Forget the AI job apocalypse. AI’s real threat is worker control and surveillance
The real danger that artificial intelligence poses to work is not just job loss – it is the growing divide between people who use AI to extend their skills and those whose working lives are increasingly shaped by opaque, AI-powered systems of surveillance and control,The debate about artificial intelligence and how it will affect workers is stuck in the wrong place,On one side are warnings that machines are coming for millions of jobs,On the other are claims that AI will turbocharge productivity,Both stories miss what is already happening in workplaces across the world, from Britain to Kenya to the United States.
For some, AI can help remove the drudgery from daily work.These are often people in better-paid, higher-autonomy roles: analysts, consultants, lawyers, academics, managers.In these jobs, provided AI is being rolled out to augment workers rather than replace them, it can feel like a copilot.It can support human judgment, speed up routine tasks and create space for more creative thinking.For many others, though, AI is not an assistant.
It is a boss.It appears in scheduling and monitoring tools, route optimisation software and automated performance dashboards – all systems that decide who gets what shift, how long a task should take and whether someone is performing at their maximum capacity.In these workplaces, AI is not something you use.It is something that watches and rules you.That is the new divide we should all be paying attention to.
A third of UK employers are already using “bossware” technology to monitor workers’ online activity.This already prevalent worker surveillance is a glimpse of what is yet to come.This is why the question of whether AI is “good” or “bad” is pointlessly crude.The truth is more nuanced.Employers are using AI to empower some workers while subjecting others to more intensive, inhumane forms of oversight.
It is creating new opportunities at the top of the labour market while tightening control lower down.And further down the line, the same methods of algorithmic management and surveillance that are being honed in warehouses, delivery vans and gig work platforms are likely to spread to corporate headquarters, hospitals and schools.We’re already seeing this at companies including Amazon, as its software engineers say they’re being surveilled and pressured to use AI to achieve more productivity, even when it counterintuitively slows them down.And Meta plans to track and capture its employees’ keystrokes, mouse movements and clicks to train its AI models.Some of the same workers benefiting from the rise of AI now are poised to eventually lose that advantage.
My own research over the past decade on worker-AI coexistence, which was cited in the 2024 White House economic report, suggests that the most pressing issue about AI’s impact on work is not immediate mass unemployment.It is the widening gap in skills, autonomy and wellbeing between those who get to work with AI and those who are finding themselves managed by it.Many jobs will remain in the future, but they will be more pressured, more fragmented and less human.That matters because work is not just about income.It is also about dignity, trust and control.
During the pandemic, many people became acutely aware of how deeply work affects mental wellbeing,AI-managed workplaces are only intensifying the pressures of work,When every click, step, call or pause a worker makes can be measured and graded by a system that they cannot fully see or challenge, the effect is stress,For people in warehousing, retail, hospitality, logistics, customer service or the gig economy, it can mean being pushed harder by systems that are presented as neutral, objective or efficient, even when they are anything but,This is not just a technical problem.
It is a social, political and moral one.Take Britain, which likes to present itself as being ambitious about AI.There are now major plans to expand AI skills across the workforce.All of that sounds positive.But beneath the rhetoric lies a more uncomfortable reality: many organisations are still poorly prepared to introduce AI fairly.
A recent global survey of business leaders found that although most say AI skills are now a source of competitive advantage, relatively few dedicated a meaningful budget amount to develop their employees’ AI skills,Even fewer have strong governance in place,Many managers still have little real responsibility for helping their teams adapt,That is how inequality hardens,If better-paid workers are trained to use AI while lower-paid workers are simply exposed to it through surveillance and automated management, then this will not be a story of shared progress.
It will be a story of deepening imbalance.Workers across the economy need access to meaningful training, not just in using digital tools but in building the wider skills that matter even more in an AI age: judgment, communication and critical thinking.We also need basic democratic principles in the workplace.Systems that affect pay and performance should be transparent and contestable.Most of all, workers need a voice in how these technologies are introduced.
AI should not be something used on people behind closed doors and then justified in the language of efficiency.It should be shaped by the people whose lives it will affect – and research has found that involving workers in the process improves their job quality and allows employers to integrate AI more effectively.The choice about how AI will reshape work is not being made in Silicon Valley boardrooms or summit speeches.It is being made right now, workplace by workplace, across Britain and around the world.And unless we pay attention, the new AI divide will become one more inequality that arrives quietly, embeds itself deeply and is only recognised once it is already everywhere.
Nazrul Islam is a chair professor of business and co-director of the Centre of FinTech at the University of East London’s Royal Docks School of Business and Law
Google announces raft of free upgrades for Android phones
Google has announced a range of features coming to Android phones this year, including a new Gemini Intelligence AI system and a tool to help users avoid distracting apps.Revealed in a livestreamed “Android Show” event, the free upgrades are scheduled to arrive in waves over the next year for high-end new and old phones alike, including Samsung and Pixel devices. Google also revealed that a new lineup of laptops will arrive in the autumn.Gemini Intelligence will combine the company’s top AI tools into one system aimed at being more proactively useful.It will be able to automate tasks by directly interacting with the apps already on a phone
Head of Microsoft’s Israel branch to step down after inquiry into dealings with Israeli military
The head of Microsoft’s Israeli subsidiary will step down in the wake of an inquiry that has scrutinised its business dealings with the Israeli military.Microsoft ordered the inquiry last year in response to a Guardian investigation revealing the military had used the company’s technology to operate a powerful surveillance system that collected Palestinian civilian phone calls on a mass scale.The joint investigation with the Israeli-Palestinian publication +972 Magazine and the Hebrew-language outlet Local Call found the military’s elite spy agency, Unit 8200, had used Microsoft’s Azure cloud platform to store a vast trove of intercepted calls from Gaza and the West Bank.The inquiry commissioned by Microsoft is understood to have recently concluded. Its findings are unclear; however, sources familiar with the situation said they prompted an announcement last week that Microsoft Israel’s general manager, Alon Haimovich, would leave the company
GameStop’s $55.5bn bid for eBay rejected as ‘neither credible nor attractive’
The board of eBay has rejected the US video games retailer GameStop’s surprise $55.5bn bid (£41bn) for the online marketplace, describing the proposal as “neither credible nor attractive”.Earlier this month, GameStop made an unsolicited bid for eBay, publishing a letter on its website outlining a half-cash, half-stock proposal.This was despite the US games company – which became a global household name during the meme stock craze of 2021 – being worth far less than its takeover target. GameStop had a market valuation of roughly $12bn before its bid, almost a quarter of eBay’s $46bn valuation
Trump heads to China to spread the gospel of American tech
Hello, and welcome to TechScape. I’m your host, Blake Montgomery, US tech editor at the Guardian.Donald Trump is headed to China this week. If his guest list is any clue, he wants to discuss technology with Xi Jinping, though perhaps after the war in Iran.On Monday, news broke that outgoing Apple CEO, Tim Cook, as well as SpaceX and Tesla’s CEO, Elon Musk, would join Trump
Trump heads to China to spread the gospel of American tech while emulating Xi Jinping on AI
Donald Trump is heading to China this week. If his guest list is any clue, he wants to discuss technology with Xi Jinping, though perhaps after the war in Iran.On Monday, news broke that outgoing Apple CEO, Tim Cook, as well as SpaceX and Tesla CEO, Elon Musk, would join the US president. Other guests from the tech sphere include Meta’s recently appointed president, Dina Powell McCormick; Sanjay Mehrotra, CEO of computer memory maker Micron; Chuck Robbins, CEO of longtime telecom giant Cisco; and Cristiano Amon, CEO of semiconductor maker Qualcomm, according to a White House official.Jensen Huang, Nvidia’s CEO – who is close to Trump but criticized the US’s limitations on chip sales to China in an April interview, saying that he didn’t want a “loser mentality” to cost the US its edge in AI – will not be joining the president
Molière Ex Machina: AI used to create ‘new work’ by beloved French playwright
Molière is to the French what Shakespeare is to the English: the last word in historical literature, drama, wit and satire.Now, more than 350 years after his death, the 17th-century dramatist has been revived after scholars at the Sorbonne University in Paris used artificial intelligence to help write an experimental play in his style.L’Astrologue ou les Faux Présages (The Astrologer, or False Omens), a three-act comedy, made its debut at the Royal Opera at the Château de Versailles last week.The two-hour play tells the story of a wealthy bourgeois Parisian who, under the instruction of a charlatan astrologer called Pseudoramus, insists his daughter Lucile marry a debt-ridden and elderly wigmaker.While the theme could well have been dreamed up by Molière, the dialogue, music, costumes and scenery were all created with the help of a French AI tool called Le Chat (The Cat)
‘Hold the line’: Burnham tells allies in parliament he still has options to return
‘It’s more incrementalism’: Starmer’s safe king’s speech fails to quell mutiny
Starmer has ‘full confidence’ in Streeting despite health secretary’s allies saying he is planning to resign – as it happened
Labour politicians should put the country before their party | Letters
Labour lost the vote of small business owners like me | Letter
King’s speech might be the last word on Starmer as reluctant monarch does his duty | John Crace