Ian Collard: the Foreign Office insider who may be key to Mandelson scandal
His name was only mentioned twice – and the meeting he had with Olly Robbins may have only lasted 10 minutes.But Ian Collard is a central – and perhaps the key – figure in the scandal over how Peter Mandelson ended up receiving the security clearance to become Britain’s ambassador in Washington.According to Robbins’s evidence to the foreign affairs committee on Tuesday, it was Collard, head of the estates, security and network directorate in the Foreign Office, who gave him an oral briefing on 29 January 2025.Robbins explained Collard had been having a “live dialogue” about Mandelson with the separate UK Security Vetting (UKSV) team, based in the Cabinet Office.Collard had then asked to speak to Robbins for what turned out to be a critical meeting: it concluded with Mandelson being granted vetting clearance.
What Collard said to Robbins during those few minutes is now the focus of great scrutiny.Robbins said to MPs he was told by Collard that officials in UKSV, who had interviewed Mandelson twice, had concluded he was a “borderline” case and were “leaning towards recommending that clearance be denied”.But that is at odds with what Downing Street and the Cabinet Office knows of the UKSV assessment.As revealed by the Guardian, the UKSV had actually been far more definitive than that.It had concluded by ticking two red boxes: “high concern” and “clearance denied”.
Now, Collard has been summoned by the foreign affairs committee to explain the apparent discrepancy.He will do so with an extensive background in the diplomatic service.With a first-class anthropology degree and a doctorate in evolutionary studies, he took the natural next step of a Cambridge graduate: he joined the Foreign Office in 2002.Postings followed in Washington and New York, before returning to London to be head of the North America department.In 2012, Collard had a role in the counter-terrorism department, helping manage security for the London Olympics.
He had a stint as ambassador in Panama, then back to Whitehall to be head of the counter-terrorism unit.Ambassadorial roles in Afghanistan and Lebanon followed until, in 2023, he became the chief property and security officer in the Foreign Office.Robbins said he and Collard met regularly and that he was “one of most important figures in the way that I was learning how to run the department”.“Ian was in and out of my private office regularly, and I was pleased about that,” Robbins said.Collard’s appearance before the select committee will not be his first.
He has previously given evidence to the public accounts committee – sat with none other than Robbins.He faced questions then about the sprawling global estate of the Foreign Office, its embassies, residences, and high commissions.But MPs, probing the decision-making in the grand neoclassical rooms of the department’s headquarters on King Charles Street, will need to establish what happened in the 24-hour period between UKSV’s decision on 28 January and the meeting with Robbins on 29 January.One former official, familiar with security processes across the British state, said that MPs should establish a timeline of events.Robbins told MPs that the Foreign Office’s personnel security team – which Collard leads – had been debating with UKSV about some of the specific risks.
As a result, he said, some of those risks had “shifted up and down a bit, and then the Foreign Office had reached its assessment and briefed me”,People in Collard’s role across Whitehall, whose day-to-day job is about risk management, do have conversations with UKSV,But MPs may want to ask more about what the content of those talks were, and what records may exist of them,Did he see the UKSV vetting file, with two red boxes ticked? If so, what happened next? It is possible, the source said, that Collard may not have even seen a full and detailed reasoning and risks report behind UKSV’s recommendation,Robbins has said that “managing these risks as part of the clearance process is not unusual”.
MPs could examine exactly just how unusual this is and ask Collard on how many occasions he had received a double-red UKSV recommendation and decided to recommend security clearance.Robbins has spoken of the “pressure” that the Foreign Office was coming under from Downing Street to get Mandelson in Washington.Did Collard feel pressure to secure clearance for Mandelson? If so, from who?
UK borrowing to be pushed up by Iran war after dropping last year; oil and gas prices rising – business live
City economist are warning that UK government borrowing is set to be driven higher by the Iran war, following this morning’s (small) drop in the annual deficit in the last financial year:Lindsay James, investment strategist at Quilter, says:double quotation mark“The conflict in the Middle East has shown the UK economy remains very exposed to geopolitical shocks. However, there are some encouraging signs that rigid fiscal rules have been having the desired effect thus far, as today’s public sector finance data shows borrowing was £12.6 billion in March. This is £1.4 billion less than the same month last year, and the lowest March reading since 2022
UK undershoots annual borrowing target by £700m
The UK government budget came in below its annual borrowing target by £700m, official figures show – but the Iran war is likely to blow a hole in Rachel Reeves’s carefully calculated fiscal “headroom” over the coming months.The government borrowed a net total of £132bn for the financial year ending in March, the Office for National Statistics (ONS) said. This slightly undershot the £132.7bn that the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) had forecast just last month.The total was £19
Tesla reports mixed financial results as Musk pivots automaker to AI and robots
Tesla reported its first-quarter earnings on Wednesday, disclosing some better-than-expected results but faltering in some key areas. The report failed to significantly buoy Tesla’s stock, which has limped along this year while its CEO, Elon Musk, has tried to sell the company’s new vision of humanoid robots and self-driving robotaxis. Its core car business has struggled in the face of competition from Chinese counterparts and backlash against his close involvement with the Trump administration.“There remains significant effort and hard work to realize our mission of Amazing Abundance,” Tesla said in its report, while claiming that demand for its vehicles was rebounding.Tesla revealed earnings of 41 cents a share on Wednesday after market close, more than the 37 cents per share that Wall Street expected
What is Mythos AI and why could it be a threat to global cybersecurity?
Anthropic has ruled out releasing its latest AI model, Mythos, to the public because of the threat it poses to global cybersecurity.However, the US tech startup behind the Claude chatbot confirmed on Wednesday it was investigating a report that a group of people had gained unauthorised access to Mythos. The alleged incident has raised concerns over the pace of development and the ability of tech companies to keep their riskiest products out of the public domain. Here, we examine Mythos and its potential impact.Mythos is an AI model – the underlying technology that powers tools such as chatbots – that, according to Anthropic, represents a serious potential threat to any organisation’s cybersecurity
Carlton coach Michael Voss accuses media of bullying after Elijah Hollands incident
Embattled Carlton coach Michael Voss has defended his staff and accused the media of bullying as the spotlight intensifies on the club for allowing Elijah Hollands to play last week during a mental health episode.Hollands behaved erratically in the match against Collingwood and is now in hospital, and speculation has focused on how Voss’s staff had allowed the young player to take the field given his struggles were obvious even from the stands.Fronting a large press pack on Thursday at Princes Park ahead of Saturday’s match against Fremantle, Voss said he wanted to respect the AFL’s investigation into the club’s actions on the night and “we accept that we need to look at process”.But he said that in a “complex situation that has history and background” his staff deserve praise.“I’m proud of my people, and the process itself will take care of itself, and we need to put our support behind that,” he said
Bournemouth 2-2 Leeds, Charlton 1-2 Ipswich: football clockwatch – as it happened
Time to sign off; I’ll leave you with Sam Cunningham’s match report from the Vitality Stadium. Thanks for joining me.Jamie Jackson watched as Manchester City won at Burnley to go top of the league …Ed Aarons was at the Valley to see Ipswich dig out a vital win:Championship table: Ipswich edge back into second place but Millwall, Southampton and Middlesbrough can all still claim automatic promotion. Oxford are not quite down after Charlton failed to take a point from their game tonight.Premier League table: Manchester City are top on goals scored, Bournemouth climb above Chelsea, and Burnley are relegated
AI hallucinations found in high-profile Wall Street law firm filing
‘An element of exploitation’: the world of TikTok child skincare influencers
UK could face ‘hacktivist attacks at scale’, says head of security agency
Rental platform unnecessarily collected the data of millions of Australians, privacy commissioner finds
Apple’s Tim Cook leaves behind complicated legacy on privacy
‘I’ll key your car’: ChatGPT can become abusive when fed real-life arguments, study finds