Harry Brook’s moment of madness a fitting epitaph for England’s flawed cult of Baz | Barney Ronay

A picture


Tough on Harry Brook, yes,But we must also be tough on the causes of Harry Brook,No child is born playing performative reverse-hoicks with a Test match to be saved, just as most acts of cult-like behaviour have their roots in a smooth-talking cult-like instructor,For England the beginning of the end of the age of Baz started when the disciples of Baz began to deny such a thing even existed; to insist that the buckle-up-and-enjoy-the-ride stuff didn’t actually exist at all, but was instead a creation of another, much worse cult, also known in this world as “the outside”,With this in mind, Brook’s dismissal in Adelaide was at least a tell, a moment of anti-gaslighting.

No, you really didn’t imagine all that,For the England regime, a hard stop is now in sight, and in the usual way of these things, in the fire of an overseas Ashes immolation,But at least we got a moment here, an epitaph for an era, albeit one that was incoherent, misspelt and appeared to have been scrawled on a hotel napkin with a frankfurter,It came just as it seemed something else might be happening,The French have a phrase, l’esprit de l’escalier, to describe the sudden realisation of what you should have said all along, the riposte you only think of when you’re already halfway down the stairs.

For three hours in Adelaide, England seemed to be producing their own cricket de l’escalier, bristling suddenly with resistance and application but doing this on the exit stairs of a burning building that has already been flame-throwered in Perth and Brisbane.So now you want to fight?It always felt like the prelude to another, deeper shade of pain.The first two Tests of England’s Ashes tour had felt like watching some theatrical reality TV humiliation.Put your head inside this box filled with kangaroo mucus.Watch Will Jacks bowling two hours of half-trackers.

Crawl through a giant millipede anus while stabbing yourself in the eye with dingo toenails.But they found something else here, a way to die slowly.Zak Crawley produced his most restrained Test match innings, as England moved doggedly to 177 for three in the 48th over.At which point the day felt like a quietly pointed, very English rejection of the code that has governed this team.The chandelier may have already fallen from the ceiling.

The cannons are taking chunks out of the walls,But we can still brush the dust from our wing collar and continue to pass the port to the left,At which point, enter Brook, who is deep in it, an entire Test career played out around this regime, and who appears to be still fighting the second world war from inside a small copse,Brook and Crawley were putting pressure on the bowlers simply by surviving,The end of the day had begun to loom.

This was England’s best batting of the series.At which point Brook did the thing.From over the wicket Nathan Lyon pitched a ball just outside off stump.Before it had been released, Brook was already sliding down on to one knee, turning his shoulders, ready to reverse slash towards what was now deep fine leg.The ball dipped, because Lyon does make it drop.

It turned, because Lyon also makes it turn.The ball missed the bat, ripped past Brook’s back leg as he fell over, and hit leg stump.And, yes, this dismissal will be howled over.It will be described as stupid, arrogant and entitled, mainly because it was.This was not just an ugly shot, but a misguided one, high-risk where risk was already quite high enough.

Brook was putting pressure back on Lyon by not getting out to him,This was a way to put pressure on his own own teammates instead,Suddenly Lyon was pepped and zinging it down, the energy of the day transformed,Does it really matter in the wider picture? A world-record fourth-innings chase was not realistically going to happen,England will lose this game by 180 runs or so.

In doing this they will probably have played up to the limit of their own capacities against a superior Australia bowling attack.One failed swish is not where the Ashes were lost.But it was still a perfect demonstration of how; of talent being wasted; of game situations thrown away; and of how scrambled and strange some of the messaging is.Mainly it was the most predictably unpredictable moment.England’s style has been about this, a performative individualism that feels increasingly mannered.

There are other kinds of excitement out there.Sometimes you can actually cook a meal rather than just sending out for a chicken box on a moped.It does feel like a point of crisis is in train here, not least for Brook, who has dined out on his Test average without actually posting any defining interventions against the better teams.Run towards the danger.As long as that danger is Pakistan on a fully asphalted road or New Zealand in New Zealand.

He can be so much better than this.England will almost certainly – no, certainly – lose this game on day five and the Ashes before Christmas.But at least we had a piece of undeniable evidence here.Joe Root and Jeetan Patel have suggested this week that the system previously known as Bazball was some kind of media construct.What have I been watching then?What in that case does Brendon McCullum actually do? Because it’s definitely not coaching, scheduling or attention to detail.

If not big-picture thinking, what do we actually need him for? Is the cost of getting rid of McCullum now reason enough to keep him? Should 2-0 become 5-0 in January, the last really Baz move on the board would be to take matters into his own hands,
technologySee all
A picture

Sony collars Snoopy in £340m deal to take control of Peanuts franchise

Sony has taken control of Charles Schulz’s Peanuts franchise including Snoopy and Charlie Brown in a deal worth C$630m (£340m).The Japanese conglomerate has bought 41% of Peanuts Holdings, which owns the intellectual property Schulz created, from the Canadian children’s entertainment company WildBrain.The deal raises Sony’s total stake, which it began building in 2018, to 80%. The Schulz family owns the remaining 20%.Peanuts, which first appeared as a comic strip in seven newspapers in 1950 and ran daily until the cartoonist’s death in 2000, has gone on to become a global franchise spanning TV, toys, films and theme park attractions

A picture

TikTok signs Trump-backed deal to avoid US ban

TikTok has reached a deal to form a joint venture that will allow it to continue operating in the US, five years after Donald Trump threatened to ban the social media platform over privacy and national security concerns, a move that further strained relations with China.ByteDance, TikTok’s Chinese owner, has signed a deal with Larry Ellison’s Oracle, the private-equity group Silver Lake and Abu Dhabi’s MGX that will allow it to retain control of its core US operations.Under the arrangement, the joint venture will take over part of TikTok’s US business, including data protection, algorithm security and content moderation.However, TikTok’s chief executive, Shou Zi Chew, told employees in a memo that ByteDance would continue to run US operations, including its main revenue drivers such as e-commerce, advertising and marketing.The deal ends five years of uncertainty over the future of TikTok in the US, where the platform has more than 130 million users

A picture

What will your life look like in 2035?

“Does it hurt when I do this?”“You seem to have dislocat…”A Eye: “NOOOO! The problem is a sprain in the brachial plexus due to you lifting that 10kg carton on Wednesday at 2.58pm and not eating enough blah blah”“Wow, err, thanks”In 2035, AIs are more than co-pilots in medicine, they have become the frontline for much primary care. Gone is the early morning scramble to get through to a harassed GP receptionist for help. Patients now contact their doctor’s AI to explain their ailments. It quickly cross-checks the information against the patient’s medical history and provides a pre-diagnosis, putting the human GP in a position to decide what to do next

A picture

Facebook tests charging users to share links in potential blow for news outlets

Facebook is testing a system that charges users for sharing web links, in a move that could prove to be a further blow to news outlets and other publishers.Meta, the social media platform’s owner, said it is carrying out a “limited test” in which those without a paid Meta Verified subscription, costing at least £9.99 a month, can only post two external links a month.The test appears to involve a subset of Facebook pages and user profiles on Professional Mode, which includes features used by content creators to monetise their posts.News organisations are not included in the test

A picture

AI boom has caused same CO2 emissions in 2025 as New York City, report claims

The AI boom has caused as much carbon dioxide to be released into the atmosphere in 2025 as emitted by the whole of New York City, it has been claimed.The global environmental impact of the rapidly spreading technology has been estimated in research published on Wednesday, which also found that AI-related water use now exceeds the entirety of global bottled-water demand.The figures have been compiled by the Dutch academic Alex de Vries-Gao, the founder of Digiconomist, a company that researches the unintended consequences of digital trends. He claimed they were the first attempt to measure the specific effect of artificial intelligence rather than datacentres in general as the use of chatbots such as OpenAI’s ChatGPT and Google’s Gemini soared in 2025.The figures show the estimated greenhouse gas emissions from AI use are also now equivalent to more than 8% of global aviation emissions

A picture

Third of UK citizens have used AI for emotional support, research reveals

A third of UK citizens have used artificial intelligence for emotional support, companionship or social interaction, according to the government’s AI security body.The AI Security Institute (AISI) said nearly one in 10 people used systems like chatbots for emotional purposes on a weekly basis, and 4% daily.AISI called for further research, citing the death this year of the US teenager Adam Raine, who killed himself after discussing suicide with ChatGPT.“People are increasingly turning to AI systems for emotional support or social interaction,” AISI said in its first Frontier AI Trends report. “While many users report positive experiences, recent high-profile cases of harm underline the need for research into this area, including the conditions under which harm could occur, and the safeguards that could enable beneficial use