OBR a backseat driver with out-of-date maps, thinktanks tell Rachel Reeves
Rachel Reeves must reform the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) to open the way to more public investment, an alliance of thinktanks has argued ahead of the chancellor’s spring forecast on Tuesday.With Keir Starmer’s government under intense pressure after Labour’s defeat by the Greens in Thursday’s Gorton and Denton byelection, the thinktanks called on Reeves to review the watchdog’s remit.The coalition includes the Labour group Progress, usually considered on the right of the party, the leftwing thinktanks the New Economics Foundation (NEF) and Common Wealth, and the feminist Women’s Budget Group.They said: “It has become increasingly clear that our current framework is contributing to instability, short-termist underinvestment and a lack of focus on long-term risks and opportunities.”Reeves is expected to focus in the spring forecast on Labour’s progress in restoring fiscal stability and point to evidence of a nascent economic recovery.
Louisa Dollimore, the director of strategy at the Good Growth Foundation, which convened the group, said: “The OBR is a backseat driver with out-of-date maps: it obstructs long-term planning and investment at a moment when Britain needs both.”Hannah Peaker, the NEF’s deputy chief executive, said: “While independent scrutiny of the government’s spending plans is important, our current system means small changes in uncertain forecasts lead to governments making kneejerk policy changes of huge consequence.This is no way to run an economy.”Last week the Institute for Fiscal Studies called for the fiscal rules to be overhauled.Some economists complain that the OBR takes insufficient account of the potential benefits of future government investment, and that the way it has been set up to deliver a pass-fail verdict on the chancellor’s fiscal rules leads to hasty decision-making – such as the £5bn in welfare cuts made in last year’s spring statement.
Reeves has since asked the OBR, which was established by George Osborne as chancellor in 2010, to give its verdict on her fiscal rules just once a year, at the autumn budget.The thinktanks have called on her to go further.Adam Langleben, the executive director of Progress, said: “The OBR was created for an era defined by austerity, and while it can clearly count the upfront cost of investment, it too often misses the long-term value, whether that’s a healthier workforce, better housing or modern transport.“Its judgments should guide decisions, not shut down ambition.The real risk isn’t investing in Britain’s future, it’s leaving things exactly as they are.
”Reeves has changed the fiscal rules to allow the Treasury to borrow more to invest, and significantly increased taxes to fund public services, but some Labour MPs remain concerned that the party has been too cautious on tax and spend,However, the former OBR directors Richard Hughes and Robert Chote said at a hearing before the Treasury select committee last week that successive governments had overspent,Hughes, who resigned last year after the accidental early release of the OBR’s budget forecasts, told MPs: “Most surprises that governments face tend to be bad ones, especially these days, and so if you don’t take account of them, you’re always going to end up with this upwards drift … of deficits going up and debts going up,”The best public interest journalism relies on first-hand accounts from people in the know,If you have something to share on this subject you can contact the Business team confidentially using the following methods:The Guardian app has a tool to send tips about stories.
Messages are end to end encrypted and concealed within the routine activity that every Guardian mobile app performs.This prevents an observer from knowing that you are communicating with us at all, let alone what is being said.If you don't already have the Guardian app, download it (iOS/Android) and go to the menu.Scroll down and click on Secure Messaging.When asked who you wish to contact please select the ‘Business (UK & Global)’ team.
Our guide at theguardian.com/tips lists several ways to contact us securely, and discusses the pros and cons of each.
Pulp have the last word in Adelaide festival saga with triumphant opening gig
Britpop rockers wow crowd and say all voices are ‘important’ in wake of Randa Abdel-Fattah controversyGet our breaking news email, free app or daily news podcast“All voices are important,” the Pulp frontman Jarvis Cocker told an adoring crowd in Adelaide on Friday. “All voices should be heard.”Message received. At one point Pulp had pulled out of the opening gig at the Adelaide festival over the Adelaide writers’ week (AWW) furore.But they turned up, they wowed the 10,000-strong crowd, and while Cocker didn’t explicitly say his comment was a reference to the brouhaha around AWW, it was pretty clear
Seth Meyers on Team Trump’s Iran threats: ‘These guys speak like they’ve been hit on the head’
On Thursday night, late-night hosts remarked on the Jeffrey Epstein investigations, the threat of a US attack on Iran and Donald Trump nominating a wellness influencer as the next US surgeon general.Meyers focused on the president’s criticisms of a landmark 2015 deal between Iran and world powers in which the country agreed to curb their nuclear program. “I’ve been making lots of wonderful deals, great deals,” Trump said. “That’s what I do. Never in my life have I seen any transaction so incompetently negotiated as our deal with Iran
How to keep free entry to UK museums and galleries | Letters
I believe that national museums should be free for all. Your report (Is the UK’s golden era of free museum entry coming to an end?, 21 February) quoted me from a Daily Telegraph article that selectively used parts of a much longer interview. I said in principle that people would be willing to pay; however, I then outlined all the reasons this would not work financially, practically and ethically. I do not wish to be represented as a mouthpiece for those who wish to introduce charges.Nick MerrimanHastingleigh, Kent There is an easy answer to the budget difficulties faced by many UK art galleries and museums: identity cards
‘You’re sweet – and I’m old!’: Billy Porter and Sam Morrison on teaming up for a comedy about love and death
The Emmy-winning singer and actor was so struck by the standup’s autobiographical one-man show Sugar Daddy that he signed on as producer. The pair discuss ‘bears’, blood sugar and bridging the divides between generations of gay menSugar Daddy is a one-man show about “love, grief and insulin” by the 31-year-old standup Sam Morrison. An autobiographical monologue that turns tragedy into comedy, it tells of how Morrison fell in love with Jonathan, who was 24 years his senior, after meeting him at a gay bear festival in Provincetown, Massachusetts. In 2021, two and a half years into their relationship, Jonathan died from Covid.For the last four years, Morrison has been performing Sugar Daddy around the world; next month he brings an updated version to London’s West End
‘Seems I’m not dead’: Magda Szubanski says she is in remission after treatment for stage four cancer
Magda Szubanski has revealed the “fantastic news” she has finished chemotherapy and is in remission from a rare, aggressive cancer she was diagnosed with nine months ago.Wishing her fans a “Happy Mardi Gras” in a video on Instagram on Friday, Szubanski said: “I wanted to share the fantastic news, which is that I’ve completed chemo, and I am now in remission. So phew, big relief.“It’s not a cure, but because I’ve got a good remission, that hopefully means that I will … keep the cancer at bay for a good long time.”In May the 64-year-old actor and comedian said she had stage four mantle cell lymphoma, an uncommon and aggressive form of non-Hodgkin lymphoma and said she had shaved her head ahead of treatment
Seth Meyers on Trump’s State of the Union address: ‘A vehicle to attack anyone who doesn’t bend the knee’
Late-night hosts tore into Donald Trump’s extremely long State of the Union address and a bombshell new report on redactions from the Jeffrey Epstein files.Donald Trump arrived to his State of the Union address on Tuesday evening with low expectations and even lower goodwill, with his approval rating hovering somewhere around a dismal 36%. “So the polling was bad before the speech and bad after the speech,” Seth Meyers reported on Wednesday evening, “and on top of that it was long and boring,” clocking in at a record one hour and 47 minutes.Or, if you’re Republican, it was “the best State of the Union speech that I’ve seen”, to quote the House speaker, Mike Johnson. Ted Cruz went one step further, calling it “majestic”
OpenAI announces $110bn funding round that would value firm at $840bn
Instagram to alert parents if teens repeatedly search self-harm terms
Jack Dorsey to cut 4,000 jobs due to AI advances at Square parent Block
Woman at heart of US trial says she was addicted to social media at age six
Riaz Hasan obituary
Met police to pilot facial recognition identity checks, mayor confirms