Labour and Lib Dem MPs demand ‘shameful’ Palantir NHS contract be scrapped
MPs have queued up to demand the government scraps its £330m NHS contract with the spy-tech company Palantir, calling it “dreadful” and “shameful” in a debate on Thursday, after which the government said it was “no fan” of the US company’s politics,Labour and Liberal Democrat MPs led the calls for Palantir, which also works for Donald Trump’s ICE immigration crackdown and the Israeli military, to be removed as a supplier to the NHS federated data platform (FDP), with one Labour backbencher, Samantha Niblett, questioning whether it could be “trusted as a custodian of the intimate health records of tens of millions of British citizens”,The Lib Dem MP Luke Taylor, who called the deal “shameful”, said: “Palantir and Peter Thiel must have their hands ripped off of our NHS before it is too late,”Thiel, a Trump-supporting tech billionaire, founded the company and has previously said that democracy and freedom are incompatible,In response to the MPs who spoke in a Westminster Hall debate, the government confirmed it would consider whether to continue with the deal when a break clause is due in spring 2027, although £210m of the £330m has already been spent.
In the face of rising pressure from doctors, MPs and the public, Dr Zubir Ahmed, a junior health minister, said: “If at that point in the break clause we evaluate and we find that there are other providers that can do the job better, of course then that needs to be looked at.”However, he said that the FDP was exceeding its performance targets, adding: “We are no fan of [Palantir’s] politics.However, the FDP and the principles that underpin it are critical to the future of the NHS.”The debate was led by the Liberal Democrat MP Martin Wrigley, who described the contract as “dreadful”.“The main issue is trust,” he said.
“The future of the NHS depends on intelligent use of data with patients’ trust.Gaining the public’s trust for such research with AI involved is going to be hard enough anyway without a company like Palantir controlling it all.”The fresh wave of calls for the contract to be axed comes as the health service and Palantir try to fight back and sell the benefits of their contract.NHS England told the Guardian it was focused on tackling “misinformation” while Palantir has been mounting a PR pushback advised by Boris Johnson’s political strategist, Isaac Levido.The FDP is proving to be one of the most controversial contracts in the UK public sector, and new internal documents obtained by the Guardian under the Freedom of Information Act have revealed health bosses’ internal fears over “negative sentiment” about the system.
Emails between officials in January discussed how they needed to “get on the front foot and put out some proactive communications on FDP”.They show NHS England considered launching a podcast series about the FDP.It was to be hosted by an NHS official who is “pro-FDP” with guests drawn almost entirely from the NHS hierarchy, the plans showed.A separate idea to use LinkedIn to communicate the system’s merits was dismissed, as public comments “could create a more confused narrative, producing negative sentiment”.The government said on Thursday that 137 NHS trusts had signed up to use the Palantir-powered system.
But there are concerns that use is “shallow”.One NHS official told the Guardian that IT experts’ concerns “are not being heard because delivery of the Palantir FDP project has become an ideological one”.“We’re being forced towards using it reluctantly in many cases,” they said.“The tools are much more difficult to use.They are not industry standard.
”And in another sign of difficulties, the Guardian has learned that training for staff to use the FDP, expected to start in February under a deal with Euan Blair’s tech-focused training company, Multiverse, has yet to begin.Palantir has countered that its software has helped deliver 110,000 additional operations and reductions in discharge delays.However, the US company’s reputation appears to be a problem.The Guardian previously revealed a briefing note to the health secretary, Wes Streeting, that warned Palantir’s public profile was “likely to make it harder to go further with the FDP”.Palantir is using social media and broadcast and newspaper interviews to hit back against critics.
The killings of US citizens by ICE agents and the destruction of much of Gaza by the Israel Defense Forces has only increased the risk it could lose the most valuable of its more than £500m in contracts with the UK public sector,It is being advised by Fleetwood Strategy, a lobbying consultancy founded by Levido, who helped the Conservatives win the 2019 general election,In recent weeks Louis Mosley, the UK head of Palantir, has attacked critics who “have chosen ideology over patient safety and patient outcomes”, placed a story with the Sun about a £60,000-a-year internship for school leavers and sponsored a political newsletter widely read in Westminster,Attacks on Palantir have become increasingly shrill,The leader of the Green party, Zack Polanski, said no one should be judged by his grandparents, but added: “This is a man who is the grandson of Oswald Mosley and still insists on wearing a black shirt every single time he is on TV.
” Mosley has taken to hitting back on X.A typical post read: “While the noise continues, the software works.”But MPs like the chair of the commons science and technology committee, Dame Chi Onwurah, have denied that critics are hawking fringe or ideological concerns, citing real anxieties about vendor lock-in, value for money and data security.An NHS England spokesperson said: “NHS England is focused on working with teams across the NHS to support the rollout of the federated data platform, tackle misinformation and reassure patients that – in addition to their data remaining fully protected at all times – the platform is helping join up care, speed up diagnosis and reduce waiting times.There is no intention to launch a podcast.
”A spokesperson for Palantir said that the software used to process data was “entirely under the control – legally and contractually – of the NHS”.“The programme is also hitting its milestones – with a green delivery rating – something which fewer than 15% of major government programmes have achieved.It is forecast to deliver a £5 return for every pound spent.”
Europe has only six weeks’ supply of jet fuel left owing to Iran war, says energy chief
Europe has only six weeks of jet fuel left before shortages will hit because of the Iran war, according to the head of a global energy watchdog.Fatih Birol, the executive director of the International Energy Agency, said there would be flight cancellations “soon” if oil supplies from the Middle East were not restored within the coming weeks.“I can tell you soon we will hear the news that some of the flights from city A to city B might be cancelled as a result of lack of jet fuel,” he told the Associated Press.KLM, part of the Air France-KLM group, said on Thursday it would cut 160 flights in the coming month because of high kerosene jet fuel prices. Although less than 1% of its schedule, the cancellations underline the financial pressures on the airline industry
Metro Bank boss handed record £2.6m a year after slashing 1,000 jobs
Metro Bank’s chief executive has been handed a £2.6m pay packet – the largest in its history – a year after slashing 1,000 jobs in response to the lender’s near collapse.The figure is more than double the £1.2m Dan Frumkin was paid in 2024. Metro pushed through the pay bump and complex bonus scheme for the former RBS and Northern Rock banker at a shareholder meeting last year
Tesco warns profits could fall amid Iran war uncertainty
Tesco has warned that profits could fall back in the year ahead, citing increased uncertainty caused by the conflict in the Middle East.Ken Murphy, its chief executive, said that despite concerns about the impact of the closure of the strait of Hormuz on oil, gas and linked chemicals, the UK’s largest supermarket chain was “in good shape” on stocks of fuel for its petrol stations and distribution network.He said Tesco was not currently seeing problems with the supply of food or groceries, or “meaningful” inflation except at the pump on its forecourts.Murphy said he did not recognise predictions from the UK’s Food and Drink Federation that food inflation could hit 9% amid fears of shortages. “None of our growers, suppliers or manufacturers have flagged any supply issues,” he said
UK could face gaps on supermarket shelves by summer if Iran war continues
The UK could face some gaps on supermarket shelves this summer if disruption caused by the Iran war continues, with shortages of carbon dioxide potentially hitting supplies of chicken, pork and fizzy drinks.Government ministers are drawing up contingency plans for a “reasonable worst-case scenario” if the key shipping lane of the strait of Hormuz does not reopen, disrupting supplies of the CO2 required by the food industry.Officials from departments including No 10, the Treasury and the Ministry of Defence have run a planning operation named Exercise Turnstone to rehearse various scenarios of how British industry could be affected by a long closure of the strait.The planning exercise run by the government’s Cobra emergency committee, details of which were first reported by the Times, was based on multiple disruptive events happening at once, including the strait still being closed in June, a lack of a permanent peace deal between the US and Iran, and a mechanical failure at one of the UK’s key CO2 plants.The business secretary said on Thursday that the public should be “reassured” by the fact ministers were making contingency plans for possible repercussions from the war, adding that supplies of CO2 were “not a concern” for the UK economy
EasyJet warns of impact on profits as Iran war hits bookings and fuel prices
The budget airline easyJet has warned the impact of the Iran war on bookings and oil prices will hit its profits, having driven up fuel costs by £25m in the last month alone.It said it expected to report an increased pre-tax loss of £540-£560m for the six months to March, up from £394m in the first half of 2024-25. The carrier typically makes its money in the second half of the year which includes the peak summer period.The airline said it remained confident in its fuel supply. While it has hedged 70% of its needs for the rest of the financial year to September, it said that each $100 (£74) movement in the spot price jet of fuel per metric tonne was adding £40m in costs for its unhedged supply – and currently the price is about $800 higher than before the conflict started
UK economy showed surprise 0.5% growth before Iran war
UK GDP expanded by a stronger than expected 0.5% in February, official figures show, suggesting the economy was gaining momentum before the onset of war in the Middle East dashed hopes of recovery.The jump, reported by the Office for National Statistics (ONS), was significantly bigger than the 0.1% forecast by economists. January’s flatlining figure was also revised up, to 0
Senate Democrats move to stall Trump’s ‘absurd’ bid to install new Fed chair
Next chief Simon Wolfson paid record £7.4m – and could get far more this year
Labour and Lib Dem MPs demand ‘shameful’ Palantir NHS contract be scrapped
Man used AI to make false statements to shut down London nightclub, police say
Fans and players unite behind Hull’s John Cartwright as St Helens go top
Tiger Woods mentioned drones over home and car, ‘president’ in remarks after crash, filing shows