Starbucks shareholders push to oust board members over stalled union talks

A picture


Starbucks shareholders are pushing to remove two board members at the company who they argue have contributed to stalling the coffee chain’s long-fought-over union drive.The SOC Investment Group, Trillium Asset Management, Merseyside Pension Fund, the non-profit Shareholder Association for Research and Education (Share), and the New York state and New York City comptrollers wrote a letter to Starbucks shareholders to vote “no” on the re-election of board members Jørgen Vig Knudstorp and Beth Ford at Starbucks’s annual shareholders meeting on 25 March.More than 680 Starbucks stores have voted to form unions since the barista-led organizing campaign started in 2021.The union has reached 34 tentative agreements with Starbucks, but the company has not reached a single final agreement.Starbucks workers began an unfair labor practice strike at the coffee chain in November 2025, escalating up to the holidays in December 2025 with several thousand workers on strike.

The union has since tapered down the number of workers on strike and pushed campaigns for the public to pressure the company, with actions such as deleting the Starbucks app, until a first contract is reached.Brian Niccol, Starbucks’s CEO, pledged to “engage constructively and in good faith” when he took the top job in 2024.But critics argue the company has since gone back on those pledges.In their letter, the shareholders argue Knudstorp, former CEO of the Lego Group, and Ford, CEO of the Land O’Lakes agricultural cooperative, bear responsibility for Starbucks’s ongoing labor dispute.Knudstorp and Ford have “had labor relations, board structure, and investor engagement responsibilities over the relevant time period.

Shareholders should evaluate their performance against those responsibilities,” the shareholders wrote.Tejal Patel, executive director of the SOC Investment Group, a Starbucks shareholder affiliated with labor unions, said: “There was a shift in 2025 which raised renewed concerns for us.Labor disputes have continued.Bargaining has not produced a first contract, and risks associated with workforce relations have intensified rather than diminished.”“The sudden U-turn on labor relations oversight by Starbucks’ Board is inconsistent with the company’s turnaround strategy and commitments – and changes have not been explained to shareholders,” the shareholders wrote in the letter.

Two proxy firms have also warned Starbucks shareholders that the company may be neglecting financial and reputational risks from labor disputes.“There are ongoing controversies related to labor disputes and it is not clear that there is sufficient board oversight of the company’s management of labor relations,” stated Institutional Shareholder Services in their recommendations for cautionary support of the two board members.The proxy firm highlighted a recent $38.9m settlement Starbucks agreed to pay over New York City fair workweek laws, the largest in the city’s history.A leading proxy adviser, Glass Lewis, recommended voting no against the board members, citing, among its reasons, the dissolution of a Starbucks board committee to oversee labor relations.

That committee was formed in response to shareholder concerns in 2023 over the company’s handling of union campaigns,“You do not simply simplify oversight of a risk that’s getting worse,You should be strengthening it,” said Kyle Seeley, deputy director of corporate governance at the New York state common retirement fund during the webinar on the vote no campaign,Daisy Pitkin, director of Starbucks Workers United, said no proposals have been made by Starbucks since April 2025 after workers voted down Starbucks’s economic proposals,Pitkin said the union is looking for base wage increases, annual pay increases that don’t lag behind inflation, and a minimum of three baristas staffed in each store.

“We’d like to see a floor, a starting wage at $17 an hour,” said Pitkin,“Despite Starbucks claiming that baristas make $30 an hour, which they have said publicly, in 34 states, Starbucks workers start at $15,25, an hour, and in another nine states, they start at $16 or below, so we want to get more money into the pockets of these lowest paid baristas,”Jasmine Leli, a Starbucks barista in Buffalo, New York, where the union campaign at Starbucks began in 2021, said: “We continue to file unfair labor practices due to the ongoing union busting at the store level,We continue to work understaffed, which is extremely stressful.

We’re struggling to pay our bills.”Starbucks said they remain committed to bargaining and they claimed the shareholder proposal is similar to a previous failed effort.“The Starbucks Board has the necessary skills and experience to effectively oversee our strategy, including human capital management, which is vital to our ability to drive growth and deliver for our customers,” Starbucks spokesperson Jaci Anderson said in an email.“Our ongoing investments in the partner experience have enabled Starbucks to offer the best jobs in retail – pay and benefits average $30 an hour for hourly partners, turnover is far below the industry average, and more than a million people apply to work here every year.”
sportSee all
A picture

Emma Raducanu suffers another setback as she withdraws from Miami Open

Emma Raducanu has sustained another significant setback as she opted to withdraw from the Miami Open due to illness. Raducanu struggled with a virus throughout February, suffering poor opening-round losses in Doha and Dubai. She is said to still have post-viral symptoms.Raducanu had been due to compete in Miami as the 24th seed and she received a first-round bye, meaning she would not have played until Thursday or Friday. However, the 23-year-old decided not to wait until the last minute before making a decision on her participation

A picture

Six Nations 2026: our writers pick their tournament highlights

From the brilliance of Bielle-Biarrey to Carré’s jaw-dropping try, our highs and lows from a sensational championshipPlayer of the tournament Impossible to look past Louis Bielle-Biarrey who, among assorted records, has become the first player to score a try in every Six Nations game in successive seasons. But Italy’s Tommaso Menoncello and Ireland’s Stuart McCloskey also deserve a podium place.Best match There will be some who dislike 50-40 and 48-46 scorelines on principle. Too fast, too loose. But Scotland’s spectacular win over France and England’s breathless loss in Paris showed what is possible when the best players let their hair down

A picture

Toto Wolff says Verstappen’s car is cause of driver’s misery, not new regulations

Toto Wolff has dismissed criticism of the new Formula One regulations from Max Verstappen as a result of the “horror show” Red Bull car the four-time world champion is having to drive.Verstappen has not been alone in his outspoken criticism of the new rules, and after he was forced to retire from the Chinese GP on Sunday he delivered his most damning condemnation yet of the emphasis on electrical energy deployment and recovery.“It’s terrible,” he said. “If someone likes this, then you really don’t know what racing is like. Not fun at all

A picture

Iowa State’s Audi Crooks is a velveteen unicorn – and March’s biggest matchup problem

Crooks is one of college basketball’s most fascinating stars, blending power and touch in a throwback game that could carry the Cyclones deep into MarchThe basketball gods really have a thing for Iowa. First came Caitlin Clark at the University of Iowa, a scoring sensation who dominated headlines and sparked cultural debates. Now, the state’s other major college program, Iowa State, has been blessed with Audi Crooks – a thunderclap in her own right.Where Clark dazzled the masses with moon ball shots and moxie off the dribble, Crooks is the kind of talent that makes other players of stature sit up and take notice, the junior center with a feel beyond her years. A 6ft 3in ballast in the paint, Crooks belongs to a protected class of hooper, the velveteen giant – post players who win with touch as much as brute force

A picture

Sydney Swans admit to altering Bondi attack tribute to omit mention of Jewish community

The Sydney Swans have again apologised for the club’s “error of judgment” that resulted in the Jewish community not being mentioned in the AFL’s opening round pre-match tribute to victims of the Bondi terror attack.In a statement on Monday, the club attempted to absolve the AFL of any blame after the league was referred to the royal commission on antisemitism and social cohesion by Liberal senator James Paterson.Before the Swans’ season-opening game against Carlton at the SCG, Sydney’s chief executive, Matthew Pavlich, led a tribute to victims of the Bondi attack and first responders, some of whom joined the teams on the field.The club has now apologised multiple times, after journalist and former player Gerard Healy revealed Pavlich’s speech had been edited to remove references to the Jewish community.“There was no directive or instruction from the AFL to remove or change the reference to the Jewish Community in the script,” the club said in a statement

A picture

Cheltenham raised a cheer – but fatalities and fallouts tainted bounce-back festival

Attendance: up. British winners: up. Bookies’ profits: through the roof. Punters will wince at the last of those after a ferociously difficult four days at Cheltenham, with winners at 66-1, 50-1, 40-1 and 33-1 among the biggest skinners for the books. The Paddy Power client in Ireland who was paid €558,000 (£484,000) after putting Friday’s first six winners into a 50 cent each-way Lucky 63 would be a very worthy inductee into the Cheltenham Hall of Fame