Here’s what a reformed House of Lords could look like | Letters
A reformed Lords could give us the best of all worlds: a chamber that connects and legitimises the disparate parts of our higgledy-piggledy devolved constitution without challenging the primacy of the directly elected Commons (So long, hereditary peers – but the Lords is still full of absurd anachronisms, 13 March).Three-quarters of its members could be indirectly elected by local councillors, with temporary seats reserved for the heads of the national governments and regional mayors.Party leaders not yet in the Commons – such as Zack Polanski – could also sit there.The remaining seats could be time‑limited appointments for experts such as retired civil servants and former ministers, perhaps with different voting rights.An independent commission could oversee appointments, vet eligibility and weed out dodgy donors.
Such a chamber would empower the regions, give popular leaders such as Andy Burnham a route into parliament (while still serving Manchester) and give us one more reason to turn out in local elections.Timothy BaileyOxford I note that hereditary peers will soon disappear completely.However, for some strange reason, 26 bishops will remain in the House of Lords.Admittedly, there are still a number of theocracies in the world, but why are we still one of them? I can see no particular justification for this.We are increasingly a secular country and the relevance of the established church becomes weaker by the year.
It saddens me, but that is the reality.Let us have an upper house that truly reflects the UK.Ian DuckworthBillington, Lancashire Reduce the Lords to 400 members, with 300 appointed on merit by an independent committee, not because they are party donors or long-serving civil servants.They should be contracted to attend a minimum number of days a year at a modest day rate.And 100 could be separately elected at the same time as a general election.
No bishops unless they make it into the group of 300.No patronage by prime ministers.No hereditary peers.Kath HowardWellington, Shropshire Polly Toynbee argues that we should move to an elected upper chamber, saying “all of Europe manages second chambers of different hues, none unelected”.Actually, Norway, Sweden, Denmark and Iceland have all abandoned their upper chambers as they found a second elected chamber superfluous.
So while we undoubtedly need to reform the House of Lords, an elected upper chamber is not a panacea.Tony VossEmsworth, Hampshire The hereditary peers have been expelled from the House of Lords supposedly in the name of democracy.The irony is that hereditary peers are elected while life peers are appointed, so the government has just removed the only members of the house with any electoral legitimacy.Robert FrazerSalford, Lancashire If the current earl of Devon thinks that his family links to the Crusades 800 years ago give him special insights into either current events in the Middle East or contemporary domestic issues, he is not just mistaken but seriously deluded – while remaining a member of our legislative machinery.Les BrightExeter Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
‘It’s not about punishing’: Five key issues for English rugby to resolve after the Six Nations
Steve Borthwick will be reprieved by the RFU’s review but there are other factors at play from the makeup of his backroom team to the conveyor belt of talentThe Rugby Football Union’s review into England’s least successful championship for 50 years is already up and running with an alacrity that would impress Louis Bielle-Biarrey. And one detail seems clear: barring something spectacular, Steve Borthwick will still be coaching the team this summer. As one well-placed insider put it: “This review is about supporting Steve to make improvements. If change is needed, change is needed but it’s not about punishing him. He’s absolutely going to be in post this summer, there’s no question about that
Meg Jones to captain England at Women’s Six Nations with Zoe Stratford pregnant
Meg Jones has been chosen to lead England’s world champions in 2026 after the regular Red Roses captain, Zoe Stratford, announced her pregnancy on Wednesday.Jones, who was vice-captain when England beat Canada to lift the World Cup last September, will take over from Stratford for the upcoming Women’s Six Nations. England kick off their campaign against Ireland on 11 April at Twickenham when a tournament-record crowd of more than 60,000 will be in the stands.The 29-year-old centre said: “Firstly, I’m really excited for Zoe and wish her and Strats [Luke, Zoe’s husband] every happiness on their news. It’s a huge honour to have been named captain of the Red Roses
For Mexico and Canada, injuries are striking just as World Cup hosting duty looms
When Marcel Ruiz slumped into the grass of San Diego FC’s Snapdragon stadium late in the first half of Toluca’s Concacaf Champions Cup game last Wednesday, he seemed to already know. He covered his mouth with his left hand and clutched his right knee – first the back of it, then the front – with his other hand. He turned his head every which way, perhaps hoping that he might scan something or someone who would tell him that this was not in fact happening. That his World Cup on home soil was not already over three months before it was to even start. That Mexico’s injury crisis had not just deepened further
No Limit: can rap mogul Master P really become an elite basketball coach?
The 55-year-old has is an assistant coach at the University of New Orleans. Now he believes he can take the step up to the top of his sportYou are Arizona State athletics director Graham Rossini, more of a forward-thinking sports executive than a classic campus administrator. The Sun Devils basketball team have just staggered through another middling season, missing the NCAA tournament for a third straight year. You’ve just fired coach Bobby Hurley, but the vacancy isn’t what anyone in the sport would call coveted – not compared to a blue-blood program like Duke or Kentucky, or even the cross-state rival Arizona Wildcats men’s basketball, standard-bearer of the old Pac-10.You could hire another hardwood hero like Hurley, a Duke Blue Devils men’s basketball supervillain whose winning pedigree as a player surfaced only in flashes over 11 uneven years on the sideline
Sixteen international games and a franchise overseas: is the NFL’s global ambition good or greed?
“Pigs get fat, hogs get slaughtered. And they’re getting hoggy.” When Mark Cuban, then owner of the NBA’s Dallas Mavericks, fired that line at the NFL in 2014, he was partly goading and partly gloating.It felt directionally true. The NFL looked bloated, arrogant and vulnerable
Chess: Scotland’s Freddy Waldhausen Gordon, 15, routs the English in British Rapidplay
Freddy Waldhausen Gordon, a 15-year-old from George Heriot’s school, Edinburgh, came through with a stunning burst to capture the annual British Rapidplay championship in Peterborough with a score of 9.5/11, defeating the top-seeded GM, Gawain Maroroa Jones, in the final round in a must-win game by a checkmating attack where White’s queen and both rooks all invaded Black’s rear rank.Maroroa Jones was in trouble early in the decisive game, soon had to concede rook for knight, and a second loss of the exchange followed at move 32. At the end, 39 Rxg7+ and 40 Qg8 mate could only be delayed by Black giving up his queen.It was the 37th staging of the British Rapidplay, whose fast time limit of all the moves in 15 minutes for each player, plus a 10 seconds increment per move, makes it possible to hold an entire 11-round tournament in a single weekend
Seth Meyers on Trump’s Nato about-face: ‘This is just how Donald Trump does friendship’
Banksy has been unmasked (again). But does this major Reuters investigation actually tell us something new?
Arts Council England must change or face ‘disaster’, culture department is told
Jimmy Kimmel on Trump: ‘He uses his bones to feel things instead of his brain’
Carnivàle revisited: is this HBO’s strangest show?
‘We kicked Bono’s arse’: how we made Atomic Kitten’s Whole Again (with a little help from Kraftwerk)