UK politics: Cooper defends Palestine Action ban despite court ruling it was unlawful – as it happened

A picture


Now to some UK news … In a significant blow to the Home Office, the High Court ruled last week that the ban of Palestine Action under terrorism legislation was unlawful and “disproportionate”, with most of their activities having not reached the level, scale and persistence to be defined as terrorism.The high court said the then home secretary Yvette Cooper had not followed her own policies when bringing in the controversial ban last summer.When asked about her decision making, Cooper told Sky News:Well, I followed the clear advice and recommendations, going through a serious process that the Home Office goes through, involving different agencies and police advice as well, which was very clear about the recommendation for proscription of this group.And the court has also concluded that this is not a normal protest group, that it has found that this group has committed acts of terrorism, that this group is not simply in line with democratic values, and has promoted violence.Cooper was pressed to reveal the advice she was given that informed her decision to pursue the ban, but did not, instead saying: “So I was given significant evidence and advice around risks of violence and risks from public safety, and that is what you take seriously.

” The foreign secretary added:“If you ignore advice that you are given about risks to public safety then you’re really not taking seriously the responsibilities of home secretary,”The foreign secretary, Yvette Cooper, defended her controversial decision to ban Palestine Action as a terror group, days after the high court ruled the move was unlawful and “disproportionate”,Cooper, who was home secretary at the time of proscription, was pressed to reveal the advice she was given that informed her decision to pursue the ban, but did not,The home secretary, Shabana Mahmood, has said she intends to appeal against the ban, something the shadow foreign secretary, Priti Patel, indicated she supported,A group of 26 Labour MPs and peers has written to the government urging it not to go ahead with its plans for appeal.

Yvette Cooper said the UK helped expose the Kremlin’s “barbaric plot” to silence the late Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny’s voice after a multi-intelligence agency inquiry found he was killed using a poison developed from a dart frog toxin administered by the Russian state two years ago.Cooper also said there were “significant process failures” surrounding the appointment of Keir Starmer’s former spin doctor Matthew Doyle to the House of Lords and expressed anger at the appointment of Peter Mandelson as the UK’s ambassador in Washington in December 2024.Thanks for joining us.We are closing this blog now.You can find all our latest coverage of UK politics here.

Keir Starmer took to the international stage at the Munich Security Conference over the weekend to suggest that Labour’s populist rivals, Reform UK and the Greens, were “soft on Russia and weak on Nato”.The Green party leader Zack Polanski is seen as a threat to Labour’s left and has caused a surge in party membership since being elected in Septmber 2025.In an interview with Sky News earlier, Polanski said he would commit to Nato’s Article 5 – an attack on one member is considered an attack against all.“If we’re in Nato as we are, then it’s clear that we need to sign up to the articles.And Article 5 says an attack on one is an attack on all,” Polanski said after stressing that he takes national security “seriously”.

Polanski also said:The very obvious thing to point out is that Donald Trump, our so-called ally who is behving increasingly dangerously and unpredicatbly is threatening to annnex Greenland.And an attack on one is an attack on all.And it just feels Keir Starmer’s speech yesterday which by the way is not 100 miles away from what I have been saying for months now, which is that we need a closer relationship with Europe.So it is quite bizarre to hear him repeating a lot of the things I have been saying and making an attack on me at the same time."I would absolutely commit to that.

"Green Party leader Zack Polanski tells @TrevorPTweets he would sign up to NATO's Article 5, despite Keir Starmer's claims that he wouldn't.#TrevorPhillipshttps://t.co/9zBRF9VlR2📺 Sky 501, Virgin 602, Freeview 233 and YouTube pic.twitter.com/yWrpCFYDoxAsked where the “very small pockets” of aboslute poverty that he referenced can be found, Zia Yusuf pointed to “Wales”.

He said:15-year-old children in Wales score in the global PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment) rankings – the most recognised international educational rankings – below the OECD average,Meaningfully below, for example, countries like Turkey to which the British taxpayer, inclduing Welsh taxpayers, are sending tens of millions of pounds in foreign aid every year,Yusuf seems to be referencing the latest PISA test scores, taken in 2022, which showed Wales’ performance slumped to its lowest level ever in maths, reading and science tests taken by 15-year-olds, below those seen across the rest of the UK,The results were a marker of the devastating effect the pandemic was thought to have had on many children’s education,According to a report on poverty in the UK published by the House of Commons library last year, the proportion of people in relative low income before housing costs was highest in Yorkshire and the Humber and the West Midlands (21%) over the three-year period between 2021/22 to 2023/24.

The north-west and Wales followed with 19%.More than a fifith of people in Wales (22%) live in poverty, totalling 700,000 individuals, according to the Joseph Rowntree Foundation.This includes 400,000 working-age adults, 200,000 children and 100,000 pensioners living in poverty in 2021–24.In an interview with Sky News this morning, Zia Yusuf, Reform UK’s head of policy, said “poverty” is often used by “left-wing politicians” as a “relative” term, which he claims means “you could increase everybody’s incomes ten-fold and that statistic would stay the same”.Asked by Trevor Phillips if the metrics of poverty measured by reputable organisations like the ONS are “illusions”, he said:It’s worse than that.

Because real poverty does exist in this country Trevor.And asbolute poverty does exist in very, very small pockets.If you actually want to do the right thing for as many people as possible in this country then you need to create social mobility.That has been crushed by the Tory government and now this Labour government.If you take the relative poverty argument then there will always be a percentage of the population that is in poverty and what that does nothing for is to help the middle classes or the people who are actually living in absolute poverty.

In the UK, poverty is more often defined as relative poverty rather than absolute poverty.The Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF) makes the distinction between the two terms here:Poverty is often measured in relative terms, comparing incomes to typical living standards in a country, or in absolute terms, based on whether incomes of poorer households are growing faster than inflation.Broadly speaking, relative measures fall if people with lower incomes see their household income rise by more than people with average incomes, while absolute measures fall if people with lower incomes see their household income rise by more than inflation.According to recent analysis by the JRF, the UK’s poorest families are getting poorer, with record numbers of people classed as in “very deep poverty” – meaning their annual household incomes fail to cover the cost of food, energy bills and clothing.Speaking to the BBC about Russia, Priti Patel said the government must look at the financial lifelines that Moscow has and “cut off the head of the snake” amid reports Russia has found ways of circumventing western-imposed sanctions brought in response to the full-scale invasion of Ukraine.

Speaking from Munich, the shadow foreign secretary said:We have got to look at cutting off all the financial flows that are basically still propping up Russia and the Russian economy.And I say that because that is what is giving them the licence to operate in this way.Russia is part of the axis of authoritarianism, along with China, Iran, North Korea.So we have got to look at the financial lifelines and really get to the top, cut off the head of the snake as I have been saying here in Munich at this security conference.We know there are oil refineries around the world, white labelling Russian oil.

We have got to target those businesses and go after them.The EU has imposed 19 rounds of sanctions on Russia since the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, targeting more than 2,700 individuals and entities, and halting trade across vast economic areas including energy, aviation, IT, luxury and consumer goods, diamonds and gold, as my colleagues note in this story.While sanctions have had an impact on Russia’s economy, which has started to stagnate, Moscow has found ways to evade western sanctions through opaque trading schemes as well as its “shadow fleet” network.Shadow foreign secretary, Priti Patel, said she was “appalled” by the high court’s ruling on Friday that the proscription of Palestine Action was unlawful and supports the government’s intention to appeal against the decision (see post at 09.35 for more details).

Speaking to Sky News this morning, Patel, a former home secretary between July 2019 and Septmeber 2022, said:I’m pretty appalled by that ruling, and clearly it’s now going to be subject to a legal appeal,And I think it’s right that it should be appealed …It is right that they feel the full force of our laws, including the proscription that has been put in place,They are on par with how terrorist organisations conduct themselves, and they plan their attacks,I think the public would be absolutely horrified to see that these individuals have been able to essentially get away with the type of activity that they have been able to thus far,'They are on par with how terrorist organisations conduct themselves and they plan their attacks.

' Dame Priti Patel says she is appalled at Palestine Action's High Court win and supports the government's intention to appeal.@TrevorPTweetshttps://t.co/iwjoy2lGiW📺 Sky 501 pic.twitter.com/TQmp6UfwT1Yvette Cooper was interviewed by the BBC’s Laura Kuenssberg on her Sunday politics progamme after the Sky interview.

Kuenssberg underscored the chaos inside Downing Street by listing all of the departures from the prime minisiter’s team since Labour won a landslide general election in July 2024.These included:Four directors of communicationsTwo chiefs of staffTwo cabinet secretariesUS ambassadorCooper acknowlegded it had been a “difficult week” in which the Scottish Labour leader, Anas Sarwar, called for the prime minister to resign after saying there had been “too many mistakes” under Keir Starmer’s leadership.Kuenssberg asks the foreign secretary whether Starmer should listen to the women in his government more.“I feel actually quite angry about some of the issues we’ve had,” Cooper said, in reference to the appointment to Peter Mandelson as US ambassador.She stressed the real focus should be on Jeffrey Epstein’s victims and the work Labour has done around tackling violence against women and girls (VAWG).

The government’s VAWG strategy includes focusing on prevention and tackling harmful behaviours in boys by teaching pupils about healthy relationships and pornography.Critics, however, have questioned whether the government’s actions have matched their rhetoric on the issue and have criticised the level of funding given to the problem.The foreign secretary, Yvette Cooper, was asked about the appointment of Keir Starmer’s former spin doctor Matthew Doyle to the House of Lords.Doyle has been suspended from the Labour whip in his new role in the Lords after it emerged that he had campaigned on behalf of a friend who had been charged with possessing indecent images of children.Trevor Phillips asked Cooper if she was confident that nobody else in “her administration” campaigned for Sean Morton, a former Labour councillor in Moray who admitted indecent child image offences in 2017.

Cooper told Sky News:I think there has clearly been some significant process failures in this appointment.There is still a review under way on that …We do take this extremely seriously.Keir Starmer has … talked about the imporatnce of standards in public life.And that is why we take this so seriously …For me there is just a wider issue here, which is that I personally in opposition made it Labour’s misson to half violence against women and girls in a decade.And also in the Home Office made that a central mission for the government.

And now in the Foreign Office I’m making it a priority as part of our foreign policy across the world,Starmer has been under intense political pressure since he admitted to appointing Peter Mandelson to the role of US ambassador despite knowing about Mandelson’s friendship with the late sex offender and financier Jeffrey Epstein,Huda Ammori, a co-founder of Palestine Action, who brought the high court challenge, called it a “monumental victory”,She said on Friday:We were banned because Palestine Action’s disruption of Israel’s largest weapons manufacturer, Elbit Systems, cost the corporation millions of pounds in profits and to lose out on multibillion-pound contracts,We’ve used the same tactics as direct action organisations throughout history, including anti-war groups Keir Starmer defended in court, and the government acknowledged in these legal proceedings that this ban was based on property damage, not violence against people.

Banning Palestine Action was always about appeasing pro-Israel lobby groups and weapons manufacturers, and nothing to do with terrorism … Today’s landmark ruling is a victory for freedom for all, and I urge the government to respect the court’s decision and bring this injustice to an end without further delay.As the Guardian’s legal affairs correspondent Haroon Saddique notes in this story, Ammori said her lawyers would resist Shabana Mahmood’s attempts to retain the ban while the home secretary tried to appeal against the judgment.The fate of more than 2,500 people arrested for supporting Palestine Action since proscription remains uncertain after the current home secretary, Shabana Mahmood, said she would appeal against the ban.Proscription makes it a criminal offence to belong to or support Palestine Action, punishable by up to 14 years in prison.Nearly 700 people have been charged with a terrorism offence and faced preliminary court proceedings although no one has yet been convicted.

The Metropolitan police said it will stop arresting protesters who hold up signs declaring “I support Palestine Action” in the wake of the High Court ruling.But the force said it will continue to gather evidence of overt support for Palestine Action, because the proscription order remains in place until the government appeal has been dealt with.A group of 26 Labour MPs and peers, including Blair-era former minister Lord Peter Hain and senior MP John McDonnell, has written to the Government urging it not to go ahead with its plans for appeal.Now to some UK news … In a significant blow to the Home Office, the High Court ruled last week that the ban of Palestine Action under terrorism legislation was unlawful and “disproportionate”, with most of their activities having not reached the level, scale and persistence to be defined as terrorism.The high court said the then home secretary Yvette Cooper had not followed her own policies when bringing in the controversial ban last summer.

When asked about her decision making, Cooper told Sky News:Well, I followed the clear advice and recommendations, going through a serious process that the Home Office goes through, involving different agencies and police advice as well, which was very clear about the recommendation for proscription of this group.And the court has also concluded that this is not a normal protest group, that it has found that this group has committed acts of terrorism, that this group is not simply in line with democratic values, and has promoted violence.Cooper was pressed to reveal the advice she was given that informed her decision to pursue the ban, but did not, instead saying: “So I was given significant evidence and advice around risks of violence and risks from public safety, and that is what you take seriously.” The foreign secretary added:“If you ignore advice that you are given about risks to public safety then you’re really not taking seriously the responsibilities of home secretary.”Yvette Cooper is asked in her Sky News interview whether she agrees with German Chancellor Friedrich Merz’s assessment that the supposed rules-based world order has collapsed.

The foreign secretary acknowledges huge political instability around the world, economic shifts, driven by the rise of China and protectionism, and marks the Russian aggression as a “persistent” threat that Europe has to face up to.She also acknowlegded that the US is “changing their focus” and will reduce funding for European security, which means Europe has to “step up to the plate” in defending itself.You can keep up with the latest lines from Europe in our Munich Security Conference blog helmed by the brilliant Jakub Krupa.Patrick Wintour is diplomatic editor for the GuardianThe intelligence agencies claimed laboratory testing found that the deadly toxin in the skin of Ecuador dart frogs (epibatidine) was found in samples from Navalny’s body and probably resulted in his death.The statement adds: “Only the Russian state had the means, motive and opportunity to deploy this lethal toxin to target Navalny during his imprisonment in a Russian penal colony in Siberia, and we hold it responsible for his death.

”“Epibatidine can be found naturally in dart frogs in the wild in South America.Dart frogs in captivity do not produce this toxin and it is not found naturally in Russia.There is no innocent explanation for its presence in Navalny’s body.”Although it had been widely assumed that Navalny had been poisoned by the Russian state, the evidence of the specific poison in his body is a new development.His wife, Yulia Navalny, posted in September that there was evidence of poison in his body at the time an autopsy was conducted.

You can read the full story here:Speaking to Sky’s Trevor Phillips from Munich, Yvette Cooper said for the two years since the announcement of Navalny’s death, work has taken place among European partners “on pursuing the evidence and pursuing the truth”,The UK’s foreign secretary said:And that is why we have together found the evidence of this lethal toxin that was found in Alexei Navalny’s body at time he died,And only the Russian regime had the motive, the means and the opportunity to administer this lethal posion while he was in prison in Russia,They wanted to silence him because he was a critic of their regime and that is why we have exposed this barbaric Kremlin plot to do so and made sure that we have done so with evidence as well,The reason as well that we have done this is was one of the things that Alexei Navalny himself said that
A picture

How to plan Ramadan meals: minimal work, maximum readiness

Ramadan arrives this year in February, in the heart of winter. Short days, cold evenings and the pressure of everyday work mean that preparation is no longer about producing abundance, but about reducing effort while maintaining care. For many households balancing jobs, children and long commutes, the question is not what to cook, but how to make the month manageable.The most effective approach to Ramadan cooking is not variety but repetition. A small set of meals that are easy to digest, quick to prepare and gentle on the body can carry a household through 30 days of fasting with far less stress than daily reinvention

A picture

Benjamina Ebuehi’s recipe for almond frangipane crepes | The sweet spot

When it comes to pancake day, I don’t discriminate and fill the day with as many types of pancakes as possible – from a fluffy American-style stack in the morning to a savoury buckwheat pancake at lunch, and finishing off with classic crepes in the evening. This version was heavily inspired by an almond croissant, so although it does lean more towards dessert, I won’t judge if this is what you choose to start your day with. Bake them until the edges go crisp but the middle stays a little gooey.Prep 5 min Rest 20+ min Cook 50 min Makes 7-8 crepes120g plain flour ½ tbsp caster sugar A pinch of salt 2 large eggs 240ml whole milk 25g melted butter, plus extra for greasing Icing sugar, for dusting Lightly whipped cream, to serve (optional)For the frangipane90g salted butter, softened90g caster sugar ¼-½ tsp almond extract1 large egg 110g ground almonds 50g flaked almondsPut the flour, sugar and salt in a bowl and whisk briefly to combine. Add the eggs, whisk to a thick paste, then pour in the milk in three batches, whisking each time to avoid any lumps

A picture

Heard it on the grapevine: Polish wine’s quiet renaissance

Swap the staid stereotypes of Żubrówka vodka and Żywiec lager for vineyards and vintages, because Poland is in the throes of a viticultural renaissance, the likes of which hasn’t been seen for centuries. On a road trip tracing Poland’s best terroirs back in the summer of 2023, I met winemakers going against the grain, unshackled by tradition and producing unpretentious, expressive pours that more than merit a place on your dining table.Lately, Polish wines have been cropping up all over bar and restaurant lists: Niemczańska’s chardonnay at London’s most emblematic Polish restaurant, the borscht-fronted Daquise in South Kensington, say, while chic bar Spry in Edinburgh has started stocking my favourite producers, Dom Bliskowice, Kamil Barczentewicz and Nizio. But you won’t find bottles nestling between the neat rows of kabanos sausages of your local Polski sklep, nor lining the supermarket shelves. Or not just yet, anyway

A picture

​My love letter to Brittany’s best exports

Every February – or occasionally March – I get together with two friends to gorge on pancakes; I provide the pan, Caro does the cocktails and poor old Harry is invariably the chef because she never fails, even three ciders in. With two half-Frenchies in the room, we always start with buckwheat galettes, usually served complète with gruyère, ham and a fried egg (though the more we eat, the more adventurous the combinations become). Then we move on to softer, thicker British sweet pancakes with lemon juice and crunchy demerara sugar to finish. We rarely manage to meet on Shrove Tuesday itself, but apart from the year I went vegan for Lent, that’s no problem. After all, any cold, dark evening is improved by a pancake party

A picture

Rachel Roddy’s recipe for cacio e pepe, the old-fashioned way | A kitchen in Rome

Nightclubs, mechanics, restaurants, a theatre, a wholesale butcher and an Apostolic church occupy some of the network of caves and tunnels that, over the centuries, were burrowed into Monte Testaccio, an ancient rubbish dump hill in the middle of Rome that’s made entirely of broken amphorae. Some places make a feature of their situation, revealing sections of pots not dissimilar to the cross section of snapped wafer biscuits, while others have smoothed the curves with plaster.A few use the caves as originally intended – that is, as natural warehouses offering steady low temperatures and good humidity. In short: the ideal temperature for storing certain foods and wine. Most recently, Vincenzo Mancini, whose project DOL distributes artisanal products from small agricultural realities in Lazio, has taken over a deep cave behind door 93, reclaiming it as an urban ageing space for cheese and cured meat

A picture

How to use up leftover pickle brine in a tartare sauce – recipe | Waste not

Depending on country, region, household or restaurant, every cook makes tartare sauce in their own way. Inspired by Auguste Escoffier’s exceptionally simple tartare, I’ve given his recipe a zero-waste twist by using whole boiled eggs and swapping in pickle brine from a jar of gherkins or capers to replace the vinegar. Everything else is optional: tarragon, mustard, cayenne … add what you like or have in store.Traditionally, tartare sauce is delicious with fish and chips, calamari or in a chicken sandwich, but I also like it tossed through potato salad with tinned sardines and radicchio. It’s also great as a dip with crudites and on top of a steaming jacket potato