Nationwide should give its boardroom challenger a fair run
James Sherwin-Smith, who is aiming to become the first customer to be voted onto the board of Nationwide in nearly 25 years, deserves top marks for perseverance,A year ago his attempt to get his name on the ballot paper was stymied, or so it seemed, by data protection rules and so forth,This time, he has the necessary 250 nominations to be a candidate at the July annual meeting,It is a development to welcome,As argued here a year ago, there is something of a democracy deficit at Nationwide.
While the UK’s most important mutually-owned society understandably milks the fact it does not have to answer to beastly shareholders, ownership by the members does not always translate into giving those members a real voice in how the place is run.When Nationwide bought Virgin Money for £2.9bn in 2024 there was no poll of members, even though a publicly-listed bank would have to win formal approval from its shareholders to increase the size of its balance sheet by a third.Nationwide argued its hands were tied by the 1986 Building Societies Act, which was legally accurate, but it was not a good look.Equally, it is perverse that Nationwide does not give its members a binding vote on boardroom pay.
When the chief executive has the potential to earn up to £7m a year, a very bankerly rate of remuneration, it really ought to ensure the members are OK with the approach, which implies a vote with teeth rather than an advisory version.Sherwin-Smith, note, does not come across as a one-dimensional rabble-rouser.He’s a former executive in the world of payment systems and presents himself as a critical friend of Nationwide.His manifesto, as it were, contains such non-radical ideas as “improving transparency” and helping to ensure the benefits of mutual ownership are “balanced”, a nod to the perpetual internal debate over the virtues of “fairer share” cash loyalty payments v keener pricing of savings and mortgage products.On the face of it, he may have something to contribute to boardroom discussion.
Is it possible that Nationwide’s board might even endorse Sherwin-Smith’s candidacy? That feels unlikely,But the building society should be careful to allow him a fair run,Another contentious aspect of voting at Nationwide is its use of a “quick vote” electronic system that allows members to tick a single box in favour of all the board’s recommendations,The claimed justification is greater engagement and a higher turnout,But the potential for such a set-up to squash an outsider’s election chances is obvious: nobody has to use the quick system, but in practice the board starts with a chunk of the votes in its back pocket.
In the circumstances, it would be the best way to keep things simple and suspend the “quick vote” system for this year’s meeting,If the board wants to oppose Sherwin-Smith, which it is perfectly entitled to do, it should make its case openly for why it considers him unsuitable or not needed,Whatever its recommendation, the board has reasons to be confident of prevailing in the end,Nationwide is a high-performing organisation that scores well, year after year, in surveys of customer satisfaction,It should not need to use a loaded voting system.
BP reports ‘horrifying’ jump in profits as Iran war boosts oil trading; Brent crude hits three-week high – business live
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of business, the financial markets and the world economy.The Iran war has helped BP to double its profits in the first quarter of this year, its latest financial results show.The oil major has just reported that it made a profit of nearly $3.2bn in the first three months of 2026, on its favoured ‘underlying replacement cost’ earnings measure.That’s higher than City analysts had predicted, with BP - which was hit by a shareholder rebellion last week – giving some of the credit to an “exceptional” contribution from its oil trading operations
Price rises in UK shops slow as retailers apply heavy discounts to lure shoppers
Price rises in UK shops have slowed as retailers applied “heavy discounting” to their goods in an effort to entice shoppers amid weakening consumer confidence, the industry’s trade group said.Shop price inflation rose by 1% year-on-year in April, a slowdown from 1.2% in March and below the three-month average of 1.1%, according to the British Retail Consortium (BRC).Retailers made discounts to clothing, furniture and DIY goods, the BRC said in its monthly survey of its members, compiled with NielsenIQ (NIQ)
MacBook Pro M5 review: serious power, still long battery life
Apple’s Macs have been on a roll this year with the brand new budget MacBook Neo and a faster MacBook Air M5, but now it’s time for its workhorse MacBook Pro to be upgraded with the fastest, most powerful M-series chips.The Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more.The latest MacBook Pro comes in two screen sizes and a large range of chip and configuration options
US supreme court hears whether smartphone location data warrants infringe users’ privacy
The US supreme court is considering whether sprawling warrants for smartphone location data infringe on Americans’ privacy rights and violate the constitution.Justices heard opening arguments in Chatrie v United States on Monday that concerned law enforcement’s reliance on so-called “geofence warrants” in difficult cases. The case was originally brought by Okello Chatrie, whose phone location data helped police in Richmond, Virginia, track him down after he robbed a bank at gunpoint and escaped with $195,000 in 2019. Chatrie pleaded guilty to armed robbery and was sentenced to 12 years in prison, but his lawyers argue none of the evidence against him should have been admissible in court.A lawyer for the US Department of Justice argued that nearly any actions taken in public while in possession of a smartphone afforded no expectation of privacy
Sabastian Sawe’s sub-two marathon feat is the Roger Bannister moment of our time | Sean Ingle
A few years ago at the London Marathon, organisers wheeled out an industrial-sized treadmill called the Tumbleator. Then they tempted curious onlookers with a simple question: can you keep up with Eliud Kipchoge? The answer was obvious. But that didn’t stop people trying. Most lasted a few seconds before comically flying off the back into crash mats.The Tumbleator has a fresh poster-boy now: Sabastian Sawe, who on Sunday claimed track and field’s last holy grail by running a sub two-hour marathon
Indigenous players back St Kilda coach Ross Lyon after comment deemed ‘casual racism’
St Kilda coach Ross Lyon has received the backing of his club’s chief executive after a group of Indigenous players – including star Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera – took offence following a comment made at training earlier this month.Lyon made the comment when three Indigenous players lined up together for a drill, saying, “I love the brother-boy connection, but we all have to remember, we are part of the bigger team here”.The players raised their concerns with the coach the following day and the matter was dealt with internally, but became public when journalist Caroline Wilson raised it on Channel Seven on Monday night.Lyon said he had misjudged the moment. “Was I being flippant? Could it be described as casual racism? I learned a lot out of what happened,” he told Wilson
Musk and Altman’s bitter feud over OpenAI to be laid bare in court
UK departments at odds over energy demands of AI datacentres
Cannes AI film festival raises eyebrows – and questions about future
Facing AI and a tough job market, gen Z turns to entrepreneurship: ‘I have to prove myself’
TikTok and Visa launch debit card to speed payouts to UK creators
Officials hugely underestimated impact of AI datacentres on UK carbon emissions