Google developers significantly misstate carbon emissions of proposed UK datacentres
Developers working for Google have significantly misstated how much carbon two proposed AI datacentres will contribute to the UK’s total emissions in planning documents reviewed by the Guardian.The tech company wants to build two huge datacentres – one 52-hectare (130 acre) project in Thurrock and another at an airfield in North Weald, both in Essex.To do so, developers are required to submit planning documents calculating how much carbon these projects will emit as a proportion of the UK’s total carbon footprint.In both cases, they appear to have compared one year of the proposed datacentre’s emissions with the UK’s entire five-year carbon budget, understating the significance of their emissions by a factor of five, according to experts at the tech justice nonprofit Foxglove.Greystoke, a company planning to build another datacentre in north Lincolnshire, one of the largest in the UK, also appears to have misstated the emissions of its project in the same way.
Taken together, the three developments will account for more than 1% of the UK’s carbon budget in 2033.This is the equivalent to the emissions of a mid-sized city such as Bristol.“Google has serious questions to answer about its dubious datacentre pollution figures,” said Tim Squirrell, the head of strategy for Foxglove, which discovered the errors.“By comparing one year of datacentre emissions with five years of UK emissions, they’re making the environmental impact look five times smaller than it really is.”He added: “Unless they can explain themselves, it looks like they are seriously misleading the council and the public over the climate pollution their facility will cause.
”These apparent misstatements are another example of a pile-up of faulty calculations surrounding AI development and its environmental footprint in the UK.Last month, the Guardian reported on a large gap between the government’s plan to decarbonise the economy and its roadmap for AI computing.The two government departments behind these plans appeared to differ on their estimates for how much UK energy datacentres will use – by a factor of 10.Google’s Thurrock datacentre, to be built on “grey belt” land, has claimed its emissions will amount to 0.033% of the UK’s budgeted carbon footprint between 2028 and 2032.
In fact, its emissions during that period will be 0.165% of the total.The North Weald datacentre, to be built on an airfield near Epping Forest, has said it will emit 0.043% of the UK’s total carbon budget from 2033 to 2037, but it will actually emit 0.215% of the total.
Steven Heather, a local councillor, said this datacentre had been given outline planning permission only and the planning department would research what Google was proposing.“If there is a gross error, they’ll obviously pick up on it.When it goes to the submissions stage, the developers will have to come back with the proper figure.”Greystoke’s datacentre in north Lincolnshire, Elsham Tech Park, has stated in planning documents that its emissions will be 0.1043% of the UK’s carbon budget in 2033, when in fact they will be 0.
5215%.Google and Greystoke have publicly argued that their developments will have a tolerable, in some cases insignificant, impact on the UK’s climate roadmap.Elsham Tech Park’s developers have said it will improve biodiversity on its campus by having bird and bat boxes, and wildflower grassland.All three developments are classed as having a “minor adverse” impact on the UK’s overall climate goals.However, the Thurrock datacentre will produce more emissions than an international airport, and Elsham Tech Park’s peak emissions will reach 1m tonnes of CO2 equivalent in 2033-34 – just short of the 1.
2m tonnes of carbon emissions of all the UK’s domestic flights.Google representatives did not respond to a request for comment.In a comment to the Guardian, Greystoke appeared to acknowledge the discrepancy, saying: “We expect to submit revised figures to the local planning authority as part of the planning process.”Elsham Tech Park said its development would “see £10bn of private investment, generating thousands of well-paid operational and construction jobs in the region, and supporting local supply chains”.
Lacunar strokes caused by widening of arteries in brain, study suggests
The cause of a type of stroke that affects about 35,000 people across the UK each year has been uncovered by researchers and may explain why some medications are ineffective as treatment.Lacunar strokes, which account for a quarter of all strokes in the UK, had been linked to the blockage of arteries in the brain by fatty deposits.However, a study published on Wednesday suggests they are not caused by blocked arteries but by the enlargement and widening of arteries in the brain.This would help to explain why aspirin and other blood thinners, commonly used to prevent ischaemic strokes, are not as effective in preventing lacunar stroke.The research by academics at the University of Edinburgh and the UK Dementia Research Institute analysed 229 patients who had experienced either a lacunar or mild non-lacunar stroke
Attempts to stop prison drone drug deliveries hampered by crumbling Victorian walls
Weak and crumbling walls in Victorian prisons are hampering attempts to halt drones from delivering drugs and weapons to inmates.Plans to install tougher netting and window grilles to stop drones from entering have been hampered because the walls have been unable to take the extra weight, prison governors said.Recent attempts to fix anti-drone netting at HMP Pentonville, the Victorian prison in north London, were stalled after they found that the bricks were too soft, sources have said.Charlie Taylor, the chief inspector of prisons for England and Wales, said last month that the Prison Service had “ceded the airspace above many of our prisons to serious organised crime”, resulting in a “national security threat”.The number of incidents at prisons involving drones has risen by more than 1,000% over four years, with gang members able to fly packages carried by drones direct to cell windows
MPs v the manosphere: ministers battle misogyny as they take a different message to men and boys across Australia
“Gender equality isn’t women versus men or a zero-sum game,” Ged Kearney says.“It delivers better outcomes for everyone. It’s important that, as we engage with men and boys, we make that really clear.”But as the assistant minister for the prevention of family violence sets off on a national listening tour with the special envoy for men’s health, Dan Repacholi, they are up against a pervasive and very different conception of how men and women relate, fostered by the loud voices of the manosphere and men’s rights activists.For decades, those activists have called for Australia to have a minister for men
Black people in England twice as likely to suffer stroke as white counterparts
People from black backgrounds in England are twice as likely to experience strokes as their white counterparts, while also being less likely to receive timely care, according to the largest study of its kind.The study, conducted by researchers at King’s College London and presented at the European Stroke Organisation conference, analysed 30 years of stroke incidents from the South London Stroke Register, one of the longest-running population-based stroke registers in the world.The register is unique due to the fact that unlike clinical trials, it recruits every single person who has had a stroke in a defined area.Within a population of 333,000 people, according to the analysis, 7,726 strokes occurred. And while stroke incidence fell by 34% between 1995-99 and 2010-14, the rate rose again by 13% between 2020 and 2024
Prosecutors to ‘fast-track’ hate crime cases in England and Wales after spate of attacks
Prosecutors in England and Wales have been told to “fast-track” hate crime prosecutions after a spate of antisemitic attacks that the prime minister on Tuesday called a “crisis for all of us”.Stephen Parkinson, the director of public prosecutions, issued guidance to his staff on Tuesday telling them to bring forward prosecutions against any sort of hate crime as quickly as they could, rather than waiting until they had gathered all possible evidence.Keir Starmer urged groups including universities, arts groups and charities to do more to tackle antisemitism during a summit in Downing Street.As well as imposing new reporting requirements on universities and the Arts Council, the prime minister threatened “consequences” against Iran if it was found to have been behind last week’s stabbing in Golders Green, north London.Parkinson said in a statement on Tuesday: “The acts of extreme violence and criminal damage that we have seen against the Jewish community in recent months have been deplorable
Rage workouts: the best way to exercise – or just infuriating?
Angry gym classes are booming, with activities including pummelling tyres with a sledgehammer. But they might not be as cathartic as they at first appearName: Rage workouts.Age: Would this be a good time to invoke Aristotle’s beliefs on catharsis?Appearance: Pumped-up, red-faced, veiny, on the brink of a disciplinary hearing.Is this about being angry at the gym? Because, this morning there was a guy just sitting, using his phone, on the machine I needed … You’re close, but you’re not quite right. This isn’t about getting angry while you’re exercising, it’s about getting angry in order to exercise
Great Western Railway to be nationalised in December
US added 115,000 jobs in April in surprise gain amid Iran war uncertainty
Iran war costs Toyota £3bn as prices of materials soar and sales fall
British Airways fares to rise in attempt to offset £1.7bn fuel cost hit
GameStop CEO opens eBay storefront to pay for potential eBay acquisition
Gas-fired power still looks a safe bet for Centrica in the renewables era