Keir Starmer vows to lead Labour into next general election after bruising week
Keir Starmer has said he will lead Labour into the next general election, as his Downing Street allies denied claims of any wrongdoing over the appointment and vetting of Peter Mandelson as US ambassador.It has been a bruising week for the prime minister after the Guardian revealed that he appointed the former Labour grandee despite vetting officials recommending that he be denied security clearance.His handling of the row was called into question, including his swift decision to sack the Foreign Office chief Olly Robbins.Darren Jones, the chief secretary to the prime minister, told Sky News’s Trevor Phillips on Sunday show: “No wrongdoing by the prime minister has been proven in relation to Lord Mandelson’s appointment,” adding: “The whole situation is regrettable.”Jones said: “Of course these particular questions of whether the prime minister had lied or misled the house, or had done any wrongdoing here, that’s all been shown not to be the case.
”On Saturday night, Starmer attempted to brush off mounting unrest inside his party and shut down questions about the future of his leadership in an interview with the Sunday Times.Asked directly if his prime ministership was over, Starmer told the newspaper: “No”.Pushed on whether he could continue, he replied: “Of course.We didn’t wait 14 years to get elected, we didn’t change the Labour party, we didn’t do all that it entailed to win the election and the mandate for change, not to deliver on it.”Asked if he would lead Labour into the next election, Starmer said: “Yes”.
Allies of the prime minister have already planned his response to what are expected to be a difficult set of Scottish, Welsh and local English elections on 7 May for Labour, and which could once again throw his leadership into peril,After the results roll in, they expect the prime minister’s initial reaction to be one of humility,“We know that voters are sending us a message: we need to acknowledge that we’ve heard it,” one source said,“Think of Obama’s ‘shellacking’ moment after the US midterms [in 2010] when the Dems took a heavy beating,Keir needs a similarly realistic and humble response.
”Downing Street also wants to “inject some hope” into the government’s narrative, one senior figure said, pointing to the king’s speech the following week as an opportunity to do so.But they added: “We know that won’t be easy.We haven’t done a good enough job telling voters about all the big things we’ve done – and we’re too good at creating our own bad headlines.It’s not just down to Keir though, we all need to do better.”The prime minister hopes to bolster the political side of his No 10 operation, after the departures in recent months of his former chief of staff Morgan McSweeney and director of strategy Paul Ovenden, with the recruitment of a heavyweight political strategist.
“We know that people won’t be jumping to join us this side of the May elections, but we hope that once things settle down, it might be a more attractive option,” one insider said.The Conservatives have sought to corner the prime minister over the row, highlighting inconsistencies between Starmer’s previous claim that “no pressure whatsoever” was applied to Robbins, and the former senior civil servant’s describing “an atmosphere of pressure” and “constant chasing” from Downing Street while Mandelson’s vetting was taking place during an interview with the foreign affairs committee.Starmer rejected the claims, saying “no pressure existed whatsoever”.He added: “There’s pressure – ‘can we get this done quickly?’ – which is not an unusual pressure.That is the everyday pressure of government.
”Starmer also rejected suggestions he should have been more inquisitive and curious about Mandelson’s clearance.“When I’m told there’s security clearance, should I go back and quiz officials and say ‘are you telling me the truth?’” he said.The Conservatives are pushing for Starmer to face the Commons privileges committee over allegations that he misled parliament.The revelation that Starmer appointed Mandelson despite officials recommending he be denied security clearance came about because of a process started by Kemi Badenoch, the Conservative leader.Chris Philp, the shadow home secretary, told the BBC’s Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg show: “Now we need the privileges committee to investigate whether Keir Starmer misled parliament, which he appears to have done.
Frankly, Keir Starmer should resign because he appointed Mandelson in the first place, which is a terrible, terrible misjudgment – a man with links to Russia and China and Jeffrey Epstein.”However, the former Tory attorney general Dominic Grieve accused the party of “political games” by seeking a vote on launching a privileges committee investigation.Grieve said: “The appointment of Peter Mandelson is currently being properly scrutinised as part of the humble address process and the work and hearings being conducted by the foreign affairs committee.“Seeing that this appointment is being explored during these processes and all the evidence is not yet considered, it is impossible to see how starting a reference to the privileges committee is either useful or indeed ‘due process’.Ensuring that ministers do not mislead parliament is of great importance, but it should not just be turned into political games.
”Harriet Harman, who chaired the privileges committee investigation into Boris Johnson, said it would be a “complete duplication” of the work being done already by the foreign affairs committee.Questions over Mandelson’s vetting will continue this week, with Starmer’s former chief of staff McSweeney due to appear before the committee.
Mother ends life at Swiss clinic four years after son’s death
A grieving mother has ended her life at a clinic in Switzerland four years after the death of her only child.Wendy Duffy, 56, a physically healthy woman, died at the Pegasos clinic in Basel after struggling to cope with the death of her 23-year-old son, Marcus.The former care worker, from the West Midlands, had previously attempted to take her own life.The case comes as assisted dying will not become law in England and Wales after proposed legislation, branded “hopelessly flawed” by opponents, ran out of time.Ruedi Habegger, the founder of Pegasos, described Duffy’s death as a “sane suicide”
MPs vow to bring back assisted dying bill after ‘undemocratic’ Lords block
MPs and peers who led the assisted dying bill have promised to bring it back to parliament after it ran out of time in the House of Lords.Kim Leadbeater, the Labour MP who tabled the private member’s bill, said the plan would be to table an identical bill in the next parliamentary session, which would prevent peers blocking it again, as the Lords cannot stop the same bill twice.The terminally ill adults (end of life) bill, which completed its passage through the Commons in June last year, was blocked in the Lords after more than 1,200 amendments were tabled. The bill’s supporters said it was a denial of democracy. More than 800 of the amendments originated from seven peers
‘Not democratic’: opponents and backers of assisted dying bill remain divided
Amid the failure of an attempt to bring in new laws allowing assisted dying for terminally ill people with less than six months to live, campaigners on both sides of the debate vented their anger and frustration with the opposing side.Its supporters, including terminally ill people, blamed the failure of the terminally ill adults (end of life) bill, which passed in the House of Commons, on sabotage by a handful of unelected peers.But opponents, who include MPs, peers and disability activists, argued the proposed legislation failed because it was poorly drafted and did not address practical concerns about how assisted dying would work in practice.Sarah Wootton, chief executive of Dignity in Dying, said a handful of peers, whom she described as “implacable opponents of assisted dying”, had dominated debates in the Lords and rained down amendments in order to talk out the bill. “It’s absolutely shameless what a tiny group, less than 1% of the unelected, the upper house, has done,” she added
Baby died after NHS trust failed to warn mother of ‘unsafe’ home birth, coroner finds
A mother who lost her baby a week after an “unsafe” home birth that went against medical advice was failed by the NHS, an inquest has found.Poppy Hope Lomas was seven days old when she died at University College hospital in London on 26 October 2022 after complications during a home birth that, according to her mother, was encouraged by midwives at Barnet hospital.An inquest into Poppy’s death at Barnet coroner’s court concluded that she probably died from a lack of oxygen reaching her brain in the 30 minutes before she was born.The senior coroner Andrew Walker said the Royal Free London NHS foundation trust had agreed to support Poppy’s mother, Gemma Lomas, with an “unsafe home delivery that was against medical advice” and had failed to address “an accumulation of risk factors”.After the inquest concluded on Thursday, Lomas said outside the court: “Nothing will ever bring her back, but hearing the truth today acknowledged means everything to us
Breaking the cycle of drugs, debt and violence in prisons | Letters
Your leader on drugs in prisons (16 April) is right about the scale of the crisis, but wrong to suggest the chief inspector has only recently found his voice. Charlie Taylor has been consistent throughout: the prison system is failing by almost every meaningful measure.This is not just about money or overcrowding. It is about leadership, culture and accountability. A system under pressure can still be well led; too often ours is not
The Preston model is not likely to unravel just yet | Letters
“Were Reform to capture the council … the Preston model might quickly unravel,” writes Andy Beckett (The UK’s radical ‘Preston model’ faces an uncertain future with local elections looming, 20 April). He is worrying unnecessarily. Reform UK at present has just one seat on Preston city council. Councillors are elected by thirds, meaning 16 of the 48 seats – including the one held by Reform – are up for grabs in May. So in theory Reform could win 16 seats, which would hardly constitute capturing the council
Disco hit: Penne alla vodka, popular in New York 80s clubs, is now a menu staple
Benjamina Ebuehi’s recipe for orange, grapefruit and bay jelly | The sweet spot
‘As intense as perfume’: which eaux de vie are worth trying?
Folded, whipped or baked into something golden, ricotta is brilliant and adaptable
Rachel Roddy’s recipe for almond and lemon spiced treacle tart | A kitchen in Rome
I’m welcoming in spring with big Mediterranean flavours