Circumcision classed as potentially harmful practice in new CPS guidance
Circumcision has been classed as a potentially harmful practice in new official guidance for criminal prosecutors in England and Wales, but controversial plans to class it as possible child abuse have been dropped.The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) decided against including circumcision alongside dowry abuse, witchcraft and female genital mutilation in its new guidance on honour-based abuse, after objections from Jewish and Muslim groups when the plans were revealed by the Guardian.Instead it has included a similar section on circumcision in updated guidance on offences against the person.It says: “In certain circumstances, such as the procedure being carried out by those falsely claiming to be suitably qualified practitioners or carried out in non-sterile conditions, it can cross the line into a harmful practice.”Prosecutors are advised to consider child cruelty offences under the Children and Young Persons Act 1933 or assault offences under the Offences against the Person Act 1861.
The guidance also refers to separate guidance on child abuse.Earlier CPS wording classing circumcision as a possible “form of child abuse” has been removed after it prompted alarm from religious leaders.Writing in the Jewish Chronicle, Rabbi Dr Jonathan Romain said the late Queen Elizabeth II had not been accused of child abuse when her three sons were each circumcised.Romain, the convener of Reform Beit Din, Progressive Judaism’s religious court, said he approved of the altered wording.“I very much welcome the change of attitude by the CPS not to castigate circumcision, as it is an important practice for so many people of different faiths and cultures,” he told the Guardian.
He added: “Circumcision can be safe and meaningful if done by experts, but rogue operators can both bring it into disrepute and endanger children,”Jonathan Arkush, co-chair of Milah UK, which promotes and protects the right of the Jewish community to carry out religious circumcision, said guidance upheld “the very longstanding status of male circumcision as a legal practice”,He added: “Male circumcision as carried out by the Jewish community was not and is not in any way related to the concept of honour-based abuse, as the CPS has rightly recognised,The updated guidance has corrected the wording that appeared in an early stage draft that was reported by the Guardian,“Some of the references to male circumcision that appeared in the early draft were misleading and wrong.
The CPS is to be commended for putting right the errors,”Since 2001, circumcision has been a factor in the deaths of seven boys, including three babies who bled to death,Birmingham Women’s and Children’s NHS trust admitted 29 babies between 2022 and 2024 with serious complications from circumcision, including sepsis and haemorrhage, according to figures obtained under freedom of information laws,Last December, a coroner issued warnings about insufficient regulation over who can perform a circumcision, after the death of a six-month-old boy, Mohamed Abdisamad, from a streptococcus infection in 2023,In January 2025 Mohammad Siddiqui, a former doctor, was jailed for causing “gratuitous pain and suffering” in circumcisions conducted between 2014 and 2019.
In May, Mohammed Alazawi, who falsely claimed to be a doctor, was convicted of six counts of wounding with intent in circumcision procedures.Alejandro Sanchez, the human rights lead at the National Secular Society, said: “Given the appalling harm wrought on children by Mohammad Siddiqui and Mohammed Alazawi, the CPS are absolutely right to include circumcision in new prosecutorial guidance.“Despite the efforts of apologists for circumcision, the guidance correctly maintains that the practice may constitute child abuse and child cruelty.Religious groups that openly perform unanaesthetised circumcisions – which the CPS described last year as ‘gratuitous infliction of pain’ – should take note.”A father, who wished to remain anonymous and who is a pursuing a complaint against a doctor who left his son seriously mutilated after a botched circumcision, said the new guidance was a “positive step” but that it was too vague.
He said: “Without clearer definitions and practical direction on consent, safeguarding and best interests, the guidance risks offering reassurance on paper while leaving families without meaningful protection in practice.”A CPS spokesperson said it recognised that circumcisionwas “a legal practice that carries social, cultural and religious significance”, adding: “However, there are certain cases when the procedure is carried out improperly and in unsafe conditions where it can cause significant harm and distress to victims.Our guidance directs prosecutors to consider the circumstances on a case-by-case basis, noting the factors that may lead to the practice amounting to a criminal offence.”
‘Excellence’: Smithsonian exhibit celebrates HBCUs amid attacks on Black history
At a time when museums and colleges are facing uncertainty and there is a push to limit the acknowledgment of Black history, the Smithsonian’s National Museum of African American History and Culture (NMAAHC) and its five partner historically Black colleges and universities (HBCUs) have launched a new exhibit to put Black history and Black archives at the forefront.At the Vanguard: Making and Saving History at HBCUs, on view at the NMAAHC now through 19 July, was developed as a part of the History and Culture Access Consortium (HCAC). After At the Vanguard leaves the NMAAHC, it will go on tour to each of the universities, along with other locations that request it.The exhibit, which is composed of archival materials and collections from each of the five HBCUs of the partnership – Jackson State University, Florida A&M University, Tuskegee University, Clark Atlanta University and Texas Southern University – is the culmination of years of work by the consortium. With more than 100 objects on display at the NMAAHC, the collection includes rare items, such as one of the only existing color videos of George Washington Carver, the agricultural scientist and inventor, from Tuskegee University
Jon Stewart on US attacks in Iran: ‘A war with no clear purpose, no end in sight’
Late-night hosts delved into the new US regime-change war in the Middle East, after Donald Trump directed the US military to bomb Iran in conjunction with Israel.Jon Stewart opened The Daily Show on Monday in a daze, after Iran state media confirmed that US and Israeli forces killed its supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, over the weekend. The host joked that, for the surprise occasion and chaos that followed, he needed to bring back “a 20-year recurring segment” titled “Mess O’Potamia”.“America, apparently, had to start an entire war to kill an 86-year-old man in ill health and not wait – I don’t know – three weeks to let saturated fat do its thing,” he joked.He then played a clip of Trump, wearing his USA hat, announcing the so-called “Operation Epic Fury” against Iran from his luxury golf course in Florida
‘My guitar was mangled – like my life!’ Goo Goo Dolls on how they made epic ballad Iris
‘I’m grateful to Taylor Swift, and others who have covered it, for introducing the song to a new generation. Three billion streams on Spotify is astonishing!’I was going through a divorce and living in a hotel in West Hollywood when my manager said Warner Brothers were seeking songs for the movie City of Angels. They already had U2, Peter Gabriel and Alanis Morissette, so I thought getting a track on there would draw attention to us. Warners showed me the film and it was like Wim Wenders’ Wings of Desire. They wanted a song for the scene where the angel – played by Nicolas Cage – decides to become human to be with the woman he loves
My cultural awakening: Leonardo da Vinci made me rethink surgery – I’ve since mended more than 3,000 hearts
For one heart surgeon, seeing the Renaissance artist’s anatomical drawings gave him a natural understanding of the body that was often overlooked in modern medical scienceIf you’d asked my teenage self, growing up in a small village in Shropshire, what I wanted to do with my life, I would have talked about art and music long before I spoke of scalpel blades and operating theatres. As an 18-year-old, I intended to go to art school, until my mother sat me down and told me rather bluntly that being an artist wouldn’t earn me much money. As she spoke, a surgical documentary flickered across the screen of the black-and-white television in our living room. I told her, half joking, that that was what I’d do instead. Which is how I ended up repeating my A-levels and fighting my way into medical school, where I qualified in 1975
From The Testament of Ann Lee to Gorillaz: your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead
Amanda Seyfried is Shaker all over in a wild period drama, while Damon Albarn and his cartoon cohort return with a polyglot offeringThe Testament of Ann LeeOut now In Mona Fastvold’s critically acclaimed drama, Amanda Seyfried shakes things up as the founder of the restorationist Christian sect the United Society of Believers in Christ’s Second Appearing. More commonly known as the Shakers, the egalitarian ecstatic worship group coalesced round the visionary female leader in the 18th century.Scream 7Out now The Kevin Williamson-scripted Scream films (1, 2, 4) are probably the best in the franchise, and this time he not only writes but directs the antics of Ghostface et al. Neve Campbell, David Arquette, Matthew Lillard and Courteney Cox all make appearances, regardless of whether you thought their characters were dead or not.SirâtOut now In the deserts of southern Morocco, a man searches for his missing daughter, enlisting the help of a group of partygoers who tell of a rave deep in the desert where perhaps she can be found
Pulp have the last word in Adelaide festival saga with triumphant opening gig
Britpop rockers wow crowd and say all voices are ‘important’ in wake of Randa Abdel-Fattah controversyGet our breaking news email, free app or daily news podcast“All voices are important,” the Pulp frontman Jarvis Cocker told an adoring crowd in Adelaide on Friday. “All voices should be heard.”Message received. At one point Pulp had pulled out of the opening gig at the Adelaide festival over the Adelaide writers’ week (AWW) furore.But they turned up, they wowed the 10,000-strong crowd, and while Cocker didn’t explicitly say his comment was a reference to the brouhaha around AWW, it was pretty clear
UK government ‘effectively allowed’ child sexual abuse, campaigners say
Circumcision classed as potentially harmful practice in new CPS guidance
Binge drinking rises sharply among gen Z in their early 20s
Scientists laud potentially life-changing drug for children with resistant form of epilepsy
Maternity services need investment in people and training, not another review | Letters
Head of carer’s allowance inquiry blames DWP ‘resistance’ for failure to fix crisis