaying symbols perceived as politically or nationally affiliated is disproportionate and discriminatory. Watermelons became symbols of Palestine amid censorship of the Palestinian flag because of its similar colours.Barts, which runs five London hospitals, introduced the ban in March in its updated uniform and dress code policy, which extends to items on workstations, laptops and iPads, even if staff are working from home and not seeing patients.The policy says it is in keeping with the trust’s responsibility to be “completely apolitical and non-biased in our care”, but the claimants point to Barts’ support for Ukraine

A picture

Teenagers who report addictive use of screens at greater risk of suicidal behaviour, study shows

Teenagers who show signs of being addicted to social media, mobile phones or video games are at greater risk of suicidal behaviour and emotional problems, according to research.A study, which tracked more than 4,000 adolescents for four years, found that nearly one in three reported increasingly addictive use of social media or mobile phones. Those whose use followed an increasingly addictive trajectory had roughly double the risk of suicidal behaviour at the end of the study.The findings do not prove screen use was the cause of mental health problems. But they highlight that compulsive use, which appears to be very common, as a significant risk factor that parents and healthcare services should be alert to

A picture

US supreme court upholds Tennessee ban on youth gender-affirming care

A Tennessee state law banning gender-affirming care for minors can stand, the US supreme court has ruled, a devastating loss for trans rights supporters in a case that could set a precedent for dozens of other lawsuits involving the rights of transgender children.The case, United States v Skrmetti, was filed last year by three families of trans children and a provider of gender-affirming care. In oral arguments, the plaintiffs – as well as the US government, then helmed by Joe Biden – argued that Tennessee’s law constituted sex-based discrimination and thus violated the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment. Under Tennessee’s law, someone assigned female at birth could not be prescribed testosterone, but someone assigned male at birth could receive those drugs.Tennessee, meanwhile, has argued that the ban is necessary to protect children from what it termed “experimental” medical treatment