DWP to reassess hundreds of thousands of cases in carer’s allowance scandal
Hundreds of thousands of vulnerable unpaid carers will have their cases reassessed after a damning official review concluded they had been left with huge debts because of government failure and maladministration.The review, due to be published on Tuesday, was triggered after a year-long Guardian investigation revealed how carers had been hit with draconian penalties of as much as £20,000 relating to carer’s allowance.Some were plunged into hardship, others were jailed.Ministers have promised to cancel or reduce penalties that were wrongly issued after the review concluded many were the result of official error rather than “wilful rule-breaking”.However, the government has stopped short of offering compensation to those affected.
It is understood compensation was both considered by the review and by ministers but is not one of the published recommendations of the review, headed by disability policy expert Liz Sayce.The stress, ill-health and anxiety endured by carers who were pushed into debt and hardship by carer’s allowance failures emerged in a series of Guardian articles over the past 20 months.Many carers said they were harassed and treated like criminals by DWP staff.Hundreds were convicted of benefit fraud.It remains unclear what will happen to carers convicted of benefit fraud as a result of official mistakes.
Pat McFadden, the welfare secretary, said putting right past failures was essential to rebuild trust with unpaid carers.“We inherited this mess from the previous government, but we’ve listened to carers, commissioned an independent review and are now making good for those affected,” he said.Ministers are understood to have accepted the vast majority of the review’s 40 recommendations.Sayce welcomed the government’s promise to review all carer’s allowance overpayments since 2015, saying the policy had “major impacts on carers’ health, finances and family wellbeing”.The reassessment of overpayments is likely to focus on those whose weekly or monthly earnings fluctuated, and who were penalised despite their “average” total earnings over a defined period being within allowed earnings limits.
Unpaid carers who look after loved ones for at least 35 hours a week are entitled to £83.30 a week carer’s allowance, as long as their weekly earnings from part-time jobs do not exceed £196.But if they exceed this limit, even by as little as 1p, they must repay that entire week’s carer’s allowance.Under the so-called “cliff-edge” earnings rules, this means someone who oversteps the threshold by as little as 1p a week for a year must repay not 52p but £4,331.60, plus a £50 civil penalty.
The draconian penalties were exacerbated by the DWP’s failure to alert carers who overstepped the weekly earnings limit, even though it had access to near real-time data.This meant overpayments in some cases were allowed to accumulate for years before unwitting carers were handed huge bills.At least two social security tribunal cases this year have found in favour of carers.Andrea Tucker and Nicola Green had overpayment penalties struck out after successfully arguing their monthly part-time earnings were lawful when averaged over a one-year period.This suggests DWP policy on the treatment of fluctuating earnings since 2020 has been flawed.
Echoing the wording of a report by MPs in 2019, which found breaches of the rules were mostly human error and not fraud, Sayce said: “This wasn’t wilful rule-breaking – it simply wasn’t clear what earnings fluctuations carers should report.”The failure to offer compensation to carers whose lives were turned into a nightmare of debt and anxiety as a result of DWP failures will disappoint many carers.Sign up to Headlines UKGet the day’s headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morningafter newsletter promotionOne told the Guardian: “A lot of carers have suffered serious stress and worry over this.They’ve suffered ill-health as a result.It should be more than just about cancelling or reducing some overpayments.
”Carers UK welcomed the report as a “big step forward” which acknowledged “the gravity of system failures” within the DWP.Its chief executive Helen Walker praised the government’s commitment “to put right the wrongs of the last 10 years”.Carers Trust’s chief executive Kirsty McHugh said: “As the review makes clear, the DWP’s guidance on overpayments was both wrong and confusing.It was a huge error going back a decade that meant countless carers were wrongly judged to have received overpayments of carer’s allowance.“We are pleased the DWP has taken it on the chin and listened to both carers and the services that support them.
”Katy Styles, of the We Care Campaign, said: “If the Sayce review finally ensures carers can claim carer’s allowance with confidence, that’s not a minor tweak, that’s justice.“If the government delivers this, it will be a huge win for people who’ve carried so much, for far too long.Carers deserve certainty, not constant anxiety.”The DWP’s repeated failure to tackle carer’s allowance design and administrative failures despite repeated warnings, not least internally by a civil servant whistleblower, caused public outrage last year and became known as the carer’s allowance scandal.It has been frequently compared to the Post Office scandal.
Currently at least 144,000 unpaid carers are repaying more than £251m in overpayments, with the total amount in carer’s allowance wrongly paid out by DWP since 2019 estimated at more than £357m,The best public interest journalism relies on first-hand accounts from people in the know,If you have something to share on this subject, you can contact us confidentially using the following methods,Secure Messaging in the Guardian appThe Guardian app has a tool to send tips about stories,Messages are end to end encrypted and concealed within the routine activity that every Guardian mobile app performs.
This prevents an observer from knowing that you are communicating with us at all, let alone what is being said.If you don't already have the Guardian app, download it (iOS/Android) and go to the menu.Select ‘Secure Messaging’.SecureDrop, instant messengers, email, telephone and postIf you can safely use the Tor network without being observed or monitored, you can send messages and documents to the Guardian via our SecureDrop platform.Finally, our guide at theguardian.
com/tips lists several ways to contact us securely, and discusses the pros and cons of each.
NHS directed pregnant women to controversial Free Birth Society via charity
Exclusive: NHS websites pointed women to factsheet featuring podcast by ‘dangerous’ influencers linked to baby deaths Full story: How the FBS is linked to baby deaths around the worldThe NHS has been directing pregnant women to a website that connected them to the Free Birth Society, an organisation that has been linked to baby deaths around the world after promoting labour without medical support.A number of NHS trusts are directing women who are contemplating a “free birth” to a charity website that until Monday referred to FBS podcasts as a source of “empowering stories” that can help British women “preparing for their own birth”.It contained a link to the FBS podcast, which medical experts warn is being used to radicalise women with misinformation.FBS advocates an extreme version of free birth, otherwise known as unassisted birth. It advises mothers not to use doctors or midwives and suggests they avoid pregnancy scans
UK charity records original music by people living with dementia
On a stage once presided over by Luciano Pavarotti, Dame Kiri Te Kanawa and Renée Fleming, people living with dementia are recording songs of their own composition.With the microphones of Glyndebourne opera house capturing every note, their voices rise and intertwine. Not echoing old, familiar tunes but shaping entirely new pieces expressing their feelings, hopes and fears – emotions that, when the music stops, their brains can no longer convey in mere words.“The public perception of people diagnosed with dementia is that everything is finished,” said Hazel Gaydon, events manager for the Raise Your Voice charity. “But what our excitement is embedded in is the fact that we’ve found musical creativity can trigger original words and tunes based on present and future thinking
DWP to reassess hundreds of thousands of cases in carer’s allowance scandal
Hundreds of thousands of vulnerable unpaid carers will have their cases reassessed after a damning official review concluded they had been left with huge debts because of government failure and maladministration.The review, due to be published on Tuesday, was triggered after a year-long Guardian investigation revealed how carers had been hit with draconian penalties of as much as £20,000 relating to carer’s allowance. Some were plunged into hardship, others were jailed.Ministers have promised to cancel or reduce penalties that were wrongly issued after the review concluded many were the result of official error rather than “wilful rule-breaking”.However, the government has stopped short of offering compensation to those affected
The carer’s allowance scandal – a timeline
Ministers have announced a major review of the penalties imposed on hundreds of thousands of unpaid carers after a damning independent investigation of the carer’s allowance scandal.The inquiry by Liz Sayce was launched after the Guardian revealed how a catalogue of failures at the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) had left scores of vulnerable families with huge debts and hundreds with criminal convictions for fraud.Those who care for loved ones for at least 35 hours a week are entitled to £83.30 a week in carer’s allowance, as long as their weekly earnings do not exceed £196. But if they exceed this limit, even by as little as 1p, they must repay that entire week’s carer’s allowance
More than 100 MPs urge Streeting to approve prostate cancer screening
More than 100 MPs, including Rishi Sunak, have urged Wes Streeting to introduce screening for prostate cancer.The UK National Screening Committee, a government agency that advises ministers and the NHS about all aspects of screening, will recommend whether men at higher risk of the disease should be offered checks. It is due to write to the health secretary later this week, the Telegraph reported.Sunak, who is leading a cross-party alliance of 125 MPs, met Streeting on Monday evening to hand him an open letter urging the government to introduce tests so men at the highest risk, including Black men, men with a family history of prostate, breast or ovarian cancer, and those carrying the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes, are “no longer left behind”.The letter says: “Our current opportunistic PSA [prostate-specific antigen] testing system is unstructured, inefficient and unfair – a postcode lottery where some men succeed because they know to ask or can pay privately, while others are turned away despite repeated requests
John Stuart Brown obituary
In 1979, the British Medical Journal published an article by a Kent GP, John Stuart Brown, titled “Minor operations in general practice”.Brown, who has died aged 90, wrote that undertaking an average of four minor operations a week in his GP surgery had huge advantages compared to referring patients to hospital. It was faster, more convenient for patients and cost-effective, saving the area health authority more than £15,000 a year. He estimated the average cost of a procedure in his GP surgery was £5, compared to £78.24 in hospital
UK to extend sugar tax to cover bottled milkshakes and pre-packaged lattes
Peak pizza? Domino’s boss who launched shift towards chicken ousted
AI could replace 3m low-skilled jobs in the UK by 2035, research finds
‘It’s hell for us here’: Mumbai families suffer as datacentres keep the city hooked on coal
England warned ‘wickets fall in clumps’ with pink ball under lights at the Gabba
Undercooked England will not play for a year until Rugby League World Cup