Elon Musk, the Anti-Defamation League and the right: what’s behind the latest blow-up?

A picture


The Anti-Defamation League, one of the most prominent Jewish advocacy and anti-hate organizations in the US, has been the center of a rightwing pressure campaign that intensified on Wednesday when the FBI director, Kash Patel, denounced the group and said the agency would cut ties with the non-profit,Patel’s announcement followed days of attacks by rightwing influencers and Elon Musk on the ADL over its online database on extremism, which included a page on slain far-right pundit Charlie Kirk’s Turning Point USA and the organization’s links to far-right extremists,On Tuesday, the ADL deleted its entire Glossary of Extremism, a flagship project which contained more than 1,000 entries on groups and movements with connections to hateful ideologies,The move failed to quell the backlash,The fury against the ADL this week has placed the 112-year-old organization in a difficult position.

It has faced years of internal turmoil as well as accusations it has attempted to appease the Trump administration and Musk at the expense of its core values.Now it finds itself targeted by some of the same conservative powers it once praised.Over the weekend, several influential rightwing accounts began posting screenshots of the ADL’s page on Turning Point USA (TPUSA), attacking the organization for including Kirk’s group in its Glossary of Extremism.One of the first posts, from a self-described “Twitter troll”, accused the ADL of having “blood on their hands”.The ADL did not actually list TPUSA as an extremist organization, but instead documented incidents where its leadership and affiliated activists had either aligned with extremists or made “racist or bigoted comments”.

Other rightwing activists soon followed the troll with more posts about the ADL.Some spread a screenshot of the ADL’s page on the Christian Identity movement – an extremist ideology that espouses a racial holy war against Jews and other minorities – to allege that the ADL was biased against Christians as a whole.The online campaign against the ADL gained more momentum and exposure on Sunday night after Musk, who owns X and boasts over 220 million followers on the platform, began responding to posts about the non-profit and joining in on the attacks.“The ADL hates Christians, therefore it is is [sic] a hate group,” Musk responded on Sunday night to an X account that usually tweets anti-immigrant content.In another post, Musk suggested that the ADL’s operations encouraged murder.

After days of rightwing outrage – that included Anna Paulina Luna, a Republican congresswoman – accusing the ADL of “creating a targeted hate campaign against Christians”, the organization announced on Tuesday that it had eliminated its entire glossary of extremism from its website – a database it touted in 2022 as “the most comprehensive and intuitive resource on extremist speech currently available to the public”.The ADL framed the decision to delete as a way to “explore new strategies and creative approaches to deliver our data and present our research more effectively”.The ADL has weathered similar pressure campaigns from rightwing activists in the past, including from Chaya Raichik of the influential Libs of TikTok account in 2023, though these campaigns did not result in drastic deletion.Despite the ADL’s apparent capitulation to Musk and others, the rightwing campaign against the group continued.Less than 24-hours later, Kash Patel, the FBI director, posted on X that his agency would end its partnership with the ADL, accused the organization of spying on conservative groups, and denounced former FBI director James Comey’s praise of the group.

The ADL had long partnered with law enforcement to hold workshops on antisemitism, conduct Holocaust education and provide information on extremist groups.“James Comey wrote ‘love letters’ to the ADL and embedded FBI agents with them – a group that ran disgraceful ops spying on Americans,” Patel posted on X.“That era is OVER.This FBI won’t partner with political fronts masquerading as watchdogs”.The ADL hasn’t received any formal communications from the Trump administration about its relationship with the FBI and is working to learn more, the organization said in a press release on Thursday.

“ADL has deep respect for the Federal Bureau of Investigation and law enforcement officers at all levels across the country who work tirelessly every single day to protect all Americans regardless of their ancestry, religion, ethnicity, faith, political affiliation or any other point of difference,” the press release reads,The campaign against the ADL has taken place against the backdrop of a conservative movement that has sought to punish people and organizations that have been critical of Kirk,Conservative activists have claimed to have targeted tens of thousands of people who have allegedly criticized Kirk or celebrated the activist’s death, with one group proclaiming: “We will reshape the rank-and-file of America’s institutions,”After the ADL removed its glossary of extremism, Musk and other right wing influencers began shifting their focus to the Southern Poverty Law Center – another prominent civil rights and anti-extremism organization,Musk called for the SPLC, which also documented Kirk’s group’s links to far-right extremism, an “evil organization” that “needs to be shut down”.

Musk’s assault on the ADL this week is part of a longstanding, fraught relationship between the tech billionaire and the non-profit,The ADL has at times criticized Musk and his companies for incidents such as his Grok chatbot promoting pro-Nazi ideology and calling itself “MechaHitler”; however, it also defended Musk when he faced allegations of antisemitism,Sign up to TechScapeA weekly dive in to how technology is shaping our livesafter newsletter promotionJonathan Greenblatt, ADL’s CEO, praised Musk in 2023 for saying he would block use of the pro-Palestinian slogan “from the river to the sea” on X,Only days before, though, Musk had endorsed an antisemitic conspiracy theory on X that claimed Jewish communities pushed hatred against white people,Greenblatt’s praise caused an uproar within the organization, and one of its top executives resigned after the incident.

The ADL went to bat for Musk once again earlier this year, after Jewish lawmakers and civil society groups condemned what they described as Musk’s fascist-style salutes on stage during a speech after Trump’s re-election.The ADL posted: “It seems that Elon Musk made an awkward gesture in a moment of enthusiasm, not a Nazi salute.”Carrying water for Musk yet again led to further turmoil within the organization, with New York Magazine reporting that confused staffers had flooded the group’s Slack channels with messages and longtime liberal donors had rescinded promised gifts.Musk has not publicly returned the praise.His clash this week is the most extreme episode in a longstanding feud that has included him amplifying calls to disband the organization and threatening to sue it over its work documenting the rise of antisemitism on X – something he claimed led to lost advertising revenue for the platform.

While the ADL has been cast into the spotlight on X this week, it has been a tumultuous few years in general for the organization.In addition to internal criticism over its defense of Musk, staffers and other extremism researchers have accused the group of prioritizing pro-Israel policies above a broader commitment to protecting civil rights and fighting antisemitism.At least 17 staffers, donors and other affiliates of the organization have quit or otherwise parted ways in recent years as the organization’s priorities have shifted, according to New York Magazine.Yet the ADL remains one of the most well-resourced and influential civil society groups in the US, with around $163m in revenue last year alone.Much of the controversy has focused on Greenblatt, who has publicly backed the Trump administration’s clampdown on pro-Palestinian speech and campus protests.

Greenblatt praised Trump last year for withholding $400m in grants to Columbia University after campus protests and the ADL complimented Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s illegal arrest of pro-Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil.“We appreciate the Trump Administration’s broad, bold set of efforts to counter campus antisemitism – and this action further illustrates that resolve by holding alleged perpetrators responsible for their actions,” the ADL posted above a tweet about Khalil’s arrest.The incident reflected a concern from some staffers and other Jewish organizations that the ADL has undermined its legitimacy as it sought to collaborate with the administration, with former ADL extremism researcher Vegas Tenold writing at the time: “By carrying the administration’s water, the ADL lends its voice and credibility to Trump’s efforts to dehumanize and criminalize dissent.”The best public interest journalism relies on first-hand accounts from people in the know.If you have something to share on this subject, you can contact us confidentially using the following methods.

Secure Messaging in the Guardian appThe Guardian app has a tool to send tips about stories.Messages are end to end encrypted and concealed within the routine activity that every Guardian mobile app performs.This prevents an observer from knowing that you are communicating with us at all, let alone what is being said.If you don't already have the Guardian app, download it (iOS/Android) and go to the menu.Select ‘Secure Messaging’.

SecureDrop, instant messengers, email, telephone and postIf you can safely use the Tor network without being observed or monitored, you can send messages and documents to the Guardian via our SecureDrop platform,Finally, our guide at theguardian,com/tips lists several ways to contact us securely, and discusses the pros and cons of each,
societySee all
A picture

Hampstead Heath swimming ponds considering limiting transgender users’ access

A consultation has been launched on transgender swimmers’ access to Hampstead Heath ponds, which could result in them being banned from using the pools for the gender they identify as.The Kenwood Ladies’ and Highgate Men’s ponds are gender-segregated, with trans people currently able to swim in whichever they feel most appropriate, or use the heath’s mixed-gender pond instead.The consultation, by the City of London Corporation (CLC), is now presenting six options for gender inclusivity in the historic institution, one of which would ban trans people from using their preferred ponds.It comes amid a battle between groups who swim in the natural pools, with a protest in 2018 in the men’s pond by women wearing fake moustaches and beards to draw attention to the organisation’s refusal to ban trans women from the ladies’ pond.While this was unsuccessful, the Kenwood Ladies’ Pond Association (KLPA) rejecting a motion among its 200 members last year that “only those born female in sex can use the pond”, pressure has since mounted after the supreme court ruled earlier this year that trans women were not legally defined as women

A picture

Stalin, Putin and an enduring obsession with immortality | Letter

Like Vladimir Putin, Joseph Stalin was interested in immortality (‘To them, ageing is a technical problem that can, and will, be fixed’: how the rich and powerful plan to live for ever, 28 September). In 1939 he read Prolonging Life, a pamphlet promising a lifespan of 150 years, by Aleksandr Bogomolets, a haematologist famous for his rapid-healing serums and blood transfusion methods.Bogomolets promised to prolong life with cytotoxic proteins, herbs and transfusions of young blood. Stalin made him a Hero of Socialist Labour and gave him generous research funding, but was dismayed when he died aged 64 in 1946 (this was hardly Bogomolets’s fault – as a boy in Tsarist times, he visited his mother, a revolutionary serving a sentence of hard labour in a Siberian prison, and caught tuberculosis).Donald RayfieldEmeritus professor, Queen Mary University of London Aleks Krotoski says dictators and US techno-billionaires are striving for immortality

A picture

More than 60,000 cancer patients in England ‘not getting necessary radiotherapy’

More than 60,000 cancer patients a year in England are not getting the radiotherapy they need at all, while some face waits of up to six months to begin the treatment, research has found.The situation is so dire that nearly 100 heads of radiotherapy and oncology – three-quarters of England’s radiotherapy leaders – have warned in an open letter that the government is failing patients.International experts agree that more than half (53%) of all cancer patients will typically need radiotherapy, but exclusive analysis of the latest NHS data in England shows only 35% actually receive it. The study by the charity Radiotherapy UK found 181,023 cancer patients should have received radiotherapy but only 120,569 did, leaving 60,455 patients a year without any radiotherapy at all.Regional inequalities are rife

A picture

Advantages of online GP booking systems | Letters

GPs in England are missing a trick (GPs in England threaten action over online appointment booking plan, 29 September). The point about non-urgent GP appointments is that they do not need triage – if a patient wants to see a primary care clinician for a routine concern, they can do so, whatever the issue.The number of routine slots available remains the same, and allowing people to book them online will reduce, not increase, workload by freeing up reception staff for other admin tasks, and making it easier to get through on the phone for urgent appointments. It’s urgent requests, not routine ones, that need triage.The big problem in primary care is the mismatch between demand and capacity, not how appointments are booked

A picture

Landmark study shows 1.4m Britons have a gambling problem

An estimated 1.4 million adults in Britain have a gambling problem, according to landmark figures released days after the chancellor hinted at plans to increase taxes on the £11.5bn betting and gaming industry.The Gambling Commission’s annual survey found that 2.7% of adults scored 8 or above on the problem gambling severity index, a widely accepted measure analysing negative consequences of betting

A picture

UK woman who refused cancer drugs was influenced by mother, inquest finds

A woman who died after refusing chemotherapy doctors believed would have given her a strong chance of recovery was “adversely influenced” by her conspiracy theorist mother, a coroner has said.Paloma Shemirani died aged 23 in July 2024 after refusing conventional treatment for non-Hodgkin lymphoma. On Thursday, the coroner in her inquest said the influence of her parents, Kay and Faramarz Shemirani, “more than minimally” contributed to her death.“It seems that if Paloma had been supported and encouraged to accept her diagnosis and considered chemotherapy with an open mind she probably would have followed that course,” Catherine Wood told a hearing at Kent and Medway coroner’s court in Maidstone.She said Kay Shemirani “took a leading role in advising Paloma in respect of and facilitating access to alternative treatments”