Musk faces third day of questioning in contentious trial over OpenAI’s founding

A picture


Elon Musk’s court case against Sam Altman continues on Thursday, after a day of contentious exchanges during OpenAI’s cross-examination of the Tesla CEO.Musk will face another round of questioning before his lawyer calls more witnesses, including OpenAI’s president, Greg Brockman.Witness testimony and evidence has revealed formerly private emails, text messages and diary entries surrounding the formation of OpenAI, giving a behind-the-scenes look at how the tech behemoth was created.Many of the tech industry’s most powerful players are named as witnesses and will give their account on the origins of Musk and Altman’s bitter feud.Altman is set to testify later in the trial, which will last three weeks.

Musk, who co-founded OpenAI in 2015, is arguing that Altman, Brockman and OpenAI broke a foundational agreement when they shifted the company from a non-profit intent on bettering humanity into a for-profit structure.Musk claims that Altman and Brockman unjustly enriched themselves and should be removed from the company.He is also seeking the undoing of the for-profit conversion and $134bn in damages to be redirected to OpenAI’s non-profit arm.OpenAI rejects Musk’s allegations and is attempting to show that Musk was always aware of plans for creating a for-profit entity.The AI firm’s attorneys have stated Musk is “motivated by jealousy” of OpenAI’s success after he left the company in 2018 after a failed attempt to take control.

OpenAI has emphasized that it is still overseen by a non-profit,OpenAI’s lead attorney, William Savitt, grilled Musk again on Wednesday as the Tesla CEO bristled at his questions,As with the previous round of cross-examination, Savitt engaged in rapid-fire questioning about what Musk knew about OpenAI’s structure and forming a for-profit branch,In response to many of the questions, Musk took a defensive tone and repeated his go-to phrase in the trial that “you can’t just steal a charity”,At one point, Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers moved to strike Musk’s charity statement from the record, saying: “That portion is stricken, we’ve heard it many times.

”Savitt asked Musk several questions about the AI company he founded in 2023, xAI, and why he didn’t set it up as a non-profit.Musk, visibly rattled after Savitt kept cutting him off if he responded at length, loudly said in a stern voice, “I started OpenAI as a non-profit.” He went on to explain that OpenAI converted into a for-profit only in the last few years.“That is the entire basis for this whole lawsuit,” Musk said.“Why would I start another non-profit when I already started a non-profit?”The trial, which began on Monday with jury selection at a federal courthouse in Oakland, California, has already produced dramatic moments and bold accusations.

Musk and Savitt spent most of Wednesday in a heated back-and-forth, with the world’s richest person becoming noticeably frustrated and saying that Savitt’s questions “are designed to trick me”.After court wrapped on Wednesday and the lawyers conferenced with the judge, Savitt groused about Musk being a difficult witness since he repeatedly refused to answer questions in a yes-and-no manner.Gonzalez Rogers essentially told him to deal with it, saying that comes with litigation.Silicon Valley is intently watching the trial for both its blockbuster testimony and the potential effects it will have on the AI industry.OpenAI is intending to go public later this year at around a $1tn valuation, but if Musk succeeds in this case, it could greatly complicate that effort – an outcome that would also benefit Musk’s own xAI artificial intelligence firm.

The nine-person jury will decide whether OpenAI is liable, but Judge Gonzalez Rogers will determine what, if any, remedies are necessary in the case,
cultureSee all
A picture

Letter: Desmond Morris obituary

I often saw Desmond Morris and his wife, Ramona, when attending Oxford United FC home games at the Manor Ground, before its move to the present Kassam Stadium in 2001. He was a season ticket holder and at different times a director, vice-chairman and vice-president of the club. Some of these roles were taken up when Robert Maxwell owned the club, but they eventually fell out.However, Morris is probably best remembered for the creation of the inspirational club logo of an ox head, based on a powerful Minoan bull. His undoubted artistic talents have been deployed by the club since 1978 and the logo continues to be used on the shirts worn by players and coaching staff, and related merchandise

A picture

Boom! A melodrama fit for Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton’s doomed love affair

“My very first memory is of pain.” More than a touch dramatic, the words could easily be lifted from the script of Boom! Instead, they are a real-life confession by its leading lady, Elizabeth Taylor.When it comes to pain, Taylor is the poster child-star. In her long life, the actor underwent more than 30 surgeries and was supposedly hospitalised on more than 100 occasions. After a bout of pneumonia almost took her out in 1961, it was the pain of nearly losing her that led to her best actress sympathy win at the Oscars

A picture

Jon Stewart on White House correspondents’ dinner: ‘We can’t even pull off a dinner that shouldn’t have existed in the first place’

Late-night hosts responded to the White House correspondents’ dinner shooting and Donald and Melania Trump’s attempts to blame political violence on Jimmy Kimmel’s jokes.Jon Stewart resumed his Monday night chair at the Daily Show less than two days after the shocking attack at the White House correspondents’ dinner on Saturday night, which resulted in the arrest of one man and, thankfully, no injuries. “It was supposed to be an evening of fun and merriment until, like most things in America, it was interrupted by gunfire,” Stewart said. “This is why we can’t have nice things. And to be perfectly frank, it’s not even a nice thing

A picture

Antiquities dealer who exposed thefts at British Museum dies aged 61

The academic turned antiquities dealer who exposed the theft of hundreds of artefacts from the British Museum has died aged 61.Dr Ittai Gradel, from Denmark, alerted the British Museum and the police after he was able to buy dozens of museum artefacts on eBay over the course of several years.Gradel died of renal cancer days after receiving a rarely presented medal from the museum in recognition of what its director called his “very significant contribution”, according to the BBC.A police investigation is still ongoing, more than three years after the museum reported the thefts to Scotland Yard after pressure from Gradel. Before his death in a Danish hospice, Gradel – who would have been a key witness in any trial – told the BBC it was “a bit annoying” he wouldn’t live to see the resolution of the case

A picture

‘Protected for another century’: experts lift 15-tonne foremast from HMS Victory

There is only one correct way to extricate a 15-tonne wrought iron mast from one of the world’s most famous and beloved warships – very slowly, and with extreme care.Which is precisely how a 30-strong team led by shipwrights and riggers set about their task on Monday night into Tuesday morning when they lifted the foremast from HMS Victory as part of a £42m conservation project.A 750-tonne crane removed the 23-metre mast from the ship in an operation requiring power to lift the wrought iron structure but also a great deal of delicacy to make sure the fabric of the vessel was not harmed.In the coming days, as long as the wind does not get up, two more masts – the mizzen and bowsprit – will also be craned off Nelson’s 18th-century flagship at the Battle of Trafalgar and laid on a Portsmouth dockside ready for conservation work to begin.At daybreak on Tuesday, Patrizia Pierazzo, the deputy project director, hailed it as a “great start”

A picture

Having Spent Life Seeking by Kae Tempest review – painfully earnest tale of trauma and transition

Kae Tempest’s new novel is dedicated to “you”, the reader. It also comes with a plea: “Be gentle though.” But to whom or what should we be gentle? The book or the writer? Having Spent Life Seeking is Tempest’s second novel, arriving a decade after his first and following a period of considerable personal change, including gender transition. Perhaps inevitably, it is a book full of struggle and soul-searching. It is also painfully earnest: an enervating read with an exhausting intensity that neither relents nor resolves