Carnivàle revisited: is this HBO’s strangest show?
Carnivàle premiered on HBO in 2003 and was cancelled after only two seasons.In the immediate aftermath, this decision was protested by the small but dedicated cult following the show had amassed (to the tune of 50,000 emails).But in the years since, as the television canon has expanded and the taste for mystery-box TV has waned, Carnivàle now seems little more than a minor curio in HBO’s ever-expanding back catalogue.So what is this curio about?Carnivàle follows the exploits of its titular carnival as they travel across the American dust bowl in the 1930s.At the beginning of the series, these nomadic showpeople pick up Ben Hawkins (Nick Stahl), an ex-con with a mysterious past (and inexplicable powers).
Interwoven into the show is the contrasting story of Brother Justin Crowe (Clancy Brown), a preacher who finds himself on the receiving end of nightmarish, foreboding visions which convince him he is God’s messenger: a man with divine purpose.Throughout much of the series, these two storylines never physically intersect, except within the confines of dreams shared by both Hawkins and Crowe.Their contrasting tales make tangible the existential, mythic battle between good and evil resting beneath Carnivàle’s literal narrative.It’s reminiscent of the broad, pulpy scope of early Stephen King novels – or, perhaps more relevant to Carnivàle, Twin Peaks’ surreal lore.The viewer knows the worlds of Hawkins and Crowe will eventually collide, and when they do, the effects will be cosmic.
What makes the show special is the way this otherworldly tone is welded on to what is, at its core, a very traditional ensemble piece.Screenwriter Ronald D Moore helmed much of Carnivàle’s first season before leaving to create Battlestar Galactica, and his sensibility – one deeply attuned to character, fascinated by human folly – informs much of the season’s slow burn.The show luxuriates in the texture of the carnival itself and the small human drama of its troupe.Also worth noting is just how handsome the production is.Many of the show’s regular directors – the likes of Jeremy Podeswa, Jack Bender and John Patterson – cut their teeth working on The Sopranos and Six Feet Under, and would later go on to helm landmark episodes of television on series such as Lost and Game of Thrones; there is also a late episode directed by Tár’s Todd Field.
As a result, the visual style of Carnivàle is consistently hypnotic – and, yes, Lynchian.There are the bizarre conversations between different members of the carnival and “Management”, an unseen, all-seeing character whom we only know through their reedy, strained voice residing in the shadows behind a curtain.Then there are the show’s many dream sequences, which move from the ethereal to the outright horrific, presenting us with images of war, of blood raining down on a tortured preacher, of nuclear explosion.Discovering the show afresh this year, it has already found its place among my own TV canon.Carnivàle’s sideshow of bizarro characters; the dense, theological mysteries which sit at its centre; its refined cinematic style: all these elements come together to create a singular experience.
A word of warning: its premature cancellation will leave you aching for more.Carnivàle is available to stream on HBO Max in Australia and the US, and on Now in the UK.For more recommendations of what to stream in Australia, click here
Memory loss strikes down Starmer and Badenoch at an infuriating PMQs | John Crace
There’s something weird going on in Westminster. A mutant pathogen in the water maybe. Whatever it is, Keir Starmer and Kemi Badenoch appear to have been struck down by it.Both have had parts of their memory wiped. At times they now sound like the living dead
Starmer claims Tory party has ‘problem with Muslims’ after Nick Timothy tweet
Keir Starmer has claimed the Conservative party “has a problem with Muslims” after the shadow justice secretary described an event where the London mayor, Sadiq Khan, joined others to pray in Trafalgar Square as “an act of domination”.During PMQs, the prime minister urged Kemi Badenoch to sack Nick Timothy over a post on X in which he shared a clip of Khan and other Muslims praying in the square.Timothy wrote: “Too many are too polite to say this. But mass ritual prayer in public places is an act of domination.” He went on to say: “The domination of public places is straight from the Islamist playbook
Starmer says Tory shadow minister should be sacked for criticism of Muslims praying in Trafalgar Square – as it happened
Badenoch says Starmer did not answer the question. Did he pick up the phone to Mandelson.She says Starmer said Mandelson lied to him. That implied that they spoke.Starmer again criticises Badenoch
Polanski positions Greens’ economic policy as radical alternative to Reeves
The venue for Zack Polanski’s economic speech on Wednesday – a sunny north London garden centre – could hardly have been more different to the sombre City backdrop for Rachel Reeves’s Mais lecture a day earlier.The chancellor was, as it happens, the last politician to give a major economic speech at the New Economics Foundation (NEF), the leftwing thinktank that invited the Green party leader, Polanski, to set out his stall as part of its 40th anniversary celebrations. Back in 2018 it hosted the speech in which, as a backbencher, Reeves called for an “everyday economy” that would prioritise the needs of low-paid workers.But with their determination to appear sober and moderate, Reeves and Labour have struggled to communicate in government a willingness to shake things up, even where they have in fact made significant changes.Enter Polanski
Zack Polanski says Greens would ditch GDP targets and focus on wellbeing instead
A government led by the Green party would not set targets for GDP growth but would instead focus on people’s mental health, social cohesion and community welfare, Zack Polanski has said in a major speech to set out his plans for the economy.In his first policy address since taking over as leader of the Greens in England and Wales six months ago, Polanski condemned what he called “rip-off Britain”, where a minority of asset owners benefited at the expense of people obliged to pay unaffordable sums for housing and other basics.In a post-speech press conference, when asked if a government he led would seek to create economic growth, Polanski argued this was the wrong way of looking at the issue.“Actually, I’m much more interested in growing people’s mental health, growing our public services, growing cohesion in our communities,” he said, arguing a focus on increasing GDP growth could create unintended incentives and outcomes.“If we’re looking at GDP – if a water company pumps sewage into the water and then pays for that to be cleaned up, then that technically improves your GDP, and that’s economic growth,” he said
Revealed: a crypto billionaire’s political base hosting ‘anti-woke’ and rightwing activists in Westminster
A British billionaire convicted in the US for failing to implement adequate money-laundering controls on his cryptocurrency business is funding a political base in the heart of Westminster used by “anti-woke” and rightwing activists.Ben Delo, 42, who was pardoned by Donald Trump last year, has given support in kind to Rupert Lowe, the anti-migration MP challenging Nigel Farage from the right – while also connecting with mainstream figures including the Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch and former cabinet minister Michael Gove.Delo, an Oxford graduate who moved to Hong Kong in 2012 and appears to still be based there, says he is a champion of “free speech” and has vowed to tackle the “nuisance” of political correctness. He supports more than 50 organisations ranging across the political spectrum and public life, as well as non-affiliated groups and individuals.Now a joint investigation by the Guardian and Hope Not Hate reveals some of the people and projects that have benefited from Delo’s largesse
Sky considers ending controversial UAE news joint venture
HelloFresh hit by sales slump as people lose appetite for meal kits
Fuel rations and no air con: south-east Asian nations race to conserve energy
US postal service will run out of money by February 2027, says agency chief
Reeves plans to give England’s regional leaders a share of national tax revenues
Oil and gas prices rise again after Iran attacks production facilities