Mistaking AI behaviour for conscious being | Letter
Richard Dawkins’ reflections on AI consciousness are striking – not because they show that machines have crossed some hidden threshold into inner life, but because they reveal how readily we can be persuaded that they have (Richard Dawkins concludes AI is conscious, even if it doesn’t know it, 5 May).Many will recognise the experience: a system that responds with fluency, humour and apparent understanding.At some point, simulation starts to feel like presence.But that shift tells us more about human cognition than machine consciousness.The error is a category one.
These systems generate highly convincing representations of thought and feeling, but they provide no evidence of subjective experience.To move from one to the other is to mistake output for ontology – to infer an inner life where there is no credible mechanism for one.There is an irony here.In his writing on religion, Dawkins has long argued that compelling narratives and deeply felt experiences are not in themselves evidence of underlying reality.The same standard should apply to machines now capable of producing those experiences on demandLanguage has been a reliable indicator of consciousness because in humans it is coupled to lived experience.
In AI, that coupling does not exist.As systems become more capable, pressure to attribute agency will grow.If we fail to distinguish between behaviour and being, we risk building ethical frameworks on a misreading of the technology.Dawkins is right to ask the question.But the answer cannot rest on how convincing the conversation feels – only on whether there is anything there that could, in principle, feel at all.
Dr Simon NiederBrampton, Derbyshire Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
World’s No 1 disabled golfer Kipp Popert: ‘The best need to play for a living. The sport has stopped’
Kipp Popert is a man on a mission. The 27-year‑old Englishman, who tops the disabled world rankings, uses one word a lot: “opportunity”. Popert was “shocked” to hear from the DP World Tour that its G4D circuit, which staged a handful of tournaments per year for disabled players between 2022 and 2025, has been placed into cold storage.The G4D Open, a tournament for 80 golfers with disabilities, will be staged at Celtic Manor from Thursday. It takes place thousands of miles from Pennsylvania and this week’s US PGA Championship, which last year bestowed $3
Racing need not fear Green party ‘conversation’ but must continue efforts on horse welfare
The Green party surged to record results at local and national level in last week’s elections, prompting Zack Polanski, the party’s leader, to suggest that two-party politics is “dead and buried”. Ladbrokes, meanwhile, subsequently cut the odds about the Green party winning the most seats at the next general election to 12-1, while an overall majority for the Greens is priced at 28-1.Not likely, in other words but, at the same time, far from impossible. In the case of a majority for Polanski’s party, it is roughly the same price as Moon Chime, the winner of the big handicap hurdle at Haydock last Saturday. However the party fares in terms of seat numbers, the Green voice in the next parliament, in three years’ time or possibly fewer, seems sure to be significantly louder than ever before
From the Pocket: Voss coached the way he played and his brutal football failed Carlton
When John Elliott died in 2021, the old, dark, imperial Carlton was dead. The new Carlton was grounded on “respect, humility and integrity”. The new president was a master networker. The new chief executive was the best administrator in football. The new coach had been one of the great players of his generation
Jason Collins, NBA's first out gay player, dies aged 47 of brain tumor
Jason Collins, the retired NBA player who made history as the league’s first openly gay athlete, has died after a short battle with stage 4 glioblastoma, an aggressive brain cancer, his family announced on Tuesday. He was 47.“Jason changed lives in unexpected ways and was an inspiration to all who knew him and to those who admired him from afar,” Collins’ family said in a statement released through the NBA. “We are grateful for the outpouring of love and prayers over the past eight months and for the exceptional medical care Jason received from his doctors and nurses. Our family will miss him dearly
Memphis Grizzlies forward Brandon Clarke dies at 29: ‘He was the gentlest soul’
Memphis Grizzlies forward Brandon Clarke has died at the age of 29, his sports agency has confirmed. A cause of death was not announced.“We are beyond devastated by the passing of Brandon Clarke,” Priority Sports said. “He was so loved by all of us here, and everyone whose life he touched. He was the gentlest soul who was the first to be there for all of his friends and family
Ruby Tui: ‘I’m going for France – the game needs someone to stop England’
Thousands will descend on Bordeaux’s Stade Atlantique on Sunday to watch the Women’s Six Nations grand slam decider between France and England, among them the New Zealand legend Ruby Tui. The World Cup winner and Olympic gold medallist, who has been working for the BBC as a pundit, says she would love to see the French come out on top in Le Crunch to end England’s seven-year trophy hold.Tui attended her first Six Nations match in round one of this year’s competition at Twickenham, as England took on Ireland. The match felt like an extension of the World Cup party for the 34-year‑old, who witnessed last year’s groundbreaking event through her media duties. The Red Roses will want to deliver the same outcome as that final last September and if they did so they would extend their Six Nations winning run to 39 games in a row and become the first team to win the tournament after claiming the World Cup
Lab testing group Intertek to back £10.6bn takeover by Swedish firm EQT
UK housebuilder Vistry warns of ‘significantly’ lower profits amid Iran war uncertainty
Sam Altman defends OpenAI in courtroom showdown with Elon Musk
Florida students boo graduation speaker who called AI ‘next Industrial Revolution’
The Spin | ‘We have a hoot on the field’: Oswestry CC boasts 10 mother-daughter pairs
How will the liberal Masai Ujiri handle leading the ultraconservative Dallas Mavericks?