MPs vow to bring back assisted dying bill after ‘undemocratic’ Lords block
MPs and peers who led the assisted dying bill have promised to bring it back to parliament after it ran out of time in the House of Lords.Kim Leadbeater, the Labour MP who tabled the private member’s bill, said the plan would be to table an identical bill in the next parliamentary session, which would prevent peers blocking it again, as the Lords cannot stop the same bill twice.The terminally ill adults (end of life) bill, which completed its passage through the Commons in June last year, was blocked in the Lords after more than 1,200 amendments were tabled.The bill’s supporters said it was a denial of democracy.More than 800 of the amendments originated from seven peers.
The bill proposed allowing adults in England and Wales with fewer than six months to live to apply for an assisted death subject to the approval of two doctors and an expert panel.With the current session of parliament ending next week, it has run out of time and has fallen.Opponents of the bill said it was flawed and campaign groups said so many Lords amendments were necessary to fix glaring weaknesses and contradictions.But speaking at a press conference shortly after the bill fell, Leadbeater said it had been sunk by disingenuous opponents who would never vote for any version of it.She added: “This isn’t what democracy looks like.
”Asked if the bill would return, Leadbeater said: “Absolutely.” She went on: “There is a clear public appetite for changing the law, and as legislators we have a duty to do something about that.“I think there is certainly an appetite to bring legislation back, even from certain people who voted against it, because they’ve been so upset by what happened in the House of Lords.“I’ve got a huge amount of respect for the House of Lords, and I’ve tried to maintain a civilised approach to this debate, but it’s really difficult to see that what’s happened is anything other than undemocratic.”She rejected the charge from opponents that the bill required more time to be put right, saying: “The idea that this has been rushed through is just utter nonsense, and it’s actually really disrespectful.
”Asked if she hoped the bill might be taken on by the government next time, Leadbeater said she accepted that as an issue of conscience which some cabinet ministers opposed, this could not happen, and it would rely on another MP taking it up after the ballot for preference over private members’ bills.The event also heard from people directly affected by the continued ban on assisted dying, including Rebecca Wilcox, whose mother, the broadcaster Esther Rantzen, has stage four lung cancer and backs a change to the law.“I know this is not the end for us; it’s absolutely the end for Mum, and I’m so annoyed that she hasn’t been able to see this go through,” she said, saying the bill had been “thwarted by such a petty few”.Charles Falconer, the Labour peer who led efforts to pass the bill in the Lords, said the sheer number of amendments tabled in the upper house were part of “an absolute travesty of our processes” manipulated by a small number of peers.He added: “In the end, it was not a problem of a lack of time.
The problem was pure obstructionism.”Tanni Grey-Thompson, a Paralympian peer who had spoken out against the bill, said it had failed because “there are too many gaps in it”, adding she felt there was “a lot of misunderstanding about what people might get” under a law change.Jane Campbell, a former commissioner at the Equality and Human Rights Commission, told fellow peers that disabled people had contacted her to say this “particular bill frightens them, and they want me to explain to your lordships why it is dangerous”.
From Mother Mary to Foo Fighters: your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead
An idiosyncratic thriller sees Anne Hathaway’s pop icon and Michaela Coel’s fashion designer embark on a psychosexual romance, while Dave Grohl and his boys are back with album number 12Mother MaryOut now Anne Hathaway and Michaela Coel play a pop star and a fashion designer embroiled in a psychosexual affair in this A24 drama-slash-thriller from the reliably idiosyncratic director David Lowery. Also starring FKA twigs, Sian Clifford and Hunter Schafer.Rose of NevadaOut now Starring George MacKay and possible future James Bond Callum Turner, this is a sci-fi drama from talented director Mark Jenkin about a boat lost at sea for three decades that mysteriously reappears. Some might suggest it’s advisable to stay away from this clearly uncanny boat, but that would make for a shorter movie.Exit 8Out now Based on the hit video game set in a Japanese metro station passageway, this high-concept horror has its protagonist, The Lost Man (Kazunari Ninomiya) trapped in a seemingly inescapable spatial loop, looking for the anomalies that will help him progress through the eerie environment
The play’s the thing – but everyone has their own favourite | Letters
Thank you for Michael Billington’s brilliant and fascinating ranking of Shakespeare’s plays, which will surely give rise to much debate (To see or not to see? Every single Shakespeare play – ranked!, 22 April).I’d like to make a case for promotion of The Tempest from its lowly 25th position. Admittedly my fondness for it started with doing it for A-level in 1968, but, having the good fortune to see both the all-female women’s prison version, starring Harriet Walter, and the RSC magical hi-tech production within a few months, I think its versatility deserves a higher ranking. I would swap it with The Winter’s Tale, which for me is just a bit too weird.Marian SainsburyEdinburgh I studied A Midsummer Night’s Dream at school in the 1960s
Jimmy Kimmel on Trump: ‘A delicate snowflake with the thinnest fat skin of any human being ever’
Late-night hosts imagined an alternative White House correspondents’ dinner roast and recapped Donald Trump’s latest erratic threats on Iran.On Thursday evening, Jimmy Kimmel looked ahead to this weekend’s annual gala hosted by the White House Correspondents’ Association (WHCA), which Donald Trump promised would be the “GREATEST, HOTTEST, and MOST SPECTACULAR DINNER, OF ANY KIND, EVER!”“The only thing hotter than this dinner are his diapers on the golf course,” the host quipped.This will be the first time that Trump attends the annual event for press and politicians as president, and the Daily Beast reported that his plan for the occasion is to lambast the media and leave, in an intentional “mic-drop moment” – “which I think would be disappointing”, said Kimmel.“This is the first time Trump is even going to the correspondents’ dinner as president,” he added, “but he doesn’t have to worry about being made fun of, because the event isn’t being hosted by a comedian this year.” Instead, the White House Correspondents’ Association hired mentalist Oz Pearlman to perform
‘It’s iconic worldwide – it’s special to skateboard there’: the South Bank skatepark turns 50
The undercroft at London’s Southbank Centre has been a haven for skateboarders since the 1970s. Now a new exhibition is celebrating its contribution to culture – and communityShane O’Brien first skated at London’s Southbank Centre in the summer of 1975, at the age of 10. But before he could call himself a “Southbanker”, a regular of the famous spot, he had to face a certain ritual. In 1983 he was launched into the Thames by senior skaters and could finally consider himself one of the crew. Now in his 60s, O’Brien calls the South Bank his second home
Seth Meyers on Kash Patel: ‘He has resting “run for your lives” face’
Late-night hosts dug into the allegations of FBI director Kash Patel’s excessive drinking, Donald Trump’s Iran war struggles and some questionable math by RFK Jr.On Wednesday evening, Seth Meyers relished more details from a shocking Atlantic report from this weekend detailing alleged excessive drinking and erratic behavior by the FBI director, Kash Patel. According to more than two dozen current and former FBI officials, Patel was known to drink to the point of obvious intoxication, and many people expected him to be fired for his unreachability and impulsivity.“Generally speaking, you don’t want to hear that the country’s top law enforcement official is known for having freak-outs, you know?” the Late Night host said. “When you’re the head of the FBI, you’re supposed to be calm and level-headed
Post your questions for Melanie C
Some former girl- and boyband stars spend a lifetime trying to escape the image that made them famous. Not Melanie C. Since the Spice Girls debuted 30 years ago this summer (What’s that sound? Oh, it’s just the unadulterated violence of mortality) she has never shied away from her past as Sporty Spice. Her ninth album, Sweat, leans firmly into it. Led by its gauntlet-throwing title track, these are work-bitch bangers for the gym, the dancefloor – inspired by her pre-Spice raving youth – and quite possibly the bedroom, sung by a triathlon fiend who forged a reputation as a world-renowned DJ
Disco hit: Penne alla vodka, popular in New York 80s clubs, is now a menu staple
Benjamina Ebuehi’s recipe for orange, grapefruit and bay jelly | The sweet spot
‘As intense as perfume’: which eaux de vie are worth trying?
Folded, whipped or baked into something golden, ricotta is brilliant and adaptable
Rachel Roddy’s recipe for almond and lemon spiced treacle tart | A kitchen in Rome
I’m welcoming in spring with big Mediterranean flavours