The key questions Keir Starmer must answer over Mandelson appointment
The next 48 hours will be crucial for Keir Starmer’s troubled premiership as he faces continuing calls to resign over his appointment of Peter Mandelson as US ambassador.On Monday, Starmer will give a statement to the House of Commons on the Guardian’s revelation that Mandelson was allowed to serve as US ambassador despite failing a vetting process run by security officials.On Tuesday, Olly Robbins, the top civil servant at the Foreign Office, who Starmer sacked on Thursday and is trying to blame for the row, will give his side of the story.Here are the key questions Starmer must answer.The appointment of Peter Mandelson as US ambassador was known to be risky.
Mandelson, who was nicknamed the “prince of darkness”, had been forced to resign twice as a Labour minister,His links to the convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein were public knowledge,As were his consultancy Global Counsel’s links to China,So on a basic level, the question is obvious: why did Starmer pick him?The current crisis facing Downing Street stems from the Guardian’s revelation that United Kingdom Security Vetting (UKSV) said Mandelson should be declined “developed vetting” clearance in late January 2025, only for that advice to be overruled by the Foreign Office so he could take up the post,Starmer has said it was “unforgivable” and “staggering” that officials did not tell him Mandelson was denied UKSV clearance.
But was the prime minister made aware there were problems with the vetting process?It has been suggested, for example, that mitigations were put in place before Mandelson took up the post,To be clear, UKSV did not recommend mitigations or “risk management”, opting for straight “clearance denied”,But when deciding to give Mandelson clearance anyway, the Foreign Office could have put in place some restrictions to mitigate risk,If that happened, was Starmer aware? And if he was told that there were issues, why did he not demand to get to the bottom of them?Days after the Foreign Office granted Mandelson “developed vetting” clearance, against the advice of security officials, the department told him the role in Washington required an even higher level of clearance, called DV+STRAP,STRAP clearance – or “indoctrination” – is required for access to documents even more sensitive than top secret, such as intelligence material.
Such documents are reportedly printed on pink paper to visually identify them,It is unclear whether or not Mandelson received STRAP clearance, but it is hard to see how he would perform his role without it,Did Mandelson get this top-level clearance? If so, how was that possible, given that he’d been denied the lower-level clearance by UKSV? And if Mandelson got STRAP clearance with mitigations put in place that affected his ability to do the role, for example by limiting his access to particular documents or areas of foreign policy, how did Starmer not know that?Friends of Robbins have said he had a legal duty not to divulge the details of a highly intrusive vetting process,Ciaran Martin, a former senior civil servant, said: “Not only is there no duty to disclose the details of a vetting case, there is a duty not to disclose them,” Simon McDonald, a former permanent secretary of the Foreign Office, said vetting was a “confidential process”, citing the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010.
According to publicly available government documents, the process includes a questionnaire and interviews requiring disclosure of highly private information, including about personal finances, business connections and sexual history.Starmer is likely to be pressed on whether he has now seen the full details of why Mandelson failed his vetting.Assuming he now has the facts, what will Starmer now tell parliament abut the reasons why Mandelson was deemed a security risk?In February, a humble address vote in the Commons forced the government to order the release to the public of “all papers” relevant to Mandelson’s appointment.Under the terms of the motion, papers deemed prejudicial to national security or international relations should go to the parliamentary intelligence and security committee.According to multiple sources, officials have been in dispute over whether to release the vetting documents to this committee.
Starmer will be asked to explain why officials considered withholding these documents, in defiance of the humble address motion,Has the committee now been provided with the documents? If not, when will that happen? And does the prime minister now think there’s a case for the public to know what’s in them?In February, Starmer told journalists: “Security vetting, carried out independently by the security services, which is an intensive exercise that gave him clearance for the role,You have to go through that before you take up the post,Clearly both the due diligence and the security vetting need to be looked at again,”He also told the Commons: “Full due process was followed during this appointment, as it is with all ambassadors.
”Why did no official tell Starmer that he had misled parliament, either at the time or subsequently when they found out that Mandelson had failed vetting? The Guardian has revealed that the cabinet secretary, Antonia Romeo, and the Cabinet Office’s permanent secretary, Catherine Little, have both known about this since March.Starmer must explain why they, and others, did not tell him earlier – and why he did not sufficiently check that what he was claiming about the vetting was true.If, as it is claimed, Starmer only discovered that Mandelson failed vetting on Tuesday night, why did he not set the record straight at the earliest opportunity? Starmer could have informed parliament on Wednesday during prime minister’s questions that he may have inadvertently misled the house about Mandelson’s vetting.But he said nothing on the issue, and will be pressed to explain why.The appointment of Mandelson has led to the resignation of Starmer’s chief of staff, Morgan McSweeney, and the firing of Robbins.
Starmer is being accused by opposition leaders of trying to blame others for a decision that was ultimately his responsibility,And frustrated civil servants think he has tried to throw Robbins under a bus over the row,He will need to provide a convincing answer to these charges, both to settle his own exasperated MPs and his disgruntled officials,
European stock markets fall and oil and gas prices jump 5% as strait of Hormuz ‘chaos’ worries investors – business live
European stock markets have dropped at the start of trading, as last Friday’s optimism about a Middle East peace deal evaporates.In London, the FTSE 100 has dropped by 42 points, or 0.4%, to 10,626 points, away from a six-week high at the end of last week.Germany’s DAX has fallen by 1.3%, and Italy’s FTSE Mib is down 1
Oil prices rise and markets fall after US seizure of ship hits Iran peace deal hopes
Oil prices have risen sharply and European stock markets have fallen after the US seizure of an Iranian vessel dented hopes for a peace deal.Brent crude, the international benchmark for oil prices, rose by 4.8% on Monday to $94.69 (£70.07) a barrel
Sonos Play review: a great jack-of-all-trades portable speaker for home or away
The Play is a new portable wifi and Bluetooth home speaker that packs the best of Sonos into a jack of all trades that is intended to be a reset point in the company’s recovery from its app debacle that lost it faith, favour and a chief executive.The Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more.It is the first truly new music speaker since Sonos launched its new app in May 2024, which junked fan-favourite features while causing stability and usage problems for new and old customers alike
How a fiery attack on Sam Altman’s home unfolded
In the early hours of 10 April, a man approached the gate of OpenAI CEO Sam Altman’s house in San Francisco and hurled a molotov cocktail at the building before fleeing. The suspect, 20-year-old Daniel Moreno-Gama, was arrested less than two hours later while allegedly attempting to break into the headquarters of OpenAI with a jug of kerosene, a lighter and an anti-AI manifesto.Federal and California state authorities have charged Moreno-Gama with a range of crimes including attempted arson and attempted murder. His parents issued a statement this week saying that their son had recently suffered a mental health crisis. Moreno-Gama, who has not yet entered a plea, faces up to life in prison if convicted
Hampshire v Somerset, Warwickshire v Essex, and more: county cricket – live
As lunch approaches:Somerset need 74 to beat Hampshire with four wickets remaining. Tom Abell, vitally, still there on 63. Big Craig, been and gone. Liam Dawson weaving magic.Lancashire, spearheaded by Keaton Jennings, 74 not out, are nearly there
Floods, baskets and Billie Jean King: how the rough and tumble WBL set the stage for the WNBA
It was the night before the 1980 Women’s Professional Basketball League draft in New York City and the Dallas Diamonds had the No 1 pick. But the team’s top brass was split. Coach Greg Williams wanted to take the 6ft 5in Danish star Inge Nissen, and the team’s GM Nancy Nichols prized Nancy Lieberman, the American point guard people called “Lady Magic”.“We argued for days about Nissen versus Lieberman,” Nichols tells the Guardian.Nichols remembers the hours after dinner that night; everyone had retired to their rooms
State of Origin coaches back Australian NRL takeover of England’s Super League
Castleford’s shock win over Wigan shows NRL that Super League still has a lot to offer
England Women are dominating rugby in a way few have done in any sport | Sarah Rendell
‘This feeling sucks’: $381m Mets, with second-highest payroll in MLB, lose 11th game in a row
James Rew shines with the bat as Somerset set up Hampshire chase – as it happened
Noah Caluori repeats five-try display as Saracens demolish sorry Sale 85-19