Teen sensations are meant to be one in a million so why does it feel as if prodigies are taking over? | Emma John

A picture


From Max Dowman to Kimi Antonelli, Sky Brown and Luke Littler, peak performance can be attained ever earlier thanks to support and scienceDes Ryan lives on the west coast of Ireland and gets over to watch Arsenal only about three times a season.It was pure fluke that the director of sports and physical wellbeing at the University of Galway was at the Emirates Stadium last weekend, when Max Dowman became the youngest ever scorer in the Premier League.He admits to getting “quite emotional” – just a few years ago he was looking after Dowman in the under-12s.“If you’re an academy specialist, then seeing the young people get their debuts, that’s your trophy,” says Ryan, who headed the Arsenal academy’s athletic development for nine years.He knows well that while Dowman’s abilities are uniquely precocious, his situation isn’t.

Marli Salmon became Arsenal’s youngest defender when he made his senior debut at 16 in December, while Brando Bailey-Joseph replaced Gabriel Martinelli on the wing in a Champions League match in January, aged 17.As Ryan notes: “These older teenagers are playing adult sport, and excelling at it.”Teenage talent is always captivating, but recently there seems to have been a glut of it.In Brazil last week the skateboarder Sky Brown won her second world championship at 17, but by this point, she’s an old hand: she took her first gold when she was 14, a year after becoming Britain’s youngest Olympic medallist with bronze in Tokyo.This makes her one of the few people in the world who could honestly relate to Luke Littler, a two-time darts world champion by the age of 18.

The snowboarder Mia Brookes was disappointed not to add a Winter Olympics medal to her successes at X Games and World Cups.Still, when you become slopestyle world champion one month after you turn 16, you’ve got plenty of time to add to your trophy cabinet.And it wasn’t that long ago that Britain’s 44-year wait for a women’s singles title in a grand slam was ended by an 18-year-old Emma Raducanu.Is there a pattern here? Or is this parade of prodigies simply a mirage, the kind of optical illusion presented to every generation of ageing sports fans that thinks that England cricket captains, like policemen, are getting younger every year? Well, Jacob Bethell did become the youngest man to lead the side against Ireland in their Twenty20 series last September – at 21, he was two years younger than Monty Bowden, who had held the record since 1889.And in his squad was Rehan Ahmed, the youngest Englishman ever to play a Test.

All this is interesting because teenage sensations are supposed to be outliers, rarities, one-in-a-million miracles,The data is clear: peak performance age across a vast range of sports is only going one way, and that’s up,Between 1992 and 2021, the average ages of Olympians, male and female, increased by two years,Since 1990, the average age of professional men’s tennis players has increased from 24,6 to 28.

6, while male cricketers and footballers are also competing at the highest level for longer.And yet here we are, in a week when Bayern Munich were seriously considering putting the 16-year-old Leonard Prescott in goal in their Champions League fixture] on Wednesday (before Jonas Urbig managed to come back from a concussion injury), and when Sunderland reportedly offered £13m for Thiago Pitarch, the 18-year-old star of Real Madrid’s academy.Not to mention the 19-year-old Kimi Antonelli becoming the second-youngest grand prix winner in history – only Max Verstappen has taken the chequered flag sooner, as an 18-year-old in 2016.In fact, Formula One may offer some clue to what is happening.There is, after all, no doubt that at the highest level of motor sport, competitors are getting younger: it’s right there in the grid-position graphics ahead, where the baby-faced images of Oliver Bearman, Isack Hadjar and Gabriel Bortoleto (all 21) look hopefully ahead to the championship aspirations of Oscar Piastri (25) and Lando Norris (26).

Even Charles Leclerc and Verstappen, two of the most senior figures on the track, haven’t yet turned 30,F1’s driver academies have evolved into some of the best funded and most advanced athlete development programmes in sport, at the cutting edge of identifying and fast-tracking talent,Technical advances – be that sports science, psychology or next-gen simulators – have made it possible to prepare drivers for the unique rigours of racing with less experience on track, and at a younger age, than in previous eras,The Premier League has undergone a similar revolution in youth training through the elite player performance plan, introduced in 2012,Ryan worked in Irish rugby for 14 years before moving to Arsenal – whose academy is in the first of the EPPP’s four tiers – and says the system has put football in “a different world”.

“It’s quite clear England are benefiting from it with lots of new talent,” he says.“When you have excellent resources, be it physical, medical, psychological, social, educational, that does increase player readiness.”Sean Cumming, the professor in paediatric exercise science at the University of Bath who helped introduce biobanding – under which athletes are grouped based on growth and maturation, rather than age – into English (and now Scottish) football, agrees.“The game itself is incredibly physical now – players are faster, more powerful, stronger.To compete at that level, you have to be able to physically compete against full-grown adults, and some of your late developers simply won’t be able to do that until about 20.

“But early developers who reach physical maturity at, say, 16, are getting better support than they’ve had previously.Athletes are in a very privileged position now in terms of the knowledge and awareness of how to support them.” In category-one academies in the Premier League, for instance, young footballers are guided through “developmentally appropriate” strength and conditioning – “not putting heavy weights on kids, but teaching them technique so that when they are ready to benefit from weight training, they’re ready to go very quickly.”There is still need for caution: while investment in sports science and coaching is “definitely paying off” in English football, says Cumming, it’s important to remember that even early developers’ bodies are still growing and completing into their early 20s, meaning they remain susceptible to injuries, and workloads need to be carefully managed.And Ryan, too, has reservations about the appropriateness of putting youth athletes into adult sport in all situations, particularly in football.

“At the end of the day, the male brain doesn’t mature till 23 – they can do silly things, make mistakes, they need people around them.So while I’d highlight the safeguarding, security, education, player care, mentoring that’s in place in category one academies, I’d have concerns about young people being fed into the adult dressing rooms below that.”
cultureSee all
A picture

Banksy has been unmasked (again). But does this major Reuters investigation actually tell us something new?

Hi Kelly, everyone is talking about Banksy (again) – what’s he done this time?Hi Nick. So a really long (8,000-word) investigation by Reuters claims it has discovered the elusive street artist’s true identity, which backs up claims made by the Mail on Sunday British tabloid almost two decades ago that he is a 52-year-old Bristol-born man called Robin Gunningham, now going by the name of David Jones.Wait … didn’t we already know that? Or was it supposed to be the guy from Massive Attack?Sort of. Previous reports suggested that Robert Del Naja, the co-founder of Massive Attack – a pioneer in trip-hop, which is a music genre that also has its roots in Bristol – was Banksy. Now it seems that Naja is Gunningham’s secret partner/enabler/scout/gatekeeper

A picture

Arts Council England must change or face ‘disaster’, culture department is told

Arts Council England requires a “radical” overhaul so it can to respond to the challenges of the culture sector, according to Margaret Hodge, who said it would be a “disaster” if ACE leaders did not heed her warnings.The Labour peer, who led a wide-ranging and critical report into ACE, made the comments at a Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) select committee, where she reiterated her calls for the organisation to embrace change.Lady Hodge said: “I think there has to be a radical review in the way that the Arts Council works; how they use the money, their role in relation to the organisations that they support, and also their role in the wider arts landscape.”She said a significant shift in approach was needed because of the “loss of confidence in how ACE serves its own communities”, caused in part by the perception of political interference in decision-making.The decision to force the English National Opera to move from London to Manchester was a “raw experience” for some of the 700 people she spoke to as part of her review, she said

A picture

Jimmy Kimmel on Trump: ‘He uses his bones to feel things instead of his brain’

Late-night hosts on Monday discussed the Academy Awards, Maga’s incoherent statements on the Iran war and raised an eyebrow to Donald Trump’s claims of support from an anonymous former president.On Jimmy Kimmel Live, the host focused on Trump’s comments to the press in week three of the Iran war, or as Kimmel called it “Operation Epsteino Distracto”.On Truth Social, Trump wrote that it was a “great honour” to kill “scumbags” in Iran.“He’s been talking very tough for a guy who seems to almost be in a coma right now,” Kimmel said.“Even with all the killing he has been enjoying so much, he is very low energy lately,” the host continued

A picture

Carnivàle revisited: is this HBO’s strangest show?

Carnivàle premiered on HBO in 2003 and was cancelled after only two seasons. In the immediate aftermath, this decision was protested by the small but dedicated cult following the show had amassed (to the tune of 50,000 emails).But in the years since, as the television canon has expanded and the taste for mystery-box TV has waned, Carnivàle now seems little more than a minor curio in HBO’s ever-expanding back catalogue. So what is this curio about?Carnivàle follows the exploits of its titular carnival as they travel across the American dust bowl in the 1930s. At the beginning of the series, these nomadic showpeople pick up Ben Hawkins (Nick Stahl), an ex-con with a mysterious past (and inexplicable powers)

A picture

‘We kicked Bono’s arse’: how we made Atomic Kitten’s Whole Again (with a little help from Kraftwerk)

‘Kerry’s spoken verse needed 39 takes spread over several months because she’d had her tonsils out’People never believe me that Kraftwerk created Atomic Kitten. In 1996, my band OMD released Walking on the Milky Way, which I thought was one of the best songs I’d ever written. But in the age of Britpop, we were perceived as an 80s synthpop band, past our sell-by date. Radio 2 wouldn’t play the song and Woolworths wouldn’t stock it. I thought: “I’m functioning with one arm tied behind my back

A picture

Gatz review – the Great Gatsby performed in eight and a half hours of attentive, immersive joy

A man enters his office in the morning, finds his computer on the fritz and, after a few attempts to turn it on and off again, comes across a copy of F Scott Fitzgerald’s 1925 novel The Great Gatsby. So he starts to read and when his colleagues enter they find themselves taking on the characters, and soon the novel unfolds around us, word by word. The New York theatre company Elevator Repair Service has produced a work that is not quite adaptation – given it doesn’t really adapt the novel at all – but that is utterly transfixing nonetheless.Following a keen interest in non-dramatic texts, the company wanted to see what would happen when a powerful literary work was read and performed in its entirety. The result is both strange and strangely familiar