Rugby brain injury case suffers blow after judge rejects court appeal
Two appeals launched by the legal firm representing former players in rugby league and rugby union have both been denied in a significant blow to the ongoing legal action about brain damage caused by the sport.It means that after five years of legal arguments a large number of the claimants in both codes face the risk of having their cases struck out before they come to trial.The appeal judge, Mr Justice Dexter Dias, ruled that the judge presiding over the management of the case, Senior Master Jeremy Cook, had been right to find that the claimants firm, Rylands Garth, had failed to fulfil its obligations to disclose necessary medical material to the defendants, World Rugby, the Wales Rugby Union, and the Rugby Football Union in one case, and the Rugby Football League in the other.The case in rugby league in particular has been hugely undermined by this latest judgement.Altogether 180 of the 321 claimants in rugby league now face having their claims struck off.
The number in rugby union is smaller, at around 20% of the total number of the 773 former players involved, but still raises questions about Rylands Garth’s handling of the case,Rylands Garth had been ordered to comply with their disclosure obligations by late October 2025, or using what is known as an unless order,That date passed without their having done it, and Rylands Garth launched an appeal,They argued that Senior Master Cook had “erred in law and misdirected himself” and that the unless orders had been “disproportionate and oppressive, irrational and perverse,” Justice Dias rejected the appeals on all grounds.
Dias criticised Rylands Garth solicitor Richard Boardman, ruling that given “the repeated extensions, the strong indications by the Judge from early in proceedings of the need for active progression of the litigation, the gross misunderstandings of Mr Boardman about his disclosure duties and the associated puzzling nature of these fundamental misconceptions with his unconvincing explanations, it was entirely reasonable in my judgment for the Judge to lack confidence in the adequacy or legal accuracy of the approach to disclosure.”Rylands Garth had provided medical material which was in their possession and that they had relied upon, but had failed to provide a quantity of other medical information that had been requested by the defendants, including GP records and medical histories.Rylands Garth argued that the size of the task made this an impossible job.Dias pointed out that “if solicitors take on substantial litigation such as this, they are dutybound professionally, both to their lay clients and to the court in their capacity of officers of it, to ensure they have made appropriate and effective logistical and administrative arrangements to comply with the lawful orders of the court.”A spokesperson for Rylands Garth said: “We are grateful to the judge for providing greater clarity regarding the required level of disclosure of claimants’ medical records.
We will continue to comply with the court’s orders as we work to fast-track the case and deliver justice for the former players we represent,To date, we have already disclosed hundreds of thousands of pages of documents in support of the case against World Rugby, the RFU and WRU, as well as the rugby league defendants,Many of these documents were disclosed several years ago,The defendants have never formally responded to the claims and continue to attempt to hold up the case’s progress through the court,“The former players we represent and their families continue to suffer every day with the devastating impact of the negligence of sports authorities,” the spokesperson continued.
“We reaffirm our commitment to accountability, meaningful change, and safeguarding the next generation of players,”The next case hearings are scheduled for March, but it is likely the defendants will now move to have all the affected cases struck off, which may cause more delays to the proceedings,
Starmer has no coherent social mobility plan, says top government adviser
Keir Starmer has no coherent strategy to tackle entrenched inequalities harming the life chances of millions of people, the government’s social mobility commissioner has said.A report warned last week that young adults in Britain’s former industrial heartlands were being left behind as a result of failed or abandoned promises by successive governments.The Social Mobility Commission (SMC), a government advisory body, said big cities such as Manchester, Edinburgh and Bristol were starting to thrive but that opportunities were “overconcentrated”.In a Guardian interview, the commission’s chair, Alun Francis, urged Starmer to outline a bold vision to tackle “the defining social mobility challenge of our generation”.He said: “We have a government that talks quite a lot about social mobility, but mainly about individuals – often about [the] social mobility of themselves or their colleagues … But what we don’t have is a coherent approach to social mobility as a useful concept that you can build a strategy around
Christmas burnout: why stressed parents find it ‘harder to be emotionally honest with children’
Advent calendars, check. Tree and decorations, check. Teachers’ presents, nativity costumes and a whole new ticketing system for the PTA’s Santa’s grotto, check. But the Christmas cards remain unwritten, the to-do list keeps growing, and that Labubu doll your child desperately wants appears to have vanished from the face of the earth.If you’re feeling frayed in the final days before Christmas, you’re not alone
Labour admits 60% of parents wrongly targeted in HMRC child benefit fraud crackdown
More than 60% of parents who had their child benefit stopped by HMRC using incorrect Home Office travel data were not fraudulently claiming the support from abroad, it has emerged.The scale of the government’s anti-fraud fiasco is four times higher than previously admitted, with 15,000 of the 23,500 parents targeted by HMRC now identified as legitimate beneficiaries living in the UK.It means 63% of parents targeted in the anti-fraud debacle first reported by the Detail and the Guardian were legitimate claimants.The government’s admission was revealed in a written answer to a parliamentary question tabled by the Conservative MP for Fylde, Andrew Snowden.Dan Tomlinson, the exchequer secretary to the Treasury, told Snowden in his written answer that figures revealed that, as of 30 November, 14,994 of the 23,794 cases where benefit had been suspended had since “been confirmed to be eligible to child benefit”
‘We’ve got more in common than what divides us’: a Muslim-Jewish kitchen in Nottingham counters hate and hunger
As antisemitism and Islamophobia rise, a community centre brings people together over shared meals, offering an antidote to food poverty, social isolation and divisionDonate to the Guardian Charity Appeal 2025 hereCommunities are our defence against hatred. Now, more than ever, we must invest in hopeIt’s 2.30pm on a Wednesday afternoon and the Himmah Hub, a community centre in Nottingham, is abuzz with activity. Crates of leftover supermarket food are being carried inside, trestle tables assembled, and volunteers are arriving to prepare meals that will be served in a few hours’ time to anyone who needs one – a queue has already begun to form outside.This is the Salaam Shalom kitchen, known as SaSh, a joint Muslim-Jewish project set up in 2015, and based on one of the core tenets of both faith groups: bringing people together through food
NHS to trial potentially life-saving treatment for deadly liver disease
The NHS is to trial a potentially life-saving new treatment for a deadly liver disease that causes the body’s vital organs to fail.Thirteen major hospitals will use a device that cleans patients’ blood that has become corrupted by toxins as a result of them developing acute-on-chronic liver failure (ACLF).ACLF is a severe and hard-to-treat form of liver disease linked to obesity, alcohol and hepatitis, in which patients suddenly deteriorate and have to be admitted to intensive care. Three out of four people affected are only diagnosed when it has already become life-threatening.Seven out of 10 people with the disease die within 28 days and only a handful of those affected are eligible for a liver transplant, which is the only existing way to reverse ACLF
Pressure grows on DWP over ‘misleading’ response to carer’s allowance scandal
Senior officials who oversaw a flawed benefits system that plunged hundreds of thousands of carers into debt are under mounting pressure over their “misleading” response to the scandal.Prof Liz Sayce, the chair of a scathing review into the government’s treatment of unpaid carers, last week called for an overhaul of management and culture at the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP).Days after the publication of the review, the DWP’s top civil servant in charge of carers’ allowance, Neil Couling, said carers themselves were at fault for the decade-long failures.His comments, revealed by the Guardian, have prompted a key adviser to the Sayce review and a leading carer’s charity to declare a lack of confidence in the department’s pledge to fix the issues.Prof Sue Yeandle, the UK’s leading expert on unpaid carers, said ministers and senior officials had issued “really misleading” claims that the failures affected only a small number of people
The Guide #222: From Celebrity Traitors to The Brutalist via Bad Bunny – our roundup of the culture that mattered in 2025
From Avatar to Amadeus: your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead
Jimmy Kimmel on a tumultuous year: ‘Don’t know what the American way even is any more’
Jimmy Kimmel on Trump’s speech: ‘Surprise primetime episode of The Worst Wing’
Stephen Colbert on Susie Wiles’s candid interviews: ‘She dished, bish’
The 50 best albums of 2025: No 3 – Blood Orange: Essex Honey