South Africa make heavy weather of victory over indisciplined Ireland

A picture


The IRFU may be disconnected from a chunk of their audience on the price of Test rugby at Lansdowne Road but at least those who paid up can claim to have witnessed a truly crazy event.In the 2013 Six Nations in Rome Ireland had their backline sundered by a freakish run of injuries, leaving holes being filled by men who didn’t know how to hold a shovel.But here, on a perfect night for rugby and with a game promising to develop into a gripping contest, we saw four players banished for crimes and misdemeanours in the first half alone.Mad stuff, at the end of which – after well over two exhausting hours – the world champions stumbled to a win that should have been managed with half the effort.“I’d say it was chaotic,” Andy Farrell said.

“I haven’t seen a game like that ever.First and foremost you look at ourselves and why things happened but my overriding reaction is that I’m incredibly proud.If you can’t learn from that then you’re in the wrong place really.”The passage to the overflowing sin-bin was halted only by the half-time whistle, at which point the referee, Matt Carley, was booed off the field with a venom you don’t often see.Their sense of injustice kicked off with the decision not to card Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu for a dangerous tackle on Tommy O’Brien.

Both Farrell and his captain Caelan Doris felt a card should have been shown,So South Africa took with them a 19-7 lead and the knowledge they would be starting the second half against 12 men, albeit not for long,Ireland meantime were down the corridor with Farrell wondering what pieces he could move around a very bare-looking chessboard,The coach had seen James Ryan go first, on a yellow card escalated to red for a no-arms clean out on Malcolm Marx,The traffic became turbo charged in the last eight minutes of the half with Sam Prendergast, replacement Jack Crowley and then Andrew Porter all going off for a variety of offences.

It was only in that bizarre passage that the Boks actually got to grips with turning their pronounced dominance at the scrum to something material on the scoreboard.They looked less confused when playing against 15 men, putting Damian Willemse over for a try inside four minutes.That said, they looked happy enough early in the second half when Sam Prendergast was back on the field to kick a penalty, only for his brother Cian to spill the restart.With yet another scrum penalty advantage to play with Feinberg-Mngomezulu, a serious athlete with a surfeit of skill, fended Jamison Gibson-Park en route to the line.That put the Boks 24-10 ahead, and looking safe.

Sign up to The BreakdownThe latest rugby union news and analysis, plus all the week's action reviewedafter newsletter promotionNot so safe that they could order-in and open a bottle of red, but given they had the combination to the penalty safe there was no secure route Ireland could take in pursuit, despite their battling qualities, which Farrell described as: “Absolutely amazing.I think the crowd recognised that and supported them for it.To be able to win the second half 6-5 in those sorts of circumstances was fantastic and that doesn’t tell the whole story of the second half.” Consider that in a six-minute spell in the second quarter South Africa put Ireland on the rack, twisting seven penalties from the home side with the scrum the primary source.And that was before the hemorrhage of home players started.

Even so, South Africa spent the last few minutes frantically defending their own line, with the slim comfort of a two-score lead, which they held until Carley blew for the last time, kicking off another chorus of boos.Ireland Hansen (Farrell 65); O’Brien (HIA Crowley 32), Ringrose (Gibson-Park 75), Aki, Lowe; Prendergast, Gibson-Park (Casey 66); Porter (McCarthy 73), Sheehan (Kelleher 56), Furlong (Bealham 60), Ryan (C Prendergast 40), Beirne, Baird (Conan 60), Van der Flier (McCarthy 42; Porter 50; McCarthy 60; Porter 63), Doris (capt).Red card Ryan 21.Yellow card Prendergast 34, Crowley 40, Porter 42, McCarthy 63.Try Sheehan.

Pens Prendergast 2,Con Crowley 1,South Africa Willemse; Moodie, Kriel, De Allende, Kolbe; S Feinberg-Mngomezulu (Libbok 59) C Reinach (Williams 69); B Venter, (Steenekamp 42), M Marx (Grobbelaar 66; Marx 73), T du Toit (Louw 42; Du Toit 73), E Etzebeth (Snyman 50), R Nortje, S Kolisi (Esterhuizen 59), P-S du Toit, J Wiese (Smith 54),Yellow card Williams 79,Tries Willemse, penalty try, Reinach, Feinberg-Mngomezulu.

Con Feinberg-Mngomezulu.Referee Matthew Carley (Eng).The Boks looked relieved, but that will last only until the review: how could a team so dominant at set–piece, and with a decent all-court game to match, end up in hand to hand combat to get over the finish line.To their credit they sailed close to the wind in keeping Ireland out, and ironically ended up a man short when Grant Williams was binned with a minute left.They will look forward to their holidays.

societySee all
A picture

We know ultra-processed foods are bad for you – but can you spot them? Take our quiz

A major global report released this week linked ultra-processed foods to harm in every major human organ. For people in the US, the UK and Australia, these foods make up more than half the calories they consume each day.But it’s not always easy to tell which foods are ultra-processed.The term was coined in 2009 by researchers at the University of São Paulo, as part of their Nova food classification system that sorts foods into four groups:Group one: unprocessed or minimally processed foods including whole fruits and vegetables, milk, oats and rice.Group two: processed basic ingredients used in cooking including salt, sugar and vegetable oils

A picture

How could Reeves hit gambling firms – and are they fearmongering over impact?

Gambling companies don’t lose very often but nor are they usually playing a game of poker against the chancellor of the exchequer.At next week’s budget, Rachel Reeves is widely expected to announce an increase in the duties that bookies and casinos pay to the Treasury, ending months of speculation and frenzied lobbying designed to sway the government.The tax rise could cost the industry anything between about £1bn and £3bn, depending on how far Reeves turns the screw.To some, that would be fair recompense for an out-of-control industry grown fat on misery. To others, it would be an anti-growth tax that will backfire, costing thousands of jobs and fuelling the illicit market

A picture

Overseas-trained doctors leaving the UK in record numbers

Record numbers of overseas-trained doctors are quitting the UK, leaving the NHS at risk of huge gaps in its workforce, with hostility towards migrants blamed for the exodus.In all, 4,880 doctors who qualified in another country left the UK during 2024 – a rise of 26% on the 3,869 who did so the year before – figures from the General Medical Council reveal.NHS leaders, senior doctors and the GMC warned that the increased denigration of and abuse directed at migrants in the UK was a significant reason for the rise in foreign medics leaving.“It’s really worrying that so many highly skilled and highly valued international doctors the NHS just can’t afford to lose are leaving in their droves,” said Daniel Elkeles, the chief executive of the hospitals group NHS Providers.“We wouldn’t have an NHS if we hadn’t for many years recruited talented and valued people from all around the world

A picture

Prozac ‘no better than placebo’ for treating children with depression, experts say

Clinical guidelines should no longer recommend Prozac for children, according to experts, after research showed it had no clinical benefit for treating depression in children and adolescents.Globally one in seven 10- to 19-year-olds have a mental health condition, according to the World Health Organization. In the UK, about a quarter of older teenagers and up to a fifth of younger children have anxiety, depression or other mental health problems.In the UK, National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice) guidance says under-18s with moderate to severe depression can be prescribed antidepressants alongside therapy.But a new review of trial data by academics in Austria and the UK concluded that fluoxetine, sold under the brand name of Prozac among others, is clinically no better than placebo drugs in treating depression in children, and should therefore no longer be prescribed to them

A picture

Councils in north of England and Midlands to get more funding in shake-up

Deprived towns and cities in the Midlands and the north of England are the big winners in a shake-up of local authority funding that will redirect cash from affluent rural areas to urban councils hit hardest by austerity.Ministers said the changes put in place a fairer system that recognised the extra needs and weaker council tax-raising powers of councils in so-called “left behind” areas. It guarantees them real-terms funding increases for the next three years.“People living in the places that suffered most from austerity will finally see their areas turned around,” the local government minister, Alison McGovern, said in a parliamentary statement.The changes, which will be introduced from April, before critical local elections in May, could see funding boosts for Reform-led councils in the north with high levels of deprivation, such as Durham and Lancashire, as well as in Kent, Reform’s flagship council

A picture

Keeping youths in care out of trouble | Letter

Diverting young people in care from the youth justice system and the associated criminalisation may help their future careers (Children in care who lash out may no longer face automatic arrest under UK review, 17 November). However, international research studies have shown that reducing the chances of young people being involved in crime to begin with are more effective.These include: stable family foster care placements; doing well at school; extending foster care placements beyond 18 years of age; having positive birth family, extended family, partner and social relationships; being settled in accommodation on leaving care; and being supported by leaving-care teams providing personal, careers, housing and financial support.For too many young people these opportunities are lacking or inconsistent, even in the face of substantial evidence detailing their unnecessary involvement in the criminal justice system, very poor outcomes and the associated costs to young people and society – see In Care, Out of Trouble, the report of Lord Laming’s review, published by the Prison Reform Trust in 2016.Prof Mike SteinUniversity of York Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section