Great Ormond Street hospital cleaners win racial discrimination appeal
Black cleaners at Great Ormond Street hospital were subjected to “indirect race discrimination” by the wait for NHS pay terms and conditions after their services were brought in-house, a tribunal has found.A case against the London children’s hospital brought by 80 cleaners – the majority of whom are from Black and minority ethnic backgrounds – was dismissed by an employment tribunal in 2024.But in a judgment handed down this week in a four-year legal battle, the employment appeal tribunal (EAT) upheld their appeal against the original decision, accepting their claim that they had suffered discrimination in not getting NHS “Agenda for Change” (AfC) pay rates “immediately or shortly thereafter” when their contracts were transferred in 2021.It is understood all staff have now been offered NHS AfC terms.If the hospital does not appeal further, the case is expected to move to discussions over financial remedy.
Between 2016 and 2021, the cleaners were employed by OCS Group UK Ltd, which held the cleaning contract at Great Ormond Street.At the time their contracts were transferred they earned the London living wage of £10.75 an hour, rather than AfC rates of £11.50, and had inferior terms and conditions to staff directly employed by the trust under the national AfC framework, which governs NHS pay, pensions, sick pay, annual leave and other benefits.The cleaners, who are members of the United Voices of the World union and were represented by the law firm Leigh Day, argued that the situation placed Black and minority ethnic staff at a disadvantage compared with their predominantly white peers who had been directly employed.
In his appeal ruling, Mr Justice Clive Sheldon found the cleaners had been discriminated against “post-transfer”, but not before their contracts were brought in-house.Petros Elia, the general secretary of United Voices of the World, said: “For too long, thousands of predominantly Black, Brown and migrant facilities workers – cleaners, porters, caterers and security staff – have been treated as second-class citizens.The EAT ruling confirms that forcing these workers to wait months or years for the pay and conditions they are legally entitled to is not just bad practice – it is unlawful race discrimination.The message to every NHS trust is clear: the era of two-tier workforces is over.”The Leigh Day solicitor Aman Thakar said: “Our clients have shown extraordinary resilience and determination in pursuing this case.
”Great Ormond Street hospital (GOSH) said it was “carefully reviewing” the decision.A spokesperson added: “Our cleaning and domestic services colleagues are valued members of our team at GOSH.This was a complex process, and we worked hard to harmonise staff into NHS employment quickly and in ways that worked best for individual staff.”
Here’s how Europe can file for divorce from Donald Trump | Phillip Inman
There is a way to file for divorce from Donald Trump and Europe needs to grab the opportunity.To the public it will look as if nothing has changed. But behind the scenes the EU and the UK could close the joint bank account and cut up the credit cards, or at least set in motion a form of financial separation that limits the power of a controlling former partner.It won’t be easy to walk away and it won’t be quick. But a degree of separation is necessary and, crucially, achievable
UK expected to reduce amount of steel it allows in tariff-free
The UK is expected to reduce the amount of foreign steel it allows in tariff-free, as the government looks to protect its domestic industry amid a global glut and a rise in protectionism.Ministers are considering changing the quota system that allows a quantity of the metal to be imported before imposing a 25% levy on anything above that level.Lower tariff-free quotas could be announced in April, for implementation from 1 July, according to three people with knowledge of discussions.The development comes amid a surfeit of steel driven by supplies from China, which is by far the world’s largest producer. Chinese steel exports hit yet another all-time high in December, while other producers such as Vietnam, Korea and Turkey are also trying to find customers
Google AI Overviews cite YouTube more than any medical site for health queries, study suggests
Google’s search feature AI Overviews cites YouTube more than any medical website when answering queries about health conditions, according to research that raises fresh questions about a tool seen by 2 billion people each month.The company has said its AI summaries, which appear at the top of search results and use generative AI to answer questions from users, are “reliable” and cite reputable medical sources such as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Mayo Clinic.However, a study that analysed responses to more than 50,000 health queries, captured using Google searches from Berlin, found the top cited source was YouTube. The video-sharing platform is the world’s second most visited website, after Google itself, and is owned by Google.Researchers at SE Ranking, a search engine optimisation platform, found YouTube made up 4
How the ‘confident authority’ of Google AI Overviews is putting public health at risk
Do I have the flu or Covid? Why do I wake up feeling tired? What is causing the pain in my chest? For more than two decades, typing medical questions into the world’s most popular search engine has served up a list of links to websites with the answers. Google those health queries today and the response will likely be written by artificial intelligence.Sundar Pichai, Google’s chief executive, first set out the company’s plans to enmesh AI into its search engine at its annual conference in Mountain View, California, in May 2024. Starting that month, he said, US users would see a new feature, AI Overviews, which would provide information summaries above traditional search results. The change marked the biggest shake-up of Google’s core product in a quarter of a century
Steve Smith hits his groove – but too late for Australia’s T20 World Cup squad
Considering that Steve Smith was once observed changing gloves after facing eight balls, it is no surprise to see him throw down a gauntlet. The surprise is that he is doing so in 20-over cricket, the format where his batting has historically made the most modest impression.It is an incongruity of Australia’s season that Smith has the hottest hand in the Big Bash League and it is too late to have him considered for an imminent World Cup with the squad selected weeks ago. Smith wanted to be there, but his bigger concern is not the T20 World Cup of 2026. It’s the Los Angeles Olympics of 2028
Donald Trump will not attend Super Bowl because it’s ‘too far away’
Donald Trump said he will not attend next month’s Super Bowl in northern California, citing the distance to the game, amid an ongoing culture-war backlash over the NFL’s choice of half-time and pre-game performers.Trump told the New York Post he plans to skip the 8 February championship game at Levi’s Stadium in Santa Clara because the trip is “just too far away”, adding that he would have considered attending if it were a shorter flight. The decision means Trump will not repeat his appearance at last year’s Super Bowl in New Orleans, where he became the first sitting US president to attend the NFL’s showcase event.The president has made high-profile appearances at sporting events a regular feature of his second term, including last year’s Daytona 500, the recent college football national championship and September’s Ryder Cup at Bethpage, New York. Many of those events were held near Florida or the US east coast, within short travel distance of the White House or Trump’s Mar-a-Lago compound
Nigel Farage’s trip to Davos hosted and paid for by family trust of billionaire
UK politics: Trump’s Nato claims ‘insulting and frankly appalling’, says Starmer –as it happened
French authorities ban British far-right activists from gathering at weekend
Starmer stands up to Trump at last and has chance to make case for Europe
Can Andy Burnham calm the anger in a Manchester seat Labour fears losing?
‘We have a clear agenda’: the teenager who broke news of Tory MP’s defection to Reform