Coles offered ‘utterly misleading’ discounts ACCC argues in federal court case

A picture


Coles disguised price increases on at least 245 products by offering discounts that were “literally true” but also “utterly misleading”, the competition regulator has argued at the beginning of a high-profile court case,A federal court battle between the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) and Coles began on Monday, testing allegations the supermarket breached the law by offering “illusory” discounts on many everyday products,The ACCC alleges Coles misled shoppers because the products were sold at one regular price for at least six months before being temporarily inflated and then dropped slightly as part of a “Down Down” promotion,The strategy is known as “was/is” comparative pricing,The consumer watchdog will argue the promoted prices were actually higher, or the same as, the previous regular price.

In many cases, Coles effected the temporary price spike to establish a higher “was” price, according to the legal claim,Sign up: AU Breaking News emailOn Monday, Justice Michael O’Bryan heard the ACCC’s opening submissions on the first day of the 10-day hearing in Melbourne, which will scrutinise Coles pricing practices between February 2022 and May 2023,Barrister Garry Rich SC, acting for the ACCC, gave the court the example of Coles’ pricing of 1,2kg cans of Nature’s Gift wet dog food,Coles had sold the dog food for $4 for 296 days between April 2022 and February 2023, Rich told the court.

The supermarket then increased the price of that product by a “whopping 50%” to $6 and sold it at the higher retail price for just seven days,After a week, Coles changed the price of the dog food to $4,50 and told customers it was on sale as part of the “Down Down” promotion, claiming that price “was” $6,Rich said while Coles’ claim $4,50 was a discounted price for the dog food was “literally true”, it was also “utterly misleading”.

“A consumer who knew the real facts would not think the price of the dog food had gone down,” he told the court,“Nor would they think the price of $4,50 was a genuine reduction or discount,”The case will put pricing practices across the supermarket industry under a microscope and have ramifications for a very similar case the ACCC is running against Woolworths, which is expected to be heard at a later date,The ACCC is seeking large penalties and community service orders against Coles, which, along with Woolworths, controls two-thirds of the Australian grocery market.

Coles will defend the ACCC’s allegations by arguing the changes in pricing were a response to increased costs from suppliers.Rich told the court on Monday that Coles disguised wholesale price increases as discounts by temporarily spiking the retail price much higher than it needed to, then reducing the price to the “new regular price”.“In our submission Coles misled its customers into thinking it had reduced its regular prices when in the space of about a month Coles had implemented a price increase for those products,” he said.The case will focus on a sample of about a dozen products, including Rexona deodorant, Arnott’s Shapes and 2L bottles of Coca-Cola, from a list of 245 which the ACCC has submitted to the court.Rich told the court that Coles had reduced the minimum length of time it had to wait after changing the retail price of an item before putting it on “Down Down” from 12 weeks to four, then failed to comply with the “revised guardrails” for almost half of the products the court will examine.

The first price was on offer for a median period of a year, before being increased to its second price, for a median of 28 days, before being reduced to a third “Down Down” price which was actually more expensive or equal to the first price.Rich presented the example of Karicare baby formula to the court to explain how he said Coles “planned” the price changes with suppliers.Coles had sold Karicare baby formula for $18 for 794 days, the ACCC submitted to the court.It increased the price to $24 for 23 days then dropped the price to $21.“The $24 price was always going to be temporary,” Rich said.

“Price two is a step along the way to what was [always] planned to be the regular price of this product.”Rich said the strategy allowed Coles to introduce higher retail prices without risking a fall in sales, and to benefit from the fact the supermarket could sell more products when they were on promotion.Coles’ weekly sales revenue of the baby formula was $67,800 when advertised as being on sale, compared to $49,680 without the discount, the court was told.The case has started during a period of reigniting inflation, with groceries and other household costs rising strongly again.The consumer price index, the government’s official inflation metric, rose 3.

8% in the 12 months to December 2025, up from a 3.4% increase in the 12 months to November 2025.Spending on food and non-alcoholic beverages contributed 3.4% to annual inflation in the 12 months to December, according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics, second only to housing.
A picture

How to plan Ramadan meals: minimal work, maximum readiness

Ramadan arrives this year in February, in the heart of winter. Short days, cold evenings and the pressure of everyday work mean that preparation is no longer about producing abundance, but about reducing effort while maintaining care. For many households balancing jobs, children and long commutes, the question is not what to cook, but how to make the month manageable.The most effective approach to Ramadan cooking is not variety but repetition. A small set of meals that are easy to digest, quick to prepare and gentle on the body can carry a household through 30 days of fasting with far less stress than daily reinvention

A picture

Benjamina Ebuehi’s recipe for almond frangipane crepes | The sweet spot

When it comes to pancake day, I don’t discriminate and fill the day with as many types of pancakes as possible – from a fluffy American-style stack in the morning to a savoury buckwheat pancake at lunch, and finishing off with classic crepes in the evening. This version was heavily inspired by an almond croissant, so although it does lean more towards dessert, I won’t judge if this is what you choose to start your day with. Bake them until the edges go crisp but the middle stays a little gooey.Prep 5 min Rest 20+ min Cook 50 min Makes 7-8 crepes120g plain flour ½ tbsp caster sugar A pinch of salt 2 large eggs 240ml whole milk 25g melted butter, plus extra for greasing Icing sugar, for dusting Lightly whipped cream, to serve (optional)For the frangipane90g salted butter, softened90g caster sugar ¼-½ tsp almond extract1 large egg 110g ground almonds 50g flaked almondsPut the flour, sugar and salt in a bowl and whisk briefly to combine. Add the eggs, whisk to a thick paste, then pour in the milk in three batches, whisking each time to avoid any lumps

A picture

Heard it on the grapevine: Polish wine’s quiet renaissance

Swap the staid stereotypes of Żubrówka vodka and Żywiec lager for vineyards and vintages, because Poland is in the throes of a viticultural renaissance, the likes of which hasn’t been seen for centuries. On a road trip tracing Poland’s best terroirs back in the summer of 2023, I met winemakers going against the grain, unshackled by tradition and producing unpretentious, expressive pours that more than merit a place on your dining table.Lately, Polish wines have been cropping up all over bar and restaurant lists: Niemczańska’s chardonnay at London’s most emblematic Polish restaurant, the borscht-fronted Daquise in South Kensington, say, while chic bar Spry in Edinburgh has started stocking my favourite producers, Dom Bliskowice, Kamil Barczentewicz and Nizio. But you won’t find bottles nestling between the neat rows of kabanos sausages of your local Polski sklep, nor lining the supermarket shelves. Or not just yet, anyway

A picture

​My love letter to Brittany’s best exports

Every February – or occasionally March – I get together with two friends to gorge on pancakes; I provide the pan, Caro does the cocktails and poor old Harry is invariably the chef because she never fails, even three ciders in. With two half-Frenchies in the room, we always start with buckwheat galettes, usually served complète with gruyère, ham and a fried egg (though the more we eat, the more adventurous the combinations become). Then we move on to softer, thicker British sweet pancakes with lemon juice and crunchy demerara sugar to finish. We rarely manage to meet on Shrove Tuesday itself, but apart from the year I went vegan for Lent, that’s no problem. After all, any cold, dark evening is improved by a pancake party

A picture

Rachel Roddy’s recipe for cacio e pepe, the old-fashioned way | A kitchen in Rome

Nightclubs, mechanics, restaurants, a theatre, a wholesale butcher and an Apostolic church occupy some of the network of caves and tunnels that, over the centuries, were burrowed into Monte Testaccio, an ancient rubbish dump hill in the middle of Rome that’s made entirely of broken amphorae. Some places make a feature of their situation, revealing sections of pots not dissimilar to the cross section of snapped wafer biscuits, while others have smoothed the curves with plaster.A few use the caves as originally intended – that is, as natural warehouses offering steady low temperatures and good humidity. In short: the ideal temperature for storing certain foods and wine. Most recently, Vincenzo Mancini, whose project DOL distributes artisanal products from small agricultural realities in Lazio, has taken over a deep cave behind door 93, reclaiming it as an urban ageing space for cheese and cured meat

A picture

How to use up leftover pickle brine in a tartare sauce – recipe | Waste not

Depending on country, region, household or restaurant, every cook makes tartare sauce in their own way. Inspired by Auguste Escoffier’s exceptionally simple tartare, I’ve given his recipe a zero-waste twist by using whole boiled eggs and swapping in pickle brine from a jar of gherkins or capers to replace the vinegar. Everything else is optional: tarragon, mustard, cayenne … add what you like or have in store.Traditionally, tartare sauce is delicious with fish and chips, calamari or in a chicken sandwich, but I also like it tossed through potato salad with tinned sardines and radicchio. It’s also great as a dip with crudites and on top of a steaming jacket potato