Residents in legal fight to halt demolition of Clockwork Orange estate

A picture


A legal challenge has been launched in an effort to halt the demolition of a 1960s Brutalist estate in south-east London that featured in Stanley Kubrick’s dystopian film A Clockwork Orange.The challenge against Bexley council and Peabody housing association, which will be carrying out the redevelopment, has been launched by the Lesnes estate resident Adam Turk.He and others living there believe the estate could be refurbished rather than demolished and rebuilt under plans for the construction of up to 1,950 homes, which the council approved on 23 December.Residents fear the redevelopment would cause environmental damage and undermine the UK’s legal obligation to reach net zero by 2050.The dispute highlights a wider tension between environmental protection and initiatives to demolish and rebuild estates.

Across London, more than 130 housing estates are earmarked for demolition.When it was built, the estate was described as “a town of tomorrow” by Greater London Council architects, though residents say it later fell into disrepair.Land values in the area have risen since the opening of the Elizabeth line in 2022, which reduced journey times into central London.The legal challenge centres on the climate impact of the proposed demolition, arguing that the council and Peabody have underestimated the greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) the project would generate.While the development’s environmental statement acknowledges that the resulting emissions would be significant, lawyers acting for Turk argue that the assessment was carried out only against an illustrative masterplan rather than the “reasonable worst-case scenario” required under planning law.

Turk said: “I’m challenging the redevelopment because I don’t believe it’s in the interest or consideration of the residents who have lived here between 15 and 40 years.The environmental impact placed on residents, such as myself, will undoubtedly cause health problems for us.”Saskia O’Hara, a legal caseworker at the Public Interest Law Centre, representing residents seeking the judicial review, said: “Across London, approximately 137 housing estates are marked for demolition.These projects generate substantial greenhouse gas emissions, calling into question our stated commitment to achieving net zero by 2050.“At a minimum, estate residents and the wider public are entitled to assurance that these emissions are accurately assessed, transparently documented and lawfully disclosed to the decision-makers charged with determining whether demolition should proceed.

“This case exemplifies the point at which the displacement of established communities coincides with irreversible environmental harm and is therefore a matter of substantial public interest and concern.”A spokesperson for Peabody said: “We’re investing in communities in and around South Thamesmead, supporting people, improving public areas and providing much-needed new homes.The planned redevelopment of the Lesnes estate will help us expand this work and create an even better place for local people to live.“We will address any legal inquiries that may come up and will continue to support residents during this period of transition.”Bexley council said: “As the matter is live it would be inappropriate for us to comment at this time.

politicsSee all
A picture

Starmer stands up to Trump at last and has chance to make case for Europe

“Serious, calm, pragmatic, behind-the-scenes diplomacy” is how No 10 has been describing Keir Starmer’s approach to the chaotic world of Donald Trump’s administration.That may have been how the week started – and tiptoeing around Trump’s volatility has been the hallmark of Starmer’s relationship with the president for a whole year.However, the president’s two major digs at Britain first over Chagos and, more seriously, his claim that UK troops did not pull their weight in Afghanistan have finally provoked Starmer into a furious rebuttal.Starmer’s demand for an apology over the “insulting and frankly appalling” words from the unrepentant Trump marks the worst week for US-UK relations since the president took over last year.With characteristic understatement, the prime minister revealed that he had been “getting a bit exasperated” with Trump’s remarks about the UK – and appeared ready at last to draw a line in the sand about what is unacceptable to say about an ally

A picture

Can Andy Burnham calm the anger in a Manchester seat Labour fears losing?

When leaked WhatsApp messages sent by former minister Andrew Gwynne were published last year, Stuart Beard was astonished at the scenes outside his office in Denton town square.“There must have been about 60 pensioners with placards,” he said, referring to local anger over Gwynne’s derogatory texts, which included one saying he hoped an elderly woman who didn’t vote Labour “croaked it” before the next election.“I’ve never seen anything like it,” said Beard. “It was like a riot – it was quite funny in a way.”The circus will return to this diverse Manchester constituency after Gwynne’s resignation triggered a potentially seismic byelection that could pave the way for Andy Burnham’s much-hyped return to Westminster

A picture

‘We have a clear agenda’: the teenager who broke news of Tory MP’s defection to Reform

Andrew Rosindell had been tipped as a potential Reform recruit long before his defection from the Conservatives last weekend took Westminster by surprise.Yet as he and Nigel Farage basked in the spotlight outside parliament on Monday, more than 200 miles away in the town of Whitby, North Yorkshire, a 15-year-old schoolboy was also savouring the moment.Incredibly – at least to those unfamiliar with the rise of his burgeoning media enterprise – Charlie Simpson appeared to have scooped all other media by predicting on the evening before that the Essex MP would join Reform.“EXCLUSIVE: MP Andrew Rosindell has reached an agreement to defect to Reform UK,” Charlie tweeted on Saturday, prompting derision from other users of X and pressure from Rosindell’s office to take down the tweet.But the following day, Rosindell, who was a shadow Foreign Office minister under Kemi Badenoch, announced on X he had quit the Conservative party “with sorrow” after 25 years and had decided to join Reform “following a conversation with Nigel Farage earlier in the evening”

A picture

‘Risky’ Tories, ‘drama queen’ Jenrick and Farage’s Trump problem: voters’ verdict on the battle for the right

Boris Johnson’s election victory in 2019 was so sweeping you could walk from Land’s End to Hadrian’s Wall without ever leaving a Tory constituency. You could also have walked between two constituencies where More in Common ran focus groups with 2019 Conservative voters this week – Warrington South and Godalming and Ash. These are two seats that tell the story of the breadth and collapse of the Conservatives’ 2019 coalition.Warrington South, a north-west marginal that has flipped between Labour and the Conservatives, sits just outside the “red wall”. It voted leave in 2016, backed Johnson in 2019 and swung to Labour in 2024

A picture

Union boss warns against Labour ‘control-freakery’ over Andy Burnham

The boss of Britain’s biggest union has warned Labour to ensure a democratic process in the Gorton byelection, amid signs a “Stop Andy Burnham” campaign is under way to prevent him posing a threat to Keir Starmer.Andrea Egan, the general secretary of Unison, who started in the job on Thursday, appeared to stand against the prospect of a stitch-up in the contest as she warned against “control-freakery” in the party.The byelection was triggered by the resignation of the independent MP Andrew Gwynne on medical grounds, paving the way for a possible return for Burnham, who is currently mayor of Greater Manchester.The Guardian reported on Thursday that allies of Starmer were trying to prevent Burnham’s return amid fears he could challenge for the leadership.Multiple members of the party’s ruling national executive committee (NEC) predicted it would be impossible for Burnham to make it through the selection process given the number of Starmer loyalists on the body

A picture

Starmer’s allies launch ‘Stop Andy Burnham’ campaign to block parliamentary return

Keir Starmer’s allies have launched a “Stop Andy Burnham” campaign to prevent the Labour mayor from returning to parliament after the resignation of a Manchester MP triggered a byelection.Multiple members of the party’s ruling national executive committee (NEC) predicted it would be impossible for Burnham to make it through the selection process given the number of Starmer loyalists on the body desperate to avoid a leadership challenge.The Labour party machine sprang into action after the Guardian revealed on Thursday that Andrew Gwynne was planning to quit due to ill health, with officials and MPs warning about the financial cost and political risk of a subsequent mayoral race.However, allies of the Greater Manchester mayor suggested there would be significant disquiet among MPs, the unions and party members should the leadership try to block him from returning to parliament, where he served as the MP for Leigh from 2001 to 2017.Burnham has made no secret of his ambitions